Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ganesh Flour Mills v. Jeewan Kumar And Another S

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Feb 23, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Ganesh Flour Mills, Nabha, through its sole proprietor Budh Sagar, filed two complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act read with Section 420 I.P.C against Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar respectively. Jeewan Kumar was alleged to have issued a cheque for Rs. 30,900/- dated June 18, 1991, which was dishonoured due to insufficient funds. Similarly, Satish Kumar was alleged to have issued a cheque for Rs. 4,000/- dated June 12, 1991, also dishonoured. Both accused were initially convicted by the Judicial Magistrate, Nabha, on October 19, 1992. However, the Additional Sessions Judge, Patiala, acquitted both accused on April 30, 1993, holding that the prosecution failed to prove that the cheques were issued in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability. The present appeals were filed by Ganesh Flour Mills challenging these acquittals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mere issuance and dishonour of a cheque under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act establishes the offence without proving that the cheque was issued in discharge of a debt or a legally enforceable liability?
  2. Whether the presumption under Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act shifts the burden of proof to the accused, and if so, whether the complainant must still prove the existence of debt or liability?
  3. Whether the appellate court was justified in acquitting the accused on the ground that the complainant failed to prove the debt or liability despite the presumption in favor of the complainant?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The learned appellate Judge overlooked the provisions of Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  • Section 139 creates a presumption that the holder of the cheque received it for discharge of a debt or liability.
  • Section 118 presumes that every negotiable instrument is drawn for consideration.
  • Based on these presumptions and the evidence of dishonour, it was argued that the amounts were due from the accused to the complainant and the accused had insufficient funds to meet the cheques.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The accused denied liability, stating that their signed blank cheques were taken by a bank Field Officer as security for a loan which was later cancelled.
  • The accused asserted that the cheques were misused after the loan was cancelled and requested their return, which was not granted.
  • The accused rebutted the presumption of debt or liability by providing detailed replies to the notice of dishonour and in their statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C. Antony v. K.G Raghavan Nair, 2002 (4) RCR (Crl.) 75 Accepted the plea that the accused had not received amount from complainant despite issuance of cheque; emphasized the need for complainant to prove payment or debt in Section 138 cases. The Court relied on this precedent to highlight that the complainant must establish the existence of debt or liability and that the accused can rebut the presumption by showing absence of such debt.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicability of Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, which create presumptions in favor of the complainant that a cheque is drawn for consideration and in discharge of a debt or liability. However, these presumptions are rebuttable. The accused had explicitly denied any debt or liability and had provided detailed replies to the notice of dishonour explaining that the signed cheques were taken by a bank official as security for a loan that was not ultimately disbursed and was cancelled. The complainant failed to produce any documentary or oral evidence to establish the existence of a debt or liability corresponding to the cheques issued. The Court found that the complainant’s failure to provide even a minimal explanation or evidence regarding the consideration or debt underlying the cheques fatally undermined the prosecution’s case. The Court further relied on the precedent of C. Antony v. K.G Raghavan Nair to affirm that the burden on the complainant to prove the debt or liability remains despite statutory presumptions. Consequently, the appellate court’s acquittal of the accused was neither unreasonable nor perverse.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are dismissed.

The Court upheld the acquittal of Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar, confirming that the complainant failed to discharge the burden of proving that the cheques were issued in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability. The decision underscores the principle that statutory presumptions under the Negotiable Instruments Act are rebuttable and that failure to produce evidence of consideration or debt can lead to acquittal. No new precedent was established; the ruling reinforces existing jurisprudence regarding the evidentiary requirements in cases under Section 138 of the Act.

Show all summary ...

K.S Garewal, J. — Criminal Appeals 475-DBA and 476-DBA of 1993 filed by Ganesh Flour Mills, Nabha to challenge the acquittal of two brother, Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar, respectively, shall be decided by this judgment. Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar were acquitted by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Patiala vide judgment dated April 30, 1993 after they had both been convicted by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Nabha vide judgement dated October 19, 1992.

2. Briefly stated the facts are that Ganesh Flour Mills, Nabha through its sole proprietor Budh Sagar had filed two complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (for short ‘the Act’) read with Section 420 I.P.C against Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar. According to the complainant Jeewan Kumar had issued a cheque for Rs. 30,900/- on June 18, 1991 drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce, Nabha. The cheque on presentation was dishonoured with the remarks “referred to drawer”. Notice of dishonour was issued upon the party on June 29, 1981 but payment was not received and hence the complaint was filed. The learned Magistrate came to the conclusion that the sum mentioned in the cheque was issued by Jeewan Kumar to the complainant. The plea of the accused that he had not taken any loan from the complainant and that his signatures on the cheque had been obtained by an employee of the bank was not accepted by the learned Magistrate. It was held that the complainant had proved that the cheque had been returned by the banker on account of the party having insufficient funds in the bank. Consequently, Jeewan Kumar was convicted.

3. The pleas and the evidence against Satish Kumar were also similar and so also was the finding of the learned Magistrate except that the amount in question was Rs. 4000/- for which cheque had been issued on June 12, 1991.

4. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, Patiala came to the conclusion that mere issuing of a cheque or signing of a cheque would not make the accused liable for the offence unless it was shown that the cheque was in discharge of a debt or a legally enforceable liability. Since the complainant had not led any evidence on this aspect of the case, the complainant's case that an offence under Section 138 of the Act had been committed was not proved. Jeewan Kumar and Satish Kumar were acquitted.

5. The learned counsel for the appellant has vehemently argued that the learned appellate Judge had over-looked the provisions of Sections 118 and 139 of the Act. According to Section 139 there was a presumption that the holder of a cheque received the cheque for the discharge, in whole or in part, or any debt or liability. Under Section 118 of the Act there was a presumption that every negotiable instrument had been drawn for consideration. Therefore, from the perusal of evidence it was evident that the amounts were due from the accused to the complainant and the cheques of the accused had been dishonoured which meant that the accused did not have sufficient amount in their accounts of meet the cheques.

6. It is all very well for the appellant complainant to argue that there was a presumption in his favour but what is not understandable is the failure of the complainant to give even a slight hint of the debt or liability which the party had incurred when the cheque had been issued. Did the appellant supply some goods on credit, did the appellant loan the amount or did he sell him some house hold articles. The appellant had disclosed nothing in his evidence as to why he had been handed over the two cheques in question. Is one to presume that the cheques were a present or a donation to charity. The appellant complainant is flour mill, therefore, it could be said that the mill had supplied flour or some by-product. Even this is not the complainant's case.

7. The Supreme Court of India in C. Antony v. K.G Raghavan Nair., 2002 (4) RCR (Crl.) 75, while dealing with a case under Section 138 of the Act, accepted the contention of the accused that he had not received any amount from the complainant although he had given a blank cheque in connection with a chit fund; the complainant did not produce any witness in whose presence the payment had been made. The Court acquitted the accused. In the above case, the complainant had allegedly advanced Rs. 26500/- in cash to the accused and it was towards repayment of this amount that the cheque had been issue which later bounced. The accused had taken up the plea that he had given a blank cheque as security for future instalments of the amount due from him in a chit transaction but the cheque had never been returned and was misused.

8. In the present case when the accused received a notice of dishonour they sent individual detailed replies dated July 8, 1991, the gist of which was that on June 12, 1991 the Field Officer of the bank took two signed blank cheques from them and assured them that they would be advanced a loan by the bank as promised. On July 1, 1991 the accused got the loan cancelled and the Field Officer issued receipt but when the accused asked for return of the signed cheques they were informed that they should come later. The cheques in question were those signed cheques which had been used to file the complaints. Therefore, the case of the accused had been explicitly pleaded in reply to the notice of dishonour. Moreover, this had also been the plea raised by the accused in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C

9. There is a presumption that every negotiable instrument had been drawn for consideration and that the cheque had been issued in discharge of any debt due from him, it becomes the duty of the complainant to establish the consideration and the debt due. Therefore, it was incumbent upon the complaint to produce documentary/oral evidence to establish that the cheques were infact issued to him in discharge of a debt or liability because the presumption had already been rebutted by the accused in their replies to the notice of dishonour. The complainant was, therefore, aware that this would be the plea of the accused in defence and he should have produced the evidence in support of his case that the cheque was issued to him for consideration. The complainant had failed to so, therefore, the appellate Court was perfectly justified in acquitting the accused. The acquittal of the accused could be set aside in this appeal against acquittal but only after finding that the conclusion of the trial Court was perverse. In the circumstances of the case it cannot at all be held that the decision of the appellate Court was either unreasonable or perverse while acquitting the accused-respondents.

In view of the above, the appeals are without merit and are dismissed.

Appeals dismissed.