Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajinder Kaur And Another v. Union Of India And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jul 1, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Rajinder Kaur and Gurdeep Kaur, wife and mother respectively of Gurbachan Singh, petitioned the Court under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of passports by the Regional Passport Officer, Chandigarh. They had applied for passports on 12.3.2003, complying with all procedural requirements, but passports were not issued due to adverse police reports allegedly linked to Gurbachan Singh, who was wanted by police and avoiding trial in Punjab. The petitioners claimed no criminal involvement and challenged the respondents' refusal as arbitrary. The respondents contended that issuance was withheld based on police reports stating Gurbachan Singh’s involvement in terrorist activities and misuse of passport. Multiple FIRs were registered against Gurbachan Singh, and he was a proclaimed offender residing abroad. The Court directed the respondents to produce records substantiating their claims, which were not furnished satisfactorily. Additional affidavits reiterated concerns about potential prejudice to criminal proceedings and national sovereignty if passports were issued to petitioners.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the refusal to issue passports to the petitioners, based on police reports related to a third party (Gurbachan Singh), without specific material against the petitioners themselves, is lawful under the provisions of The Passports Act, 1967, particularly Section 6(2)(b).
  2. Whether the authorities exercised their discretion in accordance with constitutional protections of freedom of movement and the statutory framework, ensuring decisions are based on reasonable and cogent material.
  3. The extent to which subjective satisfaction of authorities must be objectively supported by records before denying passport issuance.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners submitted complete applications and complied with all rules for passport issuance.
  • The refusal was arbitrary, lacking any basis or material implicating the petitioners in criminal or anti-national activities.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India and a Division Bench decision in Kamaljit Kaur v. Union of India to assert their entitlement to passports under the Act.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Issuance of passports requires clear investigation reports per Government of India instructions dated 28.10.1999.
  • Police reports indicated Gurbachan Singh’s involvement in terrorist activities and that he obtained a passport through false information.
  • Multiple FIRs were registered against Gurbachan Singh, who was a proclaimed offender residing abroad.
  • Issuing passports to petitioners could hamper ongoing criminal proceedings and potentially facilitate anti-national activities.
  • Denial of passports was justified under Section 6(2)(b) of The Passports Act, which permits refusal if the applicant may engage in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 Right to travel abroad is a fundamental right protected under the Constitution; executive actions affecting this right must be supported by legislative authority and reasonable material. Used to emphasize that passport denial must be based on objective material and conform to statutory grounds under The Passports Act.
Satwant Singh Sawhney v. D. Ramarathnam, AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1836 Freedom to travel is a fundamental right and any executive action prejudicial to this right must have legislative backing and be supported by material. Reiterated the constitutional protection of travel freedom and the need for authorities to have reasonable grounds for refusal.
Kamaljit Kaur v. Union of India, CWP No. 4226 of 2001 Police reports must be based on material facts and not conjectures to justify passport denial. Supported the petitioners’ claim that vague police reports without material cannot justify refusal.
Union of India v. Smt. Charanjit Kaur, (1987) 1 SCC 471 Passport authority’s discretion to refuse or impound passports must be based on sufficient material; judicial interference is limited where material exists. Distinguished on facts since in the present case no material was produced to justify refusal, unlike in Charanjit Kaur.
Manjit Singh v. Union of India, CWP No. 4073 of 2003 Discretion under The Passports Act must be exercised fairly, promptly, and in consonance with law, with communication to the applicant. Quoted to underline the obligation of authorities to apply mind and decide applications without undue delay or arbitrariness.
Ranjit Bajaj (case referenced) Authorities must balance the freedom to travel with the nature of alleged offences; minor offences should not automatically result in passport denial. Used to illustrate the requirement of objective consideration rather than mechanical rejection of passport applications.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts and submissions, noting that the petitioners themselves had no criminal record or involvement in any conspiracy. The police reports against the petitioners were vague, indefinite, and unsupported by any records maintained in the ordinary course of business. The Court emphasized that subjective satisfaction of authorities must be based on objective and reasonable material, particularly when fundamental rights such as freedom to travel are at stake. The Court analyzed the statutory provision Section 6(2)(b) of The Passports Act, which allows refusal only if the applicant may engage in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India, and held that this provision requires strict construction and cogent material. The respondents failed to produce any such material or records substantiating their apprehensions. The Court distinguished the present case from precedents where sufficient material was produced to justify denial. It also underscored the duty of authorities to apply their mind fairly and promptly, and to communicate decisions to applicants. The Court found that the police report and the respondent’s inaction amounted to an unfair exercise of power and arbitrariness, violating the petitioners’ constitutional rights.

Holding and Implications

Petitions allowed.

The Court directed the respondents to consider the petitioners’ passport applications and issue passports in accordance with law, unless they possess material justifying refusal under Section 6(2)(b) of The Passports Act. The decision underscores that passport authorities must base refusals on concrete, record-supported grounds and exercise discretion fairly, respecting constitutional protections of freedom of movement. No new precedent was established; the ruling reaffirms existing constitutional and statutory principles ensuring that passport denial is not arbitrary but founded on reasonable and cogent evidence. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Show all summary ...

Swatanter Kumar, J.:— Rajinder Kaur and Gurdeep Kaur, wife and mother respectively, of Gurbachan Singh, have approached this Court under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India praying that the Regional Passport Officer, Chandigarh, should be directed to issue passport to the petitioners. The action of the respondents in not issuing passports to the petitioners is entirely arbitrary and without any basis. According to the petitioners they had applied for issuance of a passport as they had intention to travel abroad. For this purpose, they submitted the requisite application forms after duly complying with rules and as stated in the application on 12.3.2003 Applications of both the petitioners were received by the department against receipts Serial No. Chandigarh 00019 and Chandigarh 00015 respectively on the same date. The petitioners visited the passport office on different dates including 26.9.2003 and 17.11.2003 The passports were not issued to the petitioners and they were informed that it had been reported on the enquiry slip that police report from the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala, was ∼ incorrect. Petitioners claim that they have never done any criminal act and they do not have any history of direct or indirect involvement of any crime. The respondents have no reason, whatsoever, to deny this relief to the petitioners. Mr. Gurbachan Singh is stated to be avoiding trail in State of Punjab and is wanted by the police and that is the basic reason why the State functionaries including the police are not quite inclined to issue the demanded passport to the petitioners. The petitioner while relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 Supreme Court 597, as well as judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kamaljit Kaur v. Union of India, CWP No. 4226 of 2001, decided on 9.10.2001 contended that they are really entitled to get the passports and the travel documents of travelling abroad in accordance with the provisions of The Passports Act, hereinafter referred to as the Act.

2. This petition was contested by the respondents. Two different written statements were filed. One written statement was filed on behalf of the Union of India and Regional Passport Officer together, wherein it was not disputed that application for issuance of passport was received by the Passport Office but it is averred that it is mandatory before issuance of the passport that there should be clear investigation report in terms of the instructions issued by the Government of India dated 28.10.1999, Annexure R.1 to the writ petition. As per police report, Annexure R.2 to the reply, the police authorities have not recommended issuance of passport to the petitioners on the ground that Shri Gurbachan Singh was indulging in terrorist activities and had gone on abroad on a passport which he obtained by giving wrong address.

3. Other written statement was filed on behalf of the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Samana-respondent No. 3. In the preliminary submissions of the written statement it has been stated that number of cases have been registered against Gurbachan Singh, the husband and son respectively of the two petitioners. There are as many as eight cases registered against him, which are pending and he is wanted in these cases. Since the petitioners also wanted to go to see Gurbachan Singh in America, therefore, it was not desirable to issue passport to them. The details of the cases registered against him are as under:—

1. FIR No. 26 dated 1.9.2.1989, u/s 307/34 IPC 3, 4, 5, TADA Act, P.S Patran.

2. FIR No. 67 dated 22.5.1989, u/s 302/307/34 IPC 25/54/59, Arms Act, P.S Patran.

3. FIR No. 74 dated 10.6.1989, u/s 302/34 IPC, P.S Patran.

4. FIR No. 321 dated 12.9.1989, u/s 307/148/149/120-B IPC 3, 4, 5, TADA Act, P.S Guhla, District Kaithal.

5. FIR No. 160 dated 26.8.1989, u/s 436/452/427 IPC 3, 4, 5, TADA Act, P.S Samana.

6. FIR No. 9 dated 20.1.1989, u/s 302/34 IPC 3, 4, 5, TADA Act, 25/54/59 Arms Act, P.S Ghagga.

7. FIR No. 90 dated 15.5.1989, u/s 382 IPC 3, 4, 5, TADA Act, P.S Samana.

8. FIR No. 352 dated 8.7.2000, u/s 470/471/468/120-B and 12 of Passport Act, P.S Civil Lines, Patiala.

4. In addition to the above it is also stated in the written statement that Gurbachan Singh, who had escaped from police, is residing in America and it is apprehended that the petitioners may help the said person in anti-national activities. Gurbachan Singh is further stated to be a proclaimed offender.

5. As the written statement, particularly on behalf of the police authorities, was vague and indefinite, the Court on 26.4.2004 passed the following order:—

“Two officers Mr. Shiv Kumar, Senior Superintendent of Police, Fatehgarh Sahib and Mr. A.S Rai, Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala, are present in Court. They regret that proper affidavit had not been filed in this case and they assured the Court a record based affidavit complete in all respects would be filed within one week from today with an advance copy of the learned counsel for the petitioners, who may, if so desires, file counter-affidavit to the same within three days thereafter.

List this matter for hearing on 11.5.2004

We make it clear that the relevant record should be produced in Court on that date.

The officers have also informed the Court that they are in the process of finalising the guidelines/instructions which should be followed by various districts in relation to personal particular verification by the police in response to the queries raised by the passport office.”

6. After passing of the order, Punjab Police authorities filed additional affidavit of Shri Amardeep Singh Rai, IPS, Superintendent of Police, Patiala. In this additional affidavit, further details of the various cases registered against Gurbachan Singh have been given and it is stated that if the passports are issued to the petitioners, it will hamper the proceedings of the criminal cases pending in the Court. Another sentence has been added in this affidavit to say that the case of the petitioners would be hit by the provisions of Section 6(2)(b) of the Act as the applicants may, or are likely to engage outside India in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India.

7. From the above noted facts, as they emerge from the pleadings of the parties, it is clear that there is no specific case registered against any of the petitioners. They are not involved in any conspiracy or actual commission of any crime. It is true that satisfaction of any authority involved in this process is subjective but equally true is that such subjective satisfaction must be achieved objectively keeping in mind the purpose of the statute in which the authorities are exercising the powers. Once a right is sanctioned in favour of a citizen, then it cannot be wiped out except for compelling circumstances which are available to the authorities in position as per due process of law. In our order dated 26.4.2004 we had specifically directed the respondents to produce the records in support of the averments made in the affidavit and the reply. No such record was produced.

8. Firstly, the averments made in the reply are vague and secondly, they are not supported by any records of the State Police Authorities maintained in its normal course of business. None of the petitioners have been kept under any surveillance by he respondent-department though they have been in India for years together. They are not the history-sheeters or their names have been entered on the register in the police station for overlooking the activities of these persons. Merely because Gurbachan Singh happens to be involved in certain criminal cases and has been granted asylum in the foreign country per se can or cannot be the ground for denying the issuance of the passport to the petitioners, is the question we are called upon to decide in the present petition.

9. In the case of Satwant Singh Sawhney v. D. Ramarathnam, Assistant Passport Officer, New Delhi, AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1836, the Supreme Court expanded the scope of freedom to travel and equated the same to a fundamental right and a constitutional protection available to the citizens of this country. This expansion of right of freedom has been reiterated with approval in various subsequent judgments. The Supreme Court also emphasised that every executive action which is or which may or is likely to operate prejudicial to the interests of any person must be supported by legislative authority. In the case of Smt. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (surpa) the Court held that a person cannot be deprived of his right to go abroad. There was a specific law enacted by the State in that regard. This being the settled law, obvious result is that the competent authority must have material to substantiate this objection on the basis of the record maintained by it in support of the objection for issuance of the passport. Furthermore, the Parliament having enacted a law specifying the grounds on the basis of which the authorities have wide power for refusing to issue a passport or travel document on the one hand and even right has been given to the said authorities to impound or caused to be impounded or revoke the passport or travel document. But, once the grounds have been specified, then the authorities are obliged to bring their case within those grounds and cannot be permitted to add any ground to the specified ground or to forward an interpretation which, in substance, would tantamount to introduce a new ground which apparently is beyond the preview of the existing provisions. The authorities must deal with facts of the case and raise record based objections. The authorities, thus, must apply their mind in light of the grounds existing under Section 6(2) of the Act before they decline to issue passport to the petitioners. Inter-departmental proceedings should be taken in a responsible manner so that constitutional protected right of a person is not infringed by an arbitrary action. The satisfaction to be recorded by the police department and/or even the passport authorities should be founded on some reasonable and cogent material. In the case of Manjit Singh v. Union of India, CWP No. 4073 of 2003, decided on 20.5.2004, the Court held as under:—

“……Such a discretion must be exercised in consonance with the provisions of the passport Act, 1967. They owe an obligation to the public at large to discharge their duties in terms of the provisions of the said Act in accordance with law and fairly. No justifiable reason can be given why an application should be kept pending for years together. If the competent authority is of the view that in consonance with the provisions of the Act, passport should be declined to an applicant he is bound by law to pass such an order and communicate the same to the person concerned while adhering to the principle of audi alteram partem wherever necessary. To grant or refuse to grant is the discretion of the authority to be exercised in consonance with the settled principles of law but to keep the matter in abeyance would be an act which is bound to invite judicial castism on all quarters. The authorities are duty bound to apply their mind to the facts and circumstances of each case and take decision promptly without any unnecessary delay. In the case of Ranjit Bajaj (supra) the Court held as under:—

“However, we must also notice a pertinent aspect relatable to such cases. The authorities have a duty to strike a balance between the restricted freedom available to the petitioner to travel abroad and the nature and grievousness of the crime committed by him. The development of law which is its basic and essential feature, has given wide magnitude to the expression of freedom. Enlargement of the concept of freedom by judicial pronouncement has an in-built effect of requiring the authorities to examine the matter with a greater caution and care rather than mechanically reject request for issuance of passport. To illustrate this view we may refer to a case where a person may be involved in a minor offence of traffic regulations and claims to be tried in the Court rather than paying fine at the spot. A case against him being registered under Section 112d read with Section 183 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and even Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code simpliciter and challan presented in Court, should such person be denied issuance of a passport merely because there is a case pending against him in the criminal court, will be a matter of serious concern for the passport authorities. In such cases, it will be expected of the passport authorities to consider the application for renewal/issuance of a passport objectively and in consultation with the police authorities so as to prevent injustice being done to an applicant. Default in such objectivity is in all probabilities likely to result in infringement of a fundamental protection and liberty granted to the applicant under the law of the land. The purpose for which the petitioner had prayed for issuance of the passport has lost its significance as the event at Bangkok itself is over.”

Reverting back to the facts of the present case there is no denying the fact that when the police verification report was sent by respondent No. 3 to respondent No. 2, the petitioner was not undergoing any sentence or conviction. In fact, he had been released on probation by the Court of competent jurisdiction. The period of bond had already expired in the year 2000. The report submitted by respondent No. 3 cannot be justified. In fact, that same is an unfair exercise of power. Keeping the application of the petitioner in abeyance by respondent No. 2 is again not permissible on any ground as is clear from the records provided before us. The police authorities have acted unfairly and error has been personified by inaction on the part of respondent.”

“…The authorities must advert themselves also to the fact that the police should apply its mind and make correct reports to the passport authority on the record available with the department. The applications should be processed properly and final orders granting the passport or declining the request for issuance of the passport upon due application of mind should be passed by the passport authorities. Orders so passed, essentially must be conveyed to the applicant. Such directions and or instructions must be issued by the concerned authorities at the earliest.”

10. We have already noticed that according to the contentions raised on behalf of the respondents before us, the passports cannot be issued to the petitioners in the light of the provisions contained in Section 6(2)(b) of the Act. Under Section 6(2)(b) of the Act it is stated that the passport authority shall refuse to issue a passport on the grounds that the applicant may, or is likely to engage outside India in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India. A person can be denied the right to travel abroad if the authorities are satisfied that ingredients of this provision are satisfied. The language of the section indicates the gravity of the involvement or likely involvement of an applicant in activities which would be prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of the country. These provisions, thus, must receive a strict construction as their consequences in law are not only serious but have the effect of taking away freedom granted to the petitioners in law. Before it could be stated that a person is involved in activities which are prejudicial to the sovereignty of the country, there must be some reasonable and cogent material in possession of the respondents to show involvement of the petitioners in such activities. The expression, “likely to” cannot be treated so lightly as to include every activity and relationship to be prejudicial to the sovereignty of the State.

11. Likelihood may take in its scope the apprehension which essentially must be recorded based or founded on a reasonable cause, of course, may not be directly substantiated by written documentation. Surveillance, maintenance of appropriate registers under the Police Rules, entry of the name of the person therein and at least some reasonable analytical examination by the concerned quarters in the Union of India would normally be the records which should substantiate such reasonable apprehension.

12. We have already noticed that despite order of the Court on records were produced before us to substantiate the said apprehension of the respondents. The only material before the Court is contained in the reply filed by the respondents in the shape of vague affidavit. The relevant part of the reply is reproduced as under:—

“On going through previous record of Gurbachan Singh it has revealed that he has criminal record and has even obtained Indian Passport by giving false information, false address and without disclosing his criminal records and a criminal case is pending in the Court of JMIC, Patiala in which he is a proclaimed offender. The above said passport has been obtained at the instance of maternal uncle Barbara Singh and all the above said facts were also in the knowledge of his wife Rajinder Kaur and mother Gurdeep Kaur. Moreover, Joint Director Intelligence Bureau, New Delhi has also been moved regarding absconding of Gurbachan Singh if the Passports are issued to the petitioners it will hamper the proceedings of Criminal cases pending in the Court. It will be worthwhile to mention here that surveillance and look out notices have also been issued against Gurbachan Singh accused, husband and son of the petitioners.”

13. The above averments do not satisfy any of the grounds specified in different clauses of sub-section (2) of Section 6, much less that they would satisfy even remotely the grounds stated in Section 6(2)(b). Similar is the situation in CWP No. 610 of 2004 wherein the respondents have stated in their reply that husband of the petitioner had links with extremist organisations. The husband of the petitioner Rajinder Singh is residing in some foreign country and if the passports are issued to the petitioners, they would go and join the husband, who then would never come back to India and as such the criminal proceedings against the husband would be hampered and, thus, would prejudicially affect the sovereignty of India. These allegations are equally vague and are not supported by any record, whatsoever.

14. Even during the course of arguments it has not been disputed before us that neither any case is pending against any of the petitioners in both the above writ petitions nor there is any record much less a report of a competent investigating agency or force that during their long stay in India, the petitioners are even suspected in some extremist activities or have links with the persons abroad. It is also not disputed that there is no record to show that these petitioners have carried out any activities which are, in any way, prejudicial to the sovereignty of the country.

15. Learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon another Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kamaljit Kaur (supra) where in somewhat similar circumstances the Court held that the Senior Superintendent of Police in that case had sent his report to the Regional Passport Officer on conjectures and there was no material with the police against the petitioners to recommend the passport to be issued to them. We are cautious of the fact that while exercising its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India this Court does not examine the material collected by the respondent authorities while exercising such a power under the provisions of the Act as a Court of appeal, but there has to be some definite material with the respondents which should leave to a person of common prudence to come to that conclusion while appreciating the said material in its normal course. Where not even iota of record or documents are available, we are afraid that the view taken by the respondents cannot stand the judicial scrutiny. The Court is obliged to examine the material produced before it so satisfy its conscience whether the denial of the passport is in consonance with the provisions of Section 6(2) of the Act or not and whether the action of the respondents at the face of it is arbitrary. The reliance placed by the learned counsel appearing for the respondents on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of The Union of India v. Smt. Charanjit Kaur, (1987) 1 SCC 471 : AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1057, is of not much help to the authorities. In that case their Lordships of the Supreme Court had specifically referred to the record produced before the Court including the letter of the Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi, wherein it was stated that the petitioner in that case had links with six extremists and is likely to engage in activities detrimental to the security of the State. The passport had already been issued to Smt. Charanjit Kaur which was sought to be impounded by order of the passport authority. Permitting such impounding, the Court in that case also specifically relied upon the report furnished by the Intelligence Bureau in its two independent letters. Once material is produced before the Court, then the Court may decline to interfere in exercise of discretion by the respondents, as sufficiency of material or otherwise would be a question which would normally fall in the domain of the administrative authority and can hardly be subjected to judicial review. But, where there is no material or totally irrelevant or insufficient material, in that event the Court would have no choice but to exercise its jurisdiction to prevent violation of the freedom granted to the petitioners under Article 14 read with Article 21 of the Constitution of India. Freedom to travel abroad can be circumvented on the premise and for the reasons which would strictly fall within the ambit and scope of the statutory provisions of the Act.

16. For the reasons aforestated, we allow both these petitions and direct the respondents to consider the applications of the petitioners for issuance of passports and issue the same in accordance with law, of course and unless the respondents have such material in their power and possession of the basis of which they can exercise their power under Section 6(2)(b) of the Act in light of our above observations. However, the parties are left to bear their own costs.

Petitions allowed.