Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Augur Nath Petitioner v. Kishan Chand (Now Dead Through His Lrs)

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jan 29, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Revision Petition concerning ejectment for change of user (Satish Kumar Mittal, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The landlord filed the present revision petition against an order of the Additional District Judge, Jalandhar acting as Appellate Authority under the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, which had set aside an ejectment order passed by the Rent Controller. The demised premises is a shop at Attari Bazar, Jalandhar, originally let by rent note dated 4.8.1961 at a monthly rent of Rs. 23.50.

In 1982 the landlord instituted an ejectment application under Section 13 of the Act on grounds of non-payment of rent, change of user of the shop into a godown, and that the premises had become unfit and unsafe for human habitation. The tenant contested the application, tendered claimed rent on the first hearing date and denied the other allegations. The Rent Controller, after hearing evidence, ordered ejectment on the ground of change of user but held the other grounds not proved.

On appeal the Appellate Authority reversed the Rent Controller's order, holding that the landlord had failed to discharge the burden of proving change of user. The landlord challenged that appellate order by filing this revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellate Authority erred in setting aside the Rent Controller's finding that the tenant had changed the use of the demised shop into a godown.
  2. Whether the landlord discharged the initial onus/burden to prove change of user such that the evidential burden shifted to the tenant to produce contrary evidence (e.g., books of account, bills, licence).
  3. Whether an adverse inference could be drawn against the tenant for failing to produce business records, bills and a Shops Act licence when those documents were in the tenant's possession and relevant to the issue of user.
  4. Whether, as a legal proposition, converting a shop to a godown without permission constitutes change of user rendering the tenant liable to ejectment (in light of the cited Full Bench decision).

Arguments of the Parties

Landlord's Arguments

  • The Appellate Authority reversed a well-reasoned Rent Controller finding without proper consideration and based its order on surmise and conjecture.
  • The Appellate Authority proceeded on a wrong assumption that the landlord had not discharged the burden of proof and that the burden remained static and never shifted to the tenant.
  • The landlord examined three witnesses (AW1 Nirmala Devi, AW2 Chanan Singh, AW3 Parbodh Chander) and produced an expert report marked Ex. AX, which allegedly established that the shop was being used as a godown.
  • The testimony of the tenant's witnesses (RW2 Kanshi Ram and RW3 Ravinder Vinod Sharma) was either unreliable or not relied upon by the Rent Controller; the tenant himself admitted doing cloth business at a different place.
  • The Rent Controller rightly drew an adverse inference against the tenant for not producing books of accounts, sale/purchase bills, licence under the Punjab Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1958, and electricity payment records; the Appellate Authority wrongly reversed that inference.
  • Relied on Supreme Court decision in Sawarni v. Smt. Inder Kaur (1997 (1) RCR 41) to contend that the Appellate Authority had improperly reversed the Rent Controller without examining material evidence, and on the Full Bench decision in Des Raj v. Sham Lal (1980 (2) RCR (Rent) 379 (P&H) (FB)) for the proposition that a shop leased to a tenant cannot be used as a godown and such change of user renders the tenant liable to ejection.

Tenant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the tenant relied on Section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, submitting that the burden of proof to show the shop was being used as a godown lies on the landlord and that the landlord had not discharged that burden.
  • There was no illegality or perversity in the Appellate Authority's order, and therefore the landlord's revision petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sawarni v. Smt. Inder Kaur, 1997 (1) RCR 41 (Hon'ble Supreme Court) Advocated as authority that an appellate court should not reverse a well-considered trial finding without examining material evidence; used to support the proposition that reversal without proper basis is liable to be set aside. The decision was invoked by the landlord's counsel in submissions; the opinion records this reliance. The court's written reasoning does not expressly state that it based its decision primarily on this authority.
Des Raj v. Sham Lal, 1980 (2) RCR (Rent) 379 (P&H) (Full Bench) : 1980 PLR 647 Held that where a shop is leased out to a tenant, even if the lease is silent as to purpose, the premises cannot be used as a godown; such use amounts to change of user and renders the tenant liable to ejectment. The court expressly cited and applied the Full Bench decision as supporting authority for the legal proposition that change of user from shop to godown renders the tenant liable to ejectment, and relied on it in reaching its conclusion that ejectment was warranted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the record, heard counsel and concluded that the Rent Controller's finding that the tenant had changed the use of the demised shop to a godown was a reasoned conclusion based on the evidence.

Key components of the Court's analysis:

  1. The Rent Controller's finding of change of user was based on the oral evidence led by the landlord. The Court found that the Rent Controller had legitimately preferred the landlord's witnesses (AW1 Nirmala Devi and AW2 Chanan Singh) and had valid reasons for discarding the tenant's witness RW2 (Kanshi Ram), who was a former tenant and therefore less reliable on that issue. RW3 (Ravinder Vinod Sharma) did not give testimony establishing that the demised premises was being used as a shop.
  2. The tenant produced no other neighbourhood witnesses to support his claim that the premises continued to be used as a shop.
  3. The Rent Controller drew an adverse inference against the tenant for failing to produce relevant documentary evidence within his possession — books of account, bills of sale/purchase and a licence under the Shops Act — which could have established that business was being carried on at the demised premises. The Court found this inference to be appropriate on the facts before it.
  4. The tenant had admitted in cross-examination that he was carrying on the cloth business at a different shop. The Court considered this admission material and consistent with the Rent Controller's finding of change of user.
  5. The Court addressed the evidentiary contention based on Section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act by distinguishing between "burden of proof" and "onus of proof." It explained that the initial onus to make out a case lies on the plaintiff (the landlord); once the plaintiff discharges that onus, it shifts to the defendant (tenant) to produce evidence rebutting the plaintiff’s case. The Court concluded that the landlord had discharged the initial onus and that the tenant failed to produce evidence that would falsify the landlord's case.
  6. On the question of law whether converting a shop into a godown constitutes change of user warranting ejectment, the Court relied on the Full Bench decision in Des Raj v. Sham Lal to affirm the legal principle that such a change of user renders the tenant liable to be ejected.
  7. On the basis of the foregoing factual findings and legal principles, the Court held that the Appellate Authority had wrongly set aside the Rent Controller's well-reasoned order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed. The order dated 3.1.1986 passed by the Appellate Authority is set aside. The legal representatives of the deceased respondent (tenant) are ordered to be ejected from the shop in question and are granted three months to hand over vacant possession. No order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The landlord's ejectment order (originally passed by the Rent Controller) is restored; the tenant's legal representatives must vacate within three months.
  • The Court applied existing precedent (Des Raj v. Sham Lal) to confirm the legal principle that using a demised shop as a godown constitutes change of user and justifies ejectment. The opinion does not state that it is creating any new legal precedent beyond applying and affirming existing authorities.

Disposition: Revision allowed.

Show all summary ...

Satish Kumar Mittal, J. — Augur Nath petitioner (hereinafter referred to as ‘the landlord’) has filed the instant petition against the order passed by Additional District Judge, Jalandhar, exercising the powers of Appellate Authority under the provisions of East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) vide which the order of Rent Controller, Jalandhar, ejecting the respondent Kishan Chand (now deceased through his legal representatives) (hereinafter referred to as ‘the tenant’) on the ground of change of user, was reversed.

2. The demised premises, in the present case, is a shop, situated at Attari Bazar, Jalandhar. It was let out by the landlord to the tenant vide rent note dated 4.8.1961 at monthly rent of Rs. 23.50 In the year 1982, the landlord filed the ejectment application under Section 13 of the Act for ejectment of the tenant from the demised shop on the grounds of non-payment of rent, change of user of the demised shop to godown and the premises having become unfit and unsafe for human habitation. The tenant contested the ejectment application. He tendered the claimed rent on the first date of hearing and denied the allegations of the landlord on the other two grounds. The learned Rent Controller, after taking into consideration the evidence led by both the parties, passed the order of the ejectment against the tenant on the ground of change of user. The other ground of ejectment was held to be not proved by the landlord. Regarding change of user, the learned Rent Controller has held that the tenant, who took the shop in question for running the business of cloth, is using the same as a godown, which amounts to change of user and the tenant is liable for ejectment from the demised shop.

3. On appeal by the tenant, the aforesaid order of ejectment passed by the Rent Controller was set aside by the Appellate Authority. It was held that the landlord, upon whom the burden of proof lies to prove the alleged change of user, has failed to discharge his onus. The evidence, produced by him in this regard, was found to be not sufficient to establish the alleged change of user.

4. Aggrieved against the said order, the landlord has filed the present revision petition.

5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused the records of the case.

6. Mr. Gopal Mahajan, learned counsel for the landlord submitted that the learned Appellate Authority has reversed the well considered and well reasoned finding of the learned Rent Controller on the issue of change of user without properly considering the reasoning given by the learned Rent Controller; and based its order merely on surmises and conjectures. He canvassed that, primarily, the learned Appellate Authority has proceeded on the assumption that the landlord has not discharged his burden to prove the issue of change of user and the evidence led by him is not sufficient to prove this issue. According to him, the learned Appellate Authority presumed that this burden of proof remained stagnant, and it was never shifted. In view of this wrong assumption, the learned Appellate Authority has observed that the evidence produced by the landlord was not sufficient to discharge the onus placed upon him. Learned counsel further submitted that the landlord examined three witnesses, namely AW.1 Nirmala Devi, AW.2 Chanan Singh and AW.3 Parbodh Chander and has proved on record the report of Expert as Ex. AX, which clearly prove that the tenant was not using the shop in question as a shop; rather he has changed the same into godown. On the other hand, the evidence led by the tenant in the shape of RW.2 Kanshi Ram, who was the ex-tenant of the landlord and RW.3 Ravinder Vinod Sharma, was not relied upon by the learned Rent Controller. He further submitted that in spite of the fact that the tenant himself admitted in his statement that he is doing the business of selling of cloth at some other place, the learned Appellate Authority has wrongly observed that the landlord has failed to prove that the tenant was using some other place as his shop. Similarly the learned Rent Controller, while appreciating the evidence led by both the parties, had come to the conclusion that in the demised shop there is no ‘Gaddi'; and the same is being used as a godown. He further submitted that the learned Rent Controller, after taking into consideration the facts that the tenant did not produce any books of accounts, bills of sale and purchase of clothes, licence under the Punjab Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1958 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Shops Act’) and the electricity charges paid by the tenant, drew an adverse inference against the tenant. The said finding has been reversed by the learned Appellate Authority by illegally observing that the learned Rent Controller should not have drawn such an inference against the tenant for not bringing on record such documents, because the burden of proof lies on the landlord. While relying upon the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sawarni v. Smt. Inder Kaur, 1997 (1) Recent Civil Reports 41, learned counsel for the landlord submitted that the learned Appellate Authority has reversed the well considered and well reasoned judgment of the learned Rent Controller without examining the material evidence available on the record and such decision is liable to be set aside. He further submitted that the Full Bench of this Court in Des Raj v. Sham Lal, 1980 (2) RCR (Rent) 379 (P&H) (FB) : 1980 PLR 647, has held that if the shop is leased out to the tenant, even though the lease deed is silent regarding the purpose for which is was let out, the same cannot be used as a go-down and it amounts to change of user which renders the tenant liable to be ejected. He submitted that in the present case, the tenant is liable to be ejected on the ground that he is using the demised shop as a godown, which was been duly established on record.

7. On the other hand, Sh. Sandeep Garg, learned counsel for the tenant submitted that as per Section 101 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proof lies upon the landlord to prove that the shop in question is being used by the tenant as a godown. He submitted that the said burden has not been discharged, as concluded by the learned Appellate Authority. He further submitted that there is no illegality or perversity in the order passed by the learned Appellate Authority; therefore, the revision petition filed by the landlord is liable to be dismissed.

8. After hearing the arguments of learned counsel for the parties, I am of the opinion that this revision petition filed by the landlord should be allowed; and the order passed by the learned Appellate Authority is liable to be set aside. The order of ejectment passed by the learned Rent Controller is well reasoned. After considering and appreciating the evidence led by both the parties, the learned Rent Controller has recorded a finding that the tenant has changed the use of shop and as such is using the same as a godown. This finding was recorded by the learned Rent Controller on the basis of the oral evidence led by the landlord. The learned Rent Controller, while considering the evidence led by the tenant, has rightly discarded the testimony of RW.2 Kanshi Ram because he was previously a tenant of the landlord; and his testimony to the effect that the demised shop is being used as a shop by the tenant was rightly not believed by the learned Rent Controller. Regarding the other witness, namely RW.3 Ravinder Vinod Sharma, the learned Rent Controller has observed that this witness has not uttered a word regarding the use of the demised premises as a shop by the tenant. Except these two witnesses, the tenant did not produce any other evidence or any witness from the neighbourhood. The learned Rent Controller has further rightly drawn an adverse inference against the tenant for not producing the book of accounts bills regarding sale and purchase of clothes and the licence under the Shops Act. These documents were in possession of the tenant, which could have established that he was running his shop in the demised premises. When these documents were not produced and when no other witness from the locality was examined, the learned Rent Controller has rightly drawn an adverse inference against the tenant. In his cross-examination, the tenant has specifically admitted that he is doing the business of cloth in a different shop. Admittedly, the shop in question is situated in a lane. The learned Rent Controller, after taking into consideration all these facts, has rightly come to the conclusion that the tenant has changed use of the demised shop to a go-down.

9. The contention of learned counsel for the tenant is that as per Section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the burden to prove that the tenant is liable to be ejected on the ground of change of user, lies on the landlord; and that since initially, the said burden was not discharged, therefore, there is no question of shifting the burden on the tenant to prove by producing evidence on record the account books, bills of sale and purchase of cloth and the licence under the Shops Act. The contention of learned counsel for the tenant is not acceptable. It is well settled that there is difference between burden of proof and onus of proof. The initial onus of proving a case is always on the plaintiff. If the plaintiff discharges that onus and makes out a case which entitle him to the relief, the onus shifts on to the defendant to prove the circumstances, if any, which would disentitle the plaintiff to that relief. In the present case, the landlord discharged the initial burden, but on the other hand, the tenant did not produce the evidence to establish that he was using the demised premises as a shop. The learned Appellate Authority has wrongly set aside the well considered and well reasoned judgment of the learned Rent Controller. The learned Appellate Authority has discarded the statements of AW1 Nirmala Devi and AW.2 Chanan Singh without any sufficient reason. Admittedly, the tenant is doing his businesses of cloth in a different shop. He has failed to prove that he is doing any business in the demised shop. I am of the opinion that the landlord has sufficiently discharged the initial burden of proof and on the other hand, the tenant could not lead any evidence, which may falsify the stand taken by the landlord. From the evidence, available on the record, it is clear that the tenant has changed the use of the demised shop as a godown and he is liable to be ejected therefrom, in view of the Full Bench decision of this Court in Des Raj v. Sham Lal (supra).

10. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the revision petition is allowed and the order dated 3.1.1986, passed by the learned Appellate Authority is set aside. The legal representatives of the deceased respondent are ordered to be ejected from the shop in question. However, they are granted three months time to hand over the vacant possession of the demised shop.

No order as to costs.

Revision allowed.