Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Parmatma Kaur And Another v. H.U.F Rajinder Parshad And Sons

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 25, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — S.S. Sudhalkar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (landlord) filed an ejectment petition before the Rent Controller, Ferozepore, seeking possession of a shop occupied by the petitioners (tenants). That petition was dismissed by the Rent Controller. The respondent appealed to the appellate authority, which allowed the appeal. The petitioners (tenants) then filed the present revision petition challenging the appellate authority's order.

The ground of eviction was that the petitioners had ceased to occupy the shop without sufficient cause since the death of the original tenant, Pritam Singh. Although the petitioners occupy another portion in the same building, the petition and appeal are confined to the shop that is the subject-matter of this rent petition. The dispute in this revision is confined to the issue of non-user (non-occupation).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners have ceased to occupy the demised shop for a continuous period of four months without reasonable cause, within the meaning of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949.
  2. Whether the petition's pleading that the respondents "have ceased to occupy the shop in question for a continuous period of more than four months without sufficient cause" is so vague as to defeat the eviction claim.
  3. Whether the appellate authority's finding allowing the landlord's ejectment claim should be disturbed on the facts and evidence presented in the revision.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The allegation of non-occupation is incorrect and was not pleaded in an earlier ejectment petition; the petitioners argued the non-user plea was not raised previously and that the pleadings lack particulars and specificity (no date or period specified).
  • The evidence adduced by the respondent is insufficient to prove non-use; the petitioners emphasized that the respondent's witnesses gave vague or unreliable evidence.
  • The pleadings were drafted merely by reproducing the statutory wording and were therefore too vague to support an order of eviction.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioners became tenants by operation of law after the death of Pritam Singh and have ceased to occupy the shop without sufficient cause.
  • The earlier ejectment petition relied upon by the petitioners did not pertain to the present shop, so non-mention of non-user in that earlier petition is immaterial.
  • The respondent relied on witness testimony that the shop was found closed and had remained closed for years; the respondent further relied on legal authority permitting adverse inferences where tenants fail to produce available evidence (citing Gopal Krishnaji Ketkar v. Mohamed Haji Latif & Others).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gopal Krishnaji Ketkar v. Mohamed Haji Latif & Others Supports drawing an adverse inference when a party (here, tenants) fails to produce evidence within their control (e.g., books of account, proof of electricity supply). The court relied on this authority to justify drawing an adverse inference against the petitioners for not producing evidence (books of account, proof of electricity supply) when the petitioner claimed to be using the shop despite absence of an electric meter and lack of other supporting evidence.
Puran Singh Tailor Master v. Ram Murti (son of Narain Dass) A Single Judge dismissed an eviction petition on the ground that allegations of non-occupation were vague; mere reproduction of statutory wording was held insufficient in that case. The court considered this decision but declined to follow it because the Supreme Court has taken a different view regarding loosely drafted pleadings; therefore the earlier Single Judge decision did not assist petitioners.
Karam Chand Joshi v. Shri Kartar Singh Cited in Puran Singh Tailor Master as supporting strictness about pleadings (as understood from the Single Judge's reasoning). The court noted that Karam Chand Joshi is also a Single Judge judgment of the same High Court and observed that the Supreme Court's contrary views prevail over these Single Judge rulings.
Madan Gopal Kanodia v. Mamrai (Maniram) Supreme Court principle that pleadings are often loosely drafted and courts should not defeat genuine claims on trivial technicalities; courts should not scrutinise pleadings with undue formalism. The court relied on paragraph 26 of this Supreme Court judgment to reject the petitioners' contention that vague pleadings alone should defeat the eviction claim; this authority weighed in favour of allowing evidence to prevail over minor pleading deficiencies.
Smt. Manjushri Raha v. B.L. Gupta Holds that pleadings should be interpreted with latitude and courts should be aware of low legal literacy; lack of precise legal phrasing does not preclude relief where facts and proof are clear. The court cited this decision to reinforce the proposition that loosely drafted pleadings should not bar relief; it supported the conclusion that the respondent should not be non-suited purely on the basis of pleading form.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court summarized and evaluated the evidence and legal arguments as follows:

  1. Evidence concerning non-use:
    • AW1 (Puran Chand Aggarwal, Draftsman) deposed that when he went to see the disputed shop it was found closed; he stated he sees the shop almost daily and proved the site plan (Ex.A-1).
    • AW2 (Mohan Lal, Postman) deposed that he used to see Pritam Singh at the shop about four years ago, but since Pritam Singh's death (three years back) he has seen the demised shop lying closed for about 3 to 3¼ years and has never seen it open in that period. He admitted the family of Pritam Singh resides in another portion of the same building but never went into the demised shop to deliver letters.
    • RW1 (Daljit Singh, petitioner) deposed that he sells and hires electric fans and that he runs his business in the demised premises, asserting the shop was not kept closed for any length of time. In cross-examination he admitted he also runs another shop in Main Bazar, has no servant or mechanic, is the only son, is not an income-tax payer, and currently there is no electric metre in the demised premises. He denied that he had ceased to occupy the shop since October 1975.
  2. On the effect of the earlier ejectment petition: The court examined the certified copy of the earlier plaint (Ex.R.2) and found it related to an upper storey residential portion (8/113 A upper storey Dal Chand building) and not to the present shop. Therefore, non-mention of non-user in that earlier petition did not undermine the respondent's present evidence about non-use of the shop in question.
  3. Assessment of credibility and sufficiency of evidence:
    • The appellate authority accepted the respondent's case over the petitioners' denials. The High Court found no reason to disturb that appellate authority finding.
    • The court highlighted specific facts adverse to the petitioners' claim of continued use: absence of an electric meter in the demised premises, the petitioners' admission of operating another shop in the main bazar, the petitioners' lack of any assistant (no mechanic or servant), and that Daljit examined only himself without corroborating evidence (no witnesses, no books of account, no documentary proof of electricity supply).
    • The court held that, as the tenants would be best placed to produce evidence of use (books, electricity receipts, other witnesses), their failure to produce such evidence permitted drawing an adverse inference, citing Gopal Krishnaji Ketkar v. Mohamed Haji Latif & Others.
  4. On the pleading vagueness point:
    • The rent petition's pleading stated: "That the respondents have ceased to occupy the shop in question for a continuous period of more than four months without sufficient cause."
    • The petitioners relied on a Single Judge decision (Puran Singh Tailor Master v. Ram Murti) that dismissed an ejectment petition for vagueness. However, the court contrasted that view with Supreme Court authorities (Madan Gopal Kanodia and Smt. Manjushri Raha) that admonish courts not to defeat genuine claims on trivial pleading technicalities and that pleadings be read with latitude.
    • Applying the Supreme Court's approach, the court concluded that the petitioners could not be non-suited purely because the rent petition reproduced statutory wording without more particularity; the evidence must be the decisive factor rather than a formalistic striking down for imprecise pleading.
  5. Conclusion of analysis:
    • Given the evidence accepted by the appellate authority (shop observed closed repeatedly; long period of closure per AW2; petitioners' admissions of lack of electric metre and absence of corroborating evidence), the court found no reason to disturb the appellate authority's finding that the tenant ceased to occupy the shop for a continuous period of four months without reasonable cause.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is dismissed and the appellate authority's finding — that the tenant has ceased to occupy the building for a continuous period of four months without reasonable cause — is upheld.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the eviction order obtained by the respondent (landlord) is sustained and the petitioners' revision is unsuccessful.
  • The court applied existing case law (including Supreme Court authorities) to decline to non-suit the landlord on grounds of pleading form and to permit an adverse inference where tenants failed to produce available corroborative evidence. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond applying and reconciling prior authority to the facts of this case.

R.M.S
Petition dismissed.

This summary is confined exclusively to the content and reasoning present in the provided opinion. No facts or legal conclusions beyond those contained in the opinion have been added.

Show all summary ...

S.S Sudhalkar, J.:— The respondent-landlord had filed petition for ejectment of the petitioners before the Rent Controller, Ferozepore. The same was dismissed. The appeal filed by the respondent before the appellate authority was allowed and hence the petitioner-tenants have filed this revision petition.

2. The shop which the petitioners are occupying is the subject matter of the rent petition. Ground for eviction is that the petitioners have ceased to occupy the said shop without any cause since the death of original tenant Pritam Singh. It may be stated that in the very building there is another part in which the petitioners are tenants. However, the petition and this appeal are confined to the shop only.

3. The contentions of the respondent is that Pritam Singh was the original tenant in the shop and the petitioners became tenants by operation of law after the death of Pritam Singh. The contention of the petitioners is that the plea of non-occupation of the premises is incorrect and it was not taken in an earlier petition. It may be mentioned that the prayer for arrears of rent does not arise in view of the fact that no issue in this regard is framed. In this revision also, the arguments are confined to the issue of non-user only.

4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioners has argued that except the allegation that the petitioners have ceased to occupy the shop in question for a continuous period of more than four months without sufficient cause, there is no specific pleadings as to since when the shop is not being used and that no particulars were given. He has pointed out that the allegation of non-user was not taken in another ejectment petition which was dismissed on 31.7.78 He has contended that earlier petition was filed on 15.5.78 while the present ejectment petition was filed on 8.6.78

6. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also argued that the evidence led by the respondent is not sufficient to prove that the demised premises are not used. A.W.1 is Puran Chand Aggarwal, Draftsman. He has deposed that when he went to see the disputed shop it was found closed. In the cross-examination, he has stated that he is seeing the shop almost daily. He has proved the site plan Ex.A-1.

7. AW2 is Mohan Lal. He is a Postman and has deposed that about four years back, he used to see Pritam Singh sitting at the shop and that he used to see a few electric fans laying in the shop. Pritam Singh had died three years back and he also deposed that from the last 3 or 3-¼ years he is seeing the demised shop lying closed and that during that period he has never seen the shop open. This witness has admitted the fact that the family of Pritam Singh resides in Dal Chand Building (it is the same building) but that portion is a different portion from the demised shop. He has of course stated that he never went to the said shop to deliver any letter. Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the deposition of this witness (AW2) is vague and cannot be relied upon. As against this learned counsel for the respondent has relied on the deposition of the Daljit Singh-petitioner who has been examined as RW1. He has stated in the deposition that he sells electric fans and also gives fans on hire basis. He has also stated that he is running his business in the demised premises and that he never kept the demise premises closed for any length of time. In the cross examination he has stated that he also runs his business in a shop in Main Bazar, Ferozepore Cantt. He has stated that he has never been employed anywhere so far. He has stated that he is the only son of his parents and that he opens his shop in the main market regularly and the demise premises as well. He has also stated that he is not Income Tax payer. He has admitted that he has no mechanic or servant and that he works alone. He has also stated that there is no electric metre in the demised premises at present. In reply to a suggestion made to him that he has ceased to occupy the demised premises continuously since the death of his father i.e October, 1975, he has stated that it is not correct.

8. Regarding the prior ejectment petition learned counsel for the respondent has stated that the said ejectment petition did not pertain to the shop in question in this ejectment petition and, therefore, the raising of plea of non-user of the shop did not arise. It is not disputed that in the very building, there is a residential premises of the petitioner, certified copy of the plaint in the earlier ejectment petition is at Ex.R.2 A perusal of the same shows that it does not pertain to the present shop in question. The description of the premises is in the heading of that plaint. It is as under:

“Application under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 for an order directing the respondent to deliver the actual possession of 8/113 A upper storey Dal Chand building, Ferozepore Cantt.”

9. Therefore, the non-mention of the non-user of the present shop in the said petition does not go against the evidence led by the respondent.

10. Considering all the evidence, the appellate authority has rejected the stand taken by the petitioners and accepted the case of the respondent. There is no reason to show why the finding of the appellate authority should be disturbed. The petitioner, though according to him is using the shop and is selling the electric fans etc., has admitted that there is no electric metre in the demised premises at present. He has not shown as to from where he is getting the electricity. Moreover he has no servant or mechanic to help him and he is having another shop in the main bazar. He cannot run both the shops alone. Moreover, the petitioner Daljit has examined himself only as his witness and has not produced any other evidence. If the petitioners are using the shop in question, they are the persons having best evidence regarding its use. If the petitioner are taking electricity from somewhere else, they could have shown the same. The petitioners could have produced their books of account and when this not done, adverse inference can also be drawn against them in view of the judgment in Gopal Krishnaji Ketkar v. Mohamed Haji Latif & Others Latif,1.

11. When it is held that the appellants are not using the shop, it is also found that no reason is stated by the appellants as to why they are not using it and, therefore, there is no reasonable cause shown by them for the same.

12. In view of the above reasons, finding of appellate authority that the tenant has ceased to occupy the building for a continuous period of four months without reasonable cause cannot be disturbed.

13. Learned counsel for the petitioners further argued that the pleadings in support of non-user of the premises are vague and, therefore, no eviction order can be passed because of the same. In the rent petition, the pleadings in this regard are as under:

“That the respondents have ceased to occupy the shop in question for a continuous period of more than four months without sufficient cause.”

14. Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the landlord-respondent has mentioned nothing except mentioning the law on this point and hence eviction order cannot be upheld. The relevant provision in the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) reads as under:—

“that where the building is situated in a place other than a hill station, the tenant has ceased to occupy the building for a continuous period of four months without reasonable cause.”

15. Learned counsel for the petitioners has cited before me the case in titled Puran Singh Tailor Master v. Ram Murti sort of Narain Dass,2. In that case the learned Single Judge of this Court had dismissed the petition for eviction on the ground that the allegations were quite vague. Learned Single Judge has referred to the above mentioned provision of the Act. Learned Single Judge has observed in the said case as under:—

“Apart from that, the allegations in the ejectment application to this effect are very vague. What has been stated in paragraph 5 thereof is” that the respondent has permanently shifted his residence and business to the above mentioned address and is not occupying the portion in question for the last about four months continuously.” In the reply filed thereto, it has been stated that the respondent and his family had been and is living in the house in question and the children of the petitioner are getting education in D.C Model School and D.A.V College, Ferozepore. Thus, the allegations made in the application were quite vague, as no period during which the tenant ceased to occupy the premises was mentioned therein. Merely the reproduction of the wording of statute was not sufficient to warrant the order of ejectment. Reference in this respect be made to Karam Chand Joshi v. Shri Kartar Singh).

16. The question, therefore, now comes for my consideration is that the respondents can be non-suited by holding that his plea in the rent petition is vague. The Supreme Court has taken a different view in the case of Madan Gopal Kanodia v. Mamrai Maniram,3 It has been observed in paragraph 26 of that case as under:

“………We are unable to see any substantial variation between the pleadings of the plaintiff and the evidence led by him at the trial. It is well settled that pleadings are loosely drafted in the Courts and the Courts should not scrutinise the pleading with such meticulous care so as to result in genuine claims being defeated on trivial grounds. In our opinion, the finding of the High Court that there was wide gap between the pleadings and the proof is not at all borne out from the record of the present case.”

17. Again in the case of Smt. Manjushri Raha v. B.L Gupta,4 it has been observed as under:—

“We have perused the plaint before the Claims Tribunal, which is rather loosely drafted, but it clearly contains the relief of compensation even against Gupta and Ram Swaroop driver. The High Court has pointed out that even though there is no clear plea of negligence in the claim of Raha, the facts alleged and proved in the case clearly show that Ram Swaroop the driver of the said Roadways Company was both rash and negligent. Pleadings have to be interpreted not with formalistic rigour but with latitude or awareness of low legal literacy of poor people.”

18. Because of the above view taken by the Supreme Court I find that the petitioners cannot get any help from the judgment in me case of Puran Singh Tailor Master v. Ram Murti son of Narain (supra). The judgment in the case of Karam Chand Joshi v. Shri Kartar Singh (supra) cited by the learned Single Judge in his judgment in the case of Puran Singh Tailor Master v. Ram Murti son of Marain Dass (supra) is also a judgment of Single Judge of this court and, therefore, the view taken by the Supreme Court shall prevail.

19. Keeping in mind the principle laid down by the Supreme Court when the respondent in the eviction petition pleaded that the tenant has ceased to occupy the shop in question for a continuous period of four months without sufficient cause, I find no reason to deprive the respondent of the order of eviction which he had obtained in view of the Supreme Court judgments quoted above.

20. In the result, this petition is without merit and deserves to be dismissed. The same is hereby dismissed.

R.M.S
Petition dismissed.