- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chanda v. Rattni And Anr
Factual and Procedural Background
The defendants-respondents entered into an agreement dated 25.3.1989 to sell land measuring 54 Kanals 13 Marlas to the plaintiff and received Rs.56,000 as earnest money. The sale deed was to be executed on or before 15.6.1989 upon payment of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 1,39,000. Since the defendants failed to execute the sale deed within the stipulated time, the plaintiff instituted a suit on 24.1.1990 for specific performance of the agreement. The suit was decreed ex parte on 1.5.1992, and the decree became final. The decree directed the defendants to execute the sale deed within two months upon payment of the balance sale price, failing which the plaintiff was authorized to get the deed executed through the Court under Order 21 Rule 12 CPC.
The plaintiff did not deposit the balance sale price within two months, nor did the defendants execute the sale deed. The plaintiff filed an execution application on 10.10.1992 seeking the Court's intervention to execute the sale deed and to be allowed to deposit the balance price in Court. During the pendency of this application, Sarup Singh applied to be impleaded as a party, claiming ownership of the suit land based on a decree dated 26.7.1991. The executing Court allowed his impleadment, but later dismissed his objections to the execution application, holding he was not a bona fide purchaser.
On 8.9.1998, the defendants-respondents filed an application under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act seeking rescission of the agreement to sell dated 25.3.1989 on the ground that the plaintiff failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the time allowed by the Court. The trial Court, after hearing the parties, allowed the application on 15.9.1998, rescinding the original contract and dismissing the plaintiff's execution application. The plaintiff filed the present revision petition challenging this order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial Court was justified in rescinding the agreement to sell under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act on the ground that the plaintiff failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the period prescribed in the decree?
- Whether the plaintiff was entitled to have the sale deed executed through the Court despite not depositing the balance sale price within the stipulated time?
- Whether the subsequent claims of ownership by third parties (Sarup Singh and Rajinder) affect the validity of the rescission of the original agreement?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner-Plaintiff's Arguments
- The decree for specific performance directed the defendants to execute the sale deed within two months upon payment of the balance sale price, but did not explicitly direct the plaintiff to deposit the balance sale consideration within any stipulated period.
- The trial Court erred in rescinding the contract on the ground of non-deposit of the balance sale price by the plaintiff.
- The defendants had sold the land to Rajinder (son-in-law of Sarup Singh) by an agreement dated 10.7.1991, and Sarup Singh claims ownership based on a decree dated 26.7.1991; since the defendants had washed their hands of the suit land, the original agreement should not have been rescinded.
Respondents-Defendants' Arguments
- The plaintiff failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the period prescribed in the decree.
- Accordingly, the Court was justified in rescinding the contract under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Onkar Nath and Anr. v. Basheer and Ors., (1985-2) 88 P.L.R. 432 | Supports rescission of contract under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act when the plaintiff defaults in payment as ordered by the Court in a decree for specific performance. | The Court relied on this precedent to uphold the trial Court's order rescinding the agreement due to plaintiff's failure to deposit the balance sale consideration within the prescribed period. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the decree for specific performance which directed the defendants to execute the sale deed within two months upon payment of the balance sale price. The Court interpreted this direction as implicitly requiring the plaintiff to deposit the balance sale consideration within the stipulated period, making payment a condition precedent for execution of the sale deed by the defendants. Since the plaintiff admittedly failed to deposit the balance amount, the defendants were not obliged to execute the sale deed.
Given the plaintiff's default, the defendants were entitled to seek rescission of the agreement under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act. The Court noted that the plaintiff did not seek any extension of time to deposit the balance consideration. The Court further held that the claims and impleadment of Sarup Singh and subsequent purchasers were irrelevant to the question of rescission of the original agreement. The Court found support for this reasoning in the cited precedent, affirming that rescission is justified when the plaintiff defaults in payment as ordered by the Court.
Accordingly, the Court found no error in the trial Court's order rescinding the agreement and dismissing the execution application.
Holding and Implications
The Court DISMISSED the revision petition, thereby upholding the trial Court's order dated 15.9.1998 rescinding the agreement to sell dated 25.3.1989 and dismissing the execution application.
The direct effect of this decision is that the original contract between the parties stands rescinded due to the plaintiff's failure to deposit the balance sale consideration within the prescribed time. No new precedent was established, and the decision primarily enforces the principle that compliance with payment terms in a decree for specific performance is a condition precedent for execution of sale deeds and that default therein justifies rescission under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act.
1. This is a plaintiff's revision petition directed against the order dated 15.9.1998 passed by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kaithal rescinding the agreement to sell dated 25.3.1989 and dismissing the execution application. Facts giving rise to this petition may first be noticed.
2. Defendants-respondents entered into an agreement dated 25.3.1989 to sell land measuring 54 Kanals 13 Marlas to the plaintiff and received Rs.56,000/- as earnest money. The sale deed was to be executed on or before 15.6.1989 on payment of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 1,39,000/-. Since the defendants did not execute the sale deed within the time specified in the agreement the plaintiff-petitioner instituted a suit on 24.1.1990 for specific performance of the agreement to sell. The suit was decreed ex parte on 1.5.1992 and it is common case of the parties that the decree has become final between them. Para 6 of the judgment of the trial Court decreeing the suit reads as under:-
"For the reasons discussed above, the suit succeeds. A decree for possession of the suit land by way of specific performance is hereby passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants with costs. Defendants are directed to execute the proposed sale deed on payment of the balance sale price of Rs. 1,39,000/- and get it registered within a period of two months from the date of this decree failing which the plaintiff shall be at liberty to get the sale deed executed and registered under Order 21 Rule 12 C.P.C. Decree be drawn up accordingly and file the consigned to the record room."
3. The plaintiff did not deposit the balance sale price within two months from the date of the decree nor did the defendants execute the sale deed. Plaintiff then moved an application on 10.10.1992 for the execution of the decree pleading therein that since the judgment debtor respondents had failed to execute the sale deed the same be executed through Court and that he (plaintiff) be allowed to deposit the balance sale price in Court. During the pendency of this application one Sarup Singh through his general attorney moved an application for being impleaded as a party in the execution proceedings on the plea that he was the owner in possession of the suit land on the basis of a decree dated 26.7.1991 which the defendants are alleged to have suffered in his favour. The executing Court as per its order dated 14.8.1995 allowed the applicant to be impleaded in the execution proceedings. Sarup Singh then filed objections to the execution application which were dismissed as per order dated 10.9.1998 and it was held that he was not a bona fide purchaser of the suit land. On 8.9.1998 the judgment debtors-respondents moved an application under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act (for short the Act) with a prayer that the agreement to sell dated 25.3.1989 be rescinded since the plaintiff-petitioner had failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the time allowed by the Court. This application was contested by the petitioner-plaintiff and on a consideration of the contentions advanced by the counsel for the parties the trial Court as per its order dated 15.9.1998 allowed the application and rescinded the original contract dated 25.3.1989 holding that the plaintiff had failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the time allowed by the Court. The execution application filed by the plaintiff-petitioner was consequently dismissed. Hence the present revision petition.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has assailed the impugned order of the trial Court on the ground that the Court while decreeing the suit for specific performance had directed the defendants-respondents to execute the sale deed within two months from the date of the decree and since they failed to do that the plaintiff was entitled to have the sale deed executed through Court. He referred to para 6 of the judgment to contend that since there was no direction given to the plaintiff to deposit the balance sale consideration within a stipulated period the trial Court grossly erred in law in rescinding the contract on account of non deposit of the balance sale price by the plaintiff. He also contended that the defendants-respondents claim to have sold the land to Rajinder son-in-law of Sarup Singh as per agreement to sell dated 10.7.1991 and that Sarup Singh claims to have become the owner thereof by virtue of the decree dated 26.7.1991 and since the defendants have washed their hands of the suit land the original agreement dated 25.3.1989 should not have been rescinded.
5. Shri R.K. Gupta learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, contended that since the plaintiff did not deposit the balance sale consideration within the period prescribed in the decree the Court was justified in rescinding the contract under Section 28 of the Act.
6. Having given my thoughtful consideration to the rival contentions of the parties, I find merit in what is contended on behalf of the defendants-respondents. A perusal of para 6 of the judgment of the trial Court as reproduced above whereby the suit for specific performance was decreed makes it clear that the defendants had been directed to execute the sale deed within two months from the date of the decree on payment of the balance sale price of Rs. 1,39,000/-. Payment of the balance sale consideration was, therefore, a condition precedent for the execution of the sale deed. It is implicit in the direction that the plaintiff was required to deposit the balance sale consideration within the stipulated period in the first instance and it was only then that the defendants were required to execute the sale deed. Admittedly, the plaintiff has not deposited the balance sale consideration so far. Since he failed to perform his part of the obligation under the decree the defendants were not obliged to execute the sale deed. Now when the suit for specific performance was decreed and the plaintiff failed to deposit the balance sale consideration within the period fixed by the Court the defendants had a right to ask the Court to rescind the agreement to sell because of the default committed by the plaintiff. It is not the case of the plaintiff-petitioner that he ever applied for extension of time to the Court. Section 28 of the Act is clear and enables the Court to rescind the contract where in pursuance to the decree for specific performance the plaintiff makes default in the payment of the purchase money or other sum as ordered to be paid by the court. In this view of the matter, no fault can be found with the impugned order. The fact that Sarup Singh was impleaded as a party in the execution proceedings or that the objections filed by him were dismissed by the executing Court of that the defendants claim to have sold the land to any subsequent purchaser are not relevant for the purpose of determining whether the trial Court was justified in rescinding the agreement to sell. The view that I have taken finds support from a judgment of this Court in Onkar Nath and Anr. v. Basheer and Ors., (1985-2)88 P.L.R. 432.
7. In the result, the revision petition fails and the same stands dismissed. There is no order as to costs.
Alert