Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Expo Expert Private Ltd. v. Jai Gopal Angrish And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
May 29, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under sections 541, 542 and 543 of the Companies Act, 1956, read with section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure and rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, was filed by the official liquidator on behalf of Xpo Xpert Private Limited (in liquidation). The petitioner sought a declaration that respondents Nos. 1 to 5 (the ex-managing director and ex-directors) were guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust and should be held jointly and severally liable, without limitation, for debts and unauthenticated expenditure amounting to Rs. 3,20,842; a decree for that amount; contribution to the company’s assets; and interest at 12% per annum from the winding-up date (22 September 1983).

Relevant corporate facts proved on record: Xpo Xpert Private Limited was incorporated on 29 November 1977 with paid-up capital of Rs. 2,30,500 (4,910 equity shares of Rs.100 each) and authorised capital of Rs.10,00,000. The company was ordered wound up on 22 September 1983 and the official liquidator attached to the court was appointed. The official liquidator was authorised by a subsequent order (9 January 1986) to file or defend legal proceedings in the name of the company.

The petition alleged (i) that certain amounts due to the company had become time-barred before liquidation because the ex-directors failed to take steps to recover them; (ii) that some sums could not be recovered because the ex-directors did not furnish correct addresses to the liquidator; and (iii) that Rs. 1,80,052 was shown in the cash book as spent under various heads but unsupported by vouchers or authentication by the ex-directors. The petition was accompanied by an affidavit and annexures.

Respondents Nos. 1–3 and 5 filed a joint reply denying misfeasance and breach of trust, asserting efforts had been made to recover debts and that no suit was filed on professional advice; they also denied that the liquidator had sought addresses as alleged. Respondent No. 4 was alleged by the respondents to have ceased being a director.

On the parties’ pleadings, six issues were framed and the official liquidator led evidence by three witnesses (PW‑1: a Registrar of Companies official; PW‑2: the chartered accountant who audited the accounts; PW‑3: the official liquidator himself). The contesting respondents led no evidence and did not appear as witnesses.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition discloses any cause of action under sections 541, 542 and 543 of the Companies Act, 1956? (OPP)
  2. Whether the petition discloses commission or omission or any act of misfeasance or misappropriation or breach of trust or fraud in respect of the duties of the respondents as directors of the company? (OPP)
  3. Whether due to the mismanagement, negligence and misconduct of the respondents the debts of the company have become time-barred; if so, to what effect? (OPP)
  4. Whether the respondents are personally liable to pay the amount as claimed in the petition to the official liquidator? (OPP)
  5. Whether respondent No. 4 was not a director of the company with effect from 7 December 1982; if so, to what effect? (OPR)
  6. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The ex-managing director and ex-directors committed misfeasance and breach of trust in managing the company and are therefore liable jointly and severally under sections 541, 542 and 543 of the Companies Act to make good the losses and repay the sums identified by the official liquidator (total Rs. 3,20,842).
  • Specific amounts had become time-barred prior to the winding-up order; other amounts became time-barred because ex-directors failed to provide correct addresses despite repeated intimations; and a large sum (Rs. 1,80,052) had no supporting vouchers or authentication.
  • Reliance was placed on a series of authorities supporting the proposition that directors may be made personally liable for misfeasance or breach of trust and for failing to take steps to realize company debts.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Mere inaction or failure to recover debts does not automatically amount to misfeasance or breach of trust; liability requires proof of violation of the duty cast on the director.
  • Attempts were made to recover debts and, on advice received, no suit was filed; therefore the debts becoming time-barred was not due to negligence.
  • The allegation that correct addresses were not furnished is an assertion without proof and the liquidator did not prove a failure to request or receive addresses as alleged.
  • Reliance was placed on Faridabad Rubber Soles (P.) Ltd. v. S.L. Chopra (1994) 3 PLR 78, where the court found directors were not liable because the company premises (and books) were locked by the bank, preventing access and action by directors; respondents argued this authority applied by analogy.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.A. Tendolkar v. Official Liquidator, [1967] 37 Comp Cas 392 (Mysore) This authority is cited for the proposition that where a director has misapplied, retained or become accountable for company money or property, or been guilty of misfeasance or breach of trust, the court may compel repayment or contribution to the company's assets. The court cited this decision to support the court's power to compel delinquent directors to repay or compensate the company and to justify ordering contribution by directors where loss is shown.
Smart Advertising Co. (P.) Ltd. (In Liquidation) v. Ramesh K. Nanchahal, [1989] 65 Comp Cas 92 (P & H) Applied the principle that where directors fail to take action to realize debts and the debts become time-barred before winding up, a decree against the director and managing director for the debts is appropriate (relying on P.K. Nedungadi). The court relied on this view as analogous support for ordering directors to reimburse the company for debts that became time-barred due to inaction.
P.K. Nedungadi v. Malayalee Bank Ltd., (1971) 3 SCC 598 : AIR 1971 SC 829; [1972] 42 Comp Cas 120 Establishes that it is not essential to prove fraud to hold directors liable; liability may arise from misfeasance or breach of trust (including breach of duty and misapplication of assets). The petitioner must prove (i) breach of duty/misfeasance/breach of trust and (ii) loss arising therefrom. The court applied this principle to hold that fraud need not be shown, only misfeasance/breach and resultant loss; it required the petitioner to establish breach and loss and found those elements satisfied on the record.
Official Liquidator, Supreme Bank Ltd. v. P.A. Tendolkar, [1973] 43 Comp Cas 382; (1973) 1 SCC 602 : AIR 1973 SC 1104 Holds that whether a director is liable for misfeasance is a question of fact; a director who fails to act with reasonable care or turns a blind eye to what is obvious may be held liable even absent proof of specific dishonest acts. Negligence enabling fraud suffices for liability. The court quoted this decision at length and used it to conclude that directors may be held liable for dereliction of duties where negligence of such character enabled losses; the court found respondents' inaction and failure to explain supported liability under this principle.
Official Liquidator v. Raghawa Desikachar, [1975] 45 Comp Cas 136 (SC) The decision was cited among authorities dealing with liability of directors for misfeasance or breach of trust. The opinion records this case as part of the list of authorities relied on by the petitioner; the text does not set out a specific, detailed application of its ratio within the body of the judgment.
Faridabad Rubber Soles (P.) Ltd. v. S.L. Chopra, [1994] 3 PLR 78 Applied for the proposition that where directors have no access to books/records because premises were locked by a bank, they may be excused from liability for failure to take recovery steps. The court considered this authority and distinguished it on its facts: in that case the directors had no access to books due to the lock; in the present case there was no such factual impediment and the defendants adduced no evidence to show any such excuse.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a fact‑based analysis grounded in the evidence led by the official liquidator and the legal standards in sections 541–543 of the Companies Act.

Evidence and factual findings:

  • The official liquidator produced documentary evidence and called three witnesses: PW‑1 (Registrar of Companies employee) who produced registration/annual return and Form 32; PW‑2 (chartered accountant) who audited the accounts and produced audit reports and stated the accounts were incomplete; and PW‑3 (the official liquidator) who examined the company records.
  • On review of records PW‑3 found certain recoveries had become time-barred prior to the liquidation order: a list of amounts totaling Rs. 1,30,620 (list "A").
  • PW‑3 also found Rs. 5,069 (list "B") could not be recovered because the ex-directors did not supply correct addresses despite intimations; the chartered accountant reported Rs. 1,80,052 recorded in the cash book was unsupported by vouchers or authentication.
  • The contesting respondents did not produce any evidence or testify to rebut these factual assertions or explain the unexplained expenditure.

Legal application:

  • The court explained the relevant statutory provisions: section 541 (liability where proper books not kept), section 542 (liability for carrying on business with intent to defraud), and section 543 (assessment of damages against delinquent directors and time limit for application).
  • The court applied the principles from the cited authorities (notably Official Liquidator, Supreme Bank Ltd.; P.K. Nedungadi; P.A. Tendolkar; Smart Advertising), emphasizing that directors may be held liable for misfeasance or breach of trust where negligence or a breach of duty enables losses—even if fraud is not proved. The standard is whether a director acted reasonably, honestly and with due diligence; turning a blind eye to obvious matters can be culpable.
  • Applying these principles to the proved facts, the court found (i) the amounts in list "A" had become time-barred because no steps were taken to recover them though recoveries could have been pursued within three years of last transaction; (ii) amounts in list "B" became time-barred because the ex-directors did not supply correct addresses as required; (iii) Rs. 1,80,052 lacked vouchers and explanation and thus could not be shown to have been properly expended for company purposes.
  • Because the contestants led no evidence to explain or rebut the official liquidator's case, the court treated the official liquidator's case as established on those points and held the pertinent respondents liable accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Petition allowed in part: a decree for Rs. 3,20,842 (with interest) was passed against respondents Nos. 1 to 3 and 5; the claim against respondent No. 4 was dismissed.

Specific orders and immediate consequences:

  • The court directed a decree for Rs. 3,20,842 in favour of the petitioner (official liquidator) and against respondents Nos. 1–3 and 5, together with interest at 12% per annum from 22 September 1983 until realisation.
  • The petitioner's claim against respondent No. 4 was dismissed because he was not found to be a director of the company as alleged.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications:

  • The decision applies established principles that directors may be held personally liable for misfeasance or breach of trust where a breach of duty and resulting loss are proved and where negligence or dereliction of duty enabled losses — fraud need not be established.
  • The opinion does not purport to set a new legal precedent; it applies existing authorities to the facts before the court. The ruling’s practical effect is to hold the named ex-directors personally liable to reimburse the company (via the official liquidator) for the specific sums found to have been lost or made time-barred, with interest as directed.

Show all summary ...

N.K Kapoor, J.:— This is a petition under sections 541, 542, 543 of the Companies Act, 1956, read with section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure and rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, for a declaration that respondents Nos. 1 to 5 be held guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust in relation to the affairs of the company and its creditors and thus be held responsible jointly and severally without any limitation of liability for all debts/unauthenticated expenditure as given in paragraphs 10, 11, 12 and 13 in all amounting to Rs. 3,20,842, a decree be passed in favour of the petitioner-company and against respondents Nos. 1 to 5 jointly and severally and they be directed to contribute jointly and severally to the assets of the company and to pay the amount to the official liquidator or such sum which the court may determine along with interest at the rate of 12 per cent. per annum from the date of winding up of the company, i.e, September 22, 1983, till its realisation along with costs. The case set up by the petitioner is that Xpo Xpert Private Limited was incorporated on November 29, 1977, having its registered office at S-146, Industrial Area, Sodal Chowk, Jalandhar. The paid-up capital of the company was Rs. 2,30,500 which was divided into 4,910 equity shares of Rs. 100 each, i.e, Rs. 50 called and paid up and Rs. 15,000 remaining unpaid capital. The authorised capital of the company was Rs. 10,00,000 divided into 10,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each. The main object of the company before it went into liquidation was export and import of all kinds of merchandise, machinery, equipment, articles, manufactured or otherwise processed. A winding up order of the company has already been passed on September 22, 1983, and the official liquidator attached to this court has been appointed as liquidator of the company. The official liquidator has been authorised to file or defend any suit, claim petition, prosecution or other legal proceedings, civil or criminal, in the name and on behalf of the company as per order dated January 9, 1986, passed in Company Petition No. 87 of 1985. As per averment in the petition, respondent No. 1 is the exmanaging director and respondents Nos. 2 to 5 are ex-directors of the company. All these persons were taking active part in day-to-day affairs of the company during the course of its functioning. According to the petitioner, acts of the respondents in connection with functioning of the company and its management have been found to be fraudulent and against the interest of the company and its creditors. They are, therefore, guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust in relation to the company and thus liable for such acts of commission and omission severally and jointly. Though the ex-directors of the company were required to submit the statement of affairs on or before October 7, 1983, yet they submitted the statement of affairs on June 8, 1985. The official liquidator on taking the control of the company found that the following amounts due from the parties has become time barred. The detail is as under:

Name of party Date of last transaction Amount including interest up to August, 1983 (Rs.) (1) Sun “N” Star High Street Market, Birmingham U.K 21-5-81 1,19,100 (2) Diwan Industrial Corporation Kalasia Gali, Ludhiana. 14-8-81 1,550 (3) Gothwal Machinery Stores, Agra Road, Dausa (Raj) 14-9-79 8,500 (4) Novelty Hardwar Store, Tripolia Bazar, Jaipur 09-7-80 1,075 (5) Kumar Sons, Sadar Bazar) New Delhi. 19-2-80 395 Total 1,30,620

2. Similarly, a sum of Rs. 5,069 became time barred as despite numerous intimations given to the ex-directors to furnish the correct addresses of the parties, no reply was received and so this amount too has become time barred. The detail is given as under:

Name of party Amount (Rs.) (1) Sadafal Hardware 397 (2) Pradeep Hardware Store 136 (3) Rajesh Kumar Gopal Chander 1,459 (4) Ram Bartan Bhandar 1,475 (5) Bhagwan Dass Phool Chand 694 (6) Anand Prakash Goyal 800 (7) U.P Crockery House 109 Total 5,069

3. Similarly, the official liquidator as per report submitted by the chartered accountant found that a sum of Rs. 1,80,052 stated to have been spent under different heads of expenses as per entry in the cash book is, however, not supported by any voucher nor the same has been authenticated by ex-directors of the company. With these broad averments, a prayer has been made that the ex-directors of the company—respondents Nos. 1 to 5—be held jointly and severally liable and directed to pay this amount to the official liquidator along with interest at the rate of 12 per cent. per annum till actual payment is made. This petition is duly accompanied by an affidavit. Necessary annexures in support of the claim laid too had been annexed with the petition. A joint reply has been filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 3 and 5. The respondents in their reply have stated that respondent No. 4 was not a director of the company whereas the remaining being members of the board of directors were conducting the business of the company. The respondents have denied/controverted the various material averments made in the petition. The respondents have specifically denied the charge that they are guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust in relation to the affairs of the company or that there have been acts of omission and commission on their behalf. As regards the various amounts which have become time barred, it has been stated that all efforts were made to recover the amount but they failed and the amount could not be recovered and on the advice received no suit was filed. Similarly, the answering respondents denied that the liquidator ever.demanded the addresses. It was thus prayed that the petition be dismissed.

4. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed:

(1) Whether the petition discloses any cause of action under sections 541, 542 and 543 of the Companies Act, 1956? OPP

(2) Whether the petition as filed discloses commission or omission or any act of misfeasance or misappropriation or breach of trust or fraud in respect of the duties of the respondents as directors of the company? OPP

(3) Whether due to the mismanagement, negligence and misconduct of the respondents the debts of the company have become time-barred, if so, to what effect? OPP

(4) Whether the respondents are personally liable to pay the amount as claimed in the petition to the official liquidator? OPP

(5) Whether respondent No. 4 was not the director of the company with effect from December 7, 1982? If so, to what effect? OPR

(6) Relief.

5. The official liquidator examined Harbagh Singh, UDC, in the office of the Registrar of Companies, Jalandhar, as PW-1; Mr. Rajnish Mittal, chartered accountant of Datta Singla and Company as PW-2 and appeared as his own witness as PW-3 in support of the petition. PW-1 Harbagh Singh on the basis of record deposed that at the time of winding up of the company, i.e, on September 22, 1983, Jai Gopal Angris, Om Parkash Aggarwal, Sat Pal Aggarwal, and Rajinder Nath Sharma were the directors of the company. He also placed on record the certificate of registration exhibit PW-1/1; annual return of the company filed for the year ending September 30, 1982, exhibit PW-1/2 and original Form 32—exhibit PW-1/3. Mr. Rajnish Mittal, chartered accountant, PW-2, deposed that be audited the accounts of the company and submitted the report exhibit PW-2/1. He further deposed that he had not prepared the balance-sheet as the accounts were not complete. Another report exhibit PW-2/2 was submitted by him. R.S Negi, Additional District and Sessions Judge, Mandi, as the official liquidator, deposed to the effect that on going through the statement of accounts and records of the company he found that some cases of recovery had already become time-barred, i.e, prior to the liquidation order. Similarly, he found that some correct addresses of the persons were not supplied by the ex-directors to the official liquidator and so all these amounts had become time barred. All these witnesses were cross-examined by the contesting respondents. Nothing has come on record creating any doubt to the veracity of any of the witnesses' statement. The respondents have not chosen to lead any evidence. In fact, they have also not appeared as their own witnesses.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that as per the facts proved on record, the respondents' carelessness and negligence is writ large. In fact, they are clearly guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust in running the affairs of the company till the same was taken over by the official liquidator and so they are jointly and severally liable to pay this amount along with interest to the official liquidator in terms of sections 541, 542 and 543 of the Companies Act. Reliance has been placed upon the following decisions: P.A Tendolkar v. Official Liquidator, [1967] 37 Comp Cas 392 (Mys); Smart Advertising Co. (P.) Ltd. (In Liquidation) v. Ramesh K. Nanchahal, [1989] 65 Comp Cas 92 (P & H); P.K Nedungadi v. Malayalee Bank Ltd., (1971) 3 SCC 598 : AIR 1971 SC 829; [1972] 42 Comp Cas 120; Official Liquidator, Supreme Bank Ltd. v. P.A Tendolkar, [1973] 43 Comp Cas 382; (1973) 1 SCC 602 : AIR 1973 SC 1104 and Official Liquidator v. Raghawa Desikachar, [1975] 45 Comp Cas 136 (SC).

7. Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, argued that mere inaction on the part of the directors/managing director cannot be construed as a case of misfeasance and breach of trust. To hold a director or a managing director to be liable, it has to be held that such person is clearly guilty of violating the duty cast upon him. Thus, merely for the reason that certain debts could not be recovered though attempt was made to recover the amount due cannot be held to be a case of misfeasance and breach of trust. Similarly, the allegations levelled in the petition that the answering respondents did not furnish the correct addresses of the party though asked for is merely an assertion without any proof. As a matter of fact, during the time when the answering respondents were in control of the affairs of the company every possible attempt was made to recover various amounts from the party, but despite sincere efforts made, the amount could not be recovered. Thus, there has been no negligence on the part of the respondents in carrying out the affairs of the company. The decision given by this court in the case reported as Faridabad Rubber Soles (P.) Ltd. v. S.L Chopra, [1994] 3 PLR 78 is applicable as per the facts of the present case. Consequently, the petition deserves to be dismissed.

8. Section 541 of the Companies Act fixes the liability where proper accounts are not kept. As per section 541(1) of the Companies Act, in case it comes to the notice that proper books of account were not kept by the company throughout the period of two years immediately preceding the commencement of the winding up, every officer of the company who is in default is liable to punishment with imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year unless he can show that he acted honestly and that in the circumstances in which the business of the company was carried on, the default was excusable. Under section 542 of the Companies Act, liability is fixed for fraudulent conduct of business. In case it comes to notice that business of the company has been carried on, with intent to defraud the creditors of the company, or any other persons, such person can be held personally liable for all or any of the debts or liabilities of the company as the court may direct. Similarly, under section 543 of the Companies Act, the court can assess damages against delinquent directors and direct them to repay the same with interest at such rate as the court may think just. Under this section, such an application has to be filed within five years from the date of the order for winding up. The aforesaid sections and other relevant provisions of the Companies Act envisage fixing of liability of the defaulting party as well as make them liable for a criminal prosecution. Presently, the petition has been filed to fix the liability of the delinquent director—managing director/director—with a further prayer that they be directed to reimburse the company for the losses which have occurred on account of their acts of misfeasance and breach of trust.

9. The official liquidator in support of his petition has examined a functionary of the Registrar of Companies as well as the chartered accountant who audited the accounts of the company. The chartered accountant has submitted his report on the basis of record which was made available to him. The official liquidator has also deposed to the effect that before he took over the affairs of the company, substantial amount, i.e, Rs. 1,30,620 had already become time barred. Similarly, he deposed that a sum of Rs. 5,069 could not be recovered as the ex-directors did not care to reply to the communication addressed by him requesting them to supply the correct addresses of the party. A perusal of the list of companies who owed money to the petitioner-company as per details given in the earlier part of the judgment reveals that these amounts as detailed could be recovered within a period of three years from the date of last transaction. For reasons best known to the ex-directors, no step/steps appears to have been initiated to recover these amounts consequently resulting in making these claims to be time-barred. As noticed earlier no evidence has been adduced by the contesting respondents. Thus, keeping in view the admitted position, I hold that the aforesaid amounts as at “A” became time-barred. As regards the amounts as per list “B”, the same also became time-barred on account of non-supply of correct addresses of the parties by the answering respondents. Since there is no rebuttal of the statement of the official liquidator, the same cannot be taken to have been proved.

10. Mr. Rajnish Mittal, chartered accountant of Datta Singla and Company, PW-2, had examined the accounts of the petitioner-company and has come to the conclusion that a sum of Rs. 1,80,052 alleged to have been spent by the company under different heads of expenses is, however, not supported with vouchers. In the absence of vouchers, this amount cannot be said to have been spent for the affairs of the company. In any case, it was for the ex-directors to explain as to how this amount has been spent to run the company and for its welfare.

11. The apex court in Official Liquidator, Supreme Bank Ltd.'s case, [1973] 43 Comp Cas 382; (1973) 1 SCC 602 : AIR 1973 SC 1104, was examining as to whether a director of a company is liable for misfeasance if he is found to be negligent and held as under (at page 400):

“It is certainly a question of fact, to be determined upon the evidence in each case, whether a director, alleged to be liable for misfeasance, had acted reasonably as well as honestly and with due diligence, so that he could not be held liable for conniving at fraud and misappropriation which takes place. A director may be shown to be so placed and to have been so closely and so long associated personally with the management of the company that he will be deemed to be not merely cognizant of but liable for fraud in the conduct of the business of a company even though no specific act of dishonesty is proved against him personally. He cannot shut his eyes to what must be obvious to everyone who examines the affairs of the company even superficially. If he does so he could be held liable for dereliction of duties undertaken by him and compelled to make good the losses incurred by the company due to his neglect even if he is not shown to be guilty of participating in the commission of fraud. It is enough if his negligence is of such a character as to enable frauds to be committed and losses thereby incurred by the company.”

12. Similarly, the apex court in P.K Nedungadi's case, [1972] 42 Comp Cas 120 held that it is not essential to prove fraud on the part of the director. It is sufficient to hold directors liable in case it is proved that they are guilty of misfeasance and breach of trust which includes breach of duty of the company in misapplying the company's assets. A mere act of omission cannot be construed to be a case of misfeasance or breach of trust unless the same has resulted in actual loss to the company. It is for the petitioner to establish (i) that there has been a breach of trust or duty or misfeasance; and (ii) loss which has arisen therefrom. Allegations or proof of fraud are not essential and it is wholly immaterial that acts of omission constitute offences for which director or officer may be criminally liable.

13. The Mysore High Court in P. A Tendolkar's case, [1967] 37 Comp Cas 392 held that this section applies where a director, officer, etc., has misapplied or retained or become liable or accountable for any money or property of the company or has been guilty of misfeasance or breach of trust in relation to the company. The court may compel a delinquent director, officer, etc., to repay or restore any money or property which he has misapplied or retained or became liable or accountable to the company or to contribute to the company's assets an appropriate sum by way of compensation. To similar effect is the view taken by this court in Smart Advertising Co. (P.) Ltd. (In Liquidation)'s case, [1989] 65 Comp Cas 92 (P & H). Relying upon the decision of the apex court in P. K. Nedungadi's case, [1972] 42 Comp Cas 120, the court held that where a company suffers loss on account of breach of duty on the part of a director, he is liable to compensate the company to the extent of such loss. The court further held that where the director and managing director of a company in liquidation had failed to take action for realisation of certain debts owing to the company and the debts became time-barred before the winding up order was passed by the court, is a fit case for passing a decree against the director and a managing director for the amount of the debts. The court further held the director and the managing director liable and ordered them to reimburse the company the amount of the debts.

14. To be fair to counsel for the respondents, reference to Faridabad Rubber Soles (P.) Ltd.'s case, [1994] 3 PLR 78 would be appropriate.

15. The court in the instant case came to the conclusion that the official liquidator had not alleged fraud or dishonesty on the part of the director for not recovering the amount for the company and thus held that merely for the reason that the debts have become time-barred, the same does not amount to misfeasance. This decision of this court has no bearing on the point under scrutiny. The court in the aforesaid case noticed that the company premises were locked by the State Bank of Patiala on July 17, 1982, and the books and the records of the company were inside and so the answering respondent had no access to the same since the lock was opened in November, 1987, as per direction of the court. The ex-directors of the company obviously had no access to the books of account and so could not initiate action for recovery of the amount due to the company. Under these circumstances, the court held that the respondents are not liable. In the instant case, it has been proved on record that the ex-directors/managing director did not initiate any steps to recover the amount due from the defaulting party and the same became time-barred. Similarly, a sum of Rs. 5,069 was lost as the ex-directors did not co-operate with the official liquidator and furnish the correct addresses of the defaulting party. Similarly, no explanation has been given regarding the sum of Rs. 1,80,052 for which there is no voucher on the record of the company. In any case, these could be explained by the answering respondents by adducing evidence or even stating on oath. But for reasons best known to them, they have chosen not to lead evidence or to depose on oath.

16. Accordingly, I accept this petition and pass a decree for a sum of Rs. 3,20,842 along with interest at the rate of 12 per. cent. per annum from September 22, 1983, till its realisation against respondents Nos. 1 to 3 and 5. The petitioner's claim against respondent No. 4 stands dismissed as he has not been found to be a director of the petitioner-company. No costs.