Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ajit Singh And Another v. Nusrat Ali Khan .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 22, 1997
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

General elections for the Punjab Legislative Assembly were held in February 1997. Voting in the 81-Malerkotla assembly constituency took place on 7 February 1997 and the result for that constituency was declared on 9 February 1997 at midnight, when the respondent Nusrat Ali Khan was declared elected.

An election petition under the Representation of the People Act, 1951 was filed jointly by Ajit Singh and Mohammad Ashraf on 31 March 1997 challenging the respondent's election. The Deputy Registrar (Judicial) pointed out that the petition appeared time barred because it was filed on the 50th day after declaration, whereas Section 81(1) of the Act prescribes a limitation period of 45 days. The period of limitation expired on 26 March 1997; the petition was filed on 31 March 1997.

Three official instruments relating to court holidays and arrangements were placed before the Court: (a) a gazetted notification dated 29 November 1996 which listed the calendar of holidays for 1997 and did not list 29 March 1997 as a holiday (it listed 24–28 March 1997 as holidays); (b) a Registrar's notice dated 14 March 1997 indicating officers on duty to entertain Habeas Corpus petitions during holidays and expressly noting 29 March 1997 (Saturday) as a working day; and (c) a Registrar's notice dated 18 March 1997 concerning nomination of two judges to hear Habeas Corpus petitions "during the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" and indicating such petitions would be received by the Registry and placed before those judges up to 1:00 p.m.

The Court was called upon to decide Issue No. 3: whether the petition is barred by limitation and liable to be dismissed. The Court concluded that March 29, 1997 was a working day and that the election petition, filed on 31 March 1997, was time barred. The petition was dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election petition filed on 31 March 1997 was barred by limitation under Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and therefore liable to be dismissed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (counsel: Shri J.R. Mittal)

  • The High Court was closed from 23 March 1997 to 30 March 1997; therefore the petition could not be filed on 26 March 1997 (the last day of limitation) and filing on 31 March 1997 (the first opening day after holidays) was within a permissible extension.
  • Relied on the Registrar's notice dated 18 March 1997 which stated there were "holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" and on the Supreme Court decision in Simhadri Satya Narayana Rao v. M. Budda Prasad (1994 Supp. (1) SCC 449) to support the proposition that filing on re-opening after a vacation when the Court was closed does not make the petition time barred.

Respondent's Arguments (counsel: Shri H. S. Mattewal)

  • The High Court office was closed only from 23 March 1997 (Sunday) to 28 March 1997 (Friday) and was open on 29 March 1997 (Saturday); therefore the petitioners had an opportunity to file on 29 March 1997 and did not do so.
  • Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 was inapplicable; instead Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 governs such situations, allowing filing on the next working day only if the Court or office is closed on the day when an act is required to be done. Relying on the gazette notification of 29 November 1996 and the Registrar's notice of 14 March 1997 (which listed holidays and specified 29 March as a working day), the petition is barred by limitation.
  • Relied on Hukumdev Narain Yadav v. Lalit Narain Mishra, AIR 1974 SC 480 to support applicability of Section 10 of the General Clauses Act in relation to extension of filing time to the next working day where the Court is closed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Simhadri Satya Narayana Rao v. M. Budda Prasad, 1994 Supp. (1) SCC 449 Authority for the proposition that where the High Court is closed during the limitation period and a notification shows the Court remained closed (with provision for urgent filings to vacation judges), an election petition filed on re-opening may not be dismissed as time barred under the Representation of the People Act. The Court distinguished this authority on facts: in Simhadri the notice clearly declared the Court closed for vacation and authorised urgent filings via vacation officers; by contrast, the March 18, 1997 notice in the present case related to arrangements for Habeas Corpus hearings and did not alter the previously notified calendar of holidays. Thus Simhadri did not support the petitioners' case on these facts.
Hukumdev Narain Yadav v. Lalit Narain Mishra; AIR 1974 SC 480 Support for applying Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 to permit acts to be done on the next working day when the Court or office is closed on the last day of the prescribed period. The respondent relied upon this authority to argue that Section 10 permitted filing on the next working day. The Court, however, found that the Court was not closed on 29 March 1997 (the next working day) because earlier notifications and notices had already declared 29 March a working day; therefore Section 10 was not applicable in the petitioners' favour on these facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed three relevant instruments: (i) the gazetted notification of 29 November 1996 which set out the holiday calendar for 1997 and listed holidays for 24–28 March 1997 but did not list 29 March 1997 as a holiday; (ii) the Registrar's notice of 14 March 1997 which indicated officers on duty to entertain Habeas Corpus petitions during the holiday spell and expressly identified 29 March 1997 (Saturday) as a working day; and (iii) the Registrar's notice of 18 March 1997 which nominated two judges to hear Habeas Corpus petitions "during the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" and stated such petitions would be received by the Registry and placed before the judges up to 1:00 p.m.

The Court concluded that the March 18, 1997 notice did not purport to change or supersede the holiday calendar established by the earlier gazetted notification and the March 14 notice. Instead, the March 18 notice addressed arrangements for hearing Habeas Corpus petitions (nominating judges and specifying a receiving time) and its reference to "the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" was contextual to those arrangements. The Court found no clear indication in that notice that 29 March 1997 was to be treated as a holiday for general registry purposes.

Because the gazetted notification and the March 14 notice specifically identified the holidays (24–28 March) and identified 29 March as a working day, the Court held that 29 March 1997 was a working day for the High Court registry. Consequently, the petitioners had the opportunity to file the election petition on 29 March 1997 (the next opening day after the specified holidays) but failed to do so. The Court therefore found the petition to be barred by the 45-day limitation under Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951.

The Court also considered the precedents cited by the parties. It distinguished Simhadri on its facts (where the notice clearly declared closure for vacation and provided for urgent filings via vacation judges) and declined to apply the principle invoked from Hukumdev because the factual premise for Section 10's operation — that the Court was closed on the last day of the prescribed period — did not exist here for general registry purposes.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The election petition is dismissed as time barred.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The election petition filed on 31 March 1997 was held to be outside the 45-day limitation period prescribed by Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and is therefore dismissed.
  • Precedential effect: The Court distinguished the authorities relied upon by the petitioners and applied the established principle that an extension to the next working day is only available where the Court or office is demonstrably closed on the last day of the prescribed period. The opinion makes no finding that it establishes a new legal principle beyond application of the existing authorities to the facts; no broader precedent was announced beyond the factual conclusion reached here.
Show all summary ...

1. This order shall decide Issue No. 3 framed as under :--

"ISSUE NO. 3 :

Whether the petition is barred by limitation and is liable to be dismissed.

2. General election to elect 117 members of Punjab Legislative Assembly was held in the State of Punjab in February, 1997. Election in 81-Malerkotla assembly constituency was held on February 7, 1997. Result was declared on February 9, 1997 at mid-night for that constituency and the respondent Nusrat Ali Khan was declared elected.

3. This election petition was filed on March 31, 1997 jointly by Ajit Singh and Mohammad Ashraf under the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (for short, "the Act"), Challenging the election of the respondent. After this election petition was filed in the office of the High Court, the Deputy Registrar (Judicial) pointed out, among certain other defects, that the petition was time barred because it was filed on the 50th day from the date of declaration of the result as against the period of limitation of 45 days under Section 81(1) of the Act. The respondent has also raised a plea in his written statement that the election petition is barred by limitation. Result of 81-Malerkotla assembly constituency was declared on February 9, 1997. The period of limitation of 45 days expired on March 26, 1997. The election petition was filed on March 31, 1997.

4. Shri J.R. Mittal, senior counsel for the petitioners, has argued that the High Court was closed from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997 and, therefore, the election petition could not be filed on March 26, 1997 which was the last day of limitation for filing the election petition. It is on account of the holidays that the election petition was filed on March 31, 1997, the opening day. Shri Mittal has referred to the notice dated March 18, 1997 (Annexure P-3) issued by the Registrar (Judicial) of the High Court in connection with the hearing of the Habeas Corpus petitions during the holidays. The said notice reads as under :--

"NOTICE Hon'ble the Chief Justice has been pleased to nominate Hon'ble Mr. Justice N.K. Kapoor and Hon'ble Mr. Justice K.S. Kumaran for hearing Habeas Corpus Petitions at their residences during the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997.

All such petitions shall be received by the Registry and placed before the Hon'ble Judges upto 1.00p.m. only.

Sd/-

R. C. Kathuria, Registrar (Judicial) 18-3-1997"

5. Shri H. S. Mattewal, senior counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, has argued that the office of the High Court was closed for only six days from 23-3-1997 (Sunday) to 28-3-1997 (Friday) and it opened on 29-3-1997 (Saturday). It was, therefore, incumbent upon the petitioner to file his petition on the next opening day i.e. 29-3-1997. Shri Mattewal has explained that Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 was inapplicable. It was Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 which permitted the filing of the petition on the next opening day. The said Section 10 provided that where any act or proceeding is allowed to be done or taken in any Court or office on a certain day or within a prescribed period and if the Court or office is closed on that day or the last day of the prescribed period, then the act or proceeding shall be considered as done or taken in due time if it is done or taken on the next day afterwards on which the Court or office is open. Since the election petition was to be filed in the office of the High Court, it was only the next opening day i.e. 29-3-1997 (Saturday) which was available to the petitioner for filing his petition.

6. Shri Mattewal has placed on record copy of the notification No. 362, dated November 29, 1996 (Annexure R-4) issued (by order of the Hon'ble Chief Justice and Judges) by the Assistant Registrar (General) for the Registrar. That notification was published in the Government Gazettes of Punjab. Haryana and Union Territory of Chandigarh. It notified the holidays which were to be observed during the year 1997. The relevant part of the notification reads as under :--

"THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH NOTIFICATION No. 362/XVII.3 Dated 29-11-1996 It is hereby notified for general information that the days enumerated in the Schedule below shall be observed as holidays by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh during the year 1997.

SCHEDULE Sr. Description of No.

Holidays Date on which holiday falls Day of the week No. of Holidays 1 to 8 xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

9. Holi 24th March Monday

10. Hola 25th March Tuesday

11. Local Holiday 26th March Wednesday

12. Local Holiday 27th March Thursday

13. Good Friday 28th March Friday

14. Baisakhi 13th April Sunday 15 to 39 xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx Note : Vacation : Summer vacation will be observed from 2nd June to 30th June, 1997 (both days inclusive).

By Order of the Hon'ble Chief Justice & Judges Sd/ J. P. Kaushik, Assistant Registrar (General), Registrar (Judicial)"

7. Another notice was issued by Registrar (Judicial) on March 14, 1997 (Annexure R-5) which reads as under :--

"NOTICE During the spell of Court holidays from 23-3-1997 to 28-3-1997 and 30-3-1997 (29-3-1997 is Saturday and working day), the following Officers have been put on duty to entertain Habeas Corpus, if any, in the Registry of the High Court.

1. Sh. Suresh Mohan, 23-3-1997 to 26-3-1997 Assistant Registrar, (Civil & Criminal).

8. There are thus one notification and two notices to be considered in connection with holidays observed by the High Court. The notification dated November 29, 1996 laid down the calendar of holidays for the whole year 1997. Holidays other then Sundays (52) and second Saturdays (12) were specified in seriatim in the Schedule and 29-3-1997 (Saturday) was not shown as a holiday. Holidays were shown for 24th, 25th 26th, 27th and 28th March, 1997 (Monday to Friday).

9. In the notice dated March 14, 1997 also, 29-3-1997 (Saturday) was mentioned as a working day.

10. Shri H.S. Mattewal has placed strong reliance on the notification dated November 29, 1996 and the notice dated March 14, 1997 in support of the plea that the office of the High Court was not closed on 29-3-1997. It was, therefore, incumbent upon the petitioners to file the petition on the next opening day i.e. 29-3-1997. Since the petitioners failed to file the election petition in the office of the High Court on March 29, 1997, the petition is said to be barred by limitation.

11. Shri J. R. Mittal, counsel for the petitioners has argued that the last notice dated March 18, 1997 (Annexure P-3) was the relevant notice to be seen for determining whether 29-3-1997 was a close day or not for the the High Court. That notice actually gave the unmistaken information that there were holidays in the High Court from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997. The unambiguous mention of the words "the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" in that notice left no room for any doubt that 29-3-1997 was also a holiday. Shri Mittal has also placed reliance on a decision of the Supreme Court in 'Simhadri Satya Narayana Rao v. M. Budda Prasad, 1994 Supp.

(1) SCC 449. In that case, limitation period of 45, days under Section 81 of the Act for filing an election petition had expired during vacation when High Court of Andhra Pradesh was closed. The High Court notification declaring that the Court would remain close for Sankranthi Vacation and in subsequent paras stating that the applications of urgent nature could be filed during the vacation and appointed two Judges as Vacation Judges and two Assistant Registrars as Vacation Officers clearly showed that the High Court remained closed. It was, therefore, held that the election petition filed on the re-opening of the High Court after vacations was not liable to be dismissed under Section 86 of the Act.

12. It may be noticed that, in the aforesaid case, the notice dated December 29, 1989 issued by the Registrar of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh had declared that the High Court

"will remain close for Sankranthi Vacation, 1990 from Tuesday the 2nd January to Friday the 12th January, 1990 (both days inclusive)."
In the last para of the notice, applications of urgent nature were permitted to be filed. The last paragraph read as under :--

"Notice of any application of an urgent nature shall be given to the Vacation Officers before 1.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 2nd January and the 8th January, 1990."

13. The facts in the present case, however, are entirely different. Here, notice dated March 18, 1997 pertained to the nomination of two Judges of this Court for hearing Habeas Corpus petitions at their residences. In the second paragraph of the notice, it was specified that all such petitions shall be received by the Registry and placed before the Hon'ble Judges upto 1 P.M. only. Therefore, notice dated March 18, 1997 did not specify the holidays but notified the arrangement made by Hon'ble the Chief Justice for hearing Habeas Corpus petitions. The words "during the holidays commencing from 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997" ocurring in the notice did not imply a change in the number of holidays as notified earlier. Reference to holidays from, 23-3-1997 to 30-3-1997 was in relation to the hearing of the Habeas Corpus petitions. More-over, notice dated March 18, 1997 was not issued in supersession or modification of the earlier notification dated November 29, 1996 or notice dated March 14, 1997 which had been specifically issued earlier in connection with the holidays to be observed by the High Court.

14. Shri H.S. Mattewal has placed reliance on a decision of Supreme Court in ' Hukumdev Narain Yadav v. Lalit Narain Mishra.; AIR 1974 SC 480 in support of his plea that Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 could be applicable so as to extend the period of limitation in a case of election petition. Shri Mattewal has argued in the light of the aforesaid decision that if the Court is closed on the day when limitation expired, Section 10(1) of the General Clauses Act enabled the filing of the next working day of the Court.

15. Keeping in view the object and the purpose of the notice dated March 18, 1997, it cannot be inferred that 29-3-1997 was declared a holiday. The said notice, when read as a whole, gives no impression that calendar of holidays was altered. The notice was in the nature of information to all regarding the arrangement made for hearing Habeas Corpus petitions by two Judges of the High Court. It also notified that Habeas Corpus petitions shall be received by he Registry and placed before the Judges up to p.m. In this light, notice dated March 18, 1997 cannot be said to have notified 29-3-1997 as a holiday. The Gazetted notification dated November 29, 1996 and notice dated March 14th 1997 specifically declared the holidays. March 29, 1997 was not declared as holiday in the notification dated November 29, 1996. On the other hand, March 29, 1997 was specifically mentioned as a working day in the notice dated March 14, 1997. In these circumstances, the plea put-forward by the petitioners that election petition filed on March 31, 1997 is within limitation cannot be accepted. Since March 29, 1997 was a working day for the office of the High Court, it was necessary for the petitioner to file the petition on that day which was the next opening day after holidays from 23-3-1997 to 28-3-1997.

16. The election petition is dismissed being time barred.