Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

H.M.M Limited v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax.

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jul 24, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — H.M.M. Limited (Reference under s. 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (the Tribunal) referred three questions of law to this Court under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 at the instance of the assessee, H.M.M. Limited, Nabha. The assessee, engaged in manufacture and sale of milk products, filed its return for the assessment year 1976-77 (accounting period ending 31 March 1976) declaring income of Rs. 2,93,60,200.

The three referred questions concerned (1) the deductibility of surtax paid under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, (2) the correctness of disallowance of Rs. 20,000 relating to conference/entertainment expenses, and (3) whether weighted deduction under section 35B was available in respect of freight and miscellaneous expenses aggregating in the vicinity of the amounts mentioned in the record.

At earlier stages the Assessing Officer disallowed the surtax deduction and disallowed the conference expenses in full; the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal gave partial or final decisions as recorded in the referral. The Court examines each question in the light of statutory provisions, the facts found, and relevant precedents cited in the opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in law in holding that the assessee was not entitled to deduct the surtax payable under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, in computing taxable income?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal rightly upheld the disallowance of Rs. 20,000 in respect of conference expenses?
  3. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was correct in holding that no weighted deduction under section 35B is available in respect of freight and other miscellaneous expenses amounting to the sums identified in the assessment?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (as advanced by Shri A.K. Mittal)

  • With respect to conference expenses: the holding of a “sales promotion conference” was part of the assessee's business activity and therefore should not be treated as entertainment expenditure; hospitality connected with business obligation or longstanding trade custom does not necessarily amount to entertainment.
  • At a place like Goa, providing liquor and hospitality to guests/employees was argued to be expected and part of necessary business hospitality rather than entertainment.
  • Relied on precedents where expenditures on meals/refreshments in business contexts were held to be allowable (Patel Brothers & Co. Ltd.; Bangalore Turf Club Ltd.; Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.).

Revenue's Arguments (as advanced by Shri R.P. Sawhney)

  • For section 35B issues: internal (domestic) freight charges are excluded from weighted deduction under sub-clause (iii) of section 35B(1)(b) and are not covered by sub-clause (viii); reliance placed on this Court's decisions in Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Roadmaster Industries of India Pvt. Ltd. and Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.
  • Regarding conference/entertainment expenses: Explanation 2 was inserted into section 37(2A) by Act 11 of 1983 with retrospective effect from 1 April 1976, thereby widening the scope of “entertainment expenditure” to include hospitality of every kind; after that date hospitality expenditure is disallowable unless it falls within the carved-out exception (e.g., food or beverages to employees in office, factory or other places of work).
  • Relied on Supreme Court commentary (in the review of Patel Brothers) and approved observations from the Delhi High Court (CIT v. Rajasthan Mercantile) concerning the effect and temporal operation of Explanation 2.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Highway Cycle Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, [1989] 178 ITR 601 (P&H) Held that surtax is not deductible under the Income-tax Act. The Court relied on this Division Bench decision to answer Question No. 1 against the assessee; the matter was treated as settled after examination in that precedent.
Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Roadmaster Industries of India Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 968 Addressed admissibility of internal freight charges for purposes of section 35B; supporting the view that internal freight is not admissible under sub-clause (iii) or (viii). The Revenue relied on this decision; the Court accepted the reasoning that internal freight charges were not qualified for weighted deduction under sub-clause (iii) or (viii) and applied that position to deny section 35B relief on the assessee's freight.
Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 772 (P&H) Examined allowability of expenditure on food and light refreshments to trainees/engineers and held such expenditure allowable (facts-based). The Court distinguished that case on its facts (food/light refreshments to employees/trainees) and held it did not entitle the present assessee to claim full deduction; the Court emphasized that each case depends on its facts and that Explanation 2's exception for employees must be considered.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Patel Brothers & Co. Ltd., [1977] 106 ITR 424 (Guj) Held that certain kitchen/meal expenses provided to farmer-customers were not in the nature of entertainment and were allowable as business expenditure. The assessee relied on this decision; the Court noted its reliance but also recorded that the Supreme Court later reviewed aspects of that decision and disapproved some wide observations.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Patel Brothers & Co. Ltd., [1995] 215 ITR 165 (Supreme Court) Reviewed Gujarat High Court's decision; affirmed the result but disapproved the wider observations and guidelines in the Gujarat decision. The Court cited the Supreme Court’s treatment to show limits on relying on wide observations from Patel Brothers; this influenced the treatment of hospitality/entertainment issues under Explanation 2.
CIT v. Rajasthan Mercantile Company Limited, [1995] 211 ITR 400 (Delhi) Observed that Explanation 2 widens the concept of 'entertainment expenditure' only for assessments with effect from 1 April 1976 and the widened meaning cannot be extended to past periods when Explanation 2 was not in operation. The Supreme Court referred with approval to these observations; the present Court relied on the appellate commentary in considering the temporal operation of Explanation 2 and its applicability to the facts before it.
Addl. CIT v. Bangalore Turf Club Ltd., [1980] 126 ITR 430 (Kar) Held that expenses on refreshments and liquors in certain business meetings were administrative/business expenditure, not entertainment, on the facts. The assessee relied on this authority; the Court noted it as supportive for the proposition that business meetings’ refreshments can be allowable, but emphasized fact-specific inquiry and the effect of Explanation 2.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considers each referred question by reference to statutory text, the facts before it, prior appellate decisions, and the submissions made by the parties.

Question No. 1 — Deductibility of Surtax

  1. The Tribunal, Appellate Assistant Commissioner and Assessing Officer had held that surtax paid under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, was not deductible under the Income-tax Act.
  2. The Court noted that a Division Bench of this Court in Highway Cycle Industries Ltd. v. CIT examined the same question and concluded that surtax was not deductible.
  3. Given that matter had been settled in that earlier examination, the Court answered Question No. 1 in the affirmative against the assessee and in favour of the Department — i.e., surtax is not allowable as a deduction.

Question No. 3 — Weighted Deduction under Section 35B (Freight and Miscellaneous Expenses)

  1. The Court analysed the relevant statutory provisions, in particular sub-clauses (iii) and (viii) of section 35B(1)(b), which limit weighted deduction to expenditure "wholly and exclusively" incurred on distribution, supply or provision outside India (iii) and on performance of services outside India in execution of contracts for supply outside India (viii).
  2. Sub-clause (iii) expressly excludes expenditure incurred in India in connection with distribution/supply outside India and also excludes expenditure on carriage of goods to their destination outside India or insurance of such goods when incurred before 1 April 1978.
  3. The Court found that the freight charges incurred by the assessee were internal/domestic and were not qualified for weighted deduction under sub-clause (iii). They were also not covered by sub-clause (viii) because they were not incurred on performance of services outside India in execution of a contract for supply outside India; rather, these were services performed within India. There was no material on record to show sea freight in execution of an export contract.
  4. The Court accepted the Revenue's submissions and authorities (Roadmaster; Indo Asian Switch-Gears) to the effect that internal freight does not attract the weighted deduction; accordingly it answered Question No. 3 in the affirmative against the assessee.

Question No. 2 — Disallowance of Conference/Entertainment Expenses (Rs. 20,000)

  1. Facts and amounts were examined: total conference-related expenditure of Rs. 44,270 (including dinners, liquor, snacks) incurred at a conference in Goa (21–25 March 1976). AO disallowed full amount as lavish entertainment; Appellate Assistant Commissioner reduced the disallowance to Rs. 20,000; the Tribunal upheld disallowance of Rs. 20,000.
  2. The assessee urged that the conference was a business activity (sales promotion) and hospitality thereat was necessary and not entertainment; relied on precedents where meals/refreshments provided in business contexts were held allowable.
  3. The Revenue pointed to Explanation 2 inserted in section 37(2A) by Act 11 of 1983, which was given retrospective effect from 1 April 1976 and broadened the concept of "entertainment expenditure" to include hospitality of every kind; therefore, hospitality expenditure after that date could be disallowed unless it fell within the statutory exception (e.g., food or beverages provided to employees at workplace).
  4. The Court observed that precedents favourable to the assessee (such as Indo Asian Switch-Gears) are fact-dependent and distinguished them: those cases involved food/light refreshments to trainees and employees and permitted allowances on that basis. The Court emphasised that Explanation 2 provides an exception for food/beverages to employees in office/factory/other places of work but that the exception must be strictly applied after assessing the facts.
  5. Having regard to the nature and scale of the expenditure and the statutory amendment, the Court concluded that part of the expenditure could properly be disallowed under Explanation 2 and that the Tribunal's upholding of a Rs. 20,000 disallowance was justified. The Court therefore answered Question No. 2 in the affirmative against the assessee.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Each of the three referred questions was answered in the affirmative, against the assessee and in favour of the Department.

Specific holdings:

  • Surtax deduction: The Court held that surtax payable under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, is not an allowable deduction under the Income-tax Act (Question No. 1 answered against the assessee).
  • Conference/entertainment expenses: The disallowance of Rs. 20,000 in respect of the conference expenses was upheld (Question No. 2 answered against the assessee).
  • Section 35B weighted deduction: Weighted deduction under section 35B was held not to be available for the internal freight and the miscellaneous expenses in question; sub-clause (iii) and (viii) do not cover such internal freight (Question No. 3 answered against the assessee).

Immediate consequences: The Tribunal's conclusions on the three points are affirmed by this Court: the assessee is not entitled to deduct surtax, must bear a disallowance of Rs. 20,000 for the conference expenses, and may not claim the weighted deduction under section 35B for the identified freight and related expenses. These rulings directly affect the assessee's taxable income computation for the assessment year in question.

Broader implications: The opinion applies and relies upon existing authorities and statutory interpretation (including the retrospective operation attributed to Explanation 2 from 1 April 1976). The Court treated earlier Division Bench and High Court decisions as controlling on the points discussed; the judgment does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying those authorities and interpreting the pertinent statutory clauses and Explanation 2. No broader new precedent is asserted beyond the application of established authorities and the statutory text as interpreted in this opinion.

Show all summary ...

N.K Agrawal, J.:— The following questions of law have been referred at the instance of the assessee by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (for short, “the Tribunal”) under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short, “the Act”):

“1. Whether the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal has been right in law in holding that the assessee was not entitled to deduction of surtax payable by it in pursuance of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, in arriving at the taxable income?

2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal rightly upheld the disallowance of the expenditure of Rs. 20,000 in respect of conference expenses?

3. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in holding that no weighted deduction under section 35B is available in respect of freight and other miscellaneous expenses amounting to Rs. 1,17,569?”

2. The assessee-company, H.M.M Limited, Nabha, was engaged in the manufacture and sale of milk products. The assessee filed a return of income declaring income for the assessment year 1976-77 (accounting period ending on March 31, 1976) at Rs. 2,93,60,200.

Question No. I.—The assessee claimed deduction of the amount paid as surtax. The Assessing Officer, following his order for the preceding assessment year, held that surtax was not an admissible deduction under the Act. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner as well as the Tribunal rejected the assessee's appeal, taking the view that the amount of surtax payable by the assessee under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, was not allowable as a deduction.

3. A Division Bench of this court examined a similar question about the deductibility of surtax in Highway Cycle Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax., [1989] 178 ITR 601 (P&H). This court took the view that surtax was not deductible under the Act. Since the matter has been settled after examination, the question is answered in the affirmative, i.e, against the assessee and in favour of the Department.

Question No. 5.— The assessee claimed weighted deduction under section 35B of the Act on the amount equivalent to 50 per cent, of the expenditure, amounting to Rs. 1,38,619. The Assessing Officer noticed that this expenditure included freight expenses of Rs. 1,11,476 and miscellaneous expenses of Rs. 3,231 and Rs. 2,862. The Assessing Officer declined to allow weighted deduction in respect of the freight charges on the ground that these had been specifically excluded from sub-clause (iii) of clause (b) of section 35B(1). Apart from such specific exclusion, all expenses incurred in India were also outside the purview of sub-clause (iii).

4. In appeal by the assessee, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner as well as the Tribunal rejected the plea of the assessee.

5. It would be relevant to read sub-clauses (iii) and (viii) of section 35B(1)(b). These sub-clauses read as under:

“(b) the expenditure referred to in clause (a) is that incurred wholly and exclusively on—…

(iii) distribution, supply or provision outside India of such goods, services or facilities, not being expenditure incurred in India in connection therewith or expenditure (wherever incurred) on the carriage of such goods to their destination outside India or on the insurance of such goods while in transit where such expenditure is incurred before the 1st day of April, 1978;…

(viii) performance of services outside India in connection with, or incidental to, the execution of any contract for the supply outside India of such goods, services or facilities;…”

6. It would be, thus, apparent that sub-clause (iii) permitted weighted deduction on expenditure incurred outside India wholly and exclusively on distribution, supply or provision of goods, services or facilities. It specifically excluded expenditure incurred outside India or in India on the carriage of goods to their destination outside India or on the insurance of such goods while in transit. Clause (viii) relates to expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively on the performance of services outside India in the execution of a contract for the supply of goods, services or facilities outside India.

7. The freight charges paid by the assessee are, thus, not qualified for the purposes of weighted deduction under sub-clause (iii). These expenditures were also not covered under sub-clause (viii) as these were not incurred on the performance of services outside India in the execution of a contract for the supply of goods outside India. These were expenditures on services performed in India.

8. Shri R.P Sawhney, learned senior counsel for the Revenue, has argued that internal freight charges are neither admissible under subclause (iii) nor under sub-clause (viii) in the light of the decision of this court in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Roadmaster Industries Of India Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 968. This view was followed by this court in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 772.

9. There is nothing on record to show that the expenditure incurred by the assessee related to the sea freight charges in the execution of a contract for the supply of goods. Therefore, sub-clause (viii) of section 35B(1)(b) is also not attracted.

10. Question No. 3 is answered in the affirmative, i.e, against the assessee and in favour of the Department.

Question No. 2.— During the assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer noticed that the assessee had incurred expenditure on dinner at Rs. 27,297, on liquor (wine and whisky) at Rs. 6,141 and on snacks at Rs. 10,832. The entire expenditure of Rs. 44,270 had been incurred during a conference held by the assessee-company at Goa from March 21, 1976, to March 25, 1976. Out of the expenditure on dinner, a sum of Rs. 4,594 was spent on one dinner arranged for 132 persons on March 22, 1976, and another sum of Rs. 10,536 was paid for a dinner hosted on March 25, 1976, which was attended by 125 guests. The Assessing Officer took the view that such a heavy expenditure in five days was not a normal business expenditure but was a lavish one, partaking of the character of entertainment.

11. The assessee took the plea that no daily allowance was paid to the employees who had attended the conference and, therefore, the expenditure should be allowed. The Assessing Officer, however, did not agree with the assessee and disallowed the expenditure amounting to Rs. 44,270 under section 37(2A) read with section 37(2B) of the Act.

12. The assessee went in appeal before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax with the plea that an expenditure of Rs. 33,438 was incurred on holding the annual sales conference at Goa and was incidental to its business. Similarly, expenditure of Rs. 10,832 was incurred at other places. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner, keeping in view similar disallowance made in the preceding assessment year (1975-76), reduced the disallowance to Rs. 20,000. The remaining expenditure was allowed.

13. The assessee went in further appeal before the Tribunal against disallowance of Rs. 20,000 and the Revenue also filed an appeal, feeling aggrieved by the part relief granted by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax. The Tribunal referred to the disallowance of Rs. 10,000 made in the preceding assessment year and, after considering the nature of the expenditure, upheld the disallowance at Rs. 20,000.

14. Shri A.K Mittal, learned counsel for the assessee, has argued that holding of a “sales promotion conference” was a part of the business activity and, therefore, could not be treated to be in the nature of entertainment. At a place like Goa, serving of liquor was necessary as the guests and employees expected such a hospitality. It is argued by Shri Mittal that every act of entertainment included hospitality also but every hospitality would not mean entertainment. Hospitality shown on account of obligation in business arising out of an express or implied contract or a longstanding trade custom did not amount to entertainment. Custom could not be treated to be entertainment. Holding of the conference was necessary for the purposes of the assessee's business.

15. Shri Mittal has placed reliance on a decision of the Gujarat High Court in Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Patel Brothers & Co. Ltd.. and Company Ltd., [1977] 106 ITR 424, in support of the plea that expenditure incurred by the assessee in providing meals to its workers as well as to the workers of its associate firm, was not in the nature of expenditure on entertainment. It was pleaded by the assessee in that case that it was customary out of commercial expediency to provide meals to the farmer customers. The assessee had claimed kitchen expenses for the assessment years 1969-70 to 1971-72. Part of the expenditure was disallowed by the Income-tax Officer on the ground that the expenses incurred on account of providing meals to the farmer customers were in the nature of entertainment. It was held that the expenditure was allowable, being not in the nature of entertainment expenses.

16. Reliance has also been placed by Shri Mittal, learned counsel for the assessee, on a decision of the Karnataka High Court in AddI. CIT v. Bangalore Turf Club Ltd., [1980] 126 ITR 430. That was a case where the assessee-company, which conducted horse-races, had incurred expenditure under the head “Expenditure towards the supply of refreshments, lunch, liquors, etc., in the business meetings of the stewards and of the members of the managing committee as also of the general body”. It was held that, since no sitting fees were provided to the members or office bearers attending the meetings, the expenses incurred were in the nature of administrative or business expenditure and would have no taint of expenditure in the nature of entertainment. Therefore, expenditures for the assessment years 1968-69, 1969-70 and 1970-71 were held to be allowable on the ground that these were incurred as of necessity and constituted part of the expenses for the holding of the business meetings.

17. Shri Mittal has also argued that this court in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 772, has also examined a question relating to expenditure incurred in providing food and light refreshments to trainees and engineers in the assessment years 1975-76, 1976-77 and 1977-78. The assessee had arranged seminars and conferences, wherein trainees and engineers participated. It was held by this court that the expenditure was allowable and was not in the nature of entertainment expenses under section 37(2A) of the Act.

18. Shri R.P Sawhney, learned senior counsel for the Department, has, at the outset, argued that Explanation 2 was inserted by Act 11 of 1983 in sub-section (2A) of section 37 of the Act with retrospective effect from April 1, 1976. After the insertion of that Explanation, the scope and ambit of “entertainment expenditure” stood enlarged. It also included expenditure on provision of hospitality of every kind by the assessee to any person. Therefore, after April 1, 1976, no expenditure incurred on the provision of hospitality of any kind to any person could be allowed in view of Explanation 2. Prior to April 1, 1976, the term “entertainment expenditure” might have been given a limited meaning and expenditure on hospitality may be excluded therefrom but, after April 1, 1976, even the expenditure on hospitality is not permissible inasmuch as it has been made a part of the entertainment expenditure.

19. Shri Sawhney has argued that the Supreme Court in Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Patel Brothers & Co. Ltd.. and Company Ltd., [1995] 215 ITR 165, has examined the decision of the Gujarat High Court in Patel Brothers and Company's case, [1977] 106 ITR 424, and has observed that the wide observations and the elaborate guidelines, given in the Gujarat High Court's decision, were in excess of the broad tests. Though the decision of the Gujarat High Court was affirmed, the wide observations, made therein, were not approved. The Supreme Court referred, with approval, to the following observations of the Delhi High Court in CIT v. Rajasthan Mercantile Company Limited, [1995] 211 ITR 400, 416:

“The declaration and the clarification involved in Explanation 2, are only for the purposes of assessments with effect from April 1, 1976. This provision widens the concept of ‘entertainment expenditure’ by including in its scope such of the expenditure which are otherwise traditionally understood as routine business expenditure incurred in connection with ‘business hospitality’. Therefore, the widened meaning cannot be extended to past periods when the amended Explanation 2 was not in operation.”

20. The argument of Shri A.K Mittal, learned counsel for the assessee, that expenditure incurred on the conference should be allowed in full, is, therefore, not acceptable in the light of the amendment made in section 37(2A) of the Act with effect from April 1, 1976. The view taken by this court in Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.'s case, [1996] 222 ITR 772 (P&H) would not permit the assessee in the present case to claim expenditure without looking to the peculiar facts in Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd. 's case, [1996] 222 ITR 772 (P&H). It was noticed in Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.'s case, [1996] 222 ITR 772 (P&H) that expenditure had been incurred on providing food and light refreshments to the trainees and engineers. The facts of each case had bearing on the question of allowability of expenditure. It may be noticed that, in Explanation 2 also, there is a provision for allowing expenditure on food or beverages provided by the assessee to its employees in office, factory or other places of work, It will, therefore, be necessary to examine the expenditure in each case so as to ascertain if such expenditure could be allowed within the ambit of the exception contained in the said Explanation. If the expenditure incurred on hospitality also included expenditure on food or beverages provided to the employees, the entire expenditure on hospitality shall not be disallowed. In this light, the decision of this court in Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.'s case, [1996] 222 ITR 772, does not entitle the assessee in the present case before us to claim deduction of the entire expenditure inasmuch as the facts in Indo Asian Switch-Gears (P.) Ltd.'s case, [1996] 222 ITR 772 (P&H) are distinguishable. As has been seen earlier, total expenditure incurred by the assessee on the conference held at Goa amounted to Rs. 44,270. Out of the aforesaid expenditure, a sum of Rs. 20,000 only was disallowed. It would thus appear that the entire expenditure has not been treated to be in the nature of “entertainment expenditure”. Explanation 2 under sub-section (2A) of section 37 of the Act permits disallowance of the expenditure on hospitality but carves out an exception in respect of expenditure incurred on food or beverages provided to the employees. Therefore, the disallowance of Rs. 20,000 has to be upheld in view of Explanation 2.

21. Question No. 2 is answered in the affirmative, i.e, against the assessee and in favour of the Department.