- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramesh Chand Alias Ramesh Kumar v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Hissar
Factual and Procedural Background
On 4th September 1981, Bhajan Lal (deceased) and Piare Lal were traveling on a motorcycle near village Gangua when a tractor driven by Bhagwan Dass (respondent No. 1) approached at high speed from the opposite direction. Despite Bhajan Lal steering the motorcycle towards the side, the tractor struck the motorcycle, causing injuries to both occupants and resulting in Bhajan Lal's death shortly after. The claimants, being Bhajan Lal's mother and minor child, filed a claim petition before the Tribunal.
The respondents appeared and denied involvement of the tractor in the accident. The Insurance Company contended that the accident was due to the rash and negligent driving of Bhajan Lal, who lacked a valid driving licence, and further argued that the tractor driver also lacked a valid licence, absolving the insurer of liability.
The Tribunal framed multiple issues including whether the accident was caused by the tractor driver's rash driving, the amount and source of compensation, limitation, preliminary objections, and non-joinder of parties.
The Tribunal found the tractor driver responsible for rash driving, fixed compensation based on the deceased's income and age, and held the owner and driver liable jointly and severally. The Insurance Company was absolved due to the driver's lack of a valid licence. The appellants challenged this finding regarding the driving licence in this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of Bhagwan Dass (respondent No. 1)?
- What amount of compensation are the petitioners entitled to, and from whom?
- Whether the petition is time barred?
- Whether the petition should be dismissed based on preliminary objections raised?
- Whether the petition is bad for non-joinder of parties?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants did not seriously challenge the quantum of compensation determined by the Tribunal.
- The Tribunal's finding that Bhagwan Dass did not hold a valid driving licence was incorrect.
- Additional evidence was admitted during the appeal, proving Bhagwan Dass held a driving licence (Ex. C-1), which was valid for driving a tractor.
- Based on the judgment in Ram Phul v. Krishna Makkar, the Insurance Company is liable if the driver had held a valid licence at or prior to the time of the accident.
Respondent (Insurance Company's) Arguments
- The document Ex. C-1 (driving licence) was not properly proved and therefore should not be admitted as evidence.
- Cited precedents such as Malwa Bus Service (P) Ltd. v. Amrit Kaur, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chandrawati, and an unreported judgment in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satya Devi to support this contention.
- Argued that since the licence was produced only at the appellate stage, the levy of interest on the compensation was unjustified, citing Joginder Singh v. The Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ram Phul v. Krishna Makkar (1988-2) 94 PLR 561 | Liability of Insurance Company if driver held a valid driving licence at or before the time of accident | Court accepted the principle that prior holding of a valid licence imposes liability on the insurer despite expiry at accident time. |
| Malwa Bus Service (P) Ltd. v. Amrit Kaur (1987-1) 91 PLR 618 | Proper proof of documents in evidence | Court found this precedent inapplicable due to prior acceptance of licence genuineness by Insurance Company's counsel. |
| Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chandrawati (1989-1) 95 PLR 240 | Proof and admissibility of evidence | Not applied, as the court relied on factual acceptance of licence genuineness in this case. |
| United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satya Devi (F.A.O No. 2090 of 1995) | Proof of documents and evidence admissibility | Not applied for same reasons as above. |
| Joginder Singh v. The Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. (1985-1) 87 PLR 642 | Levy of interest when documents are produced late in appeal | Court rejected Insurance Company's argument against interest levy based on burden of proof principles. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully examined the evidence, especially the driving licence document (Ex. C-1) produced during the appellate proceedings. Although the licence had expired on the date of the accident, the court relied on the precedent set in Ram Phul v. Krishna Makkar, holding that prior possession of a valid licence imposes liability on the insurer.
The court rejected the Insurance Company's objection regarding the proof and admissibility of the licence, noting that the Company's counsel had previously accepted the genuineness of the document and that no cross-examination was conducted to challenge it.
The argument that interest should not be levied due to late production of the licence was dismissed because the burden of proof to show absence of a valid licence rested on the Insurance Company.
Regarding compensation, the court found merit in the claimants' cross-objections for enhancement based on evidence that the deceased earned Rs. 1000 per month and was frugal. The monthly dependency was raised to Rs. 800, and compensation was enhanced accordingly.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL and ALLOWED THE CROSS-OBJECTIONS, enhancing the compensation amount to Rs. 1,53,600/-. It held that the United India Insurance Company alone is liable to pay the compensation. The direct effect is to impose liability on the insurer despite the licence expiry at the accident time, following established precedent. No new precedent was set beyond applying existing legal principles to the facts.
H.S Bedi, J.:— This appeal arises out of the following facts:—
2. On 4.9.1981 at about 7.15 p.m, Bhajan Lal deceased and one Piare Lal were coming to village Mangali from Hissar on Motor Cycle No. HYB-2088, Bhajan Lal was driving the motor cycle whereas Piare Lal was sitting on the rear seat. When they reached near the area of village Gangua, a tractor bearing registration No. HRB-9950 driven by Bhagwan Dass respondent No. 1 in the claim petition came from the opposite side at a very high speed. On seeing the tractor coming towards him, Bhajan Lal took the motor cycle towards the kacha portion but the tractor driver could not control his vehicle and struck against the motor cycle and as a result of the accident both Bhajan Lal and Piare Lal received injuries and were removed to the hospital where Bhajan Lal died shortly thereafter. On these facts, the claimants, i.e the mother and the minor child of Bhajan Lal filed a claim petition before the Tribunal.
3. On notices, the respondents put in appearance and claimed that the tractor had not been involved in the accident, whereas respondent No. 3 the Insurance Co. took the plea that the accident had taken place due to rash and negligent driving of the motor cycle of Bhajan Lal deceased, more particularly as he had no valid driving licence. The Insurance Company also pleaded that as the tractor driver was not holding a valid driving licence, it was not liable on that additional ground as well.
4. On the questions posed, the following issues were framed:
1. Whether the accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of Bhagwan Dass-respondent No. 1? OPP
2. To what amount of compensation the petitioners are entitled to get and from whom? OPP
3. Whether the petition is time barred? OPR
4. Whether the petition is liable to be dismissed as alleged in preliminary objection Nos. 1 and 3 of the written statement? OPR
5. Whether the petition is bad for non-joinder of parties? OPR
6. Relief.
5. The Tribunal found that the accident had taken place on account of rash and negligent driving of the tractor driver, Bhagwan Dass. On issue No. 2, the Tribunal held that on a consideration of the evidence, it was evident that the monthly income of Bhajan Lal deceased was about Rs. 600/- and that after spending a sum of Rs. 200/- per month on himself, the annual dependency worked out to be Rs. 4800/-. ???d applying a multiplier of 16 as the deceased was about 26 years of age determined the compensation at Rs. 76,800/-. The Tribunal further held that Bhagwan Dass the tractor driver did not have a driving licence and as such though the tractor stood insured, the Insurance Company was not liable to make good the compensation and accordingly held the owner and the driver of the tractor i.e, the two appellants responsible jointly and severally for the payment of the compensation. Hence this appeal at their instance.
6. Mr. L.M Suri, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants has urged that he did not seriously challenge the quantum of compensation that had been determined by the Tribunal but the finding of the Tribunal that Bhagwan Das did not hold a valid driving licence was incorrect. He has further pointed out that while this appeal remained pending here, CM No. 7591-CII and 7592-CII of 1993 was moved for additional evidence and this CM was allowed after notice to the parties and Ramesh Chand the owner of the truck and Bhagwan Dass its driver were fully examined and the driving licence Ex. C-1 in the name of Bhagwan Dass was proved in this case and as such the Insurance Company could no longer escape its liability to pay the compensation.
7. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also gone through the record. As already mentioned above, the compensation that has been found due has not been seriously challenged by Mr. Suri. The only ground by which the Insurance Company was able to escape its liability was that Bhagwan Dass did not hold a driving licence. As mentioned above, this shortcoming in the evidence was Tilled up as the licence Ex. C-1 has been produced and proved in this Court. A look at this licence (which is limited for the purpose of driving a tractor) would indicate that it was initially valid from 7.9.1965 to 6.9.1968 and that it was subsequently renewed from 7.1.1982 to 6.1.1985 It is apparent therefore that as the accident had taken place on 4.9.1981 the licence at that time was not a valid one as it had expired. However, in the light of the judgment of Ram Phul v. Krishna Makkar, (1988-2) 94 PLR 561, Mr. Suri has urged that if the driver at the time of the accident had a valid driving licence or had held one earlier, the Insurance Company was liable ipso facto. This assertion of the learned counsel is borne out by the judgment cited by him.
8. Mr. Munishwar Puri, the learned counsel for the Insurance Company has, however, argued that the document Ex. C-1 could not be read into evidence as it had not been properly proved. In this connection, he has cited Malwa Bus Service (P) Ltd., Moga District Faridkot, through its Managing Director v. Amrit Kaur, (1987-1) 91 PLR 618, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chandrawati etc., (1989-1) 95 PLR 240, and an unreported judgment of this Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satya Devi, (F.A.O No. 2090 of 1995) decided on 13th October, 1995.
9. I have gone through the judgments cited by the learned counsel and find that they do not apply to the facts of the present case. First and foremost, it is to be noticed that this argument is not open to the learned counsel in the light of the order of this Court dated 20th May, 1994 in which Mr. Puri the learned counsel appearing for the Insurance Company clearly stated that after enquiry, the Insurance Company had found out that the driving licence Ex. C-1 was a genuine document. It was, thereafter, that the additional evidence of Ramesh Kumar owner of the tractor and Bhagwan Dass its driver was recorded on 25th October, 1994 and the latter produced Ex. C-1 in Court and it was duly exhibited. Despite an opportunity having been given to Mr. Puri, not a single question was put in cross-examination. Obviously, this was so because in his statement made in Court on 20th May, 1994. Mr. Puri had accepted the genuineness of the driving licence.
10. Mr. Puri has then argued that as the driving licence had been produced at the appellate stage, the levy of interest which was found to be payable by the Insurance Company was not justified. In this connection, he has cited Joginder Singh v. The Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd., (1985-1) 87 PLR 642.
11. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, I am of the view that this argument is not open to challenge to the learned counsel Mr. Puri in the light of the fact that the obligation to show that the driver was not holding a driving licence lay on the Insurance Company.
12. The claimants have also filed cross-objections seeking enhancement of the compensation on the ground that the deceased had an income of Rs. 1000/- per month and as he was a frugal person, he spent only Rs. 200/- per month on himself. I have considered this argument of the learned counsel and find that some enhancement in the compensation is called for. As already mentioned above, the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs. 600/- and that he would have spent a sum of Rs. 200/- on himself, 1 am of the opinion that in the light of the fact that the deceased was earning Rs. 1000/- per month as per the evidence, the monthly dependency should be raised to Rs. 800/- and having come to this conclusion, the compensation is enhanced to Rs. 1,53,600/-. This appeal is, accordingly dismissed and the cross-objections are allowed, but it is held that the United India Insurance Company (respondent No. 1) alone would be liable to pay the amount of compensation.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert