Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mani Ram v. Labour Court, Ambala

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Feb 27, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Judgment — Anand, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These consolidated civil writ petitions challenge the Labour Court, Ambala's award dated December 30, 1993, which dismissed references by several workmen and denied any relief. The petitions arise from retrenchment actions taken by the employer in January–February 1983. Each petitioner had completed at least 240 days of service prior to termination; their services were terminated effective February 20, 1983.

The employer did not pay retrenchment compensation in cash at the time of retrenchment. Instead, the management issued a letter dated February 16, 1983, asking particular employees to collect retrenchment compensation on February 17 and 18, 1983. A subsequent letter dated February 25, 1983, informed workmen that their retrenchment compensation, pay and allowances for February had been drawn and were lying in the office and requested collection "at once." The employer also attempted to send amounts by money order after February 20, 1983, and relied on the postal authority's report of "refused" in support of non-acceptance.

The Labour Court concluded that the employer had offered compensation in time (by the February 17–18 notice), that the workmen deliberately refused to accept payment, and therefore the statutory conditions under S.25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, were satisfied; the Labour Court denied relief. The present writ petitions were filed against that award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the employer complied with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947—in particular clause (b)—which requires payment of retrenchment compensation "at the time of retrenchment", given that compensation was not paid in cash on the date the retrenchment took effect (February 20, 1983).
  2. Whether the employer could be regarded as having discharged its statutory obligation by (a) issuing a prior notice asking workmen to collect compensation on specified earlier dates (February 17 and 18, 1983) or (b) by sending money orders after the expiry of the notice period (i.e., after February 20, 1983).
  3. Whether the delay (the workmen instituting adjudication steps in 1986) rendered the workmen's claims stale and therefore barred relief despite any non-compliance with S.25-F.

Arguments of the Parties

Management's Arguments

  • The management contended before the Labour Court that each workman had been asked to collect retrenchment compensation before February 20, 1983 (specifically on February 17 and 18, 1983) and that every effort was made to pay the workmen; the workmen did not accept the offer.
  • The management also relied on subsequent attempts to send money orders (after February 20, 1983) and on postal reports of "refused" as evidence the workmen deliberately refused payment.
  • Before this Court, the management argued that the workmen's claim was stale because they initiated adjudication steps in 1986, and therefore the Labour Court's award dismissing the reference should be upheld on the ground of delay.

Petitioners' Arguments / Position

  • The petitioners challenged the Labour Court's conclusion and maintained that S.25-F(b) had not been complied with because retrenchment compensation was not paid at the time of retrenchment (i.e., on February 20, 1983).
  • During hearings before this Court, counsel for the petitioners conceded that they would be satisfied with reinstatement into service with continuity of service and that they would not press a claim for back-wages.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohan Lal v. Management of M/s Bharat Electronics Ltd., [1981 (2) L.L.N 23] Where a prerequisite for valid retrenchment under S.25-F is not complied with, retrenchment bringing about termination of service is void ab initio. The Court relied on this principle to hold that non-compliance with S.25-F(b) (payment "at the time of retrenchment") rendered the retrenchment invalid and therefore the workmen remained in service.
State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha, [A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 610] Failure to comply with S.25-F (a condition precedent) renders the order of retrenchment invalid and inoperative so that the workman does not cease to be in service. The Court applied this authority to reinforce that once S.25-F is not complied with, retrenchment does not bring about cessation of service; accordingly the employer's retrenchment orders could not be sustained.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the statutory prerequisites in Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The Court specifically noted clause (b) of S.25-F which requires that "the workman has been paid, at the time of retrenchment, compensation" equivalent to fifteen days' average pay for each completed year of service (or part in excess of six months).

The Court then compared the statutory requirement with the facts: the retrenchment notice dated January 20, 1983, made the retrenchment effective on February 20, 1983. However, retrenchment compensation was not paid in cash on that date. Instead, the employer had sent a letter dated February 16, 1983 asking workmen to collect compensation on February 17 and 18, 1983, and later sent another letter dated February 25, 1983 saying amounts were lying in office. The employer also attempted to send money orders after February 20, 1983.

The Court held that these steps did not satisfy the mandatory requirement of S.25-F(b): directing workmen to collect compensation on earlier dates or sending money orders after the effective date of retrenchment did not amount to payment "at the time of retrenchment." The Court described the S.25-F requirements as mandatory in nature and concluded that the Labour Court had misinterpreted the legal effect of S.25-F in holding that the employer had complied by making an offer to collect or by later postal attempts.

The Court relied on established precedents (Mohan Lal and State of Bombay) that non-compliance with S.25-F renders retrenchment void ab initio and that the workman continues to be in service. Addressing the employer's contention that the claims were stale because adjudication steps were taken in 1986, the Court observed that the Legislature had not prescribed any limitation period for raising industrial disputes; mere delay does not preclude a workman from raising a dispute, though delay may be a factor in deciding appropriate relief. The petitioners' concession that they sought reinstatement with continuity but without back-wages was accepted as a reasonable resolution that answers the management's stale-claim argument.

On this basis the Court concluded that the retrenchments were illegal for failure to comply with S.25-F and that the Labour Court's award upholding the employer's position could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

All writ petitions are allowed; the retrenchment notices are quashed.

Direct effects ordered by the Court:

  • The retrenchment notices placed in each writ petition are quashed.
  • Each petitioner shall be deemed to have been reinstated into service with effect from February 20, 1983.
  • The petitioners shall be given the benefit of continuity of service.
  • No back-wages shall be awarded (the petitioners had indicated they would not press for back-wages and the Court accepted reinstatement with continuity but without back-wages).
  • There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications beyond the parties: The Court applied existing authorities establishing that non-compliance with S.25-F renders retrenchment void ab initio. The opinion does not announce a new legal principle beyond applying that established rule; its immediate effect is to restore the petitioners to service with continuity but without back-wages.

Show all summary ...

Anand, J.:— By this judgment we dispose of Civil Writ Petitions Nos. 12538, 12718, 14418 and 16919 to 16921 of 1994 as common question of law and fact is involved in all of them with regard to the compliance of the provisions of S. 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short, the Act).

2. The petitioners in all the petitions have given challenge to the award, dated December 30, 1993, of the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Ambala, vide which it was held that there was no merit in the reference of the workmen. Resultantly, none of the workmen was entitled to any relief. It is the admitted case of the parties that each of the petitioners had completed 240 days of service before their services were terminated by the management. It is also the common case of the parties that retrenchment compensation was not paid in cash on the day when the services of the petitioners were terminated. The management took the action which can be incorporated as follows:

“It may be noted from all persons as mentioned in the list attched that they should collect their retrenchment compensation on February 17, 1983 and February 18, 1983, from this office.

(Sd) -

Executive Engineer

U.O No. 568.HC II

Dated February 16, 1983.

Yet another letter was written by the office, which reads as follows:

“Your retrenchment compensation, pay and allowances for the month of February, 1983 have been drawn and are lying in this office. You are requested to collect the same at once.

Please acknowledge the receipt of this letter.

Executive Engineer/HCII

WYC, PE Project, HSEB,

Bhudkalan”.

This letter is dated February 25, 1983. The services of all the petitioners were terminated on February 20, 1983. The stand of the management before the Labour Court was each of the workmen was asked to collect the compensation before February 20, 1983. Every effort has been made by the management but the offer to receive the retrenchment compensation has not been accepted by the workmen. Thus the provisions of S. 25-F of the Act have been complied with. It was also the case of the management before the Labour Court that the workmen served the demand notice after a period of four years and for that reason the workmen are not entitled to be reinstated into service. The claim is stale. The Labour Court came to the conclusion that the workmen had the knowledge with regard to the collection of the retrenchment compensation amount from the office of the Executive Engineer, Bhudkalan, and that the workmen could collect the compensation on February 17, 1983 and February 18, 1983, before the expiration of the notice, which was to expire on February 20, 1983. Since the workmen failed to collect the amount from the office on the said dates the management sent the amount through the money order, which was not accepted by the workmen and the report of the postal authorities indicating “refused” cannot be doubted in this regard. The Labour Court also came to the conclusion that since the management had offered retrenchment compensation to the workmen well within time and the workmen, in fact, deliberately chose not to accept the same, for this reason there is no justification in the reference of the workmen and they are not entitled to any relief either by way of reinstatement into service, continuity of service or the payment of back-wages.

3. As I submitted at the very first instance, the point for determination in this case is whether the provisions of S. 25-F of the Act have been complied with properly by the management when it simply gave a notice to the workmen to collect the retrenchment compensation on February 17, 1983 and February 18, 1983. It has also to be seen whether the management is absolved of its statutory duty by sending the money order after the expiry of the date of the notice, i.e, February 20, 1983.

Section 25-F of the Act lays down as follows

“25-F. Conditions precedent to retrenchment of workmen.— No workman employed in any industry who has been in continuous service for not less than one year under an employer shall be retrenched by that employer until—

(a) the workman has been given one month's notice in writing indicating the reasons for retrenchment and the period of notice has expired, or the workman has been paid in lieu of such notice, wages for the period of the notice;

(b) the workman has been paid, at the time of retrenchment, compensation which shall be equivalent to fifteen days' average pay for every completed year of continuous service or any part thereof in excess of six months; and

(c) notice in prescribed manner is served on the appropriate Government or such authority as may be specified by the appropriate Government by notification in the Official Gazette”.

The retrenchment notice is dated January 20, 1983, and it is mentioned in it that since there was less work in progress against which the service of the workmen could be utilised, hence one month's notice under S. 25-F of the Act was given and further it was mentioned that every workman should treat himself being relieved from service with effect from February 20, 1983, i.e, the expiry of one month's notice period. Also it was mentioned in the letter, dated January 20, 1983, that the workman can collect the retrenchment compensation if payable under S. 25-B of the Act on February 22, 1983. No retrenchment compensation was given on February 20, 1983. Rather on February 16, 1983, the management wrote the letter calling upon the workmen to collect the retrenchment compensation on February 17, 1983 and February 18, 1983. After the appointed date, i.e, February 20, 1983, the management wrote letter, dated February 25, 1983, calling upon the workman that their retrenchment compensation, pay and allowances for the month of February, 1983, had been drawn and were lying in the office. The workmen were requested to collect the same at once.

4. A perusal of the provisions of S. 25-F would reveal that these provisions are mandatory in nature and Cl. (b) of S. 25-F postulates that no workman shall be retrenched until he has been paid compensation at the time of retrenchment. This section contains mandate that the employer shall not retrench a workman unless retrenchment compensation has been paid prior or at the time of the retrenchment. In the present case the condition postulated in S. 25-F(b) has not been complied with. It is no doubt correct that the workmen were directed to collect the retrenchment compensation on February 17 and 18, 1983 but by this letter the management is not exonerated of its statutory liability. Also the management is not exonerated nor it can be said that it has complied with the provisions of S. 25-F by sending the money order, which was sent after the relevant date, i.e, February 20, 1983. Even the letter, dated February 25, 1983, is not compliance of the provisions of S. 25-F of the Act. The learned Labour Court while passing the award has not correctly appreciated or interpreted the legal effect of the statutory provisions of S. 25-F of the Act. The erroneous approach of the Labour Court while applying the provisions of S. 25-F to the facts has caused miscarriage of justice to each of the workman and which finding of the learned Labour Court cannot be upheld it has been held in Mohan Lal v. Management Of M/S Bharat Electronics Ltd., Ltd., [1981 (2) L.L.N 23], that it is well settled that where pre-requisite for valid retrenchment as laid down in S. 25-F has not been complied with, retrenchment bringing about termination of service is ab initio void. Similar view was also taken in State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha, [A.I.R 1960 S.C 610], that failure to comply with their requirement of S. 25-F which prescribes a condition precedent for a valid retrenchment renders the order of retrenchment invalid and inoperative. In other words it does not bring about cessation of service of the workman. The workman continues to be in service.

5. Realising the above difficulty posed by the provisions of S. 25-F of the Act, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the management argued before us that the claim of the workmen is stale when they took steps for adjudication of the industrial disputes in the year 1986. On this ground the award of the Labour Court should be upheld. We are not in agreement with the argument raised by the learned counsel for the respondents. The Legislature purposely in its wisdom has not mentioned any limitation about the raising of the industrial disputes by the workmen. The stale claim of a workman, however, can compel us to think as to what relief should be given to them. Mere delay in raising industrial issue does not disentitle a workman from raising the industrial dispute. Termination of service is admittedly an industrial dispute within the meaning of S. 2(k) of the said Act.

6. During the course of arguments, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners fairly conceded before us that his clients would be satisfied if they are reinstated into service with the benefit of continuity of the same and that they shall not claim back-wages. In our view, the offer made by the workmen is quite judicious. This squarely meets the arguments of the learned counsel for the respondents that the demand of the workmen was stale. Since the mandatory provisions of S. 25-F of the Act have not been complied with the management when it did not pay the retrenchment compensation simultaneously with the enforcement of the retrenchment notice, therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the retrenchment of the petitioners was illegal and the retrenchment orders are liable to be quashed and we order accordingly.

7. Resultantly, all the writ petitions are allowed. The retrenchment notice placed in each of the writ petitions is quashed. The petitioner shall be deemed to have been reinstated into serve with effect from February 20, 1983, and they shall be given the benefit of continuity of service but without back-wages. There shall be no order as to costs.