Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Subhash Chander v. Valayati Ram

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 18, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary — G.C. Garg, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-landlord filed a petition under Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 seeking eviction of the petitioner-tenant from a shop in Safidon. The landlord alleged (inter alia) that the tenant was in arrears of rent and house tax, that the premises had become unfit for human habitation, and that the tenant had carried out extensive repairs without permission — specifically, removing a partition wall, plastering the walls and relaying the floor, thereby materially impairing the value and utility of the building. The tenant denied these allegations and maintained the premises were fit and that no structural changes impairing value had been made.

At trial the landlord pressed only two grounds: (1) the building had become unfit for human habitation; and (2) the tenant had effected extensive repairs materially impairing the demised premises. The Rent Controller dismissed the petition by order dated May 8, 1989, finding no conclusive evidence that the building was unfit and that the alleged repairs did not amount to material impairment. The landlord appealed; the appellate authority accepted the appeal by order dated July 22, 1990, relying on witness statements and a report of a local commissioner which described recent whitewashing, plastering and a newly constructed front floor. The appellate authority reversed on the issue of material alteration and ordered ejectment of the tenant on the ground of material alteration.

The tenant filed the present revision petition against the appellate authority's order. The High Court (G.C. Garg, J.) heard the matter and ultimately allowed the revision, set aside the appellate authority's order and restored the Rent Controller's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the repairs and alterations allegedly carried out by the tenant (plastering walls, relaying the floor, removal of a partition wall) amounted to "material impairment" of the value and utility of the demised premises such as to justify eviction under Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973.
  2. Whether the appellate authority's acceptance of the landlord's appeal and its finding of material alteration (leading to ejectment) were legally sustainable on the evidence before it, including the report of the local commissioner and witness statements.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The landlord was required to establish that the tenant in fact carried out repairs and that those repairs materially impaired the value and utility of the demised premises; the landlord failed to prove this essential fact.
  • The premises were fit and safe for human habitation; therefore the ground of unfitness was not made out.

Respondent's (Landlord's) Arguments

  • The appellate authority recorded a finding of fact after appraising evidence, including the local commissioner's report, that the tenant had made extensive repairs and materially impaired the value and utility of the shop (e.g., replacing the front floor, plastering walls), and that finding should be upheld to justify eviction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhupinder Singh v. J.L Kapoor The Division Bench observed that no fixed parameter can determine when material alterations will amount to impairment of value and utility. It analysed two conflicting views and approved the view that material alteration or construction by a tenant does not automatically constitute material impairment; such impairment must be proved or inferred from facts. The Court relied on this precedent's ratio to hold that the landlord must prove that the tenant's repairs materially impaired value or utility; the Court applied this principle to require cogent evidence of impairment and found none sufficient in the record.
Shri Ram v. Smt. Shella Rani This case represents the view that unauthorised construction by a tenant would itself amount to material impairment of the demised premises. The Court noted this as the contrasting view rejected by the Division Bench in Bhupinder Singh; it did not adopt Shri Ram's automatic rule and treated it as one side of the earlier conflict of authorities.
Sadhu Ram v. Niranjan Dass This case holds that construction raised or alterations by a tenant will not, by themselves, entitle the landlord to ejectment unless it is further proved that such construction materially impaired the value and utility of the demised premises. The Division Bench approved this view and the Court applied the same principle here: the landlord must plead and prove material impairment, which was not done to the Court's satisfaction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in these principal steps, as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Assessment of the trial findings: The learned Rent Controller examined the evidence, including the local commissioner's report, and found that even accepting the report in toto (which described recent cementing/plastering and a newly constructed front floor), the acts reported (cementing walls, relaying the floor) did not amount to materially impairing the value and utility of the building.
  2. Review of appellate authority's conclusion: The appellate authority concluded the tenant made material alterations (replacing front floor, plastering walls, differences in roof) and inferred that such alterations indicated the shop had become unsafe or that the tenant altered the premises to avoid eviction. The High Court scrutinised whether this conclusion was supported by findings and by proper proof of material impairment.
  3. Application of precedent and legal standard: Citing Bhupinder Singh (which considered the conflicting approaches in Shri Ram and Sadhu Ram), the Court emphasised the settled principle that material alterations or constructions by a tenant do not automatically amount to material impairment; the landlord must prove, or it must be inferable from the facts, that the alterations materially diminished the value or utility of the premises. "Material impairment" was described in the opinion as a substantial change in character—diminution of quality, value, strength or becoming worse.
  4. Examination of pleaded and proved particulars: The landlord's pleadings merely alleged plastering of four walls, relaying the front floor and removal of a partition wall. The Court noted (i) no specific pleading as to how removal of the partition wall diminished value or utility, (ii) the Rent Controller doubted whether such a wall even existed, and (iii) the appellate authority did not record a firm finding that the intervening wall was removed or that the roof was replaced, nor did it explain effects on value.
  5. Conclusion on sufficiency of evidence: Even if the local commissioner's report were accepted, and the tenant had indeed carried out the limited repairs described, those acts did not, on the evidence and on ordinary assessment, amount to material impairment. The appellate authority took a narrow and improper view by treating the reported repairs as sufficient; the High Court found this to be illegal and materially irregular given the lack of pleaded particulars and cogent proof linking alterations to impairment.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The revision is allowed; the order of the appellate authority is set aside and the order of the Rent Controller is restored.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The tenant will not be ejected on the ground of material alteration; the Rent Controller's dismissal of the landlord's eviction petition is restored. The revision is allowed and the petition is noted as allowed by the Court with no costs.
  • On precedent and broader law: The opinion applies and endorses the established principle (as reflected in Bhupinder Singh and Sadhu Ram) that unauthorised repairs or construction by a tenant do not automatically equate to material impairment; the landlord must plead and prove how the alteration materially diminished the value or utility. The decision in this case resolves the dispute on the facts without announcing a new legal principle beyond the authorities it follows.
R.M.S
Petition allowed.
Show all summary ...

G.C Garg, J.:— The respondent-landlord filed a petition against the petitioner-tenant under Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 seeking eviction from a shop situated within the municipal limits of Safidon, inter alia, alleging that the tenant was in arrears of rent and the house tax, the demised premises had become unfit for human habitation and that the tenant had carried out extensive repairs without his permission and consent, inasmuch as he removed a partition wall in the shop, plastered the four walls and relayed the floor and thereby materially impaired the value and utility of the building. The tenant refuted the allegations levelled in the petition and asserted that the tenanted premises are absolutely fit for human habitation and no repair or changes in the structure of the building has been effected by him, therefore, there is no question of impairing the value and utility of the building.

2. The trial, the landlord pressed only two grounds i.e the building had become unfit for human habitation and the respondent had effected extensive repairs in the demised premises thereby materially impairing the value and utility of the demised premises. Learned Rent Controller dismissed the petition by order dated May 8, 1989, by observing that there was no conclusive evidence on the file to arrive at the conclusion that the building in question had become unfit for human habitation and that the repairs even if carried out by the tenant i.e relaying of floor and plastering the walls did not amount to materially impairing the value and utility of the building in question. Appeal preferred by the landlord was, however, accepted by the appellate authority by order dated July 22, 1990. This is how, the tenant has filed the present revision against the order of the appellate authority.

3. At the very outset, it may be noticed that while accepting the appeal, the appellate authority on the basis of the statements of the witnesses examined by the petitioner and the report of the local commissioner concluded that the tenant had made extensive repairs and even replaced the floor of the front portion. Thereafter, a reference was made to the report of the local commissioner wherein it was stated that the front portion of the shop had been white washed 5/7 days before the visit of the Local Commissioner and the scratching of the cement on the walls of the front portion showed that the same had been plastered only 10/15 days back. The appellate authority in para 11 of the judgment under revision, while affirming the finding of the Rent Controller on issue No. 3 reversed the finding on issue No. 1, by observing as under:—

“I, on the basis of statements of witnesses examined by the respondent and the report of the local commissioner conclude that the tenant has made material alteration in the front portion of the shop by replacing its floor, by plastering the walls and doing such like other things. Even the roof of front portion appeared to be quite different from the roof of the hind portion. It at all the shop had not become unfit and unsafe, for human habitation, why the tenant took the law in his own hands and he got the front portion repaired and materially altered. If it needed some minor repair, he could request the landlord to do so and in case landlord refused to do so he could apply to the Rent Controller under the provisions of Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 for such repair. There is no justification for the tenant doing material repairs or alterations himself without knowledge of the landlord or without his consent or even without seeking permission of the Rent Controller. The only inference that can be drawn is against the tenant that the shop had become unsafe and unfit for human habitation and in order to avoid his eviction on this ground the tenant made not only extensive repairs but also material alteration.”

4. In the above backdrop, the appellate authority accepted the appeal and ordered ejectment of the tenant on the ground of material alteration made by him. The exact words used by the appellate authority may be noticed as under:—

“For the aforesaid reasons the appeal succeeds and it is accepted to the extent that the landlord is entitled to eviction of the tenant from the shop in dispute on the grounds of material alteration made by the tenant.”

5. It deserves to be clarified at this stage that the ejectment had not been ordered on the ground that the building had become unfit and unsafe for human habitation. Neither any finding in that behalf had been recorded nor it is the case of the landlord in this revision petition.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that in order to seek eviction from the demised premises, the landlord is required to establish on record that the tenant has in fact carried out repairs and the repairs so carried out are such as have materially impaired the value and utility of the demised premises which he had miserably failed to prove. He further contended that the premises in question were quite fit and safe for human habitation. On the other hand, Mr. C.B Goel, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the landlord submitted that the learned appellate authority has recorded a finding of fact after appraisal of evidence and relying upon the report of the local commissioner that the tenant has materially impaired the value and utility of the shop by carrying out extensive repairs alterations. He thus, submitted that the ejectment of the tenant from the demised premises should be upheld.

7. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and going through the record, I am of the view that this petition must succeed. After appreciating the entire evidence led by the parties, learned Rent Controller has found as a fact that the repairs carried out by the tenant do not amount to materially impairing the value and utility of the building in question. The ejectment petition was filed on November 11, 1986 and on the next day local commissioner was got appointed by the landlord for inspection of the spot on the ground that repair work was going on and the building material was lying on the spot. The local commissioner reported that no building material was lying on the spot, the walls were cemented only 10/15 days back, the front portion of the shop was white washed about 5/7 days earlier and the floor of the front portion ot the shop was also newly constructed. Learned Rent Controller after considering the entire evidence including the report of the local commissioner, observed that even if the report of the local commissioner is accepted in toto, mere cementing of the walls and relaying the floor, as reported by him did not amount to materially impairing the value and utility of the building in question. Learned appellate authority in coming to the conclusion that the tenant made extensive repairs and material alteration in the front portion of the shop by replacing the floor, by plastering the walls and doing such like other things, relied upon the report of the local commissioner and the statements of the witnesses examined by the tenant. Be that as it may, even it the report of the local commissioner is taken to be correct that the tenant carried out some repairs and made alterations in the shop in question, it has still to be seen, whether such repairs and alterations did materially impair the value and utility of the building.

8. While dealing with the above question, a Division Bench of this Court in Bhupinder Singh v. J.L Kapoor,1 observed that no parameter can be culled out under which it can be assumed that the material alterations made would be taken to be impairing the value and utility of the building. In the above noticed case the question before the Division Bench was, as to which of the two views was correct, viz. the one taken in Shri Ram v. Smt. Shella Rani,2 that unauthorised construction by a tenant would itself amount to material impairment of the value and utility of the demised premises, and the other view taken in Sadhu Ram v. Niranjan Dass,3 that any construction raised by the tenant by itself would not entitle the landlord to claim his ejectment unless it is further proved that such a construction has materially impaired the value and utility of the demised premises. The Division Bench of this Court approved the view taken in the latter case by observing that after repairs or construction raised or material alteration effected or the acts of commission or omission committed by the tenant it has to be further proved or it has to be inferred from the facts proved on record that the material alteration has materially impaired the value or utility of the demised premises. The Division Bench further observed that it cannot be laid down as a principle of law that whenever there is a material alteration or new construction by the tenant, it would itself amount to material impairment of the value and/or utility of the demised premises and such material impairment has to be understood as a man of ordinary prudence would understand, not a sensitive landlord. Applying the ratio of the observations of the Division Bench noticed above to the present case the only question to be considered is whether the repairs/alterations made by the tenant amounted to material impairment.

9. ‘Material impairment’ strictly stands for substantial change in character i.e diminishing of quality, value, strength and becoming worse or reduction in quality etc. The landlord seeking ejectment of on the aforesaid ground is bound to prove as a fact that the alterations made by the tenant materially impaired the value and utility of the building by leading cogent evidence. In the present case, all that has been pleaded by the landlord is that the tenant has plastered the four walls and relayed the floor of the front portion. It has also been pleaded that the tenant had in addition removed the partition wall in the ground floor of the shop. As regards the removal of the intervening wall, it cannot be termed as material alteration as the landlord has nowhere pleaded as to in what manner the said alteration has impaired the value and utility of the building. It is not the case of the landlord that with the removal of the wall any damage has been caused to the floor, roof or the walls and therefore, the value of the shop in question has diminished. Learned Rent Controller has even observed that in the instant case it was also doubtful whether there was any wall in existence or not. No finding much less a firm finding has been recorded by the appellate authority that the tenant did remove the intervening wall and/or also replaced the roof. There is absolutely no finding about the effect thereof.

10. Adverting to the other allegations attributed to the tenant, learned appellate authority has, virtually relying upon the report of the local commissioner, concluded that the tenant had made material alteration in the front portion of the shop by replacing its floor, by plastering the walls etc. These acts of commission and omission again cannot be taken to be of such a nature as to term them as material impairment especially in the absence of there being a specific stand on behalf of the landlord in the ejectment petition as to how such alterations materially diminished the value and/or utility of the demised premises. The learned appellate authority has taken a very narrow view of the matter and thus, acted illegally and with material irregularity. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case the only conclusion that can be drawn is that the landlord failed to plead and prove on record as to how the alleged repairs/alterations attributed to the tenant impaired the value and utility of the demised premises, what to talk of materially impairing the value and utility.

11. Consequently, the order of the appellate authority is set aside and that of the Rent Controller is restored. The revision stands allowed accordingly. No costs.

R.M.S
Petition allowed.