Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pavan Om Parkash Kejriwal v. Partap Steel Rolling Mills 1935 Ltd

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 5, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant supplied iron scrap to the respondent-company intermittently, with payments recorded in their account books. As per the respondent-company's statement of account for April 1, 1988, to March 31, 1989, an outstanding balance of Rs. 2,88,366.89 existed as of March 31, 1989. After partial payments and adjustments, the amount due to the appellant was Rs. 1,23,638.08. Due to non-payment, the appellant served a statutory notice under Section 434 of the Companies Act, 1956, and subsequently filed a company petition. The respondent-company defended by asserting that the appellant failed to procure necessary endorsements and release advices for import licences related to iron scrap, which prevented the appellant from earning brokerage charges of Rs. 1,56,839. The learned company judge found the debt to be bona fide disputed and refused to proceed with the petition. The appeal challenges this refusal to advertise the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the company petition filed under Sections 433 and 434 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956, should be allowed to proceed despite the respondent-company's bona fide dispute over the debt.
  2. Whether the appellant is entitled to recover the claimed debt given the respondent-company's defence regarding the failure to procure lawful transfer of import licences and subsequent reversal of the advance payment.
  3. Whether security in the form of immovable property should be directed to protect the appellant's claim pending civil proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent-Company's Arguments

  • The appellant acted as a broker to procure and arrange transfer of import licences for iron scrap, which are regulated by the Import and Export Policy.
  • The appellant failed to obtain the necessary endorsement and release advice for licences valued at Rs. 5,40,823.
  • The respondent-company had remitted Rs. 1,56,839 in advance as brokerage charges in good faith.
  • Due to the appellant's failure, the respondent-company reversed the advance payment entry and issued a debit note for Rs. 1,56,839.
  • Considering the running account, the appellant owes Rs. 41,236.50 to the respondent-company.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant disputed the respondent-company's claim that the sum of Rs. 1,56,839 was remitted to him, asserting it was not received.
  • The appellant contended entitlement to brokerage charges only if the lawful transfer and release advice were procured.
  • The appellant did not dispute receipt of the debit note sent by the respondent-company.
  • The appellant sought recovery of the outstanding amount of Rs. 1,23,638.08 through the company petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts and found that the respondent-company had a bona fide dispute regarding the debt claimed by the appellant. The appellant's failure to procure the necessary endorsement and release advice for import licences prevented entitlement to brokerage charges. The respondent-company's reversal of the advance payment and issuance of a debit note was undisputed. Given these facts, the court held that the debt was genuinely disputed and that the respondent-company was not shown to be unable to pay the debt. The learned company judge's refusal to proceed with the petition was thus justified. However, the court directed the respondent-company to furnish security by way of immovable property equivalent to the outstanding amount to protect the appellant's interests pending civil proceedings. The appellant was relegated to ordinary civil remedies but was entitled to claim the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act for the period the petition was pending.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed, with no order as to costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the company petition under Sections 433, 434, and 439 of the Companies Act, 1956, will not proceed due to the bona fide dispute over the debt. The appellant must pursue recovery through civil suit but is protected by a direction requiring the respondent-company to furnish security in immovable property. No new legal precedent was established by this ruling.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal is directed against the order of the learned company judge refusing to advertise the petition (C. P. No. 18 of 1990) filed by the appellant under Sections 433 and 434 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956 (for short "the Act").

2. The facts :

The appellant used to supply iron scrap to the respondent-company at different intervals and the payments by the respondent-company to the appellant were reflected in the account books of the parties. As per the statement of account supplied by the respondent-company to the appellant for the period from April 1, 1988, to March 31, 1989, a balance of Rs. 2,88,366.89 stood outstanding against it on March 31, 1989. Since a sum of Rs. 1,50,000 was paid to the appellant in May, 1989, out of the balance amount and a sum of Rs. 14,728.81 was further adjusted against the amount of Laxmi Tubes and Engineering Co., Bombay, the amount still due to the appellant from the respondent-company comes to Rs. 1,23,638.08.

Since the respondent-company did not pay the amount to the appellant, statutory notice under Section 434 of the Act was served by the appellant upon the respondent-company. Non-payment of the amount due led to the filing of the company petition.

3. In the written statement, the respondent-company took the following defence :

The petitioner approached the respondent-company with an offer to procure and arrange the transfer of import licences in respect of imported scrap. The petitioner offered to act as a broker and the respondent-company agreed to pay necessary brokerage charges for lawful transfer of these licences. It may be stated that the import of licences in respect of iron scrap is regulated by the Import and Export Policy which is formulated by the Ministry of Commerce, Government of India. It was the duty of the petitioner to comply with all the formalities requisite for legal and valid transfer of the import licences before the same could be endorsed in favour of the respondent-company, thereafter, it was for the petitioner to procure the release advice, i.e., customs clearance and thereby to enable the respondent to import the goods. Admittedly, the petitioner could not get the necessary endorsement of the release advice in respect of the licences, the total value of which was Rs. 5,40,823. Had these licences been duly endorsed and the release advices procured by the petitioner, the petitioner would have been entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,56,839 being brokerage charges. Since the respondent-company was having regular dealings with the petitioner, the respondent-company in good faith had remitted a sum of Rs. 1,56,839 in advance to the petitioner on March 7, 1989. However, when the petitioner failed to get the legal and valid transfer of the import licences in favour of the respondent-company, the entry of Rs. 1,56,839 was reversed on December 30, 1989. A debit note dated December 30, 1989, for Rs. 1,56,839 was sent by the respondent to the petitioner on December 31, 1989. Taking into consideration up to date the running account between the parties, the petitioner owes a sum of Rs. 41,236.50 to the respondent-company.

4. On the basis of the material placed before him, the learned company judge held that the debt was bona fide disputed by the respondent company and the defence could not be categorised as unsubstantial. He, thus, refused to proceed with the company petition.

5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that a sum of Rs. 1,56,839 allegedly remitted by the respondent-company was not remitted to the appellant. The submission is devoid of any merit. The appellant was to procure and arrange the transfer of import licences in respect of the imported iron scrap and he was to be paid the brokerage charges for lawful transfer of these import licences. The appellant was to procure the release advice, i.e., customs clearance to enable the respondent-company to import goods. The appellant could not get the necessary endorsement of the release advice in respect of the licences of the value of Rs. 5,40,823. If these licences had been duly endorsed and the release advices procured by the appellant, the appellant would have been entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,56,839 as brokerage charges. The respondent-company in good faith advanced a sum of Rs. 1,56,839 on March 7, 1989. The appellant failed to get the legal and valid transfer of the import licences in favour of the respondent-company. So, the respondent-company reversed the entry of Rs. 1,56,839 on December 30, 1989, and on the following day sent the debit note dated December 30, 1989, for the said amount to the appellant. The receipt of the debit note dated December 30, 1989, sent by the respondent-company to the appellant on December 31, 1989, was not disputed in the rejoinder filed by the appellant. On the admitted facts, we are satisfied that the debt is bona fide disputed by the respondent and it cannot be said that the respondent-company is unable to pay the debt.

6. We find no ground to interfere with the order of the learned company judge. However, it will meet the ends of justice if the respondent-company is directed to furnish security of immovable property in the sum of Rs. 1,23,638.08 to the satisfaction of the Registrar General of this court within three* months so that in the event of appellant's succeeding in establishing his claim in the civil court he can recover the amount due to him through the sale proceeds of the property. The appellant has already been relegated to his ordinary remedy of civil suit for the recovery of the amount claimed in the petition under Sections 433, 434 and 439 of the Act. However, it is made clear that the appellant will be entitled to claim the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act for the period during which the petition was pending in this court.

7. For the reasons aforesaid, the appeal is dismissed, but with no order as to costs.