Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sardul Singh v. State Of Haryana .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 5, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by Sardul Singh under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, seeking quashment of First Information Report No. 293 dated 12.9.88 registered at Police Station Sadar Hissar for offences alleged under Sections 205, 209, 420, 467, 468, 506 and 47 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code. The primary ground advanced by the petitioner was that the taking of cognizance of the offences by any Court is barred by the provisions of Section 195(1)(b)(i), (ii) and (iii) read with Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code and, by necessary implication, that investigation into such offences is also barred.

The factual allegations in the complaint by Mst. Gurnam Kaur (complainant) were that she was the owner of land measuring 98 Kanals 8 Marias in village Beer Babran and that Sardul Singh, together with fourteen other named persons, conspired to usurp the land. It was alleged that a decree dated 9.6.88 was obtained in the civil Court of Shri S.P. Sharma, Sub Judge IInd Class, Hissar, by producing a woman impersonating Gurnam Kaur who filed a written statement and made a statement in court admitting the plaintiffs' claim to ownership in favour of Sardul Singh and others. Civil suits concerning an agreement to sell the land to Bhalla Ram and Tek Chand (and heirs) were pending; the complainant alleged continued possession and an interim stay from the civil Court restraining the accused from disturbing possession.

In the respondent State's return it was averred that a clear fraud was played on Gurnam Kaur by producing another lady instead of the complainant before the civil Court and obtaining a decree; the return also referred to a handwriting expert's report indicating the signatures of Gurnam Kaur did not match the signatures on the written statement and vakalatnama filed by the impersonator.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether taking of cognizance by any Court of offences alleged to have been committed in relation to proceedings in a Court (specifically offences under Sections 205, 209, 468, 469, 467 and related provisions) is barred by Section 195(1)(b)(i), (ii) and (iii) of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, read with Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
  2. Whether, by necessary implication, investigation into such offences is barred when the alleged offences relate to falsification, impersonation or giving false evidence in proceedings before a civil Court.
  3. Whether the First Information Report No. 293/88 and consequential criminal proceedings should be quashed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code on the basis of the above bars.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petition under Section 482 sought quashment of the FIR on the ground that cognizance of the offences alleged is specifically barred by Section 195(1)(b)(i),(ii) and (iii) read with Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code, and therefore the criminal investigation and proceedings are impermissible.

Respondent State's Arguments

  • The State's return maintained that the matter was a clear case of fraud on Gurnam Kaur because another woman had been produced in the civil Court in place of the complainant and a decree obtained; the return relied on a handwriting expert's report indicating mismatch between the complainant's signatures and the signatures on the written statement and vakalatnama filed by the impersonator.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harbans Singh v. State, AIR 1987 Punj and Hary 9 : 1986 Cri LJ 834 (Full Bench) Held that the bar in Section 195 applies to documents tampered with or fabricated after production in Court, and not to documents fabricated outside Court but later tendered in evidence. The court noted this Full Bench decision and observed that although its ratio is under challenge before a larger Full Bench (Registrar, High Court v. Madan Lal Sharma), in the present case the impersonator made a false statement in Court itself; therefore the provisions of Section 195(1)(b)(i)–(iii) apply to the offences alleged.
Registrar, High Court v. Madan Lal Sharma (Criminal Misc No. 1342-M of 1985) Identified in the opinion as a matter before a larger Full Bench challenging the ratio of Harbans Singh. The opinion records that Harbans Singh's ratio is under assail before this larger Full Bench, but proceeds to apply the relevant rule to the present facts (where false evidence/impersonation occurred in Court).
Sheela Devi v. State of Punjab, 1979 Chand LR (Cri) 195 (Punj & Har) Observed that provisions of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) and (iii) read with Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code bar not only taking of cognizance by a criminal Court but also investigation into such allegations by necessary implication. The court relied on the observations in Sheela Devi as supporting authority for the proposition that investigation into offences mentioned in Section 195 is barred because investigation would be a futile exercise if the criminal Court cannot take cognizance except on complaint in writing by the Court where offences were committed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by (i) identifying the factual matrix: a woman allegedly impersonated the complainant in the civil suit, filed a written statement and made a statement in the civil Court admitting the plaintiffs' claims; (ii) characterising the conduct as offences of impersonation, forgery and giving false evidence punishable under Sections 205, 209, 468 and 469 of the Penal Code, committed "in the civil Court itself"; (iii) citing the text of Section 195(1)(b) which bars taking cognizance by any Court of specified offences when such offences are alleged to have been committed in relation to any proceeding in any Court, except on the written complaint of that Court or a superior Court; and (iv) observing established judicial treatment (including the Full Bench in Harbans Singh and the Sheela Devi decision) concerning the scope of Section 195 and the procedure in Section 340.

Applying those principles to the facts, the court concluded that the offences alleged (including those under Sections 193 to 196, 199, 200, 205 and 209 and offences in respect of documents such as 463, 468, 471 and 476) were committed in relation to proceedings in the civil Court. Consequently, taking cognizance by a criminal Court without the written complaint by the civil Court (or its superior) is barred by Section 195(1)(b). The court further examined Section 340 which prescribes the procedure to be followed by the Court where such offences are committed: the civil Court is to record a finding, make a written complaint to the Magistrate First Class, secure appearance and bind over witnesses. The court reasoned that allowing a criminal investigation to proceed without that prescribed civil Court action would amount to the investigating agency usurping the function of the civil Court, contrary to the statutory scheme.

The court also emphasised that the offences and facts overlap and form part of the same transaction; thus Section 195(1)(b)(ii) applies to those overlapping offences as well. The decision in Sheela Devi was relied upon to support the proposition that investigation is also barred by necessary implication because proceeding with investigation would be futile if the criminal Court is precluded from taking cognizance.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Petition allowed; the First Information Report No. 293 dated 12.9.88 and other proceedings resulting therefrom are quashed.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The ongoing criminal investigation into the offences alleged in the FIR was held to be a clear abuse of process and a futile exercise because no criminal Court can take cognizance of the offences in question except on the written complaint of the civil Court where the alleged offences were committed (or of a superior Court).
  • The quashment does not bar the complainant from pursuing the procedure prescribed by Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code: Gurnam Kaur is at liberty to approach the concerned civil Court under Section 340 for filing a complaint against the accused for the referred offences.
  • The court expressly directed that the time the complainant spent in pursuing the present criminal proceedings shall not be counted against her for the purposes of limitation or laches, noting she had acted in good faith, unaware of the provisions of Sections 195 and 340.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying existing statutory provisions and cited authorities; its consequences are limited to quashing the FIR and allowing the complainant to seek relief via the procedure in Section 340.

Order: Petition allowed.

Show all summary ...

J.S Sekhon, J.:— Sardul Singh has filed this petition under Section 482 of the Criminal PC 1973, for quashing the first information report No. 293, dated 12.9.88 for offences under sections 205, 209, 420, 467, 468, 506 and 47 read with Section 120-B of the IPC registered at Police Station Sadar Hissar, inter alia on the ground that the taking of cognizance for the above referred offences by the Court is specically barred by the provisions of Section 195, sub-sections (1)(b)(i) (ii) and (iii) read with Section 340 of the Criminal PC and that by necessary implication, the investigation into such offence is also bar ed.

2. The brief resume of facts relevant for the disposal of this petition is that on the application of Mst. Gurnam Kaur, complainant, the above said case was registered at Police Station Sadar Hissar. In that application, Mst. Gurnam Kaur had averred that she is the owner of the land measuring 98 Kanals 8 Marias located in the revenue estate of village Beer Babran and has also constructed a house thereon. She has further averred that Sardul Singh accused entered into conspiracy With fourteen other persons, fully described therein, to usurp the land and in pursuance of the same, obtained a decree dated 9.6.88 from the Court of Shri S.P Sharma, Sub Judge IInd Class, Hissar, by producing some other lady impersonating as Gurnam Kaur. The lady who had impersonated as Gurnam Kaur filed a written-statement and also made a statement in the Court admitting the claim of the accused plaintiff regarding ownership over the land in dispute in favour of Sardul Singh, petitioner, as well as Baldev Singh, Joginder Singh and Shehanshah Singh. It is further alleged that Mst. Gurnam Kaur had entered into an agreement to sell this land to Bh?.Ila Ram and Tek Chand but after the death of the latter, none of the heirs of Tek Chand and Bhalla Ram came to get the sale deed executed and thus the said agreement to sell was cancelled as per its terms. Regarding this agreement, civil suits are pending in the civil Court between the applicant and Bhalla Ram and heirs of Tek Chand deceased. Thus it is maintained that these persons had entered into conspiracy to play fraud upon the complai ant for usurping the land. It is also maintained that the complainant is still in possession of the land and got an interim stay order from the civil Court restraining the accused in this case from disturbing her possession over the land in dispute.

3. In the return filed by the respondent State, it is stated that it is a clear case of playing fraud upon Gurnam Kaur as the accused had produced some other lady instead of Gurnam Kaur before the civil Court and got a decree in their favour. It is further stressed that the report of the Hand-writing Expert clearly shows that the signatures of Gurnam Kaur, complainant, do not tally with the signatures figuring on the written-statement and Vakalatnama filed by the lady impersonating as such in the above referred civil suit.

4. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties besides perusing the record.

5. Admittedly, in the case in hand, the written statement was filed by a lady allegedly impersonating as Gurnam Kaur admitting the claim of Sardul Singh and other plaintiffs regarding the ownership of the land in dispute before the Court of Sub Judge IInd Class, Hissar. The matter does not rest here as aforesaid lady who had allegedly impersonated as Gurnam Kaur had also made a statement in that civil Court admitting the claim of the plaintiffs in the suit. Thus under these circumstances, there is absolutely no doubt that the offence of impersonation, forgery and giving a false evidence etc. punishable under Sections 205, 209, 468 and 469 of the Penal Code were committed in the civil Court itself. The provisions of S. 195(1)(b)(i)(ii) of Criminal P.C 1973, read as under:

“195. Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of Pupltc servants, for offences against public justice and for offences relating to documents given in evidence — (1) No Court shall take cognizance—

… … … … … … … …

(b)(i) of any offence punishable under any of the following sections of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1890, namely, Sections 193 to 196, 199, 200, 205 to 211 (both inclusive) and 228 when such offence is alleged to have been committed in, or in relation to any proceeding in any Court………….”

6. A bare glance through the above leaves no doubt that where the offences under Sections 13 to 96, 199, 200, 205 to 211 and 228 are alleged to have been committed in or in relation to any proceedings in any Court or offences under Sections 463, 471, 475 and 476 of the Penal Code are alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in any proceedings in any Court, then taking of cognizance of such offences is baired by any Court except on the complaint in writing of that Court where such offences were committed or of some other Court to which such Court is subordinate. Although there are divergent views regarding the application of the above referred provisions of Section) 195 of the Criminal PC regarding the document which was forged outside the Court but tendered in evidence thereafter in the Court and the one where the forgery regarding the document was committed after it was placed on the file of the Court.

7. A Full Bench of this Court comprising of three Judges in Harbans Singh v. State, AIR 1987 Punj and Hary 9 : 1986 Cri LJ 834. after elaborate discussion had held that the bar enacted in Section 195 of the Criminal PC is applicable to those documents only which are tampered with or fabricated after their production in the Court and not concerning those documents which were fabricated outside the Court but tendered in evidence later on. The ratio of the decision of the above referred Full Bench is under assail before a larger Full Bench of this Court in Registrar, High Court v. Madan Lal Sharma (Criminal Misc No. 1342-M of 1985). Anyhow as in the case in hand admittedly the lady who had allegedly impersonated as Gurnam Kaur had made a false statement in the Court itself, there is no doubt that the above referred provisions of Section 195(1)(b) (i), (ii and (iii) would be applicable to the offences mentioned in Sections 193 to 196, 199, 200, 205 and 209 of the Penal Code, 1860, and the taking of cognizance of these offences by any Court except on the complaint in writing of Sub Judge IInd Class, Hissar, or some other superior Court to which that Court was subordinate. In the case in hand no such sanction was obtained. The facts and circumstances of the case constituting the above referred offences as well as the offences punishable under Sections 467, 468 and 471 are overlapping each other and form part of the same transaction. Thus by necessary implication, the provisions of Section 195 (1)(b)(ii) would be applicable to these offences also.

8. The matter does rest here as the previsions of Section 340 of the Criminal PC prescribing procedure in cases mentioned in Section 195 of the Criminal PC further make it clear that the Court where such offences mentioned in Section 195 are committed shall suo motu or on the application of the aggrieved party record a finding regarding the forgery of any document or giving of false evidence and thereafter make a complaint thereof in writing and despatch the same to the Magistrate Ist Class having jurisdiction to take cognizance of such offences. It is further provided that the Court shall take sufficient security for the appearance of the accused before such Magistrate, and bind over any person to appear and give evidence before such Magistrate, The reading of the above referred provisions of Section 195 coupled with the procedure prescribed in Section 340 of the Criminal PC absolutely leave no doubt that not only cognizance of such offences without the complaint in writing of the Court concerned is barred but also the investigation into such effences because that will amount to taking over the function of the Court, where forgery was committed, by the investigating agency which is against mandate of S. 340 of the Criminal P.C

9. The above referred view also finds support from the observations of Justice D.S Tewatia (as he then was) in Sheela Devi v. State of Punjab, 1979 Chand LR (Cri) 195 (Punj & Har). In that case also, the first information report for offences under Sections 467, 468, 471, 480 and 120 B read with Section 109 of the Penal Code was quashed by holding that the provisions of Section 95(1)(b)(ii) and (iii) read with Section 340 of the Criminal Pal P 2 not only bar the taking of cognizance of the offences by the criminal court but also the investigation into the allegations of such offences by necessary implication, as that will be a futile exercise if the Criminal Court cannot take cognizance of the offence except on the complaint in writing of the Court where such offences were committed regarding giving of false evidence or forged documents etc.

10. For the reasons recorded above, there is no escape but to conclude that the continuance of the present investigation is a clear abuse of the process of the Court and futile exercise as no Court can take cognizance of the above referred offences except on the complaint in writing of the civil Court where such offences were committed. Thus by accepting this petition, the above referred first information report and other proceedings resulting therefrom are quashed.

11. It is, however, clarified that Gurnam Kaur, complainant, shall be at liberty to approach the concerned Court under Section 340 of the Criminal PC for filing a complaint against the accused for the afore referred offences and the time spent by her in pursuing the present proceedings shall not be taken into consideration while computing the period of limitation or considering the effect of laches on her part as she has filed the complaint and lodged the first information report in good faith being oblivious of the provisions of Sections 195 and 340 of the Criminal PC.

Petition allowed.