- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gurpreet Singh (Minor) v. Chatterbhuj Goel .
Concise Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This dispute arises from an agreement to sell a house (H. No. 1577, Sector 18D, Chandigarh) entered into on 4 June 1979 between Col. Sukhdev Singh (acting as guardian of the then minor Gurpreet Singh, the appellant) and the respondent (Shri C.B. Goel). Permission for the guardian to sell the property had been obtained under S. 8 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (order dated 11 April 1979). The agreement fixed the purchase price and schedule of payments, but the sale deed was not executed within the stipulated period amid disagreements and apparent reservations on the guardian's part.
The respondent filed a suit for permanent injunction and a criminal complaint (S. 420 IPC) against Col. Sukhdev Singh. The trial Court discharged Col. Sukhdev Singh, but the High Court set that order aside; the Supreme Court thereafter set aside the High Court and restored the trial Court's order, and gave the respondent an opportunity to file a suit for specific performance of the June 1979 agreement. The respondent filed such a suit; the trial Court found default by the appellant in executing the sale deed but declined specific performance under S.20 of the Specific Relief Act, giving primacy to the minor's interest. The learned single Judge on appeal reversed that refusal and decreed specific performance. The present letters patent appeal challenges the single Judge's decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether non-compliance with Order 32, Rules 3 and 4, Civil Procedure Code (failure to obtain formal appointment/notice/consent for the guardian to represent the minor) rendered the suit incompetent and the decree void.
- Whether the various compromises/settlements recorded during proceedings (including those on 4 Feb 1980, 2 Sept 1980 and a later attempted compromise on 28 Jan 1987) operated as novation of the original agreement dated 4 June 1979.
- Whether a decree for specific performance should be granted in the exercise of the court's discretion, having regard to the interests of the minor, the conduct of the parties and any hardship or prejudice.
- Whether the plaintiff-respondent had sufficiently pleaded and shown readiness and willingness to perform his part of the contract (including conformity with Forms 47 & 48 of Appendix A to the C.P.C.).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. R.S. Bindra)
- The default in execution of the sale deed lay on the respondent rather than the appellant; thus plaintiff not entitled to decree for specific performance.
- The original contract had been novated by the compromises recorded on 4 Feb 1980 (in the High Court) and 2 Sept 1980 (in the Supreme Court), and a later compromise during the Letters Patent hearing, so the June 1979 agreement no longer governed the parties.
- The plaint did not conform to Forms Nos. 47 and 48 of Appendix 'A' to the C.P.C., and failed adequately to plead readiness and willingness to perform.
- The suit was incompetent because Col. Sukhdev Singh, though acting for the minor, had not been formally appointed as guardian in accordance with O.32, Rrs.3 & 4 C.P.C.; therefore the proceedings were void for non-compliance with mandatory rules.
Respondent's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Sarin)
- Col. Sukhdev Singh had effectively represented the minor throughout the litigation, including before the Supreme Court; no prejudice had been caused to the minor by the absence of a formal appointment under O.32, R.3 & 4.
- Reliance on O.32, R.3A C.P.C. — non-compliance will not void a decree merely because the guardian had an interest adverse to the minor; only actual prejudice will justify setting aside a decree.
- Placed reliance on several authorities (listed in the opinion) to support the proposition that effective representation and absence of prejudice sustain the decree despite procedural irregularity.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Amrik Singh v. Karnail Singh, AIR 1974 Punj & Har 315 (Full Bench) | Principle that non-compliance with O.32, R.3 may not render a decision void if the minor was effectively represented and no prejudice resulted. | The court distinguished this authority on facts: although Amrik Singh held that effective representation can cure non-compliance, the present case was found different on the facts and did not support the respondent's position that non-compliance did not vitiate the proceedings. |
| Mt. Bibi Walian / Wallian v. Banke Behari Pershad Singh, (1903) ILR 30 Cal 1021 | Historical authority interpreting Section 443 of the Civil Procedure Code (Act XIV of 1882); used by some parties as supporting representation arguments. | The court noted Nirmal Chandra's observation that Walian's case interpreted an earlier statutory provision materially different from present Order 32 rules, and therefore the present court did not treat it as controlling. |
| Bhagabat Sahu v. Parbati Samal, AIR 1982 Ori 186 | Listed as an authority relied on by respondent (specific rule cited not detailed in the opinion). | The court observed that Bhagabat Sahu (like other authorities relied upon) was distinguishable on facts and did not support the respondent's case here. |
| Anandram v. Madholal, AIR 1960 Raj 189 | Authority for the proposition that where a minor was effectively represented by a father or party whose interests were aligned, absence of a formal order of appointment may not invalidate proceedings. | The court held this authority distinguishable: in Anandram the plaintiff had applied for appointment and the court committed default; facts differed from present case and hence it did not support respondent's contention. |
| Nirmal Chandra v. Khandu Ghose, AIR 1965 Cal 562 | Holds that failure to comply with Order 32, Rule 3 (notice, written consent etc.) may vitiate a decree; non-compliance of mandatory provisions renders the decree void. | The court considered this decision factually similar and relied upon its reasoning to hold that non-compliance with mandatory provisions of O.32 Rrs.3 & 4 makes a decree void and is presumed to have caused prejudice; the single Judge's contrary finding was reversed on this ground. |
| Ranganayakamma v. Govinda Narayan, AIR 1982 Kant 264 | Principle that specific performance is discretionary; a decree will not be granted merely because it is lawful to do so, particularly where it would cause hardship to the defendant. | The court relied on this authority in exercising its discretion to refuse specific performance, holding that the plaintiff should not receive that discretionary relief given the circumstances (hardship to the minor, respondent's conduct, and other factors). |
| Civil Appeal No. 2035 of 1987 (reported AIR 1988 SC 400) | Supreme Court holding that a compromise recorded before the High Court was not valid because it had not been recorded in terms of Order 23, Rule 3 C.P.C. | The court noted the Supreme Court's finding that the attempted compromise on 28 Jan 1987 was invalid for non-compliance with O.23 R.3; nonetheless, the High Court considered the fact of the respondent's agreement and subsequent resiling as relevant in exercising its discretion on specific performance. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each tied to facts and statutory provisions as set out in the opinion:
- Default as to execution of the sale deed: The court examined the evidence and agreed with the findings of both the trial Court and the learned single Judge that the default in complying with the agreement dated 4 June 1979 had been committed by the appellant. No interference was warranted on this point.
- Whether compromises amounted to novation: The court reviewed the several compromises/settlements recorded during the litigation (4 Feb 1980; 2 Sept 1980; and the attempted compromise during the Letters Patent hearing). It concluded these were settlements proposed to end disputes, without any intention by the parties to change or modify the original June 1979 agreement; consequently those arrangements did not operate as novation of the original contract. The court applied the same reasoning to all three attempted compromises and agreed with the trial Court and single Judge on this point.
- Pleading of readiness and conformity with forms: The court examined the plaint and found that necessary averments, including readiness and willingness, had in fact been made; thus the appellant's contention that the plaint failed to conform to Forms 47 & 48 or to plead readiness was rejected.
- Compliance with Order 32, Rules 3 & 4 C.P.C.: The court undertook a detailed statutory analysis. It emphasized that O.32 R.3 provides special procedural safeguards for minors and requires an application, affidavit, notice to the relevant persons and written consent of the proposed guardian (as per R.4). The court held that the legislature had intentionally made these provisions mandatory and protective. Consequently, if an application for appointment is not made as prescribed, any person who acts as guardian lacks the requisite authority; presumed consent only arises after compliance with the prescribed steps. R.3A (relied upon by respondent) does not displace the requirement that the statutory steps first be taken.
- Effect of authorities and prejudice: The court considered authorities relied upon by the respondent (including Amrik Singh, Anandram, Wallian). It found them distinguishable on facts. The court regarded Nirmal Chandra v. Khandu Ghose as factually similar and persuasive on the point that non-compliance with mandatory O.32 Rrs.3 & 4 renders the decree void, and must be presumed to have caused prejudice. On this basis, the court reversed the learned single Judge's finding that the omission was merely an irregularity to be ignored.
-
Discretion on specific performance despite procedural defect: Although the mandatory-procedure defect would typically require remand to the trial Court for fresh decision, the court concluded that, considering other material facts and equities, remand was not appropriate. Applying the discretionary principle from Ranganayakamma (specific performance not to be granted where it results in hardship and is inequitable), the court declined to grant specific performance. Factors informing this exercise of discretion included:
- the trial Court's findings regarding the minor's interest (difficulty of reinvesting proceeds after passage of time and rising property prices);
- the respondent's conduct in repeatedly agreeing to compromises (including one before the Letters Patent Bench) and later resiling because the formalities of O.23, R.3 were not met — the court treated this conduct as forfeiting part of the respondent's equitable right to specific performance even if the compromise was legally unenforceable; and
- uneven conduct on both sides, including blemishes in the conduct of Col. Sukhdev Singh.
- Final relief fashioned: Taking the above together, the court allowed the appeal from the single Judge (i.e., set aside the decree for specific performance) but did provide a monetary remedy to the respondent: a decree for recovery of Rs. 2,25,000 as damages subject to deposit within six months with the Court's Registrar, and interest at 6% p.a. from date of filing if not timely paid. There was no order as to costs.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPEAL ALLOWED. The judgment and decree of the learned single Judge are set aside; the suit for a decree of specific performance is dismissed. The court awarded a decree for recovery of Rs. 2,25,000/- as damages in favour of the respondent subject to deposit within six months and with interest consequences if not deposited; no order as to costs.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The appellant (Gurpreet Singh) succeeds in having the specific-performance decree vacated, but the respondent is awarded monetary damages of Rs. 2,25,000/- (with payment and interest conditions).
- On procedural law: The court emphasized that Order 32, Rules 3 and 4 C.P.C. contain mandatory protections for minors; non-compliance with these provisions renders a decree void and is presumed to have caused prejudice, distinguishing authorities where effective representation and absence of prejudice justified upholding a decree. The court reversed the single Judge on that statutory point.
- On discretionary relief: The decision reiterates that specific performance is equitable and discretionary (Ranganayakamma), and past conduct of a plaintiff (e.g., agreeing then resiling from a compromise) and hardship to a defendant/minor are material factors in refusing specific performance.
- Broader precedent: The opinion does not purport to create a new principle beyond the application and reconciliation of existing authorities; it primarily applies existing statutory rules and established equitable principles to the facts before the Court.
Note: This summary reproduces and organizes conclusions and statements only as they appear in the provided opinion. No facts or inferences not present in the opinion have been added.
1. On December 18, 1978, Col. Sukhdev Singh, father of the then minor Gurpreet Singh, moved a petition under S. 8 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, for the grant of permission for the sale of H. No. 1577, Sector 18D, Chandigarh, belonging to the appellant. Vide order dated April 11, 1979, this petition was allowed by the Senior Subordinate Judge, Chandigarh and permission was granted to Col. Sukhdev Singh, acting on behalf of the minor to sell the property in question. As a sequel to the permission having been granted, Col. Sukhdev Singh, as guardian of the appellant, entered into an agreement with the respondent on June 4, 1979 for the sale of the house for Rs. 2,85,000/-. The agreement of sale fixed the schedule of payment as also the date by which the sale deed was to be executed. It appears from the evidence on record that the respondent in order to comply with the conditions of the agreement made arrangements for the payment of the sale price and was willing to have the sale deed executed. It has also come in evidence that Col. Sukhdev Singh, on the other hand seems to have developed some reservation with regard to the proposed sale, with the result that it could not be executed within the stipulated period. On July 18, 1979, the respondent filed a suit for permanent injunction against the appellant to restrain him from alienating the house in dispute to a third party as also a criminal complaint for an offence under S. 420, Indian Penal Code, against Col. Sukhdev Singh. The trial Court, however, vide order dated 31st October, 1979, discharged Col. Sukhdev Singh in the criminal complaint. Against the order of discharge, the respondent filed Criminal Revision No. 1495 of 1979 and during the pendency of the revision petition, the parties on 4-2-1980 agreed to compromise the dispute. The respondent agreed to pay a sum of Rs. 2,45,000/- plus interest of Rs. 1,35,000/- as also certain payments towards rent. Col. Sukhdev Singh was also required to obtain the sanction from the Estate Office and to execute the sale deed. Thereafter, the criminal complaint as also the civil suit were agreed to be withdrawn. It appears that once again Col. Sukhdev Singh did not faithfully abide by the terms of the compromise with the result that Crl. Revision No. 1495 of 1979 was ultimately accepted by the High Court vide order dated February 11, 1980, and the order of the trial Court discharging Col. Sukhdev Singh was set aside, Against the order of the High Court, Col. Sukhdev Singh filed Crl. Appeal No. 595 of 1980 before the Supreme Court, which was decided on 2nd September, 1980, and the order of the High Court was set aside and that of the trial Magistrate restored. The respondent was also given the opportunity to file a suit for specific performance of the agreement dated June 4, 1979. The Supreme Court, vide Us aforesaid order also directed that the appellant i.e. Gurpreet Singh would return a sum of Rs.40,000/- being the amount of earnest money, which he had received from the respondent.
2. In response to the suit filed by the respondent pursuant to the order of the Supreme Court, Col. Sukhdev Singh, as guardian of the minor appellant, filed a written statement controverting the allegations made in the plaint. On facts it was stated that the appellant had always been ready and willing to perform his part of the contract and the default had been committed by the respondent Sh. C.B. Goel. It was also mentioned that the compromise entered into between the parties during the pendency of Criminal Revision No. 1495 of 1979 could not be adhered to because the income-tax clearance certificate was not granted. It was also urged that the agreement to sell dated 4th June, 1979, stood rescinded in view of the compromise arrived at between the parties on 4th February, 1980 and by the order of the Supreme Court dated 2nd September, 1980. Objection as to the maintainability of the suit due to the non-compliance with O. 32, R. 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure was taken. The trial Court, after examining the evidence on record, came to the conclusion that the default in execution of the sale deed had been committed by the appellant and that there had been no novation of the contract as the statements in Court were in the nature of a settlement proposed in the Court at the time of the hearing of the case. The learned trial Court, however, declined to grant the decree to the plaintiff-respondent on the ground that the relief in a suit of specific performance being discretionary in view of the provisions of S. 20 of the Specific Relief Act, it was not incumbent on the Court to grant such a decree. The Court held that while granting a decree for specific performance, the interest of the minor was to be kept in view as the primary consideration. It was held that as more than two years had elapsed since the signing of the agreement dated 4th June, 1979, and as the prices of real estate in Delhi had risen substantially, during this period, it was not possible for the minor to purchase any property in Delhi with the amount that he was to receive from the respondent. This finding was based on the fact that while securing the permission to sell the property under S. 8 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 the Court had ordered that some property be purchased for the minor from the sale proceeds.
3. An additional factor which weighed with the Court while declining the relief of specific performance, was that Col. Sukhdev Singh had not been appointed the guardian for the minor appellant in terms of O. 32, R. 3, Civil Procedure Code, and as such, Col. Sukhdev Singh was not competent to defend the suit on behalf of the defendant/appellant. On the reasoning adopted by the learned trial Court it was held that the plaintiff-respondent was not entitled to the decree for specific performance. Dissatisfied with the decree of the trial Court, the respondent preferred an appeal to this Court. The learned single Judge endorsed the findings of the trial Court that the default in complying with the agreement dated 4th June, 1979 had been committed by the appellant defendant. On the question of the non-compliance with the provisions of O.32, R. 3, C.P.C. the learned single Judge held that Col. Sukhdev Singh, though not formally appointed as the guardian, had conducted the cases for the appellant effectively and fought the litigation to the best of his ability and with tenacity. It was held that the non-compliance with the aforesaid provisions of the Civil Procedure Code was an irregularity and as such, was required to be ignored in terms of O. 32, R. 3A, C.P.C. as no prejudice has been suffered by the appellant. The learned single Judge also held that the reasons recorded by the trial Court in denying the relief of specific performance were not germane. The learned single Judge allowed the appeal and decreed the suit. Against the decree of the learned single Judge, the present letters patent appeal has been filed.
4. Mr. R.S. Bindra, learned senior Advocate for the appellant has reiterated the various arguments raised before the learned single Judge. He has argued that on a reading of the evidence, it is clear that the default in execution of the sale deed lay on the respondent. We have examined this argument and perused the evidence on the record and find that the view taken by the trial Court as also by the learned single Judge on this point is correct and no interference is called for in the appeal under the letters patent.
5. Mr. Bindra then argued that the original contract stood novated in view of the agreement arrived at in the High Court on 4th February, 1980, and, thereafter in the Supreme Court on 2nd October, 1980. He has also pointed out that during the pendency of the present letters patent appeal yet another compromise had been arrived at between the parties. It appears that the hearing of this L.P. A. first commenced before a Division Bench on January 14, 1987, and continued for a number of days. On January 16, 1987, the counsel for the respondent had not concluded the argument and the hearing was adjourned to January 28, 1987. On that day the parties took time to explore the possibility of a compromise and the compromise was, in fact, arrived at between the parties. A statement was recorded by Col. Sukhdev Singh agreeing to pay Rs. 2,25,000/-to Shri C.B. Goel towards the full and final settlement of the dispute and this statement was duly endorsed by Shri V.K. Sharma, counsel for the appellant Gurpreet Singh. On this statement having been made, the offer was accepted by Shri C. B. Goel when he made the following statement:
"I accept the offer made by Col. Shkhdev Singh and Shri V.K. Sharma, counsel for the appellant Gurpreet Singh."
On this the case was adjourned to March 17, 1987, on which date, payment of Rupees 2,25,000/- was to be made. It appears however that during this interregnum the respondent changed his mind and decided to resile from the agreement taking advantage of the fact that the compromise had not been recorded in terms of O.23, R. 3, Civil Procedure Code, which required the compromise to be in writing and singed by the parties. As the compromise had fallen through, the learned Judges constituting the D.B. directed the matter to be listed for hearing before another Bench. The appellant herein however approached the Supreme Court by way of Civil Appeal No. 2035 of 1987 : (reported in AIR 1988 SC 400) praying that the statements recorded constituted a valid compromise. The Supreme Court however dismissed the appeal holding that the compromise recorded before the High Court was not valid as it had not been recorded in terms of the mandatory provisions of O.23, R. 3, Civil Procedure Code.
6. It will be seen from the above narration of facts that the argument raised by Mr. Bindra has no force as the agreements arrived at on 4th February, 1980, and the subsequent one dated 2nd September, 1980, did not constitute a novation of the contract as these were proposed settlements between the parties in order to settle the dispute and there was no intention of the parties to change or modify any part of the agreement dated 4th June, 1979. This reasoning is also to be applied with regard to the third settlement arrived at before the Letters Patent Bench on 28th January, 1987. The trial Court and the learned single Judge have also held that the action of the parties in respect of the earlier two agreements (the third one had not yet come into existence) does not constitute a novation of the contract dated 4th June, 1979. We are in agreement with the trial Court as also with the learned single Judge on this store as well.
7. Mr. Bindra has additionally contended that the plaint in a suit for specific performance must conform to the pro formas set out in Forms Nos. 47 and 48 of Appendex 'A' to the Civil Procedure Code, and it has to be specifically pleaded that the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. He has argued that these averments were lacking in the plaint. We have gone through the plaint and find that necessary averments have been made in the plaint and, as such, this argument too is misplaced.
8. The primary attack on behalf of the appellant to the judgment of the learned single Judge however is that as Col. Sukhdev Singh, guardian of the minor appellant, had not been appointed to act as such by complying with the procedure laid down under O. 32, Rr. 3 and 4, Civil Procedure Code, the suit was therefore not competent and should have been dismissed on that short ground. This argument had been considered and accepted by the trial Court, but the learned single Judge, in appeal, upset this finding holding that the appellant was effectively represented in the suit by his father and guardian Col. Sukhdev Singh and the omission of the Court to make formal order of appointment of Col. Sukhdev Singh as guardian ad litem had not caused any prejudice to the minor and, as such, the suit was competent. The matter has to be examined in the light of the provisions of O.32, Rr.3 and 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which reads as under:--
"(1) Where the defendant is a minor, the Court, on being satisfied of the fact of his minority, shall appoint a person to be guardian or the suit for such minor;
(2) An order for the appointment of a guardian for the suit may be obtained upon application in the name and on behalf of the minor or by the plaintiff.
(3) Such application shall be supported by an affidavit verifying the fact that the proposed guardian has no interest in the matters in controversy in the suit adverse to that of the minor and that he is a fit person to be so appointed.
(4) No order shall be made on any application under this rule except upon notice to any guardian of the minor appointed or declared by an authority competent in that behalf, or, where there is no such guardian, (upon notice to the father or where there is no father, to the mother, or where there is no father or mother; to other natural guardian) of the minor, or, where there is (no father, mother or other natural guardian), to the person in whose care the minor is, and after hearing any objection which may be urged on behalf of any person served with notice under this sub-rule."
Sub-rule (3) of R. 4 reads as under:
No person shall without his consent (in writing) be appointed guardian for the suit, but the Court may presume such consent to have been given unless it is expressly refused.
It will be seen from the provisions of O. 32, R.3, Civil Procedure Code, that the legislature had advisedly provided special protection for minors and persons of unsound mind as they being unable to look after their own interest, require special care. R. 3 specifically provides that for the appointment of a guardian, an application has to be made and such application must be supported by an affidavit giving the details mentioned in sub-rule (3). Sub-rule (4) of R. 3 provides that no order shall be made on the application filed under R. 3 unless a notice has been served on the guardian, if any, and where there is no such guardian, on the father or on mother or on various other persons mentioned in sub-rule (4) of R. 3. Sub-rule (3) of R. 4 stipulates that no person is to be appointed guardian without his consent in writing (and the underlined portion which is an amendment made by the State of Punjab) provides that the Court may presume such consent unless it is expressly refused. The inflexible rule therefore is that it is incumbent on the plaintiff suing a minor defendant to file an application in Court for the appointment of a guardian and the subsequent steps that are to be taken are within the purview or province of the Court. We are of the view of that if an application is not made as provided by O.32, R. 3 any guardian who may have acted for the minor, would not be clothed with the requisite authority to act as such. The consent that can be presumed is only if an application has been made, and notice issued to the proposed guardian.
9. Mr. Sarin, learned senior Advocate, appearing for the respondent has also placed reliance on the provisions of R. 3A of O. 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which reads as under:
(1) No decree passed against a minor shall be set aside merely on the ground that the next friend or guardian for the suit of the minor had an interest in the subject matter of the suit adverse to that of the minor, but the fact that by reason of such adverse interest of the next friend or guardian for the suit, prejudice has been caused to the interests of the minor, shall be a ground for setting aside the decree.
...... XX...... XX...... XX...... XX...... XX......
XX..... XX..... XX...... XX...... XX..... XX......."
He has argued that the case was admirably fought right up to the Supreme Court by Col. Sukhdev Singh and alt possible steps were taken by him to defend the interest of the minor. On this reasoning, he asserts that no prejudice has been suffered by the minor appellant and, as such, a valid decree could be passed in favour of the plaintiff-respondent. He has placed primary reliance on the Full Bench judgment of this Court reported as Amrik Singh v. Karnail Singh, AIR 1974 Punj & Har 315. He has also relied upon Wallian v. Banke Behari Pershad Singh, (1903) ILR 30 Cal 1021; Bhagabat Sahu v. Parbati Samal, AIR 1982 Ori 186 and Anandram v. Madholal, AIR 1960 Raj 189.
10. We are however of the view that all these authorities are distinguishable on facts and do not support the case of the respondent. In Amrik Singh's case (AIR 1974 Punj & Har 315) (FB) (supra) the facts were that Amrik Singh and Vir Singh minor defendants were sued through their real brother Satnam Singh as their guardian. An application was made under O. 32, R. 3, C.P.C., praying that Stanam Singh aforementioned be appointed as guardian of the minors. It was also mentioned that Ajit Singh brother, Mangal Singh father, Tirath Kaur mother and an officer of the Court were liable to be appointed as guardian of the minors. Satnam Singh refused to act as guardian and thereafter the Court appointed one Madan Gopal, Advocate as guardian of the minor defendants. It was in this situation that the Full Bench came to the conclusion that the minors had been effectively represented and no prejudice had been caused to them. The Full Bench observed as under (at 321 of AIR):
The crux of the matter is that it has to be seen whether the minor was effectively represented in the litigation. If he was, then the non-compliance with the provisions of O. 32, R. 3, which are mandatory, would not render the decision void. But if the non-compliance has caused prejudice to the minor or he was not effectively represented, the decision will be void, i.e., the minor can either ignore it or avoid it. This approach is in consonance with justice because where the matter had been properly contested and no prejudice has been caused to the minor, it will be sheer injustice to the other side to re-open the matter again, litigation is a very expensive affair and the general principle of law is that it should not be encouraged. In this view of the matter, so far as the facts of the present case are concerned, there can be no two opinions that the minors were effectively represented and no prejudice has been caused to them. Their interests were effectively safeguarded by their brothers, who were co-defendants with them and whose interests were identical.
Reliance placed on Anandram's case (AIR 1960 Raj 189) (supra) is also misplaced. In this case, the minor defendant was effectively represented by his father, who was also one of the defendants, and the Court held that no prejudice had been suffered by the minor in the defence of his case. Moreover, in this case the plaintiff had in fact presented an application in the trial Court for the appointment of a guardian ad litem and it was the Court which committed the default in not passing a formal order, On this promise it was held that the mere fact that no formal order of appointment of the guardian having been made, would not invalidate the suit.
11. Mr. Bindra has relied upon a decision of the Calcutta High Court reported as Nirmal Chandra v. Khandu Ghose, AIR 1965 Cal 562, which, in our opinin is similar on facts to the present one. In his case the minors filed a suit seeking a declaration that an ex parte rent decree which had been obtained against them was not binding on them as they had not been properly represented in that rent matter. It was argued by the other side that no prejudice had been caused to the minors as they had been represented by their brother. Reliance was also placed by that party on Mt. Bibi Walian's case (1903) ILR 30 Cal 1021 (supra). The Calcutta High Court however held that as no application had been made, as required under Order 32, Rule 3 of the Code, no notice issued to the proposed guardian as required by sub-rule (4) of Rule 3 nor the consent in writing taken from the proposed guardian under sub-rule (3) of Rule 4, the mandatory provisions of Order 32, had not been complied with and, as such, the decree in the earlier suit was vitiated. It was also held that Walian's case (supra) had interpreted Section 443 of the Civil Procedure Code (Act XIV of 1882) and the wording of that section was substantially different from the wording of Order 32, Rules 3 and 4. We too are of the view that the non-compliance with the mandatory provisions of Order 32, Rules 3 and 4 of the Code makes the decree void and must also presume to have caused prejudice to the appellant. The finding of the learned single Judge on this point is, therefore, reversed. On the above premises ordinarily the case would have to be remanded to the trial Court for a fresh decision, but for the reasons recorded in the succeeding paragraphs, we feel that this would not be the appropriate step in the facts and circumstances of this case.
12. We are of the view that the discretionary relief by way of a decree for specific performance is not liable to be given to the respondent. Reliance in this behalf can be placed on Ranganayakamma v. Govinda Narayan, AIR 1982 Kant 264, wherein it has been held that a decree for specific performance will not be given merely because it is lawful to do so, and where there is hardship to the defendant, and no such hardship to the plaintiff, the decree will not follow. The trial Court had given various reasons for declining the decree of specific performance and we reiterate those reasons. Additionally, we find that the respondent had agreed to enter into a compromise before the Letters Patent Bench and had recorded his statement to that effect. However, taking advantage of the fact that the formal compromise had not been recorded in terms of the provisions of Order 23, rule 3 of the Code, the respondent resiled from the proposed compromise. Although the Supreme Court has held that the com-
promise could not be enforced in view of the non-compliance with the provisions of Order 23, Rule 3, we are of the view that this fact can be taken into account in deciding as to whether a decree for specific performance should in the discretion of the Court be granted to the plaintiff-respondent. We feel that the respondent has forfeited the right, to this relief, as he, having agreed to enter into a compromise before the Court had subsequently resiled from it. It is also to be noted that the plaintiff-respondent had prayed for a decree for Rs. 2,50,000/- in the alternative, in case his suit for specific performance was not decreed. We are also not unmindful of the fact that the conduct of Col Sukhdev Singh too has not been entirely fair or without blemish.
13. In the result and for the reasons stated above, we allow the present appeal, set aside the judgment and decree of the learned single Judge and dismiss the suit for grant of decree of specific performance. However, we grant a decree for recovery of Rs. 2,25,000/- as damages, with the stipulation that the appellant shall deposit the same with the Registrar of this Court within a period of six months from the date of this judgment for payment to the respondent. In case the aforesaid amount is not deposited within the time stipulated, the plaintiff-respondent will be entitled to interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum from the date of filing of the suit till payment. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
14. Appeal allowed.
Alert