- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Paramjit Kaur v. Surinder Singh .
Summary of the Opinion (oral) by G.S. Chahal, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns Smt. Paramjit Kaur, who applied for interim maintenance under Section 125, Cr.P.C. against her husband, Surinder Singh. The learned Magistrate, Kurukshetra, on 12-12-1989 granted interim maintenance of Rs. 150 per month with effect from the date of her application. The respondent-husband did not challenge the quantum but contested the date from which maintenance was made payable. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, Kurukshetra, by an order dated 13-12-1990, modified the Magistrate's order so that maintenance would be payable only from the date of the Magistrate's order (not from the date of application). Smt. Paramjit Kaur preferred the present criminal revision against that modification. The trial court's interim-maintenance proceedings were decided on affidavits and counsel arguments, with adjournments occurring on multiple dates (some requested by both parties' counsel and some by the applicant's counsel).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether interim maintenance under Section 125, Cr.P.C. may be fixed by the Magistrate with effect from the date of the application, i.e., whether the Magistrate is obliged to give special reasons when granting interim maintenance from the date of application.
- Whether delay in obtaining the Magistrate's order (including adjournments during proceedings) is a sufficient ground to interfere with an order granting interim maintenance from the date of the application.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Smt. Paramjit Kaur)
- She sought interim maintenance and obtained an order of Rs. 150 per month from the date of her application; she relied on the Magistrate's discretion to fix the operative date for payment.
- She contended she was not responsible for the adjournments recorded in the Magistrate's order — some adjournments were at the request of both counsel and others at the request of the applicant's counsel — and therefore the delay was not attributable solely to her.
Respondent (Surinder Singh)
- The respondent did not challenge the amount but challenged the date from which interim maintenance was made payable, arguing that it should run only from the date of the Magistrate's order and not from the date of application.
- The respondent relied on a precedent (Charanjit Singh Grewal Alias Goggi v. Inderjit Kaur) to contend that the Magistrate was required to give special reasons if interim maintenance was fixed from the date of application, and he relied on the applicant's delay in securing the Magistrate's order.
- It was also pointed out on behalf of the respondent that a separate order by the District Judge, Kurukshetra under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act awarded maintenance pendente lite with effect from 12-8-1989, which overlapped with the period covered by the Magistrate's order.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Charanjit Singh Grewal Alias Goggi v. Inderjit Kaur — 1988 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 332 : 1988 (2) Current LJ 235 (P & H) | Relied upon by the Additional Sessions Judge for the proposition that the Magistrate must give special reasons for fixing interim maintenance from the date of the application. | The court noted that the Additional Sessions Judge was impressed by this precedent when disturbing the Magistrate's backdating; however, the High Court did not adopt that approach in this case (see application of the subsequent Division Bench decision below). |
| Shri Gurpartap Singh v. Smt. Satwant Kaur — 1991 (1) Recent Criminal Reports 40 : 1990 (2) CLR 650 (at p. 663) | Held by a Division Bench that it is not obligatory for a Magistrate to give special reasons for granting interim maintenance under Section 125, Cr.P.C. from the date of application; the date is within the Magistrate's discretion. | The court relied on and followed this Division Bench decision to conclude that the Additional Sessions Judge erred in interfering with the Magistrate's order; accordingly the Magistrate's order (with effect from the date of application) was restored. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise manner:
- Procedure of Original Interim Order: It noted that the Magistrate's interim-maintenance order was made after considering affidavits and counsels' arguments; no formal evidence was led for an interim application.
- Examination of Adjournments and Delay: On reviewing paragraph 6 of the Magistrate's order, the court observed that several adjournments occurred at the request of both parties' counsel and that some dates were granted at the applicant's counsel's request. The court reasoned that where adjournments are caused or agreed to by both sides (or requested by the applicant), the applicant cannot be blamed for delay. Therefore, the mere delay in obtaining the Magistrate's order did not justify interference.
- Precedential Guidance on Magistrate's Discretion: The court considered the law on whether a Magistrate must give 'special reasons' to fix interim maintenance from the date of application. While the Additional Sessions Judge relied on a P&H decision that suggested special reasons were necessary, the High Court followed a Division Bench judgment (Shri Gurpartap Singh v. Satwant Kaur) which held that a Magistrate is not obliged to give special reasons — fixing the operative date for interim maintenance is within the Magistrate's discretion.
- Conclusion from Reasoning: Because the applicant-wife was not responsible for the adjournments and because the Division Bench authority recognizes the Magistrate's discretion to fix the date without special reasons, the court found the Additional Sessions Judge's interference to be erroneous.
- Clarification Regarding Concurrent Orders: The court acknowledged that a District Judge had separately allowed maintenance under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act effective from 12-8-1989 in proceedings under Section 13. The court clarified that the wife may claim maintenance for overlapping periods under either the Magistrate's order (Section 125, Cr.P.C.) or the District Judge's order (Section 24, Hindu Marriage Act), and it is for her to choose which order to enforce.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The criminal revision was allowed and the High Court restored the learned Magistrate's order granting interim maintenance of Rs. 150 per month with effect from the date of the application.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The Magistrate's order (interim maintenance from the date of the application) stands restored; the Additional Sessions Judge's modification (making the operative date the date of the Magistrate's order) has been set aside.
- Concurrent remedies: The wife may choose to enforce either the Magistrate's order under Section 125, Cr.P.C. or the District Judge's order under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act for overlapping periods (the court left the choice to her).
- Precedential impact: The court applied an existing Division Bench authority holding that Magistrates have discretion to fix the date for interim maintenance and are not strictly required to give special reasons for doing so. The opinion itself did not declare a new legal principle beyond applying that earlier authority.
This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion and does not introduce information that is not contained in that opinion.
G.S Chahal, J. (Oral):— Smt. Paramjit Kaur (wife) has preferred this criminal revision against the order dated 13-12-1990 passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Kuruksh tra, vide which he modified the order of the learned Magistrate. Kurukshetra, dated 12.12.1989, passed in proceedings u/s 125, Cr. PC. granting interim maintenance with effect from the date of her application.
2. She had made application for maintenance against her husband Surinder Singh and in those proceedings she applied for the grant of interim maintenance which was allowed and the respondent-husband was ordered to pay Rs. 150/- p.m, as interim maintenance from the date of application The respondent did not challenge the quantum of interim maintenance but assailed the order in question so far as it related to the date from which it was made payable In revision the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, vide the impugned order, directed the maintenance to be paid with effect from the date of the order of the learned Magistrate and not from the date of application. For holding this view, the learned Addl. Sessions Judge was impressed by the fact that there was delay on the part of the wife in getting the order of the Magistrate and also by relying on Charanjit Singh Grewal Alias Goggi… v. Inderjit Kaur…., 1988 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 332 : 1988 (2) Current LJ 235 (P & H), he has held that the Magistrate was required to give special reasons for fixing interim maintenance from the date of the application.
3. For deciding the application for interim maintenance, the parties were not called upon to lead any evidence and it had only to be disposed of on the basis of their affidavits and the arguments of the learned counsel. A reference to paragraph 6 of the impugned order shows that on certain dates, the case was adjourned on the request of both the counsel and on two dates, arguments were heard in part. Some dates were also granted at the request of applicant's counsel. Thus, there was no fault of the applicant-wife for those adjournments. If the court showed some indulgence in adjourning the case at the request of parties' counsel, she cannot be blamed for it. The delay, thus, was not a ground for interfering with the order of the learned Magistrate, allowing interim maintencnce.
4. The controversy as to from which date, the interim maintenance should be made payable, has been set at rest by a Division Bench judgment of this Court, in Shri Gurpartap Singh… v. Smt. Satwant Kaur…. 1991 (1) Recent Criminal Reports 40 : 1990 (2) CLR 650 (at P. 663) wherein it has been held that it was not obligatory for the Magistrate to give special reasons for granting interim maintenance u/s 125, Cr.PC from date of application which was purely within his discretion. I, thus, conclude that the learned Addl. Sessions Judge was in error in interfering with the order of the Magistrate. The criminal revision is, thus, allowed and the order of the learned Mgistrate is restored.
5. It has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the respondent-husband that vide in order passed by the learned District Judge, Kurukshetra in an application u/s 24, Hindu Marriage Act, maintenance has been allowed to her with effect from 12-8-89, pendente lite with regard to petition u/s 13 of the Act, between both the spouses. In this situation, it is only clarified that the wife shall be entitled to claim maintenance for the period from 12-8-89 onwards under one of the two orders of the Magistrate u/s 125 Cr.P.C and the District Judge, u/s 24 of Hindu Marriage Act respectively and it would be for her to choose as to which of the two orders she wants to enforce.
Alert