Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajesh Kumar And Ors. v. State Of Punjab And Anr

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jun 8, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition arises from an FIR dated 12 February 1988 (Annexure P-4) lodged by Shashi Kanta (Respondent No. 2) under Sections 406 and/or 498A of the Indian Penal Code at Police Station Mohali, District Ropar. Key facts recited in the opinion are:

  • Shashi Kanta married Raghbir Chand on 10 April 1984 at Mohali (District Ropar). They subsequently lived with the husband's parents in Patiala, later moving to a rented house in Rajpura Colony, Patiala.
  • A female child was born of the marriage. Both spouses were employed in the Judicial Courts of District Patiala.
  • Differences arose and they have been living separately since 15 March 1987. Shashi Kanta alleged that dowry (as per an annexed list) was given to the husband’s family and later sought restoration; on refusal she filed the FIR.
  • The present petition to quash the FIR was filed by five persons: Rajesh (husband’s elder brother, Petitioner No.1), his wife Kiran Rani (Petitioner No.2), Kamlesh (sister, Petitioner No.4), Bhag Chand (Kamlesh’s husband, Petitioner No.3) and Manisha (sister, Petitioner No.5). The petitioners contended they were wrongly implicated and sought quashing of the FIR insofar as it related to them.

Procedural history referenced in the opinion includes:

  • The husband filed a petition under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act on 25 September 1987 (Annexure P-1). The wife did not contest and by order dated 6 April 1988 (Annexure P-3) the marriage was dissolved.
  • Police raided the husband’s parents’ house and purportedly recovered dowry articles; those articles were released to the husband on superdari subject to security of Rs. 20,000 and undertaking to produce them when required. A criminal revision (Crl. Revision No. 986 of 1988) filed by the wife against that release was disposed of by a Single Judge on 15 May 1989.
  • There were several other proceedings between the spouses: a Section 125 CrPC petition by the wife for maintenance of the minor daughter; an application for transfer of those proceedings (Crl. Misc. No. 8936-M of 1988) dismissed on 26 September 1989; a complaint by the husband under Sections 499/500 IPC against the wife and her brother (charges were framed), and related Crl. Misc. petitions for quashing or review which were dismissed on various dates recited in the opinion.
  • The wife had earlier made a written complaint dated 17 March 1987 seeking transfer to Rajpura; notably, that complaint did not name Rajesh or Bhag Chand, which the petitioners relied upon as a supportive circumstance for false implication.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the FIR lodged under Sections 406 and/or 498A IPC should be quashed as an abuse of process insofar as it implicates the petitioners.
  2. Whether the petition should be dismissed for undue delay given the police challan and the time lapse before filing the Section 482 CrPC petition.
  3. Whether the trial Court at Ropar has territorial jurisdiction to try the offences alleged, when some alleged acts (cruelty) are said to have occurred at Patiala.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended no definite allegation was made that dowry items had been entrusted to them; they were implicated out of spite to cause them undeserved hardship and thus the FIR was an abuse of process.
  • Specific factual points relied upon included dates and places of the petitioners' marriages and residences (e.g., Rajesh married in 1980 and living at Samana; Kamlesh and Manisha married earlier and residing in Chandigarh), which, counsel argued, made it improbable they could have caused harassment or retained dowry articles.
  • Reliance on the absence of their names in certain prior complaints (notably the wife’s complaint of 17 March 1987) as a supportive circumstance showing false implication.
  • Contention that alleged acts of cruelty took place at Patiala, thus contesting Ropar Court’s territorial jurisdiction over the matter.

Respondent's (Shashi Kanta) Arguments / Return

  • A preliminary objection was raised that the challan was filed on 14 August 1989 and this petition under Section 482 CrPC was filed on 15 April 1990 (the opinion records the respondent's contention that the petition was filed nine months later), and on that short ground the petition ought to be dismissed for undue delay.
  • On merits the respondent controverted the averments: in particular, she disputed the claim that Manisha was living in Chandigarh, asserting Manisha was posted in District Patiala and living with her parents.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the factual assertions made by the petitioners and the contents of the FIR and related records, and proceeded in two principal strands of analysis: (A) sufficiency and probability of allegations against the petitioners; and (B) territorial jurisdiction.

A. Sufficiency and Probability of Allegations

The court noted that many of the petitioners' arguments rested on disputed facts (dates of marriage, places of residence, absence of their names from earlier documents). The FIR alleged that the husband administered beatings to the wife allegedly at the instigation of his mother, two sisters (Kamlesh and Manisha) and the bhabi Kiran Rani, and that the names of Rajesh and Bhag Chand occurred in the FIR in the context of entrustment of dowry items.

The court held that it was not inherently impossible that close relations of the husband could have been entrusted with dowry articles. Given the state of the record before it (i.e., without the evidence collected during investigation), the court was not prepared to rule that the entrustment allegations were so improbable as to justify quashing the FIR at this stage. The court emphasized that the eventual acceptance or rejection of those allegations would depend on the evidence produced by the complainant at trial.

The court pointed out that at the trial stage the learned Magistrate should carefully consider the evidence produced and the "element of probability," which the court described as an unfailing touchstone in appreciating evidence in criminal trials.

B. Territorial Jurisdiction

The petitioners argued Ropar lacked territorial jurisdiction because the alleged cruelty occurred at Patiala. The court examined the charges and statutory provisions and found this contention prima facie untenable.

The court explained that, having regard to the definition of "cruelty" under Section 498A IPC (which the opinion characterizes as harassment of a woman to coerce her to meet any unlawful demand for property or on account of failure to meet such demand), the offences under Sections 406 or 498A (and specifically the reference to Section 498A(1-B) in the opinion) in the context of dowry constitute one series of acts connected together as the same transaction. Applying Section 220 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the court concluded that both offences could be tried at Ropar.

With respect to the offence under Section 406 IPC, the prosecution alleged that the articles were entrusted to the accused at Mohali in District Ropar where the marriage was performed. The court noted that, prima facie, Section 181(4) CrPC invested the Courts in District Ropar with territorial jurisdiction.

C. Delay Objection

The respondent raised a preliminary objection based on delay: a challan had been filed on 14 August 1989 and the petition was filed on 15 April 1990 (the return stated this was nine months later). The court recorded the objection but did not dispose of the petition solely on that ground; instead the court proceeded to consider the merits and territorial jurisdiction and ultimately concluded quashing was not appropriate on the material before it.

Holding and Implications

The FIR was not quashed in respect of the petitioners.

Implications and direct consequences recorded in the opinion:

  • The Court found it was not a fit case to quash the FIR on the basis of the material before it and made clear that nothing stated in the order was intended to prejudice either party's case; the matter is to be decided according to law on the evidence.
  • The petitioners and any accused not impleaded in the petition remain at liberty to urge at the stage of framing of charge that no evidence has been collected against a particular accused to justify framing a charge. The learned Magistrate was directed to consider such pleas and pass appropriate orders according to law.
  • The court noted that such an exercise (relying on the evidence collected during investigation) could not be undertaken by it in the absence of that evidence.
  • Procedural direction: parties and their counsel were directed to appear in the trial Court on 10 July 1990 for further proceedings according to law.

The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent; it resolves only that, on the material before the court, quashing of the FIR was not warranted and the matter should proceed to trial where evidence may be tested.

Show all summary ...

1. Facts necessary for the disposal of this petition under Section 482, Code of Criminal Procedure, are that Shashi Kanta, Respondent No. 2, mas married to Raghbir Chand at Mohali, District Ropar, on April 10, 1984. For sometime after the marriage, Shashi Kanta and her husband lived with the latter's parents at Patiala, Later on they started living separately in a rented house in Rajpura Colony, Patiala. A female child was born to them. Both of them were employed in the Judicial Courts in district Patiala. Some differences appear to have arisen and since March 15, 1987, they have been living separately from each other. According to Shashi Kanta, her father had given dowry mentioned in the list annexed with the application, on the basis on which FIR dated February 12, 1988, Annexure P-4, had been entered. When differences arose, Shashi Kanta claimed the dowry articles to be restored to her and on the demand having been turned down, sho lodged FIR under Sections 406 or 498A, Indian Penal Code, at Police Station Mohali, District Ropar, against the husband and several of his relations. The present petition has been filed by husband's elder brother Rajesh, petitioner No. 1, his wife Kiran Rani, petitioner No. 2, husband's sister Kamlesh, petitioner No. 4, Kamlesh's husband Bhag Chand, petitioner No. 3, and another sister Manisha, petitioner No. 5. The case of the petitioners is that no definite allegation had been made against the petitioners that any item of dowry was entrusted to them. They had been married long before the marriage of Shashi Kanta with Raghbir Chand. Both the sisters, Kamlesh and Manisha, petitioners 4 and 5, had been living in their marital homes in Chandigarh, while the elder brother Rajesh alongwith his wife was living at Samana. The petitioners had been involved in the aforesaid criminal case by Shashi Kanta out of spite against Raghbir Chand and to cause undeserved hardship to the petitioners. It was an abuse of the process of Court and therefore, they sought quashing of the FIR in so far as they were concerned.

2. It may be added that Raghbir Chand instituted a petition under Section 13, Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, against the wife Shashi Kanta on September 25, 1987 (Annexure P-l). When the case came up for respondent's evidence, she made an application dated February 22, 1988, Annexure P-2, that she did not want to contest the petition and she was willing to make a statement that the marriage be dissolved. Ultimately by order Annexure P-3 dated April 6, 1988, marriage between the parties was dissolved by the learned Additional District Judge, Patiala.

3. It may further be mentioned that after the registration of the case, the police raided the house of the parents of Raghbir Chand and purported to recover certain dowry articles. On an application made by the husband, the articles were directed to be delivered to him on his furnishing security in the sum of Rs. 20,000/-, undertaking to produce the articles if and when directed to do so by the Court. Against the said order, releasing articles in favour of the husband on superdari, Crl. Revision No. 986 of 1988 filed by the wife was disposed of by a learned Single Judge of this Court on May 15, 1989.

4. There has been several other rounds of litigation between the said estranged couple. The wife instituted a petition under Section 125, Code of Criminal Procedure, for maintenance for the minor daughter. Thereafter Shashi Kanta filed Crl. Misc. No. 8936-M of 1988 for transfer of those proceedings from one Court to another. The said misc. petition was dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court by order dated September 26, 1989.

5. The husband filed a complaint under Sections 499/500, Indian Penal Code, against Shashi Kanta and her brother, who were summoned and after recording preliminary evidence a charge was framed against them by the learned Addl. CJM, Patiala. Crl. Misc. No. 1745-M of 1989 filed against the order framing the charge was dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court by order dated October 5, 1989. Another Crl. Misc. No. 4929-M of 1989 for quashing the said complaint under Sections 499/500, Indian Penal Code, was dismissed by this Court by order dated November 2, 1988. Two more Crl. Misc. Nos. 3803 and 4003 of 1989 filed by the wife were dismissed by this Court on May 22 and May 26, 1989, respectively. Shashi Kanta also made a complaint in writing dated March 17, 1987 (Annexure P-5) against her husband to the District Judge, Patiala, requesting for her transfer to Rajpura. The significance of this complaint is that while Respondent No. 2 levelled allegations against sisters and sister-in-law of her husband, she made no reference to elder brother of her husband, Rajesh, or brother-in-law of her husband, named Bhag Chand. According to the petitioners, this was a supportive circumstance to show that Rajesh and Bhag Chand had been totally falsely implicated.

6. Return has been filed by respondent No. 2 Shashi Kanta. In the preliminary objection, it was stated that challan was filed by the police on August 14, 1989, and the present petition under Section 482, Code of Criminal Procedure, had been filed 9 months later on April 15, 1990. It was contended that the petition ought to be dismissed on the short ground of undue delay. On merits, the various averments made in the petition were controverted. In particular, it was stated that Manisha, petitioner No. 5, had not been living at Chandigarh. She was posted in District Patiala and she had been living with her parents.

7. Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that Rajesh, the elder brother of Raghbir Chand, was married as far back as February 7, 1980, more than 4 years before the marriage of Respondent No. 2 with Raghbir Chand. He had been living at Samana and he could not possibly either cause harassment or retain dowry articles, as alleged. With regard to Kamlesh and her husband Bhag Chand, it was pointed out that they were married as far back as March 13, 1976. They had been Jiving as Chandigarh and they had been apparently falsely implicated. With regard to Manisha, it was stated that she was .married in 1983 and had been living with her husband at Chandigarh. The contention, on the face of it, appears simple as well as attractive. A careful consideration of the contention, however, shows that it is based on certain disputed facts. According to the FIR, Raghbir Chand had been administering beating to Shashi Kanta, but he has been doing so allegedly at the instigation of his mother, Kamlesh and Manisha, besides his Bhabi Kiran Rani. The names of Rajesh and Bhag Chand occur in the FIR in the context of entrustment of dowry items. Whether the allegation made in this behalf will be accepted or not, will largely depend on the evidence produced by the complainant. All that can be said at this stage is that there is nothing inherently impossible in the aforesaid close relations of the husband being entrusted with certain items of dowry. In the facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be said at this stage that entrustment to the aforesaid relations was so highly improbable that the FIR against them should be quashed. It will, however, be open to the learned Magistrate to carefully consider the evidence which may be produced against the aforesaid petitioners and also take into consideration the element of probability, which is an unfailing touch-stone for appreciating the evidence in all criminal trials.

8. The next contention of the learned counsel is that the alleged cruelty was committed at Patiala and, therefore, the Court at Ropar had no territorial jurisdiction,-! find that prima-facie this contention is untenable. The offences alleged in this case are under Sections 406 or 498A, Indian Penal Code. Having regard to the definition of 'cruelty' under Section 498A, the harassment of the woman is confined to harassment with a view to coercing her to meet any unlawful demand for property or on account of her failure to meet such demand. The offences under Sections 406 or 498A(1-B), Indian Penal Code, therefore, in the context of dowry, constitute one series of act so connected together as to form the same transaction and, therefore, under Section 220 of the Code of Criminal Procedure both the offences become triable at Ropar. With regard to the offence under Section 406, the allegation of the prosecution is that the articles were entrusted to the accused named in the FIR at Mohali in District Ropar where the marriage was performed. Prima facie, Section 181(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, invests the Courts in District Ropar with territorial Jurisdiction.

9. For the reasons discussed above, I do not find it a fit case for quashing the FIR. It is, however, made clear that nothing stated in this order is intended to prejudice the case of either side and the case will be decided according to law. It is further made clear that it will be open to the petitioners as also the accused who have not been impleaded in the present petition to urge at the stage of framing of charge that there was no evidence collected against a particular accused to justify the framing of charge. It will be open to the learned Magistrate to consider the plea and pass appropriate orders according to law. Such an exercise is not possible in this Court in the absence of the evidence collected during investigation of the case.

10. Parties through their counsel are directed to appear in the trial Court on July 10, 1990, for further proceedings according to law.