Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Harbans Singh Grewal Petitioner, v. Puran Singh (Deceased) By His L. Rs.

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jun 5, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

A.L Bahri, J. (Oral) — This revision petition has been filed by Harbans Singh Grewal, judgment-debtor, challenging order dated January 23, 1987, passed by Additional Senior Subordinate Judge, Ludhiana. Vide this order, the decree-holder was allowed to deposit a sum of Rs. 10,000/- as sale expenses.

2. Puran Singh filed a suit against Harbans Singh Grewal for specific performance of agreement dated December 7, 1976 relating to the sale of house for a sum of Rs. 80,000/-. A sum of Rs. 44.000/- was paid as earnest money and the remaining amount of Rs. 36,000/- was agreed to be paid at the time ot execution of the sale deed. Harbans Singh Grewal contested the suit. However, on December 15, 1980 the trial Court decreed the suit. The defendant was called upon to execute the sale deed on receipt of Rs. 36,000/- before the Sub Registrar. The expenses on account of stamp and registration of the sale deed were to be borne by the plaintiff. In the event of failure of defendant Harbans Singh Grewal to execute the sale deed, the plaintiff was to deposit the balance of sale consideration of Rs. 36,000/- in Court within one month thereafter together with necessary expenses on account of stamp and registration fee and thereafter the sale deed was to be executed through the agency of the Court. In compliance of the aforesaid decree, the decree holder moved an application for deposit of Rs. 36,000/- and the expenses allowing fifteen days time. As per the decree the amount was to be deposited. On May 15, 1980. However, before this application was finally disposed of on May 21, 1980, the decree-holder deposited Rs. 36,000/- and moved an application dated May 26, 1980 for a direction to the judgment-debtor to execute the sale deed and on his failure by the Local Commissioner to be appointed for the said purpose. The delay in deposit of the amount was, thus, condoned vide order dated August 18, 1990. The Court further ordered the execution of the sale deed through the process of the Court and the decree-holder was directed to file a draft sale deed. Harbans Singh Grewal judgment-debtor, preferred a revision petition in the High Court against order dated August 18, 1980. In the meantime, Puran Singh, decree-holder, died and his legal representatives were brought on record. The High Court set aside the direction regarding execution of the sale deed and remanded the case to the lower Court for fresh decision after observing as to whether the sale expenses had been deposited or not. The parties were directed to appear in the trial Court on December 10, 1984. In the meantime, the decree-holder also died and his legal representatives were also brought on the file. Ultimately, in December 1986 an application was moved for permission to deposit Rs. 10,000/- as sale expenses. It is on this application that the impugned order was passed, which is under challenge.

3. At no stage, the judgment-debtor moved the Court under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act for rescinding the contract for sale on account of non-payment of the sale consideration or the sale expenses. The Court having granted time for deposit of balance of the sale consideration and expenses for the sale deed within a specific period, could order to extend the period while exercising power under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Furthermore, there was no direction in the decree that on failure to deposit the balance of the sale consideration of Rs. 36,000/- or a sum of 10,000/- towards expenses, the suit of the plaintiff was to be dismissed. In the absence of any such directions, time granted in the decree could be extended having resort to the provisions of Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In a such like matter Division Bench of the Patna High Court in Suraj Singh v. Rajnarain Lal and anr., AIR 1984 Patna 155, held that power of the Court under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure would be there to extend the time granted in the decree when there was nothing in the decree that non-payment of the amount within the time allowed would result in dismissal of the Suit. As a matter of fact no time was fixed for deposit of expenses in the decree.

4. In this Court the matter was considered in Smt. Parmeshwari v. Nowata, AIR 1984 Punjab & Haryana 342, by R.N Mittal, J. and Resham Singh v. Manmohan Singh, AIR 1985 Punjab & Haryana 193. In both these cases conditional decrees were passed i.e on failure to deposit the amount within the specified period, the suits were to stand as dismissed. It was held that Court could not extend the time for deposit of amount under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure. These decisions are not helpful in the present case as already stated above conditional decree was not passed.

5. Against order dated August 18, 1980 revision was filed in this Court (C.R 2004 of 1980) and S.P Goyal, J. remanded the case for fresh decision. No decision was taken therein as to whether in the facts of the present case time could be extended or not.

6. For the reasons recorded above, the trial Court was fully justified in extending the time for the deposit of Rs. 10,000/- as expenses for execution of the sale deed. Findingno merit in the revision petition the same is dismissed. No costs.

Petition dismissed.