- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rekha Mothsara v. Ram Phal And Others .
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This order, delivered by Manmohan Singh Liberhan, J., disposes of six appeals (F.A.O. 977 of 1986; F.A.O. No. 882 of 1986; F.A.O. No. 941 of 1986; and F.A.O. Nos. 57, 55 and 56 of 1987) arising out of a common award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Hissar, dated 10.9.1986 in three claim petitions concerning an accident on 20-9-1984 involving Bus No. HRT 5285 (driver: Ram Phal) and a scooter carrying Nardeep Singh (deceased) and Girwar Singh (injured).
The Tribunal originally awarded Rs. 1,90,000 to Smt. Rekha Mothsara (widow), Rs. 40,000 to Smt. Mahima (mother), and Rs. 15,100 to Girwar Singh (injured). The claimants appealed against inadequacy of the awards, and the State of Haryana filed cross-appeals challenging aspects of liability and the Tribunal's findings. The six appeals were heard together because of common questions of law and fact.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal under‑evaluated the monthly dependency (including valuation of perquisites such as free ration, accommodation, medical facilities and leave concessions) when assessing compensation for the deceased's dependants.
- Whether the multiplier of sixteen applied by the Tribunal for calculating compensation was appropriate in the facts of this case.
- Whether alleged remarriage of the widow affects her entitlement to the compensation awarded to her.
- Whether the parents and brother of the deceased are entitled to a share of compensation and, if so, whether they have demonstrated loss sufficient to justify an apportionment in their favour.
- Whether the driver Ram Phal was guilty of rash and negligent driving, thereby attracting liability of the respondents for death and injury.
- Whether the compensation awarded to the injured (Girwar Singh), including assessment of disability, was adequate.
Arguments of the Parties
Claimants' Arguments
- The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is not adequate and does not constitute just compensation.
- The Tribunal undervalued the monthly worth of perquisites (free ration, accommodation, medical treatment for self and family, leave concessions) — the appellants contended that the Tribunal's valuation (noted as Rs. 313/- per month) was too low and that the value of those facilities could not be less than a figure represented in the record as "5???0/-" per month; with further adjustments they submitted that monthly dependency should be Rs. 1,400 after deductions.
- The multiplier of sixteen adopted by the Tribunal was, according to the appellants, inadequate and should be revisited (although different contentions were raised, the common theme was that the compensation formula was inadequate).
- In F.A.O. No. 882 of 1986 the claimants (or their representatives) contended that, since the widow had allegedly remarried, the entire compensation should be payable to others (the precise claimants pursuing that contention sought entitlement to the full amount).
- Girwar Singh (injured) asserted he suffered 40% disability and claimed higher compensation for injuries, medical expenses and related losses.
Respondents' / State's Arguments
- The respondents admitted the accident but attributed its cause to the rash and negligent driving of the scooter by the deceased, asserting that the scooter dashed into the bus and that the deceased failed to control the vehicle.
- The State made an effort to challenge the Tribunal's finding of rash and negligent driving by the bus driver (Ram Phal), but this challenge was weak in the opinion's view.
- The respondents did not dispute injuries to Girwar Singh.
- Respondent witnesses (including the bus conductor) did not support the version given by the driver Ram Phal; additionally, the driver gave a materially different version in court than in his written statement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lachhman Singh v. Gurmit Kaur (1979 81 PLR 1) (Full Bench) | Principles governing the appropriate choice of multiplier in assessing compensation for death in motor accident cases. | The court relied on the principles in Lachhman Singh (and other precedent referenced generally) to hold that a multiplier of sixteen was suitable in the circumstances of this case and sustained the Tribunal's choice of multiplier. |
| Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai (AIR 1937 SC 1690) | Principle that legal heirs have locus standi to file claim petitions (i.e., legal heirs can bring claims). | The court observed that the precedent does not entitle legal heirs to compensation absent proof of loss; it held that the Tribunal's approach (requiring proof of loss to succeed in compensation claims) did not violate the principles of this decision. |
| Parkash Chand v. Pal Singh (1985-1 87 PLR 538) | Authority on claim petitions by legal heirs and related principles concerning entitlement and proof of loss. | The court noted that Parkash Chand was relied upon by the parents, but concluded the Tribunal had not violated principles in that case; legal heirs must demonstrate loss to obtain compensation and the parents had not done so with respect to the father and brother. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a stepwise analysis addressing valuation of dependency, the multiplier, entitlement disputes (remarriage and parents' claims), liability and compensation for the injured:
- Dependency valuation: The Tribunal had calculated dependency at Rs. 1,200 per month (after applying an assumed valuation of certain perquisites at Rs. 313 per month). The claimants argued for a significantly higher valuation of those perquisites. The court concluded that, given the facts and prevailing price index, only a nominal increase of Rs. 150 per month was justified. Accordingly the monthly dependency was increased to Rs. 1,350 per month.
- Multiplier: The court considered authorities (specifically citing Lachhman Singh v. Gurmit Kaur) and concluded that the Tribunal's application of a multiplier of sixteen was appropriate in the circumstances; the court was not persuaded to adopt a different multiplier.
- Calculation and rounding: Applying the increased monthly dependency (Rs. 1,350) and the multiplier of sixteen produced a total compensation figure of Rs. 2,59,200, which the court rounded up to Rs. 2,60,000.
- Apportionment between dependants: The court reviewed evidence regarding whether the widow had remarried (an issue that, if proven, could affect distribution). The Tribunal had disbelieved remarriage allegations largely because the father's in‑court testimony did not assert remarriage and a later‑filed affidavit attempting to assert remarriage was found vague and unreliable (no details of date, place or spouse and based on "belief"). The court found that affidavit to be a futile and frivolous attempt to fill a lacuna and refused to treat it as substantive evidence.
- Parents' and brother's claims: The court held that although legal heirs have locus standi to file claims, they must demonstrate actual loss. The parents' counsel failed to show evidence that the father and brother had suffered loss attributable to the deceased's death; the mother, however, was found to deserve compensation (the court increased the mother's share to Rs. 50,000 in view of enhanced dependency). The remaining portion (Rs. 2,10,000) was directed to the widow, who was described as young and having a long life ahead.
- Liability for the accident: The court found the Tribunal's finding of rash and negligent driving by the bus driver Ram Phal to be justified. The reasons included: uncontested presence and statement of Girwar Singh at the scene; the driver's account in court materially differing from his written statement; lack of support for the driver's version from the bus conductor; the fact that the driver had been dismissed from service for rash and negligent conduct; and corroborative photographs (Exhibits P.W. 7.A to F). The court therefore affirmed the finding of negligence on the part of the driver.
- Compensation for the injured (Girwar Singh): The injured had stated on oath he suffered 40% disability and had been placed in category C twice by the Board because of injuries; there was no effective rebuttal. Considering the circumstances, the court increased the compensation for the injured to Rs. 20,000 (from the Tribunal's earlier award).
- Interest and costs: The court directed interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of the applications until payment. It also recorded that there was no order as to costs in all the appeals.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeals filed by the claimants were allowed in part as specified in the opinion, and the appeals filed by the State of Haryana were dismissed. (The court made no order as to costs.)
Direct consequences and specific monetary dispositions (as recorded in the opinion):
- Total compensation assessed in respect of the death claims: Rs. 2,60,000 (rounded figure).
- Apportionment of that amount: Rs. 50,000 to the mother; Rs. 2,10,000 payable to the widow (the court explained the father and brother had no entitlement in the absence of evidence of loss to them).
- Compensation to the injured (Girwar Singh) increased to Rs. 20,000.
- Interest to be paid at 12% per annum from the date of the applications until payment.
- No new legal precedent was announced; the court applied established principles (including the multiplier principle in Lachhman Singh) and affirmed the Tribunal's factual finding of negligence against the bus driver based on testimonial and documentary evidence.
Disposition
For the reasons recorded, the three appeals filed by the claimants are allowed to the extent indicated above; the appeals filed by the State are dismissed. There is no order as to costs.
Manmohan Singh Liberhan, J.:— This order will dispose of six appeals, F.A.O 977 of 1986, Smt. Rekha Mothsara v. Ram Phal, F.A.O No. 882 of 1986, Smt. Mahima v. Ram Phal, F.A.O No. 941 of 1986, Girwar Singh, v. Ram Phal, and F.A.O Nos. 57, 55 and 56 of 1987, filed by the State of Haryana as cross appeals. They arise out of a common award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunals Hissar, dated 10.9.1986 in three claim petitions. Since common questions, of Jaw and fact arise in these appeals, the same are being disposed by one order.
2. The learned Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,90,000/- to Smt. Rekha Mothsara, widow, and Rs. 40,000/- to Smt. Mahima, mother of the deceased Nardeep Singh on account of his death caused by rash and negligent act of driver Ram Phal of Bus No. HRT 5285 of Karyana Roadways, on 20-9-1984 A sum of Rs. 15,100/- was awarded to Girwar Singh claimant, who was injured in the said accident.
3. Briefly, the facts are taken from claim Petition No. 10 of 1985 filed by Smt. Rekha Mothsara. It was averred that on 20-12-1984 at 3.30 P.M while Nardeep Singh deceased was going on a scooter from Hissar to hansi along with Girwar Singh as pillion rider, on their reaching near Gauva Garden, Hansi, the right side of bus bearing registration No HRT-5285, driven by Ram Phal driver, while attempting to overtake another bus, struck against the scooter, on left side of the road. On account of the impact, Nardeep Singh was thrown on a kutcha road on further left side of the road, which resulted in his death at the spot. Girwar Singh got multiple injuries and was taken to the hospital at Hansi where he remained admitted for some time and thereafter for one month at Rohtak and subsequently for another month in the Military Hospital. It was averred that the death of Nardeep Singh as well as injuries to Girwar Singh had been caused on account of the rash and negligent driving of the bus by Ram Phal driver. Thus, the respondents were alleged to be liable to pay the compensation to the claimants.
4. Smt. Reka Mothsara, widow of deceased Nardeep Singh, claimed Rs. 3,00,000/- as damages. It was averred by Nardeep Singh aged 28-29 years, was employed as Chief Engine Room Artificer in the Indian Navy and was drawing Rs. 1487-50 per month as his salary with all the perks of free ration, free accommodation, free medical and leave concession for self and family.
5. In claim petition No. 9 of 1985 Girwar Singh claimed damages amounting to Rs. 1,00,000/-, on account of loss caused to the scooter, expenditure on medicines and hospitalisation, pain and suffering, permanent disability of 40 per cent and on account of decategorisation in the Army service.
6. In claim petition No. 8 of 1985, the mother father and one minor brother of Nardeep Singh deceased claimed Rs. 3,00,000/- as compensation. It was averred that they were dependent upon the income of Navdeep Singh and suffered the loss on account of his death.
7. The respondents controverd the facts stated except the accident. According to the version of the respondents, the accident was caused on account of the rash and negligent driving of the scooter by the deceased which dashed into the bus, as the deceased failed to control the scooter coming at a high speed. The injuries to Girwar Singh were not disputed.
8. The learned Tribunal, after calculating the dependency of the claimants at the rate of Rs. 1,200/- per month awarded the compensation amounting to Rs. 2,30,400/- by applying the multiplier of sixteen. He apportioned the compensation by giving Rs. 1,90,300/- to widow. However, it was found that the father and brother had no locus standi to claim the compensation. Girwar Singh was awarded Rs. 15,000/- which are inclusive of Rs. 500/- for taxi expenses Rs. 4,000/- as medical expenses and Rs. 300/- for scooter repairs. Aggrieved against the award of the learned Tribunal, the claimants preferred three appeals impugning the award, so the State of Haryana impugned the award by three separate appeals.
9. The learned counsel for the claimants in the respective appeals have contended that the amount awarded is not adequate and is not a just compensation. Though the contentions were raised differently, but in pith and substance, the only contention raised was that while calculating the dependency, the Tribunal has erroneously calculated the amount of Rs. 313/- per month for the facilities like, free ration, accommodation, medical treatment for self and family, and leave concession etc. It is contended that at least by all reasonable inference the value of facilities cannot be less than Rs. 5???0/- per month and with this addition of Rs. 200/- the monthly dependency comes to Rs. 1,400/-, after giving deduction for personal expenses out of the total income of Rs. 2,000/- per month. It is further contended that taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of this case, the multiplier of sixteen is inadequate.
10. In my view, taking the facts and circumstances of the case into consideration as well as the price index, at the most a nominal increase of Rs. 150/- per month can only be granted. Neither the counsel for the appellants nor the counsel for the respondents made any serious objection to it. Thus, giving the benefit of Rs. 150/-, the dependency comes to Rs. 1,350/- per month.
11. The counsel for the appellants has been unable to persuade me to take a different view with respect to the multiplier adopted by the Tribunal. By keeping in view the principles laid down in Lachhman Singh v. Gurmit Kaur . 1979 81 PLR 1., (Full Bench) and other precedent the multiplier of sixteen is a suitable multiplier. Thus, applying the multiplier of 16 the total amount of compensation comes to Rs. 2,59,200/-. By rounding up the figure, I assess the compensation at Rs. 2,60,000/-.
12. Counsel for the claimants in F.A.O No. 882 of 1986 has contended that since the widow has remarried, they are entitled to the entire compensation. The said fact is controverted by the counsel appearing for the widow. The argument was advanced before the Tribunal also but the learned Tribunal came to the conclusion, after appreciating the oral evidence, that the version of remarriage cannot be relied upon as the father-in-law while appearing in the witness box had not stated so on oath. Haphazard statement made by the mother was not relied upon. In this appeal also, a sordid attempt has been made by making an application to place on record the affidavit of the father of the deceased to the effect that the widow has remarried. I have gone through the affidavit. To me, it appears to be a futile attempt made by the father, out of greed, to grab the entire amount of compensation. A vague and frivolous affidavit has been filed. It is an attempt to meet the reasoning adopted by the learned Tribunal in coming to the conclusion that the widow had not remarried. It was observed by the Tribunal that since the father had not stated with respect to remarriage on oath, therefore, there cannot be any remarriage. The affidavit has been filed only to fill up the lacuna. There is no mention in the affidavit about the person with whom she has re married, nor the place or the date of re-marriage has been disclosed, and in the verification the father-in-law has stated that according to his belief the widow has remarried. No reliance can be placed on such an affidavit. The learned counsel has failed to point out any provision of law under which this affidavit can be treated as a substantive evidence.
13. The learned counsel appearing for the parents-claimants has not been able to point out any evidence on the record to show that they have suffered any loss on account of the death of the deceased. There was no loss to the estate of the claimants. However, the mother has been awarded a sum of Rs. 40,000/- as compensation, which I increase to Rs. 50,000/- in view of the fact that I have enhanced the dependency. The remaining amount of Rs. 2,10,000/- shall be payable to the widow, who is very young and has to live a long life.
14. The learned counsel appearing for the State has made a frail effort to challenge the finding with respect to the rash and negligent driving of Ram Phal driver. The learned Tribunal has rightly relied upon the statement of Girwar Singh about whose presence at the spot there was no dispute. The statement of Ram Phal was rightly rejected for the reasons that while appearing in the witness-box he had putforth a totally new version of the accident than the one stated in his written statement. The Conductor of the bus examined by the respondents did not support the version stated by Ram Phal. Further, the dismissal of Ram Phal driver from service on account of his rash and negligent conduct has not been controverted at the bar. From the facts and circumstances, the only inference that can be drawn is that the accident was caused on account of the rash and negligent driving of Ram Phal. The said inference is further corroborated by the photographs Exhibits P.W 7.A to F.
15. Learned counsel appearing for the parents further contends that all the legal heirs are entitled to the compensation, that is the father, mother and the brother jointly with the widow. He has relied upon Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai . AIR 1937 SC 1690., and Parkash Chand v. Pal Singh . 1985-1 87 PLR 538.. I fail to understand how the principles laid down in the said judgments have been violated by the Tribunal. There is no dispute that the legal heirs have a locus standi to file a claim petition but in order to get the compensation, they have to further show the loss suffered by them. The statement of the mother of the deceased has been read out to me by the counsel for the widow, in which it has been categorically stated that the deceased was not contributing anything towards the family expenses after he got married. Thus, he was not contributing anything at the time of his death towards the maintenance of father and brother. Taking the totality of the circumstances into consideration, no modification is required with respect to the apportionment of the compensation between the father, mother and brother of the deceased.
16. So far as Girwar Singh injured is concerned, the only argument advanced by the learned counsel is that the compensation granted to him is too low. The injured is stated in his statement that he had sufferred 40 per cent disability. There is no rebuttal to that. He had further stated on oath that he had been placed in category C twice over by the Board because of the injuries. Again, there was no rebuttal to it Keeping all the facts and circumstances into consideration, in my opinion a total sum of Rs. 20,000/- would be a reasonable compensation and I order accordingly.
17. The claimants shall be entitled to interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of applications till the payment.
18. For the reasons recorded above, the three appeals filed by the claimants are allowed to the extent stated above and the appeals filed by the State are dismissed. However, there is no order as to costs in all the appeals.
R.M.S
Appeal dismissed.
Alert