- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Phal v. Krishna Makkar And Others .
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerns the liability of the Insurance Company in respect of a motor vehicle accident. The appellant, as the owner of the vehicle, challenged only the question of the Insurance Company's liability, while issues of negligence and quantum were not contested. The Insurance Company was initially absolved of liability on the sole ground that the driver’s licence had expired on the date of the accident. The driver had a valid licence until 16-11-1984, the accident occurred on 17-12-1984, and the licence was renewed on 28-11-1986.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Insurance Company is liable for compensation when the driver’s licence had expired on the date of the accident but the driver had held a valid permanent licence and was not disqualified from holding it.
- Whether the Insurance Company can avoid liability on the ground of an expired licence without evidence that the insured owner breached the policy condition by entrusting the vehicle to an unlicensed or disqualified driver.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Tribunal’s absolution of the Insurance Company on the ground of the expired licence is unsustainable given the insurance policy condition that liability attaches if the driver holds a valid licence at the time of the accident or had held a permanent licence and was not disqualified.
- The driver was not disqualified from holding a licence and had held a permanent licence at the time of the accident.
- Reliance on United India Fire & Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Avisa to argue that the Insurance Company cannot avoid liability merely because the licence was expired if the driver was not disqualified.
- Reliance on Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan which holds that a breach of policy conditions requires a wilful infringement by the insured in entrusting the vehicle to an unlicensed or disqualified driver; absent such breach, the insurer remains liable.
- No evidence exists that the insured owner breached the promise by placing the vehicle in charge of an unlicensed or disqualified driver.
Respondent's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments beyond the initial position that the Insurance Company was absolved because the driver’s licence had expired on the accident date.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| United India Fire & Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Avisa, 1979 A.C.J 526 | Insurance Company cannot avoid liability if the driver was not disqualified and had held a valid licence at some point. | Supported the appellant’s contention that the Insurance Company’s liability cannot be negated solely on the basis of an expired licence if the driver was not disqualified. |
| Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987-1 91 PLR 665 | Breach of insurance policy condition requires a wilful infringement by the insured in entrusting the vehicle to an unlicensed or disqualified driver; insurer’s immunity arises only on such breach. | Reinforced that the Insurance Company must prove a breach by the insured to be absolved; absence of such evidence means insurer remains liable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the insurance policy condition which requires that a driver hold a valid licence at the time of the accident or have held a permanent licence and not be disqualified. The Court found no evidence that the driver was disqualified or that the insured owner breached the policy by entrusting the vehicle to an unlicensed or disqualified driver. The Court relied on authoritative precedents which clarify that insurer’s immunity applies only if the insured is guilty of a wilful breach by placing the vehicle in charge of an unlicensed or disqualified driver. Since the driver had held a valid permanent licence and there was no evidence of breach by the insured, the Insurance Company could not be absolved of liability. The Court thus modified the Tribunal’s award to hold the owner, driver, and Insurance Company jointly and severally liable.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed.
The Court held that the Insurance Company is liable for compensation jointly and severally with the owner and driver. This decision reverses the Tribunal’s absolution of the insurer on the ground of an expired licence in the absence of any breach by the insured. No new precedent was set; the ruling follows established principles requiring proof of breach of policy conditions by the insured before insurer immunity can be invoked.
Manmohan Singh Liberhan, J.:— This appeal by the appellant as owner of the vehicle was admitted on the short question with respect to liability of the Insurance Company. The questions of negligence and quantum have not been challenged in this appeal.
2. The Insurance Company was absolved of its liability solely on the ground that on the date of accident the driving licence of the insured had expired. It is not disputed at the bar that the driver of the ill-fated truck had a valid licence upto 16-11-1984 and while the accident took place on 17-12-1984 and the licence was got renewed on 28-11-1986.
3. Counsel for the appellant contends that the reasoning adopted by the Tribunal in absolving the Insurance Company from its liability on the ground that the driver did not have a valid driving licence on the date of accident, cannot be sustained in view of the fact that in the insurance Policy Exhibit R. 1, the condition imposed for making it liable reads as under:—
“Provided that a person driving holds a valid driving licence at the time of accident or had held a permanent driving licence and is not disqualified from holding such a licence.”
4. Counsel for the respondent has been unable to show that the driver was ever disqualified from holding such licence. He could not controvert that the driver had held a permanent driving licence at the time of accident.
5. Counsel for the appellant has relied upon United India Fire & Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Avisa . 1979 A.C.J 526., where in it had been held that the Insurance Company cannot avoid the liability as the driver of the vehicle who drove it had not been disqualified from holding the licence and further found the (company to be liable for an accident caused by the driver who at one time held a valid licence with him. The learned counsel further contends that in the absence of any evidence on the record that the insured had placed the vehicle in charge of an person who did not have a driving licence, the insured cannot be held guilty of breach of promise and the Insurance Company cannot be absolved of its liability. In order to buttress this submission, he relies upon Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan . 1987-1 91 PLR 665., wherein their Lordship of the Supreme Court has observed as under:
“Section 96 (2)(b)(ii) extends immunity to the Insurance Company if a breach is committed of the condition excluding driving by a named person or by any person who is not fully licensed, or by any person who has been disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence during the period of disqualification. The expression ‘breach’ is of great significance. The dictionary meaning of ‘breach’ is infringement or violation of a promise or obligation (See Collins English Dictionary). It is, therefore, abundantly clear that the Insurer will have to establish that the insured is guilty of an infringement or violation of a promise that a person who is not duly licensed will have to be in charge of the vehicle. The very concept of infiringment or violation of the promise that the expression ‘breach’ carriers within itself induces an inference that the violation of infringement on the part of the pro-miser must be a wilful infringement or violation. If the insured is not at all at fault and has not done anything he should not have done or is not amiss in any respect how can it be conscientiously posited that he has committed “a breach? It is only when the insured himself places the vehicle in charge of a person who does not hold a driving licence, that it can be said that he is ‘guilty’ of the breach of the promise that the vehicle will be driven by a licensed driver. It must be established by the Insurance Company that the breach was on the part of the insured and the it was the insured who was guilty of violating the promise or infringement of the contract. Unless the insured is at fault and is guilty of the breach the Insurer cannot escape from the obligation to indemnify the insured and successfully contend that he is exonerated having regard to the fact that the promissor (the insured) committed a breach of his promise. Not when some mishap occurs by some mischance.”
6. There is not an iota of evidence on the record that the insured owner had ever committed any breach of the promise, rather there is a positive evidence on the record to show that he handed over the vehicle to a driver who was holding a valid driving licence and he had taken all possible care not to comit any breach of the Policy. Counsel for the respondent was unable to controvert the submissions made by the counsel for the appellant in which I find force.
7. In view of my above observations, the award of the Tribunal is modified and it is held that the owner, the driver as well as the Insurance Company shall be liable for the compensation jointly and severally. The appeal is allowed with no order as to costs.
R.M.S
Appeal allowed.
Alert