Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Of Haryana, Petitioner. v. Satya Narain, .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 13, 1973
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Jagdish Lal of village Bishanpura (Police Station Pilani, Rajasthan) was charged under Section 304A, Indian Penal Code. On 26 July 1968 Satya Narain stood surety before the police, undertaking to produce Jagdish Lal before the police or a competent court when required and promising to pay Rs. 2,000 to the State of Haryana in case of default. The case was tried by the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Bhiwani. Jagdish Lal failed to appear before the Court; non-bailable warrants were issued without result. Notice was given to the surety, Satya Narain, who repeatedly sought adjournments but could not produce the accused. The learned Magistrate, relying on Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, forfeited the surety bond and directed payment of a fine of Rs. 1,000.

Satya Narain appealed the forfeiture order. The Sessions Judge, Hissar, accepted the appeal and set aside the forfeiture relying on the decision in Surjit Singh v. State (1964 Cur LJ 202 (Punj)), which held that an undertaking given to a police officer is a promise to an official and not to a Court and therefore not forfeitable under Section 514 CrPC. The State of Haryana filed a revision petition to the Court that delivered the present opinion. A learned Judge observed conflicting High Court decisions on Section 514 and referred the question to a larger Bench for determination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a bail bond taken by a police officer (and not by a Court) can be forfeited under Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  2. Whether, on the facts of this case, the particular bond executed by the surety could be forfeited given its wording (not specifying time and place) and the uncertainty whether it was taken under Section 499 or Section 170 CrPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (State of Haryana) Arguments

  • The State contended that the Sessions Judge's acceptance of the surety's appeal (based on Surjit Singh) was incorrect and that a conflict of authority existed which warranted reference to a larger Bench.
  • One argument advanced on behalf of the petitioner was that the bail bond in the present case had been given under Section 170 CrPC (i.e., security taken by the officer in charge of the police station for appearance before a Magistrate).

Respondent's (Satya Narain / surety) Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the respondent argued that the bond could not be forfeited because it was vague: it did not specify the time and place for production of the accused (it referred only to "the appointed date and time" and to production "on being required by the police or Court of competent jurisdiction").
  • Implicitly, the respondent relied on the penal character of forfeiture provisions and the requirement for strict compliance with statutory formalities (e.g., section 499(1) CrPC) to argue that no liability could be fastened on the surety where time and place were not specified.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surjit Singh v. State (1964 Cur LJ 202 (Punj)) Held that an undertaking given to a police officer is a promise to a particular official and not to a Court, and such a security bond could not be forfeited under Section 514 CrPC. The Sessions Judge relied on this case to set aside the forfeiture; the present Court reviewed and disagreed with Surjit Singh's interpretation of the Supreme Court authority it relied upon.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammed Sayeed (Supreme Court) Interpreted the phrase "such bond" in Section 514(1) as referring to "bond under this Code", meaning Section 514 applies only to bonds executed under the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Court used this ruling to clarify that Section 514(1) covers bonds executed under the CrPC, and that bonds taken by police under the Code for appearance before a Court fall within the scope of Section 514(1).
Rameshwar Bhartia v. State of Assam (Supreme Court) Held Section 514 CrPC inapplicable where the bond was given to a Procurement Inspector for production of property (i.e., the bond was not in favour of the State or Central Government under the Code). The Court distinguished Rameshwar Bhartia (which concerned a bond for property given to an official) from the present situation (a bond for accused's appearance given to police), noting that Rameshwar did not establish that police-taken appearance bonds were outside Section 514.
Sailesh Chandra v. The State (Calcutta High Court) Held that for appearance of an accused before the Court it is sufficient that the bond was taken by the police; it need not be taken by the Court itself for Section 514 to apply. The Court cited this authority as support for the proposition that police-taken appearance bonds are subject to forfeiture under Section 514.
Chhaganlal Kikabhai v. State of Gujarat (1969 Cri LJ 1164 (Guj)) Supported the view that a bail bond taken by the police for appearance before a Court can be dealt with under Section 514 CrPC. Used as another High Court authority aligning with the Court's conclusion that police-taken appearance bonds fall within Section 514.
State of Bihar v. M. Homi (Supreme Court) Referenced in relation to the penal character of forfeiture provisions and the requirement for strict compliance with statutory formalities. The Court invoked the principle that penal provisions governing forfeiture must be strictly construed when assessing whether a bond's terms permit forfeiture.
Chanan Shah v. The State (1963) 65 Pun LR 716 Held that if the statutory requirements of Section 499(1) CrPC (time and place to be mentioned in bond) are not complied with, no liability can be fastened on the surety. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that because the bond in the present case did not specify time and place, no liability could be imposed on the surety under that bond.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a textual interpretation of Section 514(1) CrPC and analysed its two parts:

  1. It observed that Section 514(1) divides into (a) bonds "taken by the Court under this Code" and (b) bonds "for appearance before a Court." The first part explicitly contemplates bonds taken by a Court; the second part refers to bonds for appearance before a Court and does not specify that they must be taken by a Court.
  2. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's interpretation in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammed Sayeed that the words "such bond" in Section 514(1) refer back to "bond under this Code" and therefore Section 514 applies only to bonds executed under the Code. From this the Court concluded that bonds taken by police officers under provisions of the CrPC (for example Sections 170, 496, 499) for appearance before a Court are included within the second part of Section 514(1).
  3. The Court reasoned that excluding police-taken appearance bonds from Section 514's operation would render police practice (taking such bonds) practically meaningless because there would be no statutory mechanism to forfeit them when the surety failed to produce the accused. As there is no other section in the Code dealing with forfeiture of such bonds, the second part of Section 514(1) must be read to encompass police-taken bonds for appearance before a Court.
  4. The Court considered Rameshwar Bhartia (Supreme Court) which had been relied upon in Surjit Singh, and found that Rameshwar Bhartia concerned a bond for production of property executed in favour of a Procurement Inspector. The Supreme Court in that case held Section 514 inapplicable because the bond was not one taken by a court under the Code; the present Court held that Rameshwar Bhartia did not establish the proposition that police-taken appearance bonds fall outside Section 514.
  5. The Court found support for its view in High Court precedents (Sailesh Chandra and Chhaganlal Kikabhai) which held that police-taken bonds for appearance before a Court are within Section 514's scope.
  6. Turning to the specific bond in the case, the Court examined its wording. The bond undertook that Jagdish Lal "shall appear ... on the appointed date and time on being required by the police or Court of competent jurisdiction" and promised Rs. 2,000 in case of default. The Court noted that the bond did not specify the time or place for production.
  7. The Court applied the principle that penal provisions (such as forfeiture of bonds) must be strictly construed and observed the requirement in Section 499(1) CrPC that a bond must mention the time and place at which the accused is to appear. Relying on Chanan Shah, the Court concluded that where Section 499(1) has not been complied with (time and place omitted), no liability can be fastened on the surety.
  8. The Court noted an argument that the bond might have been taken under Section 170 rather than Section 499, but found no record supporting the contention that the bond was taken under Section 170. Where doubt exists as to whether the bond was taken under Section 499 or Section 170, the benefit of the doubt must be given to the person whose bond is sought to be forfeited.
  9. Consequently, although the Court held generally that police-taken bail bonds for appearance may be forfeited under Section 514 CrPC, it concluded that on the specific wording of the bond in this case (lack of specified time and place and doubt as to statutory basis), the surety could not be held liable and the bond could not be forfeited.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The Court held two key points:

  • Police-taken bail bonds for appearance before a Court can be forfeited under Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • However, in the present case the surety's bond could not be forfeited because the bond did not specify the time and place of appearance (non-compliance with Section 499(1) CrPC) and there was doubt whether the bond was taken under Section 499 or Section 170; such doubt must be given in favour of the surety.

Immediate consequences:

  • The Sessions Judge's order (which had accepted the appeal of the surety) was upheld, but on a different ground than originally relied upon by that Judge.
  • The surety (Satya Narain) is not penalised and his bail bond is not forfeited in this specific matter.
  • The revision petition filed by the State of Haryana was disposed of in accordance with the Court's conclusions described above.

The opinion does not elaborate on broader policy consequences beyond these direct effects; it confines its implications to the applicability of Section 514 to police-taken appearance bonds and to the result on the particular bond before the Court.

Show all summary ...

1. One Jagdish Lal of village Bishanpura, Police Station Pilani (Rajasthan), was involved in a case under Section 304A, Indian Penal Code. On 26th July, 1968, Satya Narain stood surety for him before the police undertaking to produce him either before the police or a competent Court, if and when required and if he failed to do so, he undertook to nay Rs. 2,000/- to the State of Haryana. The case against Jagdish Lal was tried by the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Bhiwani, and he did not appear before the Court, with the result that the learned Magistrate issued non-bailable warrants against him but to no effect. Notice was, consequently, given to Satya Narain surety, who took a number of adjournments to produce the accused in Court but was unable to do so. As a result, the learned Magistrate passed an order under Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, forfeiting the surety bond furnished by him and directed him to pay a fine of Rs, 1,000/-.

2. As a result of the said forfeiture, Satya Narain filed an appeal against the above order and the same was accept" ed by the learned Sessions Judge, Hissar, on the basis of a decision of this Court in Surjit Singh v. State 1964 Cur LJ 202 (Punj), where it was held by Shamsher Bahadur, J. that where an undertaking is given by the surety before a Police Officer that the accused would be produced before the Court, it was a promise made to a particular official and not to a Court and such a security bond could not be forfeited under the provisions of Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

3. Against that decision, the State of Haryana filed the present revision petition in this Court. It, in the first instance, came up for hearing before my learned brother who was of the view that there was a conflict amongst the various High Courts regarding the interpretation of the provisions of Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and since an important question of law was involved, which was bound to arise in a number of, cases, he thought it expedient to refer this case to a larger Bench. That is how the matter has been placed before us.

4. The first question for decisions is whether a bail bond which is taken by a police officer and not by a Court can be forfeited under Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The relevant portion of section 514 of the said code reads:

514. (1) Whenever it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court by which a bond under this Code has been taken, or of the Court of a Presidency Magistrate or Magistrate of the first class, or, when the bond is for appearance before a Court, to the satisfaction of such Court.

that such bond has been forfeited, the Court shall record the grounds of such proof, and may call upon any person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof, or to show cause why it should not be paid.

A bare reading of this provision would show that this sub-section is divided into two parts. The first part relates to a bond which is taken by the Court under the Code of Criminal Procedure, and the second part talks of a bond for appearance before a Court. The proceedings in respect of the bonds which are covered by the first part can be taken either by the Court by which the said bond had been taken or the Court of a Presidency Magistrate or the Court of a Magistrate of the first class. Whenever it is proved to the satisfaction of either of the three Courts that such bond, namely, the bond which has been : referred to in the first part, has been forfeited, the said Court shall record the grounds of such proof and may call upon any person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof or to show cause why it should not be paid. The second part deals with a bond which is taken only for appearance before a Court. In that case, when it is proved to the satisfaction of that Court before whom the accused had to appear that such bond had been forfeited, the said Court shall record the grounds of such proof, and may call upon any person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof or to show cause why it should not be paid. From the language employed in this sub-section, it will be apparent that in the first part, the bond is taken by the Court, whereas in the second part, it is not said that the bond has to be taken by the Court meaning thereby that the second part also refers to the bonds taken by the police officers. Under the second part, all that is essential is that the bond is taken for the appearance of the accused before a Court, It may further be noticed that in the first part, it has been specifically mentioned that the bond has to be under the Code of Criminal Procedure. But in the second part, the words "under this Code" have not been incorporated after the word "bond" and it could perhaps be then argued that under the second part, it was not necessary that the bond should be under the Code of Criminal Procedure. This matter has been set at rest by the Supreme Court in State Of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammed Sayeed . where it has been laid down that the words "such bond" occurring in Section 514 (1) refer to the words "bond under this Code" in the first paragraph of the sub-section and include only bonds executed under the Code of Criminal Procedure. In other words, if the bond was not in favour of the State or the Central Government, it was not one under the Code of Criminal Procedure to which Section 514 thereof would apply. As I have already said, in the first cart it has been stated that the bond is taken by the Court, whereas in the second part, it is not so stated, and all that is mentioned is that the bond has to be for appearance before a Court. It can, therefore, be safely assumed that the second part would cover those cases where the bond has been taken under the provisions of the Code by the police officer for appearance before a Court. It is beyond dispute that there are provisions in the Code of Criminal Procedure, e.g., Sections 170, 496 and 499, which deal with bonds for appearance before the Court. This is also beyond dispute that under the Code bonds are taken by the police officers as well. If it were to be held that the second part of Section 514 (1) also deals with bonds which are taken by the Court only, and not the police officers, then the result will be that if a police officer takes a bond for the appearance of a person involved in a criminal case before a Court and the surety is unable to produce him before the said Court, such a bond will not be forfeited under Section 514. Code of Criminal Procedure. Concededly, there is no other section in the Code which deals with forfeiture of a bond. The consequence will be that it will be practically meaningless for the police officers to take bonds for the appearance of persons involved in criminal cases before a Court, and that will obviously result in great injustice. I am, therefore, of the view that the second part of Section 514 (1) will also apply to cases where the bonds are taken by the police officers under the Code for appearance before a Court.

5. Shamsher Bahadur, J. in Surjit Singh's case, 1964 Cur LJ 202 (Punj.)(supra) relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in Rameshwar Bhartia v. State Of Assam. , in coming to the conclusion that he did. I have gone through the facts of the Supreme Court authority and in my opinion, the learned Judges have not laid down that if a police officer takes a bond for the appearance of the accused before a Court then such a bond cannot be forfeited under Section 514 (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, if the surety is unable to produce the accused before the Court. The Supreme Court in that ruling had dealt with a case where a shoe-keeper was in possession of foodgrains in excess of the permitted quantity. A Procurement Inspector raided the shop and allowed the shopkeeper to keep the said foodgrains under a security bond by which an undertaking was given that the seized foodgrains would be produced before the Court when required. The bond was executed in favour of the Procurement Inspector. The surety later on was not able to produce the foodgrains before the Court with the result that the surety was directed to procure the same quantity of foodgrains after taking an appropriate licence and hand over the same to (he Procurement Department. Against that order, the District Magistrate made a reference to the High Court under Section 438, Code of Criminal Procedure, for enhancement of the sentence. The High Court accepted the reference. As regards the security bond, the High Court remanded the case to the trial Court for taking action under Section 514, Code of Criminal Procedure, for its forfeiture. The surety filed an appeal in the Supreme Court against the order of his conviction and remand. The Supreme Court, in those circumstances, held that the provisions of Section 514, Code of Criminal Procedure, were not applicable, inasmuch as; the bond had been given to the Procurement Inspector and observed:

The High Court was in error in thinking that Section 514, Criminal Procedure Code, applied. Action could be taken only when the bond is taken by the court under the provisions of the Code such as Section 91 for appearance, the several security sections or those relating to bail.... The language is perfectly clear; the power to forfeit and the imposition of the penalty provided for in the later parts of the section arise only if the preliminary conditions are satisfied.

It would, thus, be seen that the Supreme Court was dealing with a case where the bond was taken for the production of some property and it was executed in favour of a Procurement Officer, and it was then held that provisions of Section 514. Code of Criminal Procedure, did not apply.

6. The view that I have taken finds support from a Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court in Sailesh Chandra v. The State , where it was held that in respect of appearance of an accused before the Court, it was sufficient under Section 514, Code of Criminal Procedure, that the bond was taken by the police and it was not necessary that it should be taken by the Court itself. In this authority, reference was made to Rameshwar Bhartia's case (supra) and distinguished. The same view was taken by the Gujarat High Court in Chhaganlal Kikabhai v. State of Gujarat 1969 Cri LJ 1164 (Gut). I, therefore, hold that the bail bond taken by the police for the appearance of the accused before the Court can also be forfeited under Section 514, Code of Criminal Procedure. Shamsher Bahadur, J. in Surjit Singh's case, 1964 Cur LJ 202 (Punj.) had not, if I may say so with respect, correctly interpreted the decision in Rameshwar Bhartia's case.

7. The learned Counsel for the respondent then submitted that the bond given by his client in the instant case could not be forfeited, because it was vaguely worded and it did not mention the time and place for the production of the accused. The bond, as I have already said, was given to the police and it was stated therein,-

"I shall make Jagdish Lal aforesaid appear to answer the charge under Section 304A, Indian Penal Code, on the appointed date and time on being required by the police or Court of competent jurisdiction. In case of default, I shall pay a sum of Rs. 2,000/- by way of penalty to the State of Haryana."
It will thus be seen that it does not mention as to when, at what time and where the surety was required to produce Jagdish Lal. It is undisputed that the provisions about the imposition of a penalty and the forfeiture of a bond are penal in character and it is essential that they should be strictly followed. Reference in this connection may be made to a Supreme Court case reported as State of Bihar v. M. Homi . Section 499 (1), Criminal Procedure Code, says,-

Before any person is released on bail or released on his own bond, a bond for such sum of money as the police officer or Court, as the case may be, thinks sufficient shall be executed by such person, and, when he is released on bail, by one or more sufficient sureties conditioned that such person shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond, and shall continue so to attend until otherwise directed by the police officer or Court, as the case may be.

This sub-section requires that the time and place at which the accused is to appear must be mentioned in the bond. It has been held in Chanan Shah v. The State (1963) 65 Pun LR 716, that if there is infraction of the statutory provisions mentioned in Section 499 (1), Code of Criminal Procedure, no liability on the basis of the bond can be fastened on the surety. As already stated, neither the time nor the place at which the accused was to appear before the Court had been mentioned in the bail bond in the instant case. That being so no liability can be fastened on the surety on the basis of this bond.

8. It was argued by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the bail bond in the present case was given under Section 170, Criminal Procedure Code, the relevant part of which reads:

170. (1) If, upon an investigation under this Chapter, it appears to the officer in charge of the police station that there is sufficient evidence or reasonable ground as aforesaid, such officer shall forward the accused under custody to a Magistrate empowered to take cognizance of the offence upon a police report and to try the accused or commit him for trial or, if the offence is bailable and the accused is able to give security, shall take security from him for his appearance before such Magistrate on a day fixed and for his attendance from day to day before such Magistrate until otherwise directed.

There is, however, nothing on the record to show that the bond was given under the provisions of this section. If there is a doubt as to whether the bond is given under Section 499 or Section 170, Code of Criminal Procedure, then the benefit of doubt has to be given to the person whose bond is going to be forfeited. I, therefore, hold that on the wording of the bond itself, no liability can be fastened on the surety for the non-appearance of Jagdish Lal before the Court.

9. The result is that though the petitioner succeeds in getting a finding in its favour that a bail bond taken by a police officer for the appearance of an accused before the Court can also be forfeited under Section 514, Code of Criminal Procedure, but the surety, in the instant case, cannot be penalised and his bail-bond forfeited because of the language employed therein. The order passed by the learned Sessions Judge is, therefore, upheld but on a different ground. The revision petition is accordingly, disposed of as indicated above.