Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Nath And Anr. v. Central Government, New Delhi And Ors

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 27, 1959
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Following the 1947 partition, numerous displaced persons who had left urban agricultural lands in Pakistan were, whenever possible, allotted similar lands in India. Some displaced persons who had held such lands within the corporation area of Lahore and municipal limits of Gujranwala were leased or allotted similar lands in the municipal areas of Jullundur, Ferozepore and Amritsar.

When the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954 ("the Act") was enacted, the Central Government acquired these lands and placed them in the compensation pool. The Central Government issued a press note on 4-6-1957 indicating the method for permanent transfer of these lands, and a modifying press note on 15-10-1958. On 27-11-1958 the Chief Settlement Commissioner issued a memorandum purportedly clarifying the press notes; that memorandum gave lessees of urban agricultural lands a right to select one plot (one khasra number) of value less than Rs. 10,000 and provided that the remainder was to be sold by auction.

Some displaced persons, dissatisfied with the press notes and the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum, filed separate writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging their validity. Several petitions were consolidated for decision (Civil Writs Nos. 345, 346, 352, 353, 364, 366, 367, 368, 369, 370, 395 and 711 of 1959). Only Civil Writ No. 395 of 1959 was argued before the court, and the court treated the common legal question as appropriate for a single judgment resolving all the listed petitions.

The opinion also summarizes the historical and administrative context: the Land Resettlement Manual (accepted by the Supreme Court as a work of authority) and the Administration of Evacuee Property Act, 1950 treated urban agricultural land as a separate category distinct from general agricultural land and described the resettlement scheme as not dealing with urban agricultural land in the same way as rural agricultural land.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Government press notes (dated 4-6-1957 and 15-10-1958) and the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum (27-11-1958) validly regulated the mode of transfer/payment of compensation for urban agricultural lands forming part of the compensation pool under the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954.
  2. Whether Chapter VIII of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Rules (and specifically Rules 49–69) applies to urban agricultural land or only to rural agricultural land.
  3. Whether Section 16 of the Act (and Rule 87) empowered the Central Government or the Chief Settlement Commissioner to prescribe the mode of transfer of property in the compensation pool by press notes or by a memorandum, thereby bypassing the rule-making requirements and parliamentary control under Section 8(2) and Section 40 of the Act.
  4. Whether the memorandum issued by the Chief Settlement Commissioner (27-11-1958) was validly issued under Rule 87 or otherwise.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought that the urban land leased to them and in their occupation should be allotted and transferred to them by setting off its valuation against the compensation payable to them under Section 8 of the Act.
  • They relied on the provisions of Section 8 (and Section 8(2)) which authorise rules to regulate the form and manner of payment; such rules must be notified and laid before Parliament, securing parliamentary control.
  • Accordingly, the petitioners contended that the Central Government could not invoke Section 16 or issue press notes to prescribe a mode for payment/transfer to lessees of urban agricultural land that would bypass the statutory rule-making procedure and parliamentary oversight.

Respondents' Arguments

  • In their written statement, respondents relied on Rule 87 to contend that any property in the compensation pool may be sold by public auction, by inviting tenders or by any other method; they asserted the Government had, as a concession, decided to give some land by allotment to lessees and that the press notes merely recorded that concession.
  • The Advocate-General argued that the press notes conveyed the measures the Central Government was taking for disposal of the compensation pool under Section 16 of the Act, and that the Chief Settlement Commissioner acted under Rule 87 when issuing his memorandum on 27-11-1958.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the statutory scheme and administrative history, proceeding step-by-step:

  1. Classification of land and legislative context:
    • The Land Resettlement Manual and the Administration of Evacuee Property Act, 1950 treated urban agricultural land as a distinct category separate from rural agricultural land; resettlement schemes generally addressed rural agricultural land, not urban agricultural land.
    • Under the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954, evacuee property (including urban agricultural land) became part of the compensation pool (Section 14). Displaced persons with verified claims applied for compensation (Section 4), and Section 8 sets out modes for the payment of compensation (including transfer by sale or other modes). Section 40 empowers the Central Government to make rules to carry out the Act’s purposes and, in particular, to provide for the scales, form and manner, and instalments by which compensation may be paid.
  2. Interpretation of the Rules:
    • Rules under the Act (the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Rules, 1955) are divided into chapters. Chapters V–X deal with payment of compensation from different categories of evacuee property. Chapter V deals with residential properties, shops and industrial concerns, and does not specifically deal with urban agricultural land; Chapter VIII deals with agricultural land left in West Pakistan but does not apply to agricultural land mentioned under section 10 (per the opinion) and the court concluded Chapter VIII relates to rural agricultural land rather than urban agricultural land.
    • The court observed Rules 49–69 are in Chapter VIII and that Rule 50 fixes value in terms of standard acres and Rule 51 ties sale/allotment to a quasi-permanent land allotment scheme used in Punjab and Pepsu. Those valuation methods (standard acres, wheat yield) plainly apply to rural agricultural land and are unsuitable for urban agricultural land whose value is largely market-driven due to location.
    • Because urban agricultural land had historically been treated as a separate, “urban” category (by agreement and prior administrative practice), and because the rules and chapters dealing with agricultural land adopt rural valuation methodology, the court held that Chapter VIII was not intended to apply to urban agricultural land absent a specific mention.
  3. On the validity of press notes and memorandum:
    • The petitioners sought transfer/allotment by setting off valuation under Section 8, which contemplates rule-making subject to parliamentary control (rules to be notified and laid before Parliament for at least 30 days under Section 8(2)). The court emphasized that the parliamentary control over rules is deliberate and central.
    • The court rejected the respondents’ attempt to rely on Section 16 (and Rule 87) to justify the press notes and the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum as a means of prescribing the mode of transfer/payment. The court acknowledged that Section 16(1) is broadly worded but concluded it should not be construed so as to enable the Central Government to determine the mode of transfer of any property in the compensation pool without making rules pursuant to Section 8(2) and Section 40 and without parliamentary oversight.
    • The court reasoned that construing Section 16(1) literally to allow such power would render the rule-making provisions and other statutory safeguards (including Section 32 and the rules made under the Act) redundant and ineffective. Section 8(2)(b) specifically provides for rules regulating the form and manner of payment; Section 16 was not intended to permit bypass of those provisions.
    • With respect to Rule 87 (in Chapter XIV), the court held Rule 87 empowered the Chief Settlement Commissioner to adopt methods of sale for property in the compensation pool but did not authorize the Commissioner to explain or amend press notes or to introduce substantial changes in the manner asserted by respondents. Therefore Rule 87 did not validate the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum of 27-11-1958.
  4. Conclusion of analysis:
    • Because Chapter VIII does not apply to urban agricultural land, because the statutory rule-making procedure under Section 8(2) and Section 40 must be followed to determine the mode of transfer/payment for occupants of urban agricultural land, and because neither Section 16 nor Rule 87 validated the press notes or the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum, the court found those instruments invalid for the purpose asserted by respondents.
    • All orders challenged by the writ petitions that relied upon the press notes and the memorandum were therefore made without lawful authority and were quashed.

The court also observed that the absence of specific rules relating to urban agricultural land was due to an accidental omission and that the press notes were issued to expedite disposal of the compensation pool, but this did not validate the press notes or the memorandum.

Holding and Implications

All writ petitions succeed and the impugned orders (made in accordance with the Central Government press notes of 4-6-1957 and 15-10-1958 and the Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum of 27-11-1958) are quashed.

Direct consequences: the specific orders challenged in the listed writ petitions were set aside; the parties were left to bear their own costs. The court’s decision requires that any mode of transfer or payment of compensation for urban agricultural land forming part of the compensation pool must be provided for by rules made under the Act (in accordance with Section 8(2) and Section 40) and subjected to the statutory procedure and parliamentary oversight; press notes and a Chief Settlement Commissioner’s memorandum cannot lawfully substitute for those rules.

Broader implications: the opinion does not purport to create new general principles beyond enforcing the statutory rule-making and parliamentary-control scheme; it addresses and decides the specific legal and procedural defects in the Government’s reliance on press notes and the memorandum in these cases.

Show all summary ...

(1) Numerous displaced persons left urban agricultural lands in Pakistan. They were allotted similar lands in Indian whenever possible under evacuee legislation. Some of these displaced persons who owned such lands within the corporation area of Lahore and within the municipal limits of Gujranwala were leased or allotted similar lands within the municipal area of Jullundur, Ferozepore and Amritsar. When the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act 1954, was enacted, the Government acquired these lands and put them in the compensation pool. The Central Government on 4-6-1957 issued a press note indicating the method by which these lands would be permanently transferred. Another press note was issued on 15-10-1958 modifying the previous press note.

The Chief Settlement Commissioner on 27-11-1958 issued a memorandum purporting to clarify the terms of the press notes issued by the Central Government. According to these instructions the lessees of urban agricultural lands were given the right to select one plot, that is, one khasra number of the value of less than Rs. 10,000/- and the rest was intended to be sold by auction. Accordingly the Managing Officer called upon the displaced persons concerned to make the necessary selection for permanent transfer thereof to them Dissatisfied with these demands some of the displaced persons have filed separate petitions under Art. 226 of the Constitution challenging the validity of these Government press notes and the memorandum issued by the Chief Settlement Commissioner.

Some of these petitions are these (Civil Writs Nos. 345, 346, 352, 353, 364, 366, 367, 368, 369, 370, 395 and 711 of 1959). The learned counsel for both sides agree that in spite of different facts in each petition, the question that requires determination in all these cases is the same and that it will be convenient to decide them all by one judgment. In fact only Civil Writ No. 395 of 1959 was argued before me and it was stated that the same arguments are relevant in all other petitions. I shall, therefore, decide all these writ petitions by this judgment.

(2) When in 1947 at the time of partition of the country Hindus and Sikhs migrated en masses from West Punjab and Muslims left this country, it became necessary to resettle the displaced persons and to get the evacuee lands cultivated. The mode adopted for giving evacuee lands to the displaced persons is described in detail by Shri Tarlok Singh in his well known Land Resettlement manual and this Manual has been accepted by the Supreme Court as a work of authority. At page 100 of this Manual Shri Tarlok Singh has stated--

"By an agreement between the two Dominions (Indian and Pakistan) agricultural property has been defined as 'land not included within the limits of a Corporation, Municipal Committee, Notified Area Committee. Town Area, Small Town Committee and Cantonment, as these limits stood on 15-8-1947.......... For this reason the general scheme of land resettlement comprises only those evacuee lands which re not by definition urban lands.

From the area abandoned by a displaced person, therefore, land held by him in an urban area has been placed in a separate category and only the balance of his land, described as agricultural property, is subjected to valuation and cut with a view to allotment of agricultural land in East Punjab and Pepsu."

The resettlement scheme, therefore, does not deal with urban agricultural land. It, however, deals with agricultural land in the suburbs of a city of town but by evaluating it at a higher figure on account of its location. It is, therefore, clear that under the Administration of Evacuee Property Act, 1950, the urban agricultural land was considered to belong to a special category and was leased and allotted as such to displaced persons who had left similar lands in Pakistan.

(3) These leases and allotments made by the Custodian were, however, of temporary nature. In 1954 the Government of India came to the conclusion that the evacuee property should be dealt with on permanent basis and the displaced persons should be given final compensation. Accordingly it enacted the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act (Act No. 4 of 1954). Section 14 of this Act constituted a compensation pool which inter alia consisted of all evacuee property acquired under S. 12 of the Act. The Central Government acquired the evacuee urban agricultural lands besides other agricultural lands etc. Under S. 4 of the Act all displaced persons having verified claims were to apply for payment of compensation. This was done.

Section 8 lays down the mode of payment of compensation. Under this provision the compensation may inter alia be paid by sale of any property or by any other mode of transfer to the displaced persons from the compensation pool. The Central Government under S. 40 has been empowered to make rules to carry out the purposes of the Act and in particular inter alia to provide for the scales according to which, the form and manner in which, and the instalments by which, compensation may be paid to displaced persons.

Exhaustive rules under this Act have been made and are known as "Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Rules, 1955" which have been modified from time to time. These Rules are divided into chapters. Chapters V to X deal with payment of compensation out of various categories of evacuee properties constituting part of the compensation pool. Chapter V makes rules relating to transfer of evacuee property. The properties mentioned therein are residential properties, shops and industrial concerns. This Chapter does not specifically deal with urban agricultural land. It is for this reason that both sides in their pleadings state that Chapter V does not deal with urban agricultural land.

Chapter VI deals with transfer of Government built property while Chapter VII deals with rural houses and shops left in West Pakistan and, therefore, have nothing to do with the present case. Chapter VIII deals with compensation payable in respect of verified claims for agricultural land left in West Pakistan. This chapter does not apply to agricultural land mentioned under section 10 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act. Chapter X deals specifically with such properties. Chapter IX deals with allotment and sale of groves and gardens outside the Punjab and Pepsu. Chapters XI and XII deal payment of compensation to different categories of displaced persons, for example, minors, inmates of a Home or infirmary etc. (4) In this state of statutory provisions the petitioners' case is that Chapter VIII governs the present cases as this Chapter deals with agricultural land without drawing any distinction between urban and rural categories thereof particularly when no other provision in the Act or the Rules deals with such lands. It was further argued that no provision has been made for dealing with urban agricultural land which forms part of compensation pool. I am unable to accept this contention of the petitioners. Rules 49 to 69 are found in Chapter 8. Rule 50 lays down that the value of agricultural land shall be fixed in terms of standard acres and rule 51 lays down that the sale of allotment shall be the same as provided in the quasi-permanent land allotment scheme in the State of Punjab and Pepsu.

Now under this scheme only rural agricultural land as distinct from urban agricultural land has been valued in terms of standard acres on the basis of yield of crop of wheat. This mode has also been adopted in rule 2(g) of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Rules. The mode adopted need not be described in this judgment as this method is discussed at length in the Land Resettlement Manual. There is no suggestion in any of the petitions that the urban agricultural land was valued in terms of standard acres--the indication if any is to the contrary. R. 51 shows clearly that this chapter deals with ruler agricultural land as the quasi-permanent allotment scheme in Punjab and Pepsu applied only to rural agricultural land.

It would be unreal to value urban agricultural land on the basis of wheat yield and would work hardship on displaced persons entitled to get this category of land. Such land can be satisfactorily valued only according to its market value as its value substantially increases its price. Moreover the entire evacuee property to start with vested in the Custodian under the evacuee legislation. The Custodian while administering evacuee property was entitled to lease or allot it to any person.

A scheme was devised under that Act which is discussed in the Land Resettlement Manual. By agreement with Pakistan the urban agricultural land, however, was treated as a separate category of land and was not included in the general scheme. It was treated as urban land. The Displaced Persons (Compensation and rehabilitation) act and the rules made thereunder preeminently deal with evacuee property. Elaborate provisions have been made in the Rules for transferring proprietary rights in evacuee properties of each category to displaced persons.

Various categories of properties are mentioned in the Rules and are treated separately. The special category of urban agricultural land which was treated as a distinct category and dealt with separately under the Administration of Evacuee Property Act has not been specifically mentioned in the Rules made under the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act. Considering this legislative environment I am clearly of the opinion that if Chapter VIII was intended to apply to urban agricultural land then specific mention thereof would have been made in the preamble to this Chapter or in one of the Rules in the Chapter. In the absence of such a specific mention it must be held that Chapter VIII does not relate to urban agricultural land.

(5) In this view of the matter it is not necessary to discuss the exact scope of Rule 49.

(6) This bring me to the respondents' case. In the written statement it is stated that under rule 87 any property forming part of the compensation pool may be sold by public auction or by inviting tenders or by any other method and that the Government has as a matter of concession decided to give some land by allotment to the lessees of urban agricultural land and that the press notes merely record this concession. The learned Advocate-General urged that the various press notes are intended to convey to the public the measures that the Central Government is taking for the disposal of the compensation pool as laid down in S. 16 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act and that the Chief Settlement Commissioner has acted under rule 87 when he issued his memorandum on 27-11-1958. It is necessary to examine the validity of these contentions.

(7) Now in the present case the petitioners want that the urban land leased to them and in their occupation, should be allotted and transferred to them by setting off its valuation against the compensation payable to them in accordance with the provisions of S. 8 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act. This section deals with the matter under consideration and S. 8(2) lays down that the Central Government may make rules for this purpose. These rules are to be notified in the official gazette and must be laid before both Houses of Parliament for not less than 30 days.

The control of the Parliament over these rules is thus secured. In this context it is not open to the Central Government to invoke section 16 and prescribe a mode for payment of compensation to the displaced person who are lessees of urban agricultural land by issue of press notes. Section 16(2) deals with the appointments of officers and it will not be improper to consider that section 16(1) in this context relates to appointment of officers and other cognate matters for management of compensation pool although this sub-section is rather widely worded. In my opinion it should not be so construed as to enable the Central Government to determine the mode of transfer of any property forming part of compensation pool without making rules for that purpose.

Section 16(1) construed literally gives absolute power to issue directions for management of compensation pool and if that be accepted then all the rules made under the Act and even provisions of S. 32 would become redundant and ineffective. Section 8(2)(b) specifically provides that rules should be made regulating the form and manner in which the compensation may be paid. Section 16 is not intended to empower the Government to ignore and by-pass section 8(2) and S. 40 of the Act and also to deprive the Parliament of its control over the matter. When rules relating to payment of compensation to occupants of other categories of lands have been made, I do not see why rules for urban agricultural land should also not be made. I am, therefore, of the opinion that these press notes could not validly regulate the way that compensation is to be paid out of the compensation pool to those displaced persons who have been leased urban agricultural land.

(8) Rule 87 has no application to the memorandum issued by the Chief Settlement Commissioner. This rule occurs in Chapter XIV and its preamble states that the rules in this Chapter prescribe procedure for sale of property in the compensation pool. Property may be sold in many ways and rule 87 empowers the Chief Settlement Commissioner to adopt any one or more of those various ways. This rule does not enable the Chief Settlement Commissioner to explain the press notes issued by the Central Government or as alleged by the petitioner to introduce amendments of substantial nature while construing the press note. I, therefore, hold that the memorandum issued by the Chief Settlement Commissioner on 27-11-1958 is invalid.

(9) All the orders which are challenged by these writ petitions have been made in accordance with the press notes and the memorandum discussed above on the assumption that they have the force of law. I have come to a different conclusion.

(10) The result is that all these writ petitions succeed and the impugned, orders are quashed. There can be no doubt that the absence of rules relating to urban agricultural land is due to an accidental omission and that press notes were issued to expedite disposal of compensation pool. I, therefore, leave the parties to bear their own costs of these petitions.

(11) Orders quashed.