- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M.G. Dua v. Balli Mal
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, Messrs. Bali Mal Nawal Kishore, filed a suit on 2nd February 1950 in the Court of Sub Judge, Panipat, against the appellant, Messrs. M. G. Dua of Bombay, seeking recovery of Rs. 8,000 based on bahi accounts. The defendants were initially summoned for 10th March 1955, but due to the presiding officer’s leave, the hearing was postponed to 22nd March 1955. On this date, summonses had not been served, so summonses for 26th April 1955 were sent by registered post. The defendant did not appear on 26th April despite receiving the registered cover, leading to ex parte proceedings. Evidence was recorded on 29th April 1955, and an ex parte decree was passed against the defendant for the full amount. On 21st May 1955, the defendant applied to set aside the ex parte decree, alleging sufficient cause for non-appearance, stating that the registered cover lacked a copy of the plaint. The defendant’s solicitors had requested a copy of the plaint and an adjournment, and the defendant relied on their advice not to appear. Additionally, the defendant had filed a suit on the same subject in Bombay and intended to seek a stay of the Panipat suit. The Sub Judge dismissed the application to set aside the decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the summons was duly served on the defendant in compliance with the Civil Procedure Code, specifically whether the summons was accompanied by a copy of the plaint as required under Order 5 Rule 2.
- Whether ex parte proceedings under Order 9 Rule 6 could be validly initiated without proper service of summons.
- Whether the defendant demonstrated sufficient cause to set aside the ex parte decree under Order 9 Rule 13, based on non-appearance justified by solicitor’s advice and pending litigation in another court.
- Whether the mode of service by registered post after unsuccessful personal service contravened the proviso to Order 5 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The summons was not duly served as it was not accompanied by a copy of the plaint, violating Order 5 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Code.
- Ex parte proceedings under Order 9 Rule 6 require proof of due service of summons, which was lacking.
- The summons was initially to be served personally, but subsequent service by registered post was improper as it violated the proviso to Order 5 Rule 10.
- The defendant had a valid reason for non-appearance, having filed a suit on the same matter in Bombay and having acted on solicitor’s advice to seek a stay and adjournment.
Respondent's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mohan Lal v. Sundar Lal Nand Lal, AIR 1949 E.P. 295 | Prohibition on serving summons by registered post after unsuccessful personal service under proviso to Order 5 Rule 10, CPC | The Court held that summons sent by registered post after an unsuccessful attempt at personal service was improper, reinforcing that registered post service must be the first mode if chosen by the plaintiff. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the service of summons in light of the Civil Procedure Code provisions. Section 27 CPC mandates that summons must be served in a prescribed manner, and Order 5 Rule 2 requires every summons to be accompanied by a copy of the plaint or a concise statement. The defendant’s solicitors’ letters and the plaintiff’s admission confirmed that no copy of the plaint was sent with the summons, rendering the service incomplete and invalid. Without a copy of the plaint, the defendant could not be expected to understand the nature of the suit or decide on the necessity of appearance.
Further, the Court noted that the summons was initially ordered to be served personally, and only later was service by registered post attempted. This violated the proviso to Order 5 Rule 10, which allows service by registered post only as the first mode if the plaintiff so wishes. The Court relied on the precedent in Mohan Lal v. Sundar Lal Nand Lal to reinforce this interpretation.
Given these defects in service, the Court concluded that the summons was not duly served, which alone warranted setting aside the ex parte decree under Order 9 Rule 13. Additionally, the defendant showed sufficient cause for non-appearance by demonstrating reliance on solicitor’s advice and ongoing litigation in another court, further justifying setting aside the decree.
Holding and Implications
The appeal was allowed and the ex parte decree was set aside.
The Court ordered the case to be remitted to the Sub Judge, Panipat, for further proceedings and decision in accordance with law. The parties were directed to appear on 13th January 1958. Each party was to bear its own costs of the appeal, but the defendant was ordered to pay Rs. 150 to the plaintiff as costs for setting aside the ex parte decree, with payment being a condition precedent.
This decision directly affects the parties by reinstating the suit for adjudication on merits and clarifies the procedural requirement that summons must be duly served with a copy of the plaint and in compliance with prescribed modes of service. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing procedural rules and precedent.
(1.) THIS is an appeal from an order of Sub Judge First Class, Kamal (at Panipat), refusing to set aside an ex parte decree under order 9 Rule 13, Civil Procedure code. Messrs. Bali Mal Nawal Kishore respondent brought a suit in the Court of sub Judge, Panipat, for recovery or Rs. 8,000/- on the basis of bahi accounts against Messrs. M. G. Dua of Bombay the appellant. The suit was instituted on 2nd february, 1950. The defendants were directed to be summoned for 10th March, 1955. Since the presiding officer was to be on leave that day, the case was ordered to be put up on the 22nd March, 1955. On this later date the summonses had not been served. Summonses for appearance of the defendant on 26th April, 1955, were ordered to be sent by registered post. The defendant did not appear on 26th, though he had received the registered cover. Ex parte proceedings were therefore ordered. After recording some evidence of the plaintiff on the adjourned hearing viz. 29th April, 1955, the Court passed an ex parte decree for the full amount against the defendant. On 21st May, 1955, the defendant presented an application for setting aside the ex parte decree alleging that he was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing in Court on 26th April, 1955. In support of his application, the defendant gave his own statement on oath. He stated that the registered cover did not contain a copy of the plaint. He therefore contacted his solicitors. The solicitors wrote a letter to the Court and another to the plaintiff requesting that a copy of the plaint be supplied to the defendant and also praying for an adjournment in the case. On the advice given to him by the solicitors, the defendant did not deem it necessary to appear on the date fixed- in the case at Panipat. He further stated that he had already filed a suit against the plaintiff in the Court of City Civil Judge, Bombay, on the same subject matter, and he wanted to apply to the Court at Bombay for an order staying the suit instituted against him in Panipat. No evidence was given in rebuttal. The learned Sub Judge did not consider the reasons to be sufficient and dismissed the application.
(2.) MR. Manchanda, learned counsel for the appellant, in the first instance, contends that the defendant had not been duly served and therefore ex parte proceedings under Order 9 Rule 6, Civil Procedure Code, could not be ordered. The contention is not without force. Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Code lays down that where a suit has been duly instituted, a summons may be issued to the defendant to appear and answer the claim and it may be served in the manner prescribed. Order 5 of the First Schedule prescribes the manner in which service is to be effected. Rule 2 of the Order 5 says --
"* * *every summons shall be accompanied by a copy of the plaint or, if so permitted, by a concise statement."evidently, no copy of the plaint was sent to the defendant along with the summons. It is so stated by the plaintiff and the fact was mentioned in the letters written by his solicitors to the Court and to the plaintiff. Ex parte proceedings under Order 9 Rule 6, Civil Procedure Code, can only be taken where the defendant does not appear when the suit is called for hearing, if it is proved that the summons was duly served. A summons cannot be regarded as duly served, unless it is accompanied by a copy of the plaint. Without a copy of the plaint, the defendant had no means of knowing as to what was the nature of the suit and deciding whether it was at all necessary for him to defend it.
(3.) THERE is yet another reason for holding that the defendant was not duly served. The service, in the first instance, was directed to be made in the ordinary mode, by personal service on the defendant. It was only on the second or the third hearing that summonses were ordered to be sent by registered post. This contravened the proviso added to Order 5 Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code, in this State. The proviso says--
"provided that in any case if the plaintiff so wishes, the Court may serve the summons in the first instance by registered post (acknowledgment due) instead of in the mode of service laid down in this rule."
It means that the summons shall be sent by registered post only in the first instance, if it is so wished by the plaintiff. If any other mode of service was tried in the first instance and if it failed to yield any fruitful result, it is not open to the court, in view of the prohibition contained in the proviso, to endeavour to effect service on the defendant by registered post (Mohan Lal v. Sundar Lal Nand Lal, air 1949 E. P. 295).
(4.) I am, therefore, clearly of the opinion that the summons had not been duly served on the defendant. An ex parte decree shall be set aside under Order 9 Rule 13, if the defendant satisfies the Court that the summons was not duly served. The ex parte decree, therefore, ought to have been set aside on this ground alone.
(5.) ON the second ground also, I think the defendant has shown sufficient reason for his non-appearance. He had already filed a suit against the plaintiff in Bombay. On receipt of the summons he approached his solicitor in Bombay for guidance and advice. The solicitors rightly or wrongly gave the impression that an order for stay of the suit at Panipat could be obtained on an application to the Bombay court. Since the City Civil Court in Bombay was to close for vacation from 30th april to 20th June, 1955, the solicitors thought it fit to request "the Court at panipat for adjourning the case to the month of July, 1955. On 13th April, 1955, the solicitors wrote a letter of request to the Court at Panipat, which was received on 15th of April, 1955. A similar letter was also written by the solicitors to the plaintiff. The defendant, according to his statement, acted on this advice of his solicitors and did not appear at Panipat on 26th April, 1955.
(6.) FOR all these reasons, I would accept this appeal and set aside the ex parte decree passed by the Sub Judge. The case is remitted to the said Court for being proceeded with and decided in accordance with the law. The parties have been directed to appear before the Sub Judge on 13th January, 1958. They shall bear their own costs in this appeal, but the defendant shall pay Rs. 150/-to the plaintiff as costs for setting aside the ex parte decree, payment of which shall be condition precedent.
Order 9 Rule 13,Alert