- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S. Santokh Singh v. Bhai Siri Ram Singh
Factual and Procedural Background
The trial court passed a preliminary decree in a suit for rendition of accounts and appointed a Commissioner to examine the accounts. The defendant appealed to the District Judge and sought a stay of proceedings before the Commissioner under Order XLI Rule 5 and section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The District Judge refused the stay, leading the defendant to approach the High Court in revision. [1]
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, absent special or exceptional circumstances, an unsuccessful litigant may delay the passing of a final decree by appealing against a preliminary decree and seeking a stay of further proceedings until the appeal is decided. [2]
- Whether the District Judge improperly exercised the discretion to refuse a stay of the accounting proceedings. [3][4]
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The defendant argued that the proceedings should be stayed because it was an established practice to stay proceedings pending an appeal against a preliminary decree. [5]
- It was also contended that the appeal was likely to succeed. [6]
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nerot v. Burnand | Proceedings for taking accounts are not ordinarily stayed pending an appeal unless irreparable injury would otherwise result. | The Court relied on this authority to reject the claim that proceedings should invariably be stayed. [7] |
| Coleman & Co., Ltd. v. Stephen Smith & Co. Ltd. | A stay may be justified where failure to grant it would cause irreparable injury. | The Court cited the case as supporting the limited exception to the general refusal to stay accounting proceedings. [7] |
| In Re Palmer's Trade Mark | When a question of law decided on a preliminary objection is under appeal, the trial of factual issues will not generally be stayed. | The Court used this principle to support continuation of proceedings despite the pending appeal. [7] |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court rejected the asserted practice of granting a stay in every case where an appeal is filed against a preliminary decree. The applicable practice was instead that accounting proceedings should continue unless refusing a stay would cause irreparable injury. [5][7]
The Court further held that any practice must yield to the express language of Order XLI Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code, which provides that an appeal does not operate as a stay unless the appellate court orders one. The word “may” gives the court a discretion to grant or refuse a stay; that discretion need not invariably favour the appellant. [3]
Permitting accounts to remain unexamined merely because an unsuccessful litigant has appealed would, absent exceptional circumstances, unreasonably prolong the litigation. [8]
The decision whether to grant a stay is discretionary, and the High Court may interfere only where the lower court acted on wrong principles. The possibility that the appeal had strong grounds, or was likely to succeed, was insufficient by itself to justify a stay. [4][6]
Holding and Implications
REVISION PARTLY DISMISSED/ORDER UPHELD: The District Judge's order was upheld to the extent that the Commissioner was directed to continue examining the parties' accounts and submit a report. However, no final decree was to be passed until the appeal against the preliminary decree was heard and decided. The District Judge was directed to endeavour to hear the appeal expeditiously. [9]
The direct effect was that the accounting proceedings continued, while final decree proceedings remained deferred pending disposal of the appeal. The opinion states no broader implications, and no new precedent was set. [9]
Bhandari, C.J:— The short point for decision is whether in the absence of special circumstances an unsuccessful litigant should be permitted to delay the passing of a final decree by filing an appeal from the preliminary decree and requiring that no further proceedings should be taken until his appeal is heard and decided.
2. The trial court passed a preliminary decree in a suit for rendition of accounts and appointed a Commissioner to examine the accounts. The defendant preferred an appeal to the District Judge and presented an application under Order XLI rule 5 and section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the stay of further proceedings before the local commissioner until such time as the appeal was heard and decided. The District Judge declined to order a stay and the defendant has accordingly come to this court in revision.
3. Mr. D.K Mahajan who appears for the defendant prays that the proceedings in the present case be stayed as it is an established practice of the Courts to stay proceedings in such cases until the appeal against the preliminary decree is determined. I regret I am unable to concur in this contention.
4. In the first place, I am not aware of any practice that the court will, in every case, whether there are particular circumstances in the case or not, make an order for the stay of proceedings pending an appeal from the preliminary decree. On the contrary the practice appears to be that the Court will not stay the taking of accounts pending an appeal Nerot v. Burnand . 2 Russell 56. unless an irreparable injury would otherwise be caused (Coleman & Co., Ltd. v. Stephen Smith & Co. Ltd. . 1911 2 Ch. D. 572, 580.). In Re Palmer's Trade Mark3 it was held that when a question of law has been decided on a preliminary objection, and an appeal has been brought, the Court will not in general stay the trial of the issues of fact pending the appeal. In dismissing the application to stay the proceedings pending an appeal to the House of Lords, Cotton L.J, observed as follows:—
“No doubt the House of Lords may take a different view, but that is no reason for depriving the applicants of what is their right. They wish to go on with the proceedings, and this court has decided that they have a right to do so, and the mere fact of extra costs being incurred, which may be useless if the House of Lords decide in favour of the appeal, is no sufficient reason for restraining them.
5. Secondly, it is obvious that even if a particular practice has been established it cannot be countenanced by the court if it is contrary to the express provisions of law. Rule 5 of Order XLI of the Civil Procedure Code declares in unambiguous language that an appeal shall not operate as a stay of proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except so far as the appellate court may order. The use of the word ‘may’ confers a discretion on the court to stay or not to stay proceedings and it is idle to suggest that this discretion must always be exercised in favour of the appellant.
6. Thirdly, it is unreasonable that save in exceptional circumstances an unsuccessful litigant should be permitted to protract the litigation by requiring that accounts should not be taken until after the appeal has been heard and decided.
7. Fourthly, the matter is one of discretion and the High Court can interfere only if the court below has acted on wrong principles.
8. It may be that, as contended by Mr. Mahajan, the appeal is likely to succeed, but the mere fact that there are strong grounds for the appeal would not justify an order of stay. A person is expected to prefer an appeal only when there are strong reasons for doing so.
9. For these reasons, I would uphold the order of the learned District Judge to the extent that the Commissioner appointed by the Court to examine the accounts of the parties should continue to examine the accounts and to submit his report thereon. No final decree will, however be passed in the case until the appeal preferred against the preliminary decree has been heard and decided. The learned District Judge should endeavour to deal with this appeal as quickly as possible. The parties have been directed to appear before the Commissioner on Monday the 26th April, 1954.
10. Order accordingly.
Alert