Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mst. Santi, v. Sudh Ram And Others,

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jun 15, 1954
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Judicial Opinion — Regular First Appeal No. 195 of 1951

Factual and Procedural Background

Shrimati Santi instituted Civil Suit No. 147 of 1948 (filed 1 April 1948) claiming possession of shop No. 148 in Bartanganj, Moga Mandi, and recovery of Rs. 2,400 as arrears of maintenance for the past year. Alternatively she sought maintenance at Rs. 200 per mensem for life and a charge on shop No. 148 for payment of that maintenance.

The defendants resisted the suit and several factual and legal issues were framed. The Court of first instance made findings on the composition of the family, the character of the shop (joint family property), the validity and effect of certain documents (a memorandum Exhibit P.17, a mortgage Exhibit D.1 and a Will Exhibit D.2), and as to the plaintiffs' entitlement to maintenance and a charge on the shop. The trial court dismissed the plaintiff's suit insofar as possession of the shop was concerned, but awarded maintenance at Rs. 40 per mensem, granted a decree for Rs. 480 as arrears, and charged future maintenance on the shop subject to the existing mortgage (Exhibit D.1).

From that decree Shrimati Santi appealed under section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure; the defendants filed cross-objections. This order disposes of Regular First Appeal No. 195 of 1951 and the cross-objections arising therefrom.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Was Budh Ram not a member of the joint Hindu family of the defendants at the time of his death?
  2. Is the shop in dispute joint family property?
  3. Did Ganga Ram create a charge on the shop for the maintenance and residence of the plaintiff?
  4. What is the amount of the maintenance due to the plaintiff per mensem?
  5. Is the plaintiff entitled to a charge for that maintenance on the shop in suit and is she entitled to residence in the shop?
  6. Is the plaintiff entitled to arrears of maintenance and at what rate?
  7. Did Ganga Ram execute a Will and a mortgage with regard to the shop in dispute?
  8. Can the plaintiff challenge the Will and the mortgage?
  9. If so, were the Will and the mortgage valid so as to defeat the right of the plaintiff for maintenance and residence?
  10. Are the defendants liable for payment of maintenance to the plaintiff, if issue No. 1 is proved and issue No. 2 not proved?
  11. Otherwise are the defendants not liable for the payment of the plaintiff's maintenance?
  12. Was the Will made when he was of sound disposing mind?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff-Appellant's Arguments (as recorded)

  • That the Court of first instance erred in dismissing the plaintiff's claim for possession of shop No. 148.
  • Reliance was placed on memorandum Exhibit P.17 (dated 4 June 1925) to establish the plaintiff's right to possession and residence; the memorandum allegedly showed an interest or right in the shop.
  • That Exhibit P.17 should be admissible notwithstanding registration requirements, invoking Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • That the maintenance awarded (Rs. 40 per mensem) was inadequate.
  • That the court-fee payable on the plaint could not be made a first charge on the amount of future maintenance; reliance was placed on Section 60(1)(n) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • That the court-fee had been incorrectly assessed in the decree and should be fixed at Rs. 1,680 (being the fee payable on the relief that carries the highest court-fee in the plaint).

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific arguments advanced by the defendants beyond noting that they cross-objected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sailendra Nath v. Hade Kaza, AIR 1932 Cal 356 Assignment of future rents (i.e., benefits to arise out of land) amounts to an interest requiring registration under the Registration Act (Registration Act, s.2(e)); registration of assignment of future rents is compulsory. Used to support the conclusion that memorandum Exhibit P.17, which purports to declare the plaintiff's future interest, required registration and so was not admissible without registration.
Bai Parsan v. Lallunbi Vandra-bandas, AIR 1932 Bom 217 Deeds purporting to bestow residence or food from house rent are declarations of future interest and prima facie require registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act. Relied on to characterise Exhibit P.17 as declaring a future interest (residence/entitlement from rent) thus necessitating registration for admissibility.
Mt. Dan Kuer v. Mt. Sarla Devi, AIR 1947 PC 8 (per M. R. Jayakar) Explains the interplay under Hindu law between (1) obligations to pay binding debts of the family and (2) moral/legal obligation to provide maintenance to widows; where maintenance assumes the shape of a charge it takes precedence; this rule accords with the principle underlying Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act. Quoted to explain the scope of Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act and to situate the plaintiff's claim to enforce maintenance against transferees or family members.
Somasundaram Chetty v. Unnamalai Ammal, AIR 1920 Mad 722 Authority cited in support of the Hindu law principle discussed with respect to maintenance and priority among obligations (as illustrative of the principle underlying Section 39). Referenced to support the explanation of how a maintenance charge, if created, takes precedence under the rule aligned with Section 39.
Mangalaswami v. Subbiah Pillai, 34 Mad 64 Authority referenced for the proposition that assignment of future rents requires registration. Cited parenthetically in support of the principle that assignments of future rents are registrable, thereby reinforcing the treatment of Exhibit P.17 as requiring registration.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the admissibility and legal effect of memorandum Exhibit P.17 and the plaintiff's entitlement to maintenance and its charge on the property by reference to statutory and decided-law principles recorded in the evidence and submissions.

1. Characterisation and registration of Exhibit P.17:

  • The court examined Exhibit P.17 and concluded that it "purports to declare what the interest of the plaintiff in the shop is to be in future" (para 12).
  • Relying on authorities (Sailendra Nath and Bai Parsan) stating that instruments declaring future interests (including assignments of future rents or grants of residence from rent) prima facie require registration, the court held registration of Exhibit P.17 was compulsory (paras 10–11, 12).
  • Accordingly, Exhibit P.17 was held not to be admissible in evidence for want of registration (para 14), and the court confirmed the trial court's finding on issue No. 3 (that no charge was created by Ganga Ram for the plaintiff's maintenance on shop No. 148).

2. Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act:

  • The plaintiff-appellant invoked Section 53A to argue Exhibit P.17 was admissible notwithstanding registration requirements. The court noted that Section 53A's protection is available only to a defendant (i.e., to protect possession), and not generally to validate unregistered instruments that create future interests (para 13).
  • Because Exhibit P.17 was not registered and did not bring the plaintiff's case within the scope of Section 53A, Section 53A could not cure admissibility defects (para 13, 18).

3. Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act and the plaintiff's ability to enforce maintenance against transferees:

  • The court considered the argument that certain defendants, being parties to a family partition, were liable under the principle underlying Section 39. The court set out the statutory provision (para 16) and quoted the Privy Council explanation (Dan Kuer) of the Hindu law background and the alignment with Section 39 (para 42–44).
  • Because Exhibit P.17 was inadmissible for want of registration, the plaintiff had failed to bring her case within Section 39 (para 18); thus enforcement against transferees or certain defendants under that section could not be sustained on the basis of Exhibit P.17.

4. Quantum of maintenance:

  • The court described the factors to be considered in fixing maintenance: value of estate (with debts), position and status of husband and widow, reasonable wants of the widow (including religious and station-related expenses), and past relations (para 20).
  • The trial court had found the total value of the joint family property in 1926 did not exceed Rs. 40,000 (para 21), and the appellate court found on the evidence that the maintenance fixed (Rs. 40 per mensem) was adequate (para 22).

5. Court-fee assessment and priority of court-fee charge:

  • The plaintiff contended the court-fee payable on the plaint could not be made a first charge on future maintenance, relying on Section 60(1)(n) of the Code of Civil Procedure (para 23).
  • The court observed that Section 60(1)(n) exempts "right to future maintenance" from attachment and sale in execution of a decree but does not control provisions of Rule 10 of Order XXXIII of the Code of Civil Procedure (para 24).
  • On the correct assessment of court-fee, because the plaint claimed alternative reliefs and the relief carrying the highest court-fee determines the fee payable, the court found the court-fee payable on the plaint to be Rs. 1,680 (para 26) rather than Rs. 2,972-8 as assessed in the decree under appeal (para 27).

6. Disposition on other points:

  • The court confirmed the trial court's material findings (membership of Budh Ram in the joint family; the shop being joint family property; validity of the mortgage Exhibit D.1; that neither the Will nor the mortgage were executed to defeat the plaintiff's rights; plaintiff's right to challenge the Will and mortgage; and awarding maintenance including arrears) as recorded by the trial court (paras 16–26 and 4).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

I allow the appeal by directing the amendment of the decree under appeal so far as the Court-fee payable on the plaint is concerned. In all other respects the appeal falls and is dismissed. (para 28)

Direct consequences and practical implications for the parties:

  • The decree under appeal is affirmed on the merits except insofar as it assessed the court-fee; the court orders amendment to reflect the correct court-fee payable on the plaint as Rs. 1,680 (paras 27–28).
  • The plaintiff's broader claims to possession based on Exhibit P.17 fail for want of registration; therefore Exhibit P.17 was not admitted and did not create a charge in the plaintiff's favour (paras 12–14, 18).
  • The trial court's award of maintenance (Rs. 40 per mensem) and decree for Rs. 480 as arrears, with future maintenance charged on the shop subject to the mortgage, is maintained (paras 5, 22, 27–28).
  • Cross-objections filed by the defendants are dismissed (para 29).
  • Each party is to bear their own costs in the appeal and cross-objections (para 30).

Broader legal precedent: The opinion applies existing principles (registration requirements for instruments purporting to create future rights; the limited scope of Section 53A; statutory and Hindu-law background to Section 39) to the facts of the case. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle; it applies settled authorities to conclude Exhibit P.17 was inadmissible for want of registration and to resolve the other disputes.

Judgment delivered by: Khosla, J. (with concurrence noted at paragraph 31).

Show all summary ...

1. By this order I dispose of Regular First appeal no. 195 of 1951 and the cross-objections arising therefrom.

2. Shrimati Santi instituted Civil Suit No. 147 of 1948 on the 1st of April, 1948. In that suit Shrimati Santi claimed possession of shop No. 148 situate in Bartanganj, Moga Mandi, and for the recovery of rupees 2,400/- on account of arrears of maintenance for the past year. In the alternative Shrimati Santi claimed in that suit maintenance at the rate of rupees 200/- per mensem for life and a charge on shop No. 148 for the -payment of that maintenance.

3. In resisting the suit the defendants raised pleas which gave rise to the following issues on merits:

"1. Was Budh Rani not a member of the joint Hindu family of the defendants at the time of his death?

2. Is the shop in dispute joint family property?

3. Did Ganga Ram create a charge on the shop for the maintenance and residence of the plaintiff?

4. What is the amount of the maintenance due to the plaintiff per mensem?

5. Is the plaintiff erxtitled to a charge for that maintenance on the shop in suit and is she entitled to residence in the shop?

6. Is the plaintiff entitled to arrears of maintenance and at what rate?

7. Did Ganga Ram execute a Will and a mortgage with regard to the shop in dispute?

8. Can the plaintiff challenge the Will and the mortgage?

9. If so, were the Will and the mortgage valid so as to defeat the right of the plaintiff for maintenance and residence?

10. Are the defendants liable for payment of maintenance to the. plaintiff, if issue No. 1 is proved and issue No. 2 not proved?

11. Otherwise are the defendants not liable for the payment of the plaintiff's maintenance?

12. Was the Will made when he was of sound disposing mind?"

4. In deciding civil suit No. 147 of 1948 the Court of first instance has found:

(a) that Budh Ram was member of the joint Hindu family at the time of his death;

(b) that the shop in dispute was joint family property;

(c) that Ganga Ram had not created any charge for the plaintiffs maintenance on shop No. 148;

(d) that the maintenance fixed for the plain-, tiff should be a charge on shop No. 148;

(e) that the sum of rupees 480/- was payable to the plaintiff on account of arrears of maintenance;

(f) that the sum of rupees 480/- payable to the plaintiff on account of arrears of maintenance;

(g) that in view of the admission of the defendants that they were liable to maintain the plaintiff it was not necessary to give a finding whether the will, Exhibit D. 2, was made by Ganga Ram when he was of sound disposing mind;

(h) that the plaintiff has right to challenge the factum and validity of the Will and the mortgage;

(i) that the mortgage deed, Exhibit D. 1, was valid and binding; and

(j) that neither the Will nor the mortgage were effected with the intent on to defeat the plaintiff's right of maintenance or residence.

5. In dismissing the plaintiff's suit with regard to the possession of the shop the Court of first Instance has awarded maintenance to the plaintiff at rupees 40/- per mensem and granted her decree for rupees 480 on account of arrears of maintenance charging future maintenance on the shop in suit. In the decree it is stated that the charge of Shrimati Santi on the shop would be subject to the mortgage, Exhibit D. 1 made by Ganga Ram.

6. From the decree passed in civil suit No. 147 of 194S Shrimati Santi appeals under section 96 of the Code of civil Procedure while the "defendants cross-object.

7. In order to appreciate the points that arise for decision, it is necessary to set out the pedigree-table of the parties. That pedigree-table is as under:

GANGA RAM ________________________|_______________________ | | | | Budh Ram = Sudh Ram Bansi Ram Kanshi Ram (Defdt. No. 1) (Defdt. No. 2) (Defdt. No. 3) Mst. Santi | | widow | | _____________|_______ | | | | Banarsi Das Lal Chand | Defdt. 4 Defdt. 5 | __________________|_____________ | | | Nauhria Mal Lahori Mal Kehar Chand minor (Defdt. 6) (Defdt. 7) (Defdt. 8)

8. Mr. Madan Lal Sethi appearing for the plaintiff-appellant urges that the Court of first instance was in error in dismissing the suit of the plaintiff for possession of shop No. 148. In arguments reliance is placed on the memorandum, Exhibit P. 17, made on the 4th of June 1925, by Ganga Ram.

9. Now, the memoradum, Exhibit P. 17, so far as material to the question that arises for decision in Regular First Appeal No. 195 of 1951 reads:

"I and Mussummat Santi, widow of Budh Ram shall remain in possession of shop No. 148, situate in Moga Mandi, in equal shares. After my and Mt. Santi's death, it shall be jointly owned by the three brothers, namely, Sudh Ram, Bansi Ram and Kanshi Ram. When any one of us dies, the other shall receive the rent. The brothers shall not hold any share therein till any one of us remains alive."

10. In -- 'Sailendra Nath v. Hade Kaza', AIR 1932 Cal 356 (A), Mukherji and Guha JJ. said:

"Immovable property as defined in the Registration Act, Section 2, Clause (e) includes "any other benefit to arise out of land. The assignment of future rents, that is to say, of rents to arise in future and not of rents which had already accrued due: see -- 'Mangalaswaml v. Subbiah Pillar, 34 Mad 64 (B), and consequently registration of the assignment was compulsory."

11. In -- 'Bai Parsan v. Lallunbi Vandra-bandas', AIR 1932 Bom 217 (C), Beaumont C. J. (Nanavati J. concurring) said;

"That a deed purporting to bestow residence in the house and food from the rent of the house is not a declaration of an existing right of a person in respect of that house but a declaration of what his interest in that house is to be in future and therefore prima, facie it requires registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act"
.

12. In plain words, memorandum, Exhibit p. 17, purports to declare what the interest of the plaintiff in the shop is to be in future. If so, registration of the memorandum. Exhibit P. 17, was compulsory.

13. Mr. Madan Lal Sethi basing himself on the provisions of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, then urges that the memorandum, Exhibit P. 17, was admissible in evidence notwithstanding that the document was required to be registered. From a perusal of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act it is plain that the right conferred by that section is only available to a defendant to protect his possession.

14. Finding as I do, that the memorandum, Exhibit P. 17, was not admissible in evidence for want of registration I confirm the finding given by the Court of first instance on issue No. 3

15. Then it is said that defendants No. 1, a and 5 being parties to the family partition the right of maintenance of Shrimati Santi was enforceable against them on the principle underlying Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act.

16. Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act provides 'inter alia' that where a third person has a right to receive maintenance from the profits of immovable property, and such property is transferred, the right may be enforced against the transferee, if he has notice thereof or if the transfer is gratuitous; but not against a transferee for consideration and without notice of the right, nor against such property in his hands.

17. In explaining the scope of Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act Mr. M. R. Jayakar said In -- 'Mt. Dan Kuer v. Mt. Sarla Devi', AIR 1947 PC 8 (D), at page 14:

"The true rule of Hindu Law in such matters would appear to be as follows:

Two obligations confront a joint Hindu family (1) the obligation to pay the debts (for instance, of the father) binding on the family; and (2) the moral obligation to provide maintenance to the widows of the family. The latter obligation would, under certain circumstances, ripen into a legal obligation, as, for instance, when a charge is created on specific property of the family either by agreement or a decree of the Court; that, so long as neither of these two obligations has taken the form of a charge on the family property, the obligation to pay the binding debts will have precedence (as for Instance, in the course of the administration of the estate) over mere claims of a female member's maintenance; but, if either of these two obligations assumes the shape of a charge, it would take precedence over the other. This rule of Hindu Law is thus in accord with the principle underlying Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act: See -- 'Somasundaram Chetty v. Unnamalai Ammal', AIR 1920 Mad 722

18. For the reasons given hereinbefore, I have found that the memorandum, Exhibit P. 17, is not admissible in evidence for want of registration. If so, the plaintiff has failed to bring the case within Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act.

19. Again it is said that the amount of maintenance was much too inadequate.

20. In determining the amount of maintenance, the Court proceeds on the following circumstances:

(1) the value of the estate, taking the debts for which it is liable also into consideration;

(2) the position and status of the deceased husband and of the widow;

(3) the reasonable wants of the widow including not only the ordinary expenses of living but what she might reasonably expend for religious and other due duties incident to her station in life; and (4) the past relations between her and her husband.

21. In fixing maintenance the Court was of the opinion that in 1926 the total value of the joint family property was not more than rupees 40,000/-. That finding is not challenged in appeal.

22. (After discussing the evidence on this point His Lordship proceeded). On the evidence given in Civil Suit No. 147 of 1948 I find that th maintenance fixed is adequate.

23. Mr. Madan Lal Sethi urges that the court fee payable on the plaint cannot be first charge on the amount of future maintenance. In this connection reliance is placed on the provisions of Section 60(1)(n) of the Code of Civil Procedure.

24. Section 60(1)(n) of the Code of Civil Procedure exempts 'right to future maintenance' from attachment and sale in execution of a decree. In the recovery of court-fee from the subject-matter of the suit the judgment-debtors have no interest. Plainly, Section 60(1)(n) of the Code of Civil Procedure does not control the provisions of Rule 10 of Order XXXIII of the Code, of Civil Procedure.

25. In closing the arguments Mr. Madan Lal Sethi points out that the court-fee payable on the plaint has not been correctly assessed.

26. In the plaint maintenance at the rate oil rupees 200/- per mensem was claimed in the alternative. If so, court-fee was payable on the relief for the possession of the shop which was valued at rupees 30,000/- and not on the sum of rupees 2,4007- claimed on account of arrears of maintenance for one year. Indisputably, in a suit where reliefs are claimed in the alternative the court-fee is payable in respect of the relief which carries the highest court-fee. In these proceedings it is common ground that the court-fee payable on the plaint was rupees 1680/-.

27. For the foregoing reasons. I maintain the judgment and decree under appeal on merits. In the matter of court-fee I find that the court-fee payable on the plaint was rupees 1,680/- and nob rupees 2,972/8/- as assessed in the decree under appeal.

28. In the result I allow the appeal by directing the amendment of the decree under appeal so far as the Court-fee payable on the plaint is concerned. In all other respects the appeal falls and is dismissed.

29. Cross-objecions preferred by the defendants Jail and are dismissed.

30. Parties are left to bear their own costs in Regular First Appeal No. 195-51 and the cross-objection arising therefrom.

Khosla, J.

31. I agree.