- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Nath v. Bashir-Ud-Din
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute arose between neighbouring landowners. The defendant owned a wall separating contiguous properties. On 19-9-1946 the defendant sent a registered notice to the plaintiff complaining that the plaintiff's piling of bricks and building materials against the wall endangered its safety and warning the plaintiff of liability for any resulting damage. The plaintiff ignored the notice. On the night of 4-10-1946 the wall collapsed, damaging a tenant's printing press. The defendant reported the incident to the police and on 10-1-1947 lodged a formal complaint alleging, inter alia, intentional piling of materials to demolish the wall and theft of the defendant's wall materials, and sought action under Sections 427 and 379, Penal Code. The accused were discharged by the trial Court under Section 253, Criminal P.C., on 31-7-1947, the trial Court finding guilt not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
On 13-11-1947 the plaintiff sued the defendant for Rs. 10,000 as damages for malicious prosecution, alleging that the criminal complaint was malicious and without reasonable or probable cause. The trial Court dismissed the civil suit with costs. The plaintiff appealed to the Court whose opinion is summarized here.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court below was justified in dismissing the plaintiff's suit for damages for malicious prosecution on the ground that the prosecution was not inspired by malice and was not destitute of any reasonable or probable cause.
- Whether different counts of the original criminal complaint (specifically the charges under Section 427 and Section 379, Penal Code) must be treated separately for the purposes of determining reasonable and probable cause and malice, and if so, whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages in respect of any charge that was malicious and without reasonable or probable cause.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The defendant maliciously and without reasonable and probable cause lodged a false complaint against the plaintiff and his munim, seeking to damage the plaintiff's reputation and obtain damages of Rs. 10,000 (para 4).
- The theft charge under Section 379 was particularly serious, involved moral turpitude and was aimed at attacking the plaintiff's reputation; it was improbable that the plaintiff (described as a respectable taxpayer and landowner) would have stolen a few bricks (para 8).
- The allegation of theft was absent from the initial police report dated 5-10-1946 and appeared for the first time only in the formal complaint before the Magistrate on 10-1-1947, indicating that the theft charge lacked reasonable and probable cause (para 8).
Defendant's Arguments
- The defendant contended that he honestly believed an offence under Section 427, Penal Code, had been committed by the plaintiff — piling materials against the wall and damaging it — and therefore had reasonable and probable cause to prosecute (paras 2, 6, 7).
- In deposition, the defendant stated that one object of instituting the criminal complaint was to compel the plaintiff to reconstruct the wall demolished by acts of the plaintiff's servants; the defendant relied on his belief in the offence rather than an improper motive (para 7).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Brown v. Hawkes, (1891) 2 QB 718 at p. 722 | Definition and explanation of malice in malicious prosecution: malice may be shown by a wrong or indirect motive, or inferred from circumstances where prosecution can only be accounted for by imputing such a motive. | The Court quoted the passage to explain the nature of malice and to state that malice may be inferred from circumstances, but that malice alone is insufficient without want of probable cause (para 6). |
| Reed v. Taylor, (1812) 128 E. R. 472 | Principle that if an indictment contains several charges and some are preferred maliciously and without probable cause, the plaintiff may recover for those charges even if others had probable cause. | The Court cited this case to support the proposition that where some charges were without probable cause but others had probable cause, the plaintiff may obtain a decree for those charges lacking probable cause (para 9). |
| Ellis v. Abrahams, (1846) 2 Q. B. 709 | Where an indictment contains multiple assignments, the plaintiff cannot be prevented from relying on one assignment proved maliciously and without probable cause by showing reasonable cause for another assignment not relied upon. | The Court relied on this authority to justify treating individual charges separately and to deny the defendant the benefit of reasonable cause for other counts where the plaintiff confines the action to the malicious counts (para 10). |
| Delisser v. Towne, (1841) 1 Q. B. 333 | Illustrates that when multiple assignments are charged and the plaintiff proves want of probable cause as to some counts but not others, recovery may be limited and costs allocated accordingly. | The Court cited it to show the approach to costs and recovery when only some assignments are proved to lack probable cause (para 11). |
| Boaler v. Holder, (1887) 3 T. L. R. 546 | Authority that a conviction (or different procedural disposition) on one count does not necessarily bar an action for malicious prosecution on another count improperly preferred. | The Court referred to this case to support the principle that different charges must be considered separately for malicious prosecution purposes (para 11). |
| Palmer v. Birmingham Manufacturing Co, (1902) 18 T. L. R. 552 | Where an indictment alleges stealing multiple articles, absence of reasonable and probable cause as to some articles permits an action for malicious prosecution on proof of malice. | The Court used this case to reinforce the view that if reasonable cause was absent for some parts of an indictment, an action for malicious prosecution can succeed as to those parts (para 11). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by stating the well-established elements necessary in an action for malicious prosecution: (1) previous proceedings commenced or continued without reasonable and probable cause, (2) with malice, and (3) which terminated in the plaintiff's favour (para 5). The Court defined reasonable and probable cause as reasonable grounds for suspicion supported by circumstances sufficiently strong to warrant an ordinary prudent and cautious person in believing the accused probably guilty. The Court also explained that malice denotes an improper or wrongful motive to use legal process for an inappropriate purpose and quoted Brown v. Hawkes on how malice may be inferred (para 6).
Applying these principles to the facts, the Court divided the analysis by the two criminal charges:
- Section 427, Penal Code (wilful damage): The Court found ample factual basis for concluding that the defendant honestly believed there was reasonable and probable cause to prosecute under Section 427. The Court relied on the sequence of events: earlier mortgage dispute and eviction, construction of the wall by the defendant after eviction, the plaintiff's objection and claim that wall encroached, the plaintiff's collection and piling of building materials adjacent to the defendant's nine-foot wall, the defendant's registered notice to remove the materials, the plaintiff's ignoring of the notice, and the wall's subsequent collapse. Given these circumstances, the Court held the defendant had an honest belief in the commission of an offence and therefore reasonable and probable cause existed as to the Section 427 charge (paras 6–7).
- The defendant's deposition that he also sought to compel reconstruction of the wall: The Court addressed the plaintiff's contention that this collateral objective made the prosecution malicious. It rejected that contention, reasoning that a motive to secure reconstruction is not necessarily improper if the prosecutor honestly believed an offence had been committed; pursuing a civil remedy instead would not, by itself, render a prosecution malicious where reasonable cause existed (para 7).
- Section 379, Penal Code (theft): The Court analyzed whether the theft allegation was supported by reasonable and probable cause. It observed that the theft accusation first appeared in the formal complaint to the Magistrate and had not been included in the earlier police report; the record contained no indication that the plaintiff had committed theft or appropriated the defendant's materials to his own use. Given the absence of evidence or circumstances to support a belief in theft, the Court found the defendant acted maliciously and without reasonable and probable cause in preferring the theft charge (para 8).
The Court then applied established authorities (Reed v. Taylor and others) to the situation where some charges in the original proceedings have probable cause and others do not, holding that a plaintiff may recover in respect of those charges which were preferred maliciously and without probable cause (paras 9–11).
On the quantum of damages, the Court observed that no special damages were proved and the plaintiff did not specify reputational or additional pecuniary loss arising uniquely from the theft allegation; moreover, the plaintiff had to defend the Section 427 charge (for which reasonable cause existed). Considering these factors, the Court concluded nominal damages would meet the ends of justice (para 10–12).
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Court held that liability for malicious prosecution existed in part and awarded nominal damages. Specifically, the Court found that:
- The dismissal of the plaintiff's suit by the Court below was justified so far as the Section 427 charge was concerned — the prosecution under Section 427 was not malicious and was supported by reasonable and probable cause (paras 6–7).
- The prosecution was malicious and without reasonable and probable cause in respect of the charge under Section 379 (theft); accordingly, the plaintiff was entitled to a decree in respect of that charge (para 8).
- In respect of relief, the Court awarded nominal damages of Re. 1/- to the plaintiff for the false theft accusation and ordered that the parties bear their own costs (para 12).
Implications: The direct effect is a split judgment on the plaintiff's malicious prosecution claim — the claim failed as to the wilful-damage charge (Section 427) but succeeded in respect of the theft charge (Section 379), with only nominal damages awarded because no special damage was proved. The Court applied established authorities to treat separate counts discretely for the purposes of reasonable and probable cause and malice. The opinion did not purport to establish any broader new legal principle beyond applying existing case law to these facts.
Opinion Authorship and Concurrence
The opinion includes the name Weston, C.J. at the end of the judgment (para 13), followed by a short note "I agree" (para 14), indicating concurrence by another judge whose name is not given in the provided text.
1. The short point for decision in the present case is whether the Court below was justified in dismissing the plaintiff's suit for damages for malicious prosecution on the ground that the prosecution was not inspired by malice and was not destitute of any reasonable or probable cause.
2. The parties to the litigation out of which this appeal has arisen are owners of two contiguous properties which were separated by a wall belonging to the defendant. On 19-9-1946 the defendant sent a registered notice to the plaintiff in which he complained that the plaintiff was endangering the safety of his wall by piling up bricks and other building materials against the wall and warned him that if his property sustained damage by reason of any act done by him, his agents or his labourers, the plaintiff would be held responsible for any loss that may be caused.
3. The plaintiff paid no heed to this notice and at 10 O'clock on the night of 4-10-1946 the wall came down all of a sudden causing a certain amount of damage to a printing press which a tenant of the defendant had set up near the wall. The defendant reported the matter to the Police on the following day and filed a regular complaint on 10-1-1947, in this complaint he alleged that both the plaintiff and his 'munim' Mithan Lal had intentionally and mischievously piled up a large quantity of building material against the wall with the object of demolishing the wall and encroaching upon the land belonging to the defendant and that they had stolen the materials of the complainant's wall and brought the same to their own use. It was accordingly prayed that action be taken against them under Sections 427 and 379, Penal Code. The trial Court came to the conclusion that the guilt had not been brought home to the accused beyond reasonable doubt and ordered their discharge under Section 253, Criminal P. C. This was on 31-7-1947.
4. On 13-11-1947 the plaintiff brought the present action for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 10,000/- by way of damages from the defendant on the ground that the latter had maliciously and without reasonable and probable cause brought a false complaint against him and his 'munim' Mithan Lal. The trial Court dismissed the suit with costs and the plaintiff has accordingly come to this Court in appeal.
5. The essential ingredients of an action for damages for malicious prosecution are well known and well understood. A person who wishes to recover damages to person, property or reputation must establish that he sustained injury by reason of previous proceeding which was commenced or continued without reasonable and probable cause, but with malice, and which has terminated in favour of the plaintiff. These elements must all unite in order to produce liability. Reasonable and probable cause may be defined to mean reasonable grounds for suspicion supported lay circumstances sufficiently strong in themselves to warrant any ordinary prudent and cautious man in the belief that the person charged with the crime was probably guilty of the offence with which he is charged. There can be no reasonable and probable cause unless the defendant genuinely and honestly believed that the prosecution, or other proceeding complained of, was justifiable. Malice means the presence of some improper and wrongful motive that is to say, an intent to use the legal process in question for some other than its legally appointed and appropriate purpose.
As pointed out by Cave, J., in --'Brown v. Hawkes', (1891) 2 QB 718 at p. 722,
"malice in its widest and vaguest sense has been said to mean any wrong or indirect motive; and malice can be proved, either by showing what the motive was and that it was wrong, or by showing that the circumstances were such that the prosecution can only be accounted for by imputing some wrong or indirect motive to the prosecutor."The co-existence of malice and want of probable cause is an essential prerequisite to the success of an action for malicious prosecution. Malice alone, however great, is insufficient. Want of probable cause cannot be inferred from malice, however great such malice may be, but malice may be implied or inferred as a fact from want of probable cause. The question is not what the actual facts were but what the defendant had reason to believe they were.
6. There can be no manner of doubt that the Court below was justified in dismissing the plaintiff's suit in so far as the charge under Section 427, Penal Code was concerned. It is common ground that the property belonging to the defendant was at one time mortgaged with the father of the plaintiff; that the plaintiff's father declined to surrender possession thereof even after the mortgage was redeemed; that the defendant was reluctantly compelled to seek the intervention of a Court of law and to secure his eviction; that after the eviction of the plaintiff's father the defendant promptly constructed a wall with the object of separating his own property from that of the plaintiff; that the plaintiff objected to the construction of the wall and stated that it had been constructed on a part of the land belonging to him; that while this dispute was in progress the plaintiff collected building material with the object of constructing some shops on the land belonging to himself; that he piled up this material against the defendant's wall which is said to have been about 9 feet high, 12 feet long and 9 inches wide; that the defendant sent a registered notice to the plaintiff asking him to remove the building material which was likely to damage the wall; that the plaintiff paid no heed to this notice and that the wall actually collapsed on the night of 4-10-1946. These circumstances make it quite clear that the defendant honestly believed that he had a reasonable & probable cause to put the criminal law in motion against the defendant.
7. During the course of arguments our attention was invited to the fact that in his deposition before the trial Court the defendant had stated that he had instituted the criminal complaint with the object of compelling the plaintiff to reconstruct the wall which had been demolished by the acts of his servants. It is contended on behalf of the plaintiff that as the defendant, set the machinery of law in motion not with the object of vindicating the law and securing the punishment of the offender but the collateral object of securing the reconstruction of the wall, the criminal proceedings must be deemed to be malicious. This argument appears to me to be wholly devoid of force. It seems to me that a motive on the part of the defendant to secure the reconstruction of the wall at the expense of the plaintiff cannot be regarded as improper if it is established, as has been established in the present case, that the had an honest belief that an offence under Section 427 had been committed. The defendant had a reasonable and probable cause for setting the criminal law in motion and the mere fact, therefore, that he might have pursued a civil remedy cannot render him liable for malicious prosecution.
8. But, even though the facts and circumstances of the case indicate that the prosecution was not malicious in so far as the charge under Section 427, Penal Code is concerned, the question arises whether the prosecution was malicious in so far as the charge under Section 379 is concerned. It is contended on behalf of the plaintiff that a charge under Section 379, Penal Code is more serious of the two charges preferred against him; that a prosecution under this section involves moral turpitude and was deliberately designed to attack the fair name of the plaintiff who is a respectable and respected citizen of Delhi; that it was impossible for the defendant to believe that the plaintiff, who was paying a large sum of money by way of income-tax and who was the owner of a considerable amount of landed property, could, have stooped so low as to steal a few bricks belonging to the defendant; that although the defendant notified the Police as early as 5-10-1946, he made no allegation in the report that any theft had been committed; that the allegation of theft was made for the first time when the complaint was lodged before the Magistrate on 10-1-1947 and that this scandalous accusation was made without a reasonable and probable cause. There is, in my opinion, considerable force in this argument for there is nothing on the record to indicate either that the plaintiff had committed theft or that he had appropriated material belonging to the defendant to his own use. It must, therefore, be held that in preferring the charge of theft against the plaintiff, the defendant acted maliciously and without a reasonable and probable cause.
9. In cases of this kind when the plaintiff is able to establish that there was no reasonable and probable cause for some of the charges preferred by the defendant in the original proceeding but that there may have been such cause for others, the Court ought to grant a decree to the plaintiff in respect of the charges for which there was no reasonable or probable cause. In -- 'Reed v. Taylor', (1812) 128 E. R. 472 (B), it was held that if the plaintiff declares that the defendant maliciously and without probable cause preferred an indictment, setting it forth, the averment is proved if some charges in the indictment were maliciously- and without probable cause preferred, although there was good ground for others of the charges preferred. A similar view was taken in -- 'Ellis v. Abrahams', (1846) 2 Q. B. 709 (C). It was held that in an action for malicious prosecution for perjury, where the indictment contains two assignments of perjury, if the plaintiff at the trial of the action confines his case to one of the assignments, the defendant is not entitled to prove that there was reasonable and probable cause for the charge contained in the other assignment.
In -- 'Delisser v. Towne', (1841) 1 Q. B. 333 (D), a declaration in case for a malicious prosecution for perjury, in one count, set out ten assignments of perjury, which were alleged to have been prosecuted maliciously and without probable cause; at the trial the plaintiff failed in proving want of probable cause as to nine of the assignments. He obtained a verdict with damages on the tenth assignment. It was held that he was not entitled to the costs of the witnesses called to give evidence of want of probable cause as to those nine; and the defendant was not entitled to the costs or witnesses subpoenaed by him to show probable cause as to those assignments. In -- Boaler v. Holder', (1887) 3 T. L. R. 546 (E), the plaintiff was indicted under Section 4, Libel Act. 1843, though committed for trial only under Section 5. He, therefore, brought an action for malicious prosecution. It was held that the conviction was no bar to an action for malicious prosecution under Section 4 of the Act. In --'Palmer v. Birmingham Manufacturing Co', (1902) 18 T. L. R. 552 (P), the plaintiff having been indicted in one count with having stolen a number of articles and having been acquitted, it was held that if there was an absence of reasonable and probable cause for the charge as regards one or more of the articles, an action for malicious prosecution will lie on proof of malice.
10. The question as to the amount of damages which the defendant should be required to pay for making a false accusation against the plaintiff under Section 379, Penal Code is not easy to determine. No special damage has been proved. The plaintiff has not been able to indicate the damage which has been caused to his reputation by reason of the charge under Section 379 having been preferred against him or to his property by reason of the expense which he was called upon to incur in securing his acquittal of that charge. As stated above, the complaint under Section 427, Penal Code was not destitute of reasonable or probable cause and it was necessary for him to defend himself in a Court of law. It has not been indicated whether he has incurred any additional expenditure in connection with the charge under Section 379 and if so, what. I am of the opinion that the ends of justice would be served if nominal damages to the extent of Re. 1/- are awarded in this case. The parties will bear their own costs throughout.
Weston, C.J.
11. I agree.
Alert