- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Sumitra Devi Petitioner, v. State Of Haryana .
G.R Majithia, J. — This is an application for grant of benefit of enhanced solatium as provided under Section 30(2) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, 1984 (for short, ‘the Act’).
2. The State of Haryana issued notification dated July 7, 1973 for acquiring 2206 acres of agricultural land situate in the Revenue Estate of Garhi Brahmnan and Patti Jatan, Sonepat for the construction of Mini Secretariat and residential quarters for the Government employees at Sonepat. The notification was followed by a declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act made vide notification dated December 24, 1973. The Deputy Commissioner, who was acting as a Land Acquisition Collector Sonepat, assessed the compensation vide his award No. 3. dated September 5, 1974. The claimant-landowners were not satisfied with the compensation awarded by the Collector and got references made to the Land Acquisition Court. The Land Acquisition Court announced the compensation vide order dated October 24, 1981. The claimants-landowners were still dissatisfied and they came to this Court in Regular First Appeal, which was disposed of on October 15, 1982. There was dispute with regard to the interpretation of Section 30(2) of the Act. The same was settled by the Supreme Court in Union of India and another v. Raghubir (dead) by Lrs. which is reported as Judgments Today 1989 (2) S.C 427 : (1989 (1) Recent Revenue Reports 552) and it was held thus:
“The expanded meaning given to Section 30(2) in the latter case does not, in our opinion, flow reasonably from the language of that sub-section. It seems to us that the learned Judges in that case missed, the significance of the word ‘such’ in the collocation ‘any such award’ in section 30(2). Due significance most be attached to that word, and to our mind, it must necessarily intend that the appeal to the High Court or the Supreme Court in which the benefit of the enhanced solatium is to be given, must be confined to an appeal against an award of the Collector or of the Court rendered between 30th April, 1982 and 24th September, 1984.”
3. It was settled that the benefit of Section 30(2) of the Act is applicable to orders made by the High Court or the Supreme Court in appeals against the awards made between April 30, 1982 and September 24, 1984. In the instant case, the Collector rendered the award on March 5, 1974 and the supplementary award on November 26, 1974. The Land Acquisition Court rendered the judgment on October 24, 1981. The award was not made between April 30, 1982 and September 24, 1984. Resultantly the applicant is not entitled to the benefit of the provisions of Section 30(2) of the Act.
The application is rejected.
Alert