- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Chairman, Bihar ... v. The Joint Secretary,...
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN SINHA)
Respondent No. 1 was dismissed from service on 28.01.2003, after a Departmental Proceeding. The Appeal preferred by him was rejected on 02.05.2003 The writ application has been allowed setting aside the order of dismissal, entitling respondent no. 1 to all consequential benefits. The learned Single Judge held that the Departmental Proceedings were not held in accordance with law for a major punishment. Respondent no. 1 was not given opportunity to examine the documents relied upon by the Enquiry Officer or lead evidence of his witnesses. No list of documents on which the charge was proposed to be proved was supplied to respondent no. 1 with the charge memo. It could not be said that the charge stood proved in absence of any evidence in support of the same. In view of the intervening superannuation of the respondent no. 1 the matter would not be remanded to proceed afresh from the stage of irregularity in the proceedings as Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules had not been adopted by the Appellant Board.
Three charges were framed against respondent no. 1 after he was suspended on 13.10.2000 The first charge stated that candidate Gopal Prasad with Code No. 7301, Serial No. 318 in the 1978 Supplementary Matriculation Examination had been issued, three separate mark - sheets with different marks after obtaining blank mark-sheets from the store. Charge No. 2 stated that the Tabulation Register which was a computerized chart was different on the relevant page in which the name of Gopal Prasad figured as compared to other candidates. His marks were mentioned as 614 in the 1st Division along with the 10th optional paper totaling to 659 which apparently was typed after erasing the original marks. Charge No. 3 stated that despite Tabulation Register being suspicious the respondent no. 1 issued mark sheets on 05.05.1991, 30.05.1991 and 18.09.1996 without expressing any suspicion, when it was apparent that there was overwriting of marks in the Tabulation register. It appeared to have been done in collusion with the student for illegal gain. The 4 Charge was for issuance of a passing certificate dated 30.05.1991 on basis of the aforesaid mark-sheets. The last charge was ultimately found attributable to another person with the same name as that of respondent no. 1. It, therefore, need not be the subject of consideration by us except with regard to what action may or may not have been taken against the concerned.
Learned counsel for the Appellant submitted that respondent no. 1 did not deny that he had issued the three mark-sheets. It is also not denied that the relevant page of the Tabulation Register in which the name of Gopal Prasad figured had been torn out and re-pasted as also that his marks bore erasing and overwriting. Respondent no. 1 in his written statement to the charges acknowledged that he had made a mistake in issuing the mark sheets urging a defence that others connected with the process did not raise objections also. The repeated issuance of three mark-sheets based on basis of the suspicious Tabulation Register without objecting, takes the conduct of respondent no. 1 beyond a mere error of judgment which may constitute an innocuous negligence. But if he issued three successive mark-sheets, acknowledging that the Tabulation Register was suspicious, without raising any objection, the level of negligence goes beyond a casual omission and has to be termed as callous or deliberate.
Once the charge stood admitted, any procedural irregularity in the conduct of the Departmental proceedings was inconsequential if not irrelevant as admitted charges need not be proved. Reliance was placed on (1996) 2 SCC 12 (Additional District Magistrate (City) v. Prabhakar Chaturvedi). No prejudice could be said to have been caused to respondent no. 1. The charges against him were all documentary in nature. Documents were evidence by themselves and were not required to be proved by any formal evidence.
The fact that any other may not have been proceeded with cannot be relevant in a situation where an employee acknowledges his own lapse, as then he stands in a class apart.
It was lastly submitted that the Appellant was fully empowered to invoke Rule 43(b) of the Pension Rules also which has not been properly considered. Since, we propose to dispose off this appeal on another short question of law, we open up the controversy whether the Appellant Board can invoke Rule 43(b) or not against its employees and leave it open for consideration in an appropriate case. The conclusion to that effect in the order under Appeal is read down as inter parties.
Counsel for the respondent no. 1 submitted that there are no allegations against the respondent no. 1 with regard to tearing, pasting or interpolation of marks in the Tabulation register. There are no allegations for having obtained blank mark-sheets on three occasions in an improper manner. Respondent no. 1 simply issued the mark-sheets on basis of the entries in the Tabulation Register. According to procedures, the mark-sheet passed through more than one hand. No objections were raised at any stage. The Enquiry report itself stated that those who were associated with preparation and keeping of the Tabulation Register were clearly blame worthy and action should be taken against the then Section Officer (Records) and the concerned Assistant (OTR). It also mentions action against Jagdish Sah, the person who had issued the passing certificate on basis of the mark-sheets given by the petitioner. But to the best of the knowledge of respondent no. 1 no action whatsoever has been taken against any one of them. The culpability or misconduct was higher of the Section Officer and the concerned Assistant who have been let off. Respondent no. 1 has been made a scapegoat for the entire episode. Reliance was placed on (2007) 7 SCC 206 (Bongaigaon Refinery & Petrochemicals Ltd. v. Girish Chandra Sarma).
We have considered the submissions on behalf of the parties. In our opinion, once the respondent no. 1 acknowledged that the three mark-sheets were issued by him and that he did so on basis of a suspicious Tabulation Register taking a defence that there were others also through whose hands the documents had passed and they must also be answerable, he virtually admits the charge. Learned counsel for the Appellant has rightly urged relying on Prabhakar Chaturvedi (supra) that admitted charges need not be proved and any procedural impropriety in conduct of the Departmental Proceedings in such a case becomes irrelevant.
Furthermore, if respondent no. 1 had issued only one mark-sheet on basis of a suspicious Tabulation Register, acknowledged by him to be so, or protested at the time of issuance of the second certificate even, it may have been possible for us to hold that it was a mere error of judgment, constituting a negligence which may fall in the category of human error. But if he issued three mark-sheets consecutively with regard to the same student on basis of the same suspicious Tabulation Register, it does not remain in the realm of a bona fide error but assumes the nature of behaviour which takes it beyond simple human error. But at the same time we have to keep in mind that there has been no evidence against him that he did it with any ulterior motive much less for any illegal consideration.
Having observed so much to the detriment of the respondent no. 1, we would be failing in our duty if we did not appropriately take into consideration the objections raised on behalf of respondent no. 1 even on the aforesaid admitted facts. If there are more than one delinquent involved in a course of events, and the charges, evidence, against them are common, unless there be extenuating circumstances, even at the stage of punishment Article 14 would operate to maintain parity. But if in the same consequences of events, charges are more serious against some and lesser against others, to selectively punish those with lesser charges and let go those with more serious charges, especially when the act of the former was an outcome of the conduct of the latter, may assume issues of arbitrary discrimination.
The observation of the Enquiry Officer with regard to the conduct of the Section Officer (records) and the Assistant (OTR), undoubtedly pertained to the administrative realm. The appellants did not differ with the views of the enquiry officer and on the contrary accepted it by issuing show cause notice to the two. Thereafter the matter was permitted to go into oblivion of administrative domain never to see the light of the day. This conduct of the appellants is held to be arbitrary and discriminatory with regard to respondent no. 1.
Considering the importance of fairness in administrative action it has been observed in (2008) 12 SCC 331 (Man Singh v. State of Haryana) as follows;
“20. We may reiterate the settled position of law for the benefit of the administrative authorities that any act of the repository of power whether legislative or administrative or quasi-judicial is open to challenge if it is so arbitrary or unreasonable that no fair-minded authority could ever have made it. The concept of equality as enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution of India embraces the entire realm of State action. It would extend to an individual as well not only when he is discriminated against in the matter of exercise of right, but also in the matter of imposing liability upon him. Equals have to be treated equally even in the matter of executive or administrative action. As a matter of fact, the doctrine of equality is now turned as a synonym of fairness in the concept of justice and stands as the most accepted methodology of a governmental action. The administrative action is to be just on the test of “fair play” and reasonableness.”
Similarly in (2012) 1 SCC 157 (Sanchit Bansal v. Joint Admission Board) it has been observed:
“28. An action is said to be arbitrary and capricious, where a person, in particular, a person in authority does any action based on individual discretion by ignoring prescribed rules, procedure or law and the action or decision is founded on prejudice or preference rather than reason or fact. To be termed as arbitrary and capricious, the action must be illogical and whimsical, something without any reasonable explanation…”
We queried the counsel for the Appellant with regard to the action taken if any against the Section Officer (Records) and the then Assistant (OTR). Counsel for the Appellant fairly acknowledged from the counter affidavit that his instructions are limited to the issuance of a show cause notice to the concerned and he is unable to assist us on the issue whether any punishment was finally imposed much less the nature of the punishment. Likewise, even with regard to the other Jagdish Sah who is stated to have issued the School Matriculation Leaving Certificate based on mark-sheets which are issued after the stage for preparation of mark-sheet, learned counsel for the Appellant was again unable to inform us from the counter affidavit of any punishment given to him either.
That takes it beyond the pale of any controversy that in the transaction from the stage of interpolations in the Tabulation Register till issuance of the Matriculation certificate, respondent no. 1 was at an intermediary stage and no action has been taken against those indicted by the Enquiry Officer at the former stage with more serious allegations against them much less has any action being taken against the person whose duty figured after that of the respondent no. 1. Counsel for the respondent no. 1 has rightly relied upon Girish Chandra Sarma (supra) in support of the submission that he has been made out a scapegoat in the entire episode, observing as follows:
“18. After going through the report and the finding recorded by the Division Bench of the High Court, we are of opinion that in fact the Division Bench correctly assessed the situation that the respondent alone was made a scapegoat whereas the decision by all three Committees was unanimous decision by all these members participating in the negotiations and the price was finalized accordingly. It is not the respondent alone who can be held responsible when the decision was taken by the Committees. If the decision of the committee stinks, it cannot be said that the respondent alone stinks; it will be arbitrary. If all fish stink, to pick one and say only it stinks is unfair in the matter of unanimous decision of the Committee.
In conclusion for reasons discussed, we find no reason to interfere with the order under Appeal, but for different reasons.
The Appeal is dismissed.
Alert