- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The State Of Bihar T... v. The Finance Commissi...
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The State filed three Letters Patent Appeals to challenge the correctness and legality of a judgment and order by a learned Single Judge in Sunil Kumar v. State of Bihar (C.W.J.C No. 14243 of 2004) which was allowed on 13.10.2006. L.P.A. No. 234 of 2007 was filed directly against that judgment; the other two appeals arise from later Single Judge judgments adopting the same view.
The core factual matrix is that the writ petitioners (respondents in these appeals) appeared in a IIIrd Graduate Level Recruitment Examination and, after a common combined competitive examination, were appointed to various Class-III Graduate Level supervisory posts across 16 categories in different departments. At recruitment (and thereafter) these 16 posts were treated as equivalent and carried the same pay scale; allotment to particular services was done randomly rather than by merit-cum-choice because the posts carried identical pay at that time.
Subsequent pay revisions altered relative pay scales: the Fourth Pay Revision Committee (effective 01.04.1981) placed ten services at Rs. 850-1360 and six at a lower scale; a Pay Anomaly Removal Committee later remedied that for the six. The Fifth Pay Revision Committee (recommendation dated 15.12.1989, effective 01.01.1986) recommended Rs. 1600-2750 for ten services and Rs. 1500-2750 for the remaining six. Aggrieved employees obtained relief in Nagendra Sahani (C.W.J.C No. 8419 of 1992) by judgment dated 22.09.1993.
On account of demands for central pay-scale equivalence, the State constituted a Fitment Committee on 02.01.1998 to work out equivalence with central pay scales. The Fitment Committee report (08.02.1999) placed a majority of the 16 services (14 of them) in Rs. 5000-8000; some posts were placed at Rs. 4500-7000 or Rs. 5500-9000. An Aggrieved group approached the Fitment Appellate Committee (constituted 15.01.2000), which recommended a common pay scale of Rs. 5000-8000 for all 16 services on the ground that recruitment was from a common examination and allotment had been random. The State did not accept that recommendation, prompting several writ petitions (including the Sunil Kumar matter).
The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petitions on the basis that similarly situated persons recruited by the same combined examination and randomly allotted to the 16 services could not be discriminated against by placing some services in lower pay scales. The Single Judge relied on the Fitment Appellate Committee's recommendation and on the Division Bench judgment in Nagendra Sahani. The State appealed; the Division Bench (Shiva Kirti Singh & Hemant Kumar Srivastava, JJ.) heard these Letters Patent Appeals and related matters.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether employees appointed through a common combined competitive examination and randomly allotted to different posts that were previously treated as equivalent can be validly placed in different (unequal) pay scales by the State.
- Whether the State's effort to achieve equivalence with Central Pay Scales can justify classification that results in different pay scales for employees who were originally similarly situated.
- What remedy, if any, should be provided (including the appropriate common pay scale and effective dates) for employees found to have been discriminated against by differential pay-scale placement.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (State of Bihar) — Principal Arguments
- The Fitment Committee's terms of reference, driven by a demand for Central Pay Scale equivalence, required working out equivalence between State pay scales and the Central scales recommended by the Fifth Pay Commission; the process of fitment justified differential placement of some services.
- The terms contemplated that State employees who may be getting higher or lower pay scales should be granted appropriate equivalent central pay scales.
- The State pointed to the practice in Civil Services Examination where a common examination leads to allocation to different posts carrying different pay scales, suggesting differential pay is an established practice where selection/allocation mechanisms differ.
- Before the Division Bench, the State attempted to distinguish the Division Bench judgment in Nagendra Sahani on the ground that a fitment exercise to achieve central equivalence necessitated the classification adopted.
Respondents (Writ Petitioners) — Principal Contentions
- The writ petitioners were recruited through a common combined competitive examination and were allotted different posts randomly when the posts carried the same pay scale; therefore they constitute a single class of similarly situated employees and cannot be discriminated against by placing some of those posts in a lower pay scale.
- The Fitment Appellate Committee recommended a common pay scale of Rs. 5000-8000 for all 16 services on the ground that differential scales would result in persons with higher examination marks receiving lower pay through no fault of theirs.
- The petitioners relied on earlier judicial relief in Nagendra Sahani and on the Fitment Appellate Committee's recommendation to support uniform pay for the 16 services.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nagendra Sahani (C.W.J.C No. 8419 of 1992) — judgment dated 22.09.1993 | The principle that appointees belonging to a single class (recruited by a common examination and similarly placed at recruitment) are entitled to the same replacement / revised pay scale. | The Single Judge relied on this Division Bench judgment to support the conclusion that the 16 services form one class and cannot be subjected to discriminatory pay-scale classification; the Division Bench in the present appeals accepted that approach. |
| Sunil Kumar v. State of Bihar (C.W.J.C No. 14243 of 2004) — Single Judge judgment dated 13.10.2006 | The Single Judge's ruling that writ petitioners appointed through a common competitive examination could not be discriminated against by placing some among the 16 services in a lower pay scale; acceptance of the Fitment Appellate Committee's recommendation (subject to prospective application considerations). | The Division Bench agreed with the Single Judge's reasoning and affirmed the outcome, disposing of the appeals accordingly and giving directions about uniform pay scales and implementation dates. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Division Bench articulated a stepwise reasoning, grounded in the factual matrix and the legal principle of equal treatment of similarly situated persons:
- Fact-finding: The Court noted that the 16 services were originally treated as equivalent and had identical pay scales at the time of recruitment; appointments were made after a common combined competitive examination and allotment to services was random rather than on the basis of merit-cum-choice.
- On classification: The Court found that placing some of these equivalently treated posts into a lower pay scale post facto amounted to an impermissible classification and discrimination because similarly situated employees would suffer disadvantage through no fault of theirs.
- On the State's fitment justification: The Court accepted that the State had a legitimate task of finding equivalence with Central Pay Scales, but held that achieving central equivalence did not require—or justify—creating discriminatory pay-scale distinctions amongst persons who had been recruited and treated as equivalent. The Fitment Appellate Committee had specifically offered a non-discriminatory option (a common scale) which the State declined to adopt.
- Analogy rejected: The Court rejected the State's comparison with Civil Services examinations because, in that system, allocation to different posts is made on the basis of merit-cum-choice, which distinguishes it from the present facts where allotment had been random.
- Relief and temporal scope: Applying the above principles and relying on the Fitment Appellate Committee recommendation and the Single Judge judgment, the Court concluded that the writ petitioners (and similarly situated employees) must be given the same revised pay scale notionally from 01.01.1996 and with effect from 01.04.1997.
- Administrative implementation: The Court left determination of which common scale to adopt (Rs. 5000-8000 or Rs. 5500-9000) to the State Government, directing the State to make the selection judiciously within six months and to invite objections from those currently receiving the higher scale. If the State failed to act within six months, the writ petitioners and similarly situated employees would be entitled to the higher scale of Rs. 5500-9000 as provided by the writ court.
- Prospective option: The Court further noted that the State remains free to adopt the Fitment Appellate Committee’s approach of applying any new pay scales only prospectively for future appointments.
Holding and Implications
Primary Holding: The appeals were disposed of by the Division Bench in favor of the writ petitioners: the Court held that employees appointed through a common combined competitive examination and randomly allotted to posts that had been equivalent at recruitment cannot be validly discriminated against by placing some of those posts in a lower pay scale. The Court directed that those employees be given the same revised pay scale notionally from 01.01.1996 and effectively from 01.04.1997.
Remedial Directions and Immediate Consequences:
- The State Government must decide, within six months, which common pay scale to apply to all 16 services — either Rs. 5000-8000 or Rs. 5500-9000 — and may invite objections from incumbents who currently receive the higher scale. If the State fails to take a decision within six months, the writ petitioners and those similarly situated will be entitled to the higher pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000 as ordered by the writ court.
- The State may alternatively adopt the Fitment Appellate Committee’s recommendation to apply the suggested pay scales prospectively, i.e., for future appointments only.
- The appeals were disposed of accordingly and there was no order as to costs.
Broader implication: The Court's decision enforces the principle that administrative exercises (such as fitment for central equivalence) must not result in impermissible discrimination among employees who were similarly situated at recruitment. The opinion does not expressly state that it creates a new general precedent beyond the resolution of these cases; it affirms the Single Judge's and the Nagendra Sahani Division Bench's approach as applied to the facts before the Court.
Shiva Kirti Singh & Hemant Kumar Srivastava, JJ.
State has preferred these three Letters Patent Appeals to test the correctness and legality of judgment and order by learned Single Judge in the case of Sunil Kumar v. State of Bihar bearing C.W.J.C No. 14243 of 2004 allowed on 13.10.2006 Directly against that judgment is L.P.A No. 234 of 2007 whereas the other two appeals arise out of later judgments by learned Single Judges adopting the view taken in the case of Sunil Kumar (supra).
2. The facts necessary for deciding the issue involved in these appeals lie within a narrow compass. The writ petitioners who are respondents in these appeals appeared in IIIrd Graduate Level Recruitment Examination alongwith other candidates. On the basis of common combined competitive examination, appointments were made in different class-III Graduate Level Supervisory Posts in different departments of the state. The dispute relates to 16 categories of posts under different departments which at the time of recruitment and even thereafter, were treated as equal and carried same pay scale. Allotment was made to these posts not on the basis of merit-cum-choice but in a random manner because allotment and appointment to any of the 16 services had no adverse effect on anyone due to same pay scale.
3. As a result of recommendation of the Fourth Pay Revision Committee, w.e.f 01.04.1981; ten of the services from the group of 16 were placed in higher pay scale of Rs. 850-1360, while the remaining six were placed in a lower scale. The dispute went to Pay Anomaly Removal Committee which found the grievance of the six left out services to be genuine and, therefore, they also were granted the pay scale of Rs. 850-1360. Again, as a result of recommendation of Fifth Pay Revision Committee made on 15.12.89, but effective from 01.01.1986, for ten services the revised scale was of Rs. 1600-2750 and for the remaining six, the recommendation was for Rs. 1500-2750.
4. The employees adversely affected by the aforesaid decision and grant of lower pay scale challenged the decision of the State Government through a writ petition preferred by Nagendra Sahani bearing C.W.J.C No. 8419 of 1992 which was allowed by judgment and order dated 22.09.1993 Copy of that judgment is available in the records of several writ petitions including C.W.J.C No. 14281 of 2004 out of which L.P.A No. 234 of 2007 arises. For the sake of convenience, facts have been taken from the records of this case only.
5. On account of demand by the employees of the State Government for grant of Central Pay Scale, a Fitment Committee was constituted by the State Government on 02.01.1998 Its terms of reference are annexed as Annexure-R/3 to the counter affidavit in the Appeal. On behalf of the state two features of the terms of reference have been highlighted to support the submissions on behalf of the state. The terms of reference mention that a demand for Central Pay Scale was made by the employees of the State Government and on their demand, reference was made to the Fitment Committee for working out possible equivalence between the pay scale of state employees and the pay scales being given to central employees on account of recommendations of Fifth Pay Commission. The second aspect is that even those state employees who may be getting higher or lower pay scales should also be granted appropriate equivalent central pay scale. On the basis of report of the Fitment Committee dated 08.02.1999, the majority of 16 services, to be particular 14 of them were placed in the pay scale of Rs. 5,000-8000 whereas the post of Co-operative Extension Officer in the Co-operative Department was placed in the scale of Rs. 4500-7000 whereas post of Labour Inspector and Labour Officer was placed in a higher scale of 5500-9000. Subsequently, the post of Senior Auditor Grade-II has also been admittedly placed in the higher scale of Rs. 5500-9000 whereas the post of Co-operative Officer has been subsequently granted the scale of Rs. 5000-8000 by the State Government itself.
6. On account of award of different pay scales to different services (posts) out of 16 which were earlier treated as equivalent to each other, a grievance was raised before the Fitment Appellate Committee constituted by the State Government on 15.01.2000 This Committee considered the grievance raised on behalf of the writ petitioners who are respondents in these appeals and on the ground that they were recruited through a common combined competitive examination and allotted different posts/services having similar pay scale in a random manner without adopting any criteria/principles based on marks and choice, it held that all the 16 posts/services deserved to be placed in one pay scale otherwise persons having secured higher marks in the competitive examination will get lesser pay scale for no fault of theirs. The Fitment Appellate Committee recommended for adopting a common pay scale of Rs. 5000-8000 for all the 16 services.
7. Since the State Government did not accept the recommendation of the Fitment Appellate Committee, the writ petitions in question were filed to claim pay sale of Rs. 5500-9000 being given initially only to Labour Inspectors and Labour Officers and subsequently to Senior Auditor Grade-II also. By the order under appeal, the claim of the writ petitioners has been allowed on the ground that since all the petitioners had been recruited on account of a common combined competitive examination, and allotted different services/posts in a random manner without regard to merit or option and the services at the time of recruitment carried same pay scales, the State could not discriminate by placing some of the services out of 16 in a lower pay scale. The writ court agreed with the recommendation of the Fitment Appellate Committed which was headed by sitting judge of this court, Mr. Justice Aftab Alam as he then was, that the recommendations of the Fitment Committee could be accepted by the state but only prospectively. While allowing the writ petitions, the learned Single Judge also considered the judgment of the Division Bench in the case of Nagendra Sahani (supra) in support of the submission that since the appointees in the 16 services belong to one class, they were entitled to same replacement scale. The defence of the State of Bihar that further classification was necessitated on account of demand for Central Pay Scale was not accepted by the learned Single Judge because it was found obligatory on the part of the state to treat similarly situated employees in similar manner and such obligation could not be avoided on the plea of necessity to grant central pay scale equivalence.
8. Another ground urged on behalf of the state that even in Civil Services Examination, recruitments are made to different categories of posts carrying different pay scales was found to be of no help because in Civil Services Examination although the examination is common but allocation to different posts and services are made on the basis of merit-cum-choice principle.
9. Before us also on behalf of the state, same arguments were advanced and an attempt was made to distinguish the judgment of the Division Bench in the case of Nagendra Sahani only on the basis of necessity to take up the exercise of fitment for finding out equivalence with central pay scales.
10. We find ourselves in agreement with the views expressed by the learned Single Judges in the orders under appeal. All those employees of the state who were appointed on different dates through the same combined competitive examination on random basis and when the posts were having same pay scale and were therefore, admittedly equivalent to each other cannot be made to suffer by the state by placing some of the 16 such services in lower pay scale. This would amount to impermissible classification and discrimination. The purpose of granting central equivalence in pay scales can be achieved without resorting to such discrimination and for this, the option was given by the Fitment Appellate Committee as well as by the learned Single Judge in the case of Sunil Kumar But unfortunately, the state has not opted for such a suggested course of action. Hence in our view, there is no scope to take a different view in the matter. We are also of the considered view that such employees as the writ petitioners belonging to one or other of the 16 services must be given same revised pay scale w.e.f 01.01.1996 notionally and effective from 01.04.1997
11. As to what should be the common pay scale for all the 16 services in the light of recommendations of the Fitment Appellate Committee and our judgment in these cases, should first be decided by the State Government itself. It is required to select between one of the two pay scales i.e of Rs. 5000-8000 or 5500-9000. This exercise should best be left to the State Government to be done in a judicious manner which may require inviting objections from the holders of the post of Labour Inspectors and Labour Officers and Senior Auditor Grade-II who are in receipt of the higher pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000. This should be done expeditiously and in any case, within six months from today. If the State Government fails to take a decision within the period of six months, in that event the writ petitioners and others similarly situated would be entitled to be higher pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000 as provided by the writ court.
12. It will be open for the State Government to adopt the recommendations of the Fitment Appellate Committee that the pay scales suggested by the Fitment Committee may be adopted only prospectively, i.e for appointments to be made to the concerned services in future.
13. The appeals are disposed of accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert