- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Bihar Public Service Commi v. Satyendra Kumar Singh & Ors
Structured Summary of the Opinion (as provided)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Bihar Public Service Commission (referred to in the opinion as "the Commission") appealed against a common single-judge judgment dated 30.1.2009 which had allowed six writ petitions and set aside the Preliminary Test ("P.T.") of the combined competitive examination for the 48th to 52nd batches, directing a fresh P.T. The six writ petitions raised common issues and were disposed of by a common judgment; the appeals are being disposed of together.
The Commission had published advertisement No.4 of 2007 inviting applications for the P.T. of the combined competitive examination for five batches (48th to 52nd). A total of 2,63,265 applications were received, admit cards issued, and 1,76,984 candidates actually appeared on 25.5.2008 at 530 centres across 34 districts. The P.T. was objective, 150 multiple-choice questions, distributed in Question Booklets in four series (A, B, C, D). Answer sheets were Optical Mark Reader (OMR) sheets evaluated by computer software keyed to the Booklet series.
The writ petitions challenged two broad categories of defects: (1) some questions were incorrectly formulated or had incorrect suggested answers; and (2) some Question Booklets were defective (misbinding, duplication, repetition of pages or questions), with some booklets allegedly containing more than 150 questions or repeated pages.
The Commission constituted two expert committees prior to publication of results: a 12-member committee to evaluate the correctness of questions/answers (report dated 7.7.2008) which recommended deletion of 14 questions, and a 5-member committee (report dated 19.8.2008) which examined 94 complaints about defective/misbound Booklets and found no substance in the objections. The Commission accepted and implemented recommendations (deleted 14 questions and evaluated candidates on remaining 136 questions) and published PT results on 19.9.2008, inviting representations by 17.10.2008 under Clause 6 of the result notification. Over 5,700 representations were received in total.
The single-judge had set aside the PT on the ground that defects (including booklets containing more than 150 questions, repetition, incorrect formulation) were so pervasive as to make the PT unreliable and directed that a fresh PT be held. The Commission appealed that decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Preliminary Test (P.T.) for the combined competitive examination (48th–52nd batches) should be set aside in its entirety because of defects in question formulation, suggested answers, and alleged defective/misbound Question Booklets.
- If cancellation is not warranted for the entire P.T., whether limited relief (including a fresh test) should be granted to the candidates who specifically complained of receiving defective/misbound Question Booklets.
- What remedial steps are appropriate where the Commission had constituted expert committees, deleted certain questions, invited representations and taken administrative steps prior to publishing results — i.e., the extent to which the court should interfere with or substitute its view for administrative corrections taken in the selection process.
- Whether the Court should exercise broader powers (e.g., extend relief to all similarly placed candidates) when only some candidates raised specific complaints before the Commission or the Court.
Arguments of the Parties
Advocate General / Commission (in support of the appeals)
- The Question Booklet contained "12 important instructions" (some in bold). Candidates had a duty to check booklets immediately under instruction no.4 and to request replacement where defects were noticed; many candidates did so and had booklets replaced in the hall.
- The Commission acted fairly and in good faith: it constituted two committees pre-publication to examine and rectify defects; deleted 14 questions; and invited representations after results were published.
- No mala fide was alleged against the Commission; remedial measures were taken in good faith and on administrative scrutiny.
- Relied on the Supreme Court authority Karnataka Public Service Commission v. B M Vijaya Shankar to emphasize that candidates must follow exam instructions and that courts/tribunals should be cautious in overriding administrative discretion where candidates failed to comply with instructions.
- In the larger public interest — given extensive vacancies and longstanding delay in recruitment — minor defects should not result in cancellation of the entire selection process.
Petitioners / Unsuccessful Candidates
- Pressed a range of defects totaling about 30 specific complaints: many questions were wrongly formulated; many suggested answers were incorrect; several booklets had more than 150 questions due to repetition; differences between English and Hindi versions; unlawful replacement by different series booklets (e.g., A/C replaced by B) causing OMR mis-evaluation.
- Contended that 7 of the 14 deleted questions were erroneously deleted and the expert reports were not reliable — characterized as superficial and possibly biased in favor of the Commission.
- Argued that replacement Booklets were not supplied to many candidates despite requests and that replacement instructions were not followed at centre level; matching/extra time was not afforded to candidates whose booklets were replaced.
- Some counsel (Ganesh Prasad Singh) additionally argued that amended Rules permitting examination for multiple batches at once were illegal and that a full cancellation was required due to widespread malaise; sought relief extended to all affected candidates.
- Reliance on several authorities (including Union of India vs. Chakradhar and others) to argue that where irregularities are widespread and affect results, the entire selection may be cancelled.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For (as stated in this opinion) | Application by the Court (how the opinion used the precedent) |
|---|---|---|
| Karnataka Public Service Commission v. B M Vijaya Shankar [1992(2) SCC 206] | The Supreme Court emphasized that instructions are issued to ensure fairness in examinations; tribunals/courts should not approach matters technically to override instruction-based disqualifications; High Court/Tribunal should be slow to interfere where candidate failed to follow instructions. | The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that candidates have a duty to follow examination instructions (e.g., check booklet pages and seek replacement) and that failure to do so does not necessarily warrant judicial interference or setting aside the examination. |
| Sadanand Halo v. Mamtaz Ali Sheikh [2008(4) SCC 619] | The Supreme Court held that the validity of recruitment cannot be judged on microscopic details; High Courts should not undertake a roving inquiry; unsuccessful candidates cannot mount a general challenge except in limited exceptions (e.g., mala fide, widespread irregularities). | The opinion relied on paragraphs 58–60 to caution against substituting a court's fact-finding for that of the selection authorities and to limit interference where there is no finding of mala fide or large-scale irregularity. |
| 2007 (8) SCC 449 (Prestige Light Ltd. vs. State Bank of India) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | The case was cited by petitioners' counsel (as part of authorities relied upon) but the opinion does not extract or discuss a specific principle from it in the text provided. |
| Rajkumar Soni v. State of U.P. [2007(10) SCC 635] | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Cited by petitioners' counsel among authorities; the opinion does not record a detailed principle from it in the passages provided. |
| Union of India v. Chakradhar [2002 (3) SCC 146] | Where irregularities are so widespread and all-pervasive that it is impossible to identify persons who were unlawfully benefited or wrongfully deprived, the only option may be to cancel the whole selection; motive and pervasiveness matter. | The court distinguished the present case from Chakradhar, concluding that the present defects were limited, remedied in stages, and not of the widespread, all-pervasive character that justified cancellation in Chakradhar. |
| Ajay Kumar v. State of Bihar [2008 (1) PLJR 357] ( affirmed 2008(2) PLJR 310) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Cited by petitioners' counsel in support of the argument for scrapping the PT, but the opinion does not supply a specific principle or explain how it applies in this record. |
| Inder Pal Yadav v. Union of India (1985 PLJR (SC) 36) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Cited by petitioners' counsel (Ganesh Prasad Singh) to support broad remedial powers of the Court; the opinion does not elaborate a specific application from the excerpted text. |
| Union of India v. S. Vinod Kumar (citation not reproduced) | Not specified in the provided opinion beyond being cited as authority for the general rule that unsuccessful candidates who participated cannot later challenge unfairness absent exceptions. | Quoted indirectly in the opinion (via Sadanand Halo discussion) to illustrate that unsuccessful candidates cannot generally assail process after participating unless exceptional circumstances exist. |
| Om Prakash Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla (citation not reproduced) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Mentioned in the context of the general proposition that a candidate who participates and later finds result unpalatable cannot normally challenge the process; the opinion references it as authority quoted in Sadanand Halo. |
| Union of India v. Bikash Kumar (citation not reproduced) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Referenced in Sadanand Halo excerpt to show that selection processes are presumed correct in absence of allegations of favouritism or bias; used in the opinion's reasoning to support presumption of correctness of official acts. |
| Sunil Kumar Sinha v. State of Bihar [2009(1) PLJR 744] | Noted by this Court as a contrasting instance where selection was cancelled due to widespread irregularities amounting to mala fide and criminality (CBI report, arrests, large scale tampering), making it infeasible to separate lawful from unlawful selections. | The court relied on Sunil Kumar Sinha to distinguish present facts: Sunil involved large-scale corrupt manipulation, arrests and CBI involvement; by contrast, this case involved limited defects fairly addressed by the Commission and did not warrant cancellation of the whole selection. |
| Krishan Yadav (referred to in context — citation not reproduced) | Not specified in the provided opinion. | Referred to in the subsidiary discussion (via Chakradhar reasoning) as precedent applicable where irregularities are so widespread that whole selection must be cancelled; the opinion uses the principle but does not elaborate an independent application beyond distinguishing facts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a structured analysis examining each principal complaint and the administrative response. The reasoning, in sequential steps set out in the opinion, is summarized below.
-
Initial defects in questions/answers:
The Commission had promptly constituted a 12-member expert Committee (report dated 7.7.2008) to evaluate challenged questions and suggested answers. The Committee recommended deletion of 14 out of 150 questions. The Commission accepted the report (with certain modifications) and deleted those 14 questions, evaluating every candidate on the remaining 136 questions before publishing results on 19.9.2008. The court held that this administrative step largely addressed the category of defects concerning wrongly formulated questions or incorrect suggested answers.
-
Interpretation of question/answer anomalies vis-à-vis instructions:
The court examined specific example questions (e.g., sequence number of President Pratibha Patil; ambiguous spellings such as "Sphigomoho meter" for sphygmomanometer; historical questions about Permanent Settlement) and found that instruction no.9 (which told candidates to mark the best of multiple possible answers) and the expert Committee's deletions provided a reasonable administrative mechanism to deal with such anomalies. The court held that such objective-type questions require interpretive precision but are not automatically fatal where administrative remedial measures were taken.
-
Defective/misbound Question Booklets and replacements:
Instruction no.4 required candidates to check immediately that the booklet contained 40 printed pages and to get replacements of defective booklets of the same series. Centre Superintendents' reports and the record showed that many booklets were replaced in the hall and that 94 formal complaints were received by the Commission. The Commission constituted a five-member Committee (report dated 19.8.2008) to scrutinize these complaints and accepted its conclusions. The court found no convincing evidence that the committee reports were mere sham or dictated by the Commission.
-
Allegation that replaced booklets were of a different series causing OMR mis-evaluation:
The Commission's rejoinder stated that where an A or C series booklet had been replaced by a B series booklet, the OMR evaluation used the B series key to adjudge those answer sheets. The court accepted that explanation as addressing the particular grievance about series mismatches.
-
Time/onus objections regarding detection of defects and replacement:
The court reasoned that the instruction to check the booklet of 40 pages would take little time and that 150 objective questions were to be answered in 120 minutes (so average time per question was small). Accordingly, it was not unreasonable to expect candidates to detect obvious defects and seek replacement without causing significant prejudice; while some candidates might still have genuine grief, administrative remedy and later scrutiny were available.
-
Reliance on authority and the principle of non-interference:
The court emphasized precedents (notably Karnataka PSC v. Vijaya Shankar and Sadanand Halo v. Mamtaz Ali Sheikh) that courts should not convert writ petitions into roving fact-finding exercises or substitute their view for administrative selection committees when defects are limited and there is no mala fide. The court also contrasted the facts with Chakradhar and Sunil Kumar Sinha where cancellation was appropriate due to pervasive, systemic, and corrupt irregularities — not present here.
-
Proportional remedial approach:
Considering the Commission's pre- and post-publication remedial steps (two committees, deletion of 14 questions, invitations for representations under Clause 6, additional administrative corrections including correcting encoded roll numbers, and issuing calls to some candidates for the next stage), and given the large administrative burden and public interest in filling long-standing vacancies, the court concluded that wholesale cancellation was not justified. However, acknowledging that some grievances (specifically the 94 formal complaints received before publication alleging defective misbound booklets) still warranted redress, the court opted for a limited remedial measure: a fresh P.T. for those 94 candidates.
Holding and Implications
Holding
The Court modified the order of the learned single Judge and declined to cancel the entire first phase (P.T.) of the selection process. Instead, the Court directed that a fresh Preliminary Test be held only for the 94 candidates who had, after the PT and before publication of results, submitted representations to the Commission alleging they had been supplied defective/misbound Question Booklets (this group includes the six writ petitioners). The Court explicitly extended relief to all 94 complainants rather than limiting it to just the six writ petitioners. There was no order as to costs.
Implications / Consequences
- Direct effect: The single-judge cancellation of the entire P.T. was set aside and replaced by a more limited remedy — a fresh PT for the 94 identified complainants. The remainder of the candidates and the published results stood subject to the corrections already administratively made.
- Practical scheduling: The fresh PT for the 94 candidates is to be conducted in a format as nearly identical and practicable to the original test; the second phase of the selection process already scheduled to commence on 25.5.2009 shall not be impeded by this direction. The third phase shall be common to all candidates.
- Precedential scope: The Court emphasized that no new broad precedent to cancel recruitment processes for limited defects was being established; in the absence of widespread mala fide or all-pervasive irregularities, limited administrative defects remedied in stages do not justify wholesale cancellation. The decision is fact-specific: an administrative remediation plus absence of mala fide led to limited relief rather than total annulment.
- Costs: No order as to costs was made.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to and faithful to the information contained in the provided opinion text. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been added.
as `the Commission') has preferred this batch of six appeals against a common judgment dated 30.1.2009, passed by a learned single Judge of this Court, whereby he has allowed the six writ petitions, has set aside the Preliminary Test (hereinafter referred to as `P.T.') of the combined competitive examination for the 48th to 52nd batches for the reasons to be discussed hereinafter, and has directed the Commission to hold fresh P.T. The six writ petitions raised common issues of facts and law, were disposed of by a common judgment, and the appeals are being disposed of by a common judgment. The basic facts shall be drawn from CWJC No.11858 of 2008 (Mukesh Kumar Singh vs. State of Bihar & Others), as well as LPA No.178 of 2009, unless needed by specific reference to a particular writ petition or appeal.
2. The Commission issued advertisement no.4 of 2007, which was published in the local dailies on 6.11.2007, inviting applications from eligible candidates for the P.T. of the combined competitive examination for 48th to 52nd batches. The entire selection process comprises of three phases. The first one comprises of the PT, the second one of written test, and the final phase of viva-voce test. The answer sheets of the PT in the Optical Marker Reader (OMR, in brief), was programmed to be deciphered by a computer software in an objective-type answer sheet. The Commission received a total number of 2,63,265 applications. Admit cards were issued to all the candidates, but 1,76,984 candidates appeared in the PT, at 530 centres, in 34 districts, spread all over the State of Bihar, and was held on 25.5.2008.
3. Before we proceed further, we would like to indicate the format of the PT. The candidates were required to answer all the 150 questions with multiple choice of answers. It was of objective type. The candidates were supplied the Question Booklets covering 40 pages, and the answer sheet of one sheet both sides of which were used. Question Booklets were marked A, B, C, and D series. The four series were expected to incorporate just the same 150 questions, with the same multiple choice of answers. The difference in the four series was that arrangement, i.e. serial number, of the questions were different in the four series to avoid copying in the halls. One candidate got one series which he could carry back home. Each candidate was also given one answer sheet both sides of which had to be used as per the instructions, the first page of which contained columns to be filled in the own handwriting of the candidate. The reverse page, namely, page no. 2 provided the spaces for the candidates to indicate their preference of suggested answers in the Question Booklets. Only black/blue ink ball point pen could be used. There were different computer programming to decipher every answer sheet as per the series of the Question Booklet given to each candidate. As many as twelve important instructions were printed on the Question Booklets to be read and followed by the candidates.
4. The writ proceedings were confined to two kinds of objections, some of the questions were incorrect or the suggested answers were incorrect and, secondly, the Question Booklets supplied to some candidates were defective in various ways. In so far as the first kind of objections are concerned, as per its set norms and established procedure, the Commission constituted an expert committee to evaluate the key answers given by question setters. The Committee which dealt with the first aspect of the matter comprised of the following members :
(i) Dr. B K Jha Former Head of the Department of Political Science Magadh University
(ii) Prof. Dr. Surendra Gopal Former Head of the Department, History Patna University
(iii) Dr. Imtiyaz Ahmad Director, Khudabaksh Library, Patna
(iv) Dr. Bhagwan Prasad Singh Professor, Economics Department Patna University
(v) Dr. Randhir Singh Head of Department, Public Administration A N College, Patna
(vi) Dr. N P Sinha Retd. Head of Department Geography Department, Patna University, Patna
(vii) Prof. Ram Vijay Singh Retd. Professor, Mathematics Department B R A Bihar University, Muzaffarpur
(viii) Dr. Arun Kumar Sinha Professor & Head of Department Statistics Department, Patna University, Patna
(ix) Dr. Ashok Kumar Gupta Professor & Head of Department Botany Department, Patna University, Patna
(x) Padmashree Dr. Vijay Prakash Singh Professor & Head of Department of Medicine Patna Medical College, Patna
(xi) Dr. N Laxmi Nath, Vice Chancellor Chanakya National Law University, Patna
(xii) Dr. L M Rai Retd. Professor & Head of Department Magadh University, Bodh Gaya The Committee's report was submitted on 7th July 2008, before publication of the PT results, and is on record (Annexure 5 to the Commission's Supplementary Affidavit in LPA No. 178 of 2009). The Committee was of the view that some of the answers printed in the Question Booklets were incorrect and, therefore, recommended deletion of a few questions. The report was placed before the Commission on 31.7.2008 and 7.8.2008, and the Commission decided to delete 14 questions from the reckoning, and evaluated the answer sheets with respect to the remaining 136 questions leading to the PT results published on 19.9.2008. This was before publication of the PT result.
5. In so far as the second kind of objections are concerned, before publication of the PT results, the Commission constituted another Committee on 14.8.2008, comprising of the following five members to examine the grievances of 94 candidates who had submitted their representations/complaints alleging duplication of questions, and mis- binding or mis-structuring of the Question Booklets:-
(i) Prof. K P Sinha, Ex-Vice Chancellor B R Ambedkar Bihar University,Muzaffarpur
(ii)Dr. V Mukunda Das Director, Chandragupta Institute of Management Patna
(iii) Dr. L N Ram Ex Vice-Chancellor, Patna University, Patna
(iv) Dr. Surendra Gopal Retd. Professor,Deptt. of History Patna University, Patna
(v) Dr. Chakradhar Narain Sinha Retd. Professor, N.I.T. Patna The Committee submitted its report on 19.8.2008. Copies of the report are found at different places of the proceedings. It is marked Annexure-D to the Commission's counter affidavit. The Committee had examined 94 applications regarding defective Booklets, and did not find any substance in their objections. The Commission accepted the report in its entirety.
6. On 19.9.2008 the result of the PT was published. 19,318 candidates were declared to have passed the PT and were sent up for final examination. It is relevant to state in view of Clause 6 incorporated in the result of the PT (reproduced in Paragraph- 28 below), the aggrieved candidates were called upon to submit their objections/representations with respect to the selection process, and /or conduct of the PT, and the result.
7. The Commission received altogether 5713 representations till 17.10.2008, over and above 94 objections discussed hereinabove. Paragraph-20 of the Commission's supplementary counter affidavit is reproduced hereinbelow :-
" 20. That it is submitted that in all 5713 candidates filed representations by 17.10.2008. The representations mainly relate to the following:
(a) Re-totalling/Re-evaluation of Answer Sheets
(b) Wrong answers © Mistake about the category (reservation)
(d) Claim to obtain marks equal to cut-off marks or more
(e) the roll no. and marks of the candidate not available on website."
We are not concerned with all the objections.
8. The selection process generated lot of grievances amongst the candidates leading to six writ petitions. The same are as follows :-
(a) CWJC No. 11858 of 2008 (Mukesh Kumar Singh vs. State of Bihar & Ors.), giving rise to present LPA No. 178 of 2009
(b) CWJC No. 16015 of 2008 (Rajkishore & Ors. vs. BPSC & Ors.), giving rise to LPA No.182 of 2009 © CWJC No. 16056 of 2008 (Satyendra Kumar Singh vs.BPSC), giving rise to LPA No.180 of 2009
(d) CWJC No. 15479 of 2008 (Mrityunjay Kumar & Ors. vs. BPSC), giving rise to LPA No.179 of 2009
(e) CWJC No. 16993 of 2008 (Vagish Chandra Jha & Ors. vs. BPSC), giving rise to LPA No.184 of 2009
(f) CWJC No. 16462 of 2008 (Vikas Kumar & another vs. BPSC), giving rise to LPA No.181 of 2009 All the 37 writ petitioners are unsuccessful candidates. Out of these 37 writ petitioners, 6 of them allege supply of defective Question Booklets which were misbound and were not replaced. The contest before the learned single Judge was between the unsuccessful candidates and the Commission. After consideration of the matter, the six writ petitions have been allowed by a common judgment dated 30.1.2009, whereby the PT has been set aside on the ground that some of the booklets contained more than 150 questions. The questions were not printed in the same sequence in all the Question Booklets of one series. Some of the questions were repetitive, or incorrectly formulated, or the suggested answers of some of them were incorrect. In the estimation of the learned single Judge, the defects are so all-pervasive that it would be unsafe to depend on the PT. It has, therefore, been
- 10 -
further directed to hold fresh PT. Aggrieved by the judgment, the Commission has preferred the aforesaid six appeals.
9. Learned Advocate general has appeared in support of the appeals and submits that as many as "12 important instructions" were printed on page 1 of the Question Booklet, and the more important ones were highlighted in bold print. He further submits that the materials on record clearly state that a large number of candidates had taken aid of the instructions, and had the defective Question Booklets replaced. Those who failed to take advantage of the situation in the examination hall will have to blame themselves. He submits that there is a duty on the Commission to hold a fair selection process, but there is an equally corresponding duty on the candidates to appear at the examination as per the instructions and the code of discipline formulated by the Commission for uniform application. He relies on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Karnataka Public Service Commission vs. B M Vijaya Shankar [ 1992(2) SCC 206, Para 3]. He submits in the same vein that condition no.4 of the question booklet clearly provided for replacement of the defective Question Booklet. Apart from those who asked for replacement and got the same in the examination hall, 94 of the candidates represented before the Commission which have been examined by the five- member Committee from amongst whom only six have approached
- 11 -
this Court with the grievance. Learned Advocate General further submits that no mala fides have been attributed to the Commission. On the contrary, its fairness in identifying the defects in the selection process and the further effort to rectify the same is writ large on the proceedings. Even before publication of the result, the Commission constituted two Committees and remedial measures as suggested were taken. After publication of the result, the Commission invited representations/objections from aggrieved candidates. The matter was examined in depth and remedial measures were taken. He relies on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Sadanand Halo vs. Momtaj Ali Sheikh [2008(4) SCC 619).
9.1 He also submits that enormity of holding such a test conducted by human agencies may bring about some grievances. In view of the bonafide attempts on the part of the Commission to rectify the defects in the selection process, hardly any grievance survives except those of the unsuccessful candidates who were unable to measure up to the minimum requirements of PT.
9.2 He next submits that a large number of vacancies exist in the State of Bihar. According to the Rules, the selection process has to take place once every year after taking into account the anticipated vacancies till December of the year following, which, for historical reasons, could not take place as a result of which the State
- 12 -
Government amended the Rules enabling it to conduct the selection process for more than one batch at a time. The net result is that examinations of the 48th to 52nd batches are being held together. In other words, no examination has taken place since 2001. The PT has taken more than the needed time as a result of which the examination for the 53rd to 55th batches are now due. He, therefore, submits that in the larger interest of the State, minor defects, if any, may be ignored.
10. Mr. Dinesh Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the petitioners has, in his elaborate submissions, pointed out a large number of defects in the conduct of the PT. The selection process is afflicted by as many as 30 defects. He has pointed out that a large number of questions were wrongly formulated, and many of the suggested answers were also wholly incorrect. He next submits that out of the 14 questions which have been deleted from consideration, seven were erroneously deleted. He next submits that a number of questions were repeated as a result of which many of them got more than 150 questions to be answered. He also pointed out that there was variation in the English version and the Hindi version in the same series. He next submits that the instructions clearly stated that a wrong Question Booklet had to be replaced by another Booklet of the same series which was not followed. In other words, for example, the candidates who were given A or C series were replaced by Booklet B
- 13 -
series, as a result of which the computer format evaluated the answer sheets erroneously. He also submits that the instructions were very onerous and unreasonable, incapable of being followed within the time fixed for the examination. Matching/extra time was not allowed to the candidates whose Question Booklets were replaced. The two enquiry reports were eye-wash, were as per the dictates of the Commission, to save its own skin. The reports are so superficial that the same do not inspire confidence. He submits in the same vein that the reasons assigned by the two Committees are contrary to the materials on record. The Commission has not come with clean hands. He relies on the following reported judgments :
(i) 2007 (8) SCC 449 (para 33) (Prestige Light Ltd. vs. State Bank of India)
(ii) 2007(10) SCC 635 (Rajkumar Soni vs. State of U.P.) He wrapped up his elaborate submissions by submitting that, in the interest of justice to the entire body of candidates, the PT as a whole should be scrapped. He relies on the following reported judgments :-
(i) 2002 (3) SCC 146 (para 8) (Union of India vs. Chakradhar)
(ii) 2008 (1) PLJR 357 (Ajay Kumar vs. State of Bihar) which was affirmed by a Division Bench of this Court (reported in 2008(2) PLJR 310)
- 14 -
11. Mr. Ganesh Prasad Singh, appearing for the writ petitioner of CWJC No. 16015 of 2008 (LPA No. 182 of 2009), submitted that the amended Rules permitting examination of five batches at a time is illegal. He next submits that it is a case of wide-spread malaise and, therefore, the PT as a whole has to be set aside. Any relief short of that will do injustice to a large number of candidates. He lastly submits that powers of this Court to do justice is unlimited. In a case like the present one, the relief should not be confined to the writ petitioners alone, and should be extended to each and every sufferer.
He relies on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Inder Pal Yadav vs. Union of India (1985 PLJR (SC) 36 (page 39).
12. Mr. Mahesh Narain Parbat for the writ petitioner of CWJC No.16056 of 2008 (LPA No. 180 of 2009), submits that the petitioners were not supplied the replacement Question Booklets inspite of persistent requests. He submitted his complaint/representation dated 2.6.2008 (Annexure 5). He has also expressed lack of confidence in the two Committees. The booklets of many of the candidates had more than 150 questions. He has also relied on the Commission's instructions to the Centre Superintendents which did not contain instructions to supply replacement Question Booklets in appropriate cases.
- 15 -
13. The remaining writ petitioners in the other three appeals adopted the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners in CWJC No. 11858 of 2008.
14. Learned Advocate General as well as the Additional Advocate General III in their separate sets of submissions in reply attempted to counter the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the writ petitioners.
15. We have perused the materials on record and considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties. We shall first deal with the question relating to the grievance in respect of the defective questions and answers suggested in the Question Booklet. As stated hereinabove, the PT was held on 25.5.2008, the Commission soon thereafter as per its norms and on its motion, constituted a Committee of twelve distinguished academicians of the State to evaluate the key answers given by question setters. The Committee in its report dated 7.7.2008 (Annexure 5 in LPA No. 178 of 2009), suggested that 14 out of 150 questions were either wrongly formulated or the suggested answers were erroneous. The Commission considered the report and deleted 14 questions from the reckoning, as a result of which each and every candidate was evaluated for the remaining 136 questions. This takes care of the grievance raised on behalf of the writ petitioners that
- 16 -
the Question Booklets contained defective questions and defective answers.
16. Learned counsel for the petitioners have taken us through the Question Booklet in detail to point out the anomalies. For example, question no.1 of Booklet A series reads as follows :-
"1. What is the sequence number of Ms. Pratibha Patil as President of the Republic of India?
(A) 10th (B) 11th © 12th (D) 13th The writ petitioner has produced before us a document issued by the Election Commission of India to show that Smt. Pratibha Patil is the 13th President of India. On the other hand, the learned Advocate General has produced before us a copy of the document released by the Rashtrapati Bhawan showing that she is the 12th President of India. In this connection, instruction no.9 printed on the Question Booklet may be reproduced hereinbelow:-
"9. Questions and their responses are printed in English and Hindi versions in this booklet. Each question comprises four responses - (A),(B),(C) and (D). You are to select ONLY ONE correct response and mark in your Answer Sheet. In case you feel that there are more than one correct answer, mark the response which you consider the best. In any case choose ONLY ONE response for each question. Your total marks will depend on the number of correct responses marked by you in the Answer Sheet." (Emphasis added)
- 17 -
The instructions itself stated that ".......in case you feel that there are more than one correct answer, mark the response which you consider the best......." In such a situation, evaluation of the answer to this question will entirely depend on the correct answer determined by the Chief Examiner, whether she is the 12th or the 13th President of the Republic of India. Both the documents supplied by learned counsel for the parties indicate the correct position, but from different angles. Both are equally correct answers and, therefore, this instruction takes care of the situation. Dr. Rajendra Prasad, the first President of India, had occupied the office for two consecutive terms. From this angle, she is the 12th President of India, and in that situation the communiqué of the Rashtrapati Bhawan is correct. However, the other document supplied by the Election Commission of India, which is charged with the duty of conducting the election of the President of India, is equally correct, but from a different angle. The Election Commission conducted the thirteenth election. This is apart from the position that a Committee of twelve distinguished academicians examined the entire Question Booklets and have deleted 14 incorrect questions. Questions in such objective type tests are intelligently formulated, and the answer has to be selected in relation to the preciosity of language used in formulating the question.
16.1) Question no.70 of Booklet no. A series reads as follows:-
- 18 -"70. The serial number of Mr. Mohammad Ansari as Vice President of India is (A) 10th (B) 11th © 12th (D) 13th The explanation is comparable to the previous one. 16.2) Question no.149 of the Booklet no. A series reads as follows:-
"149. Which one of the following is correct about the permanent settlement introduced in Bihar (A) The Zaminders were deprived of the ownership of the land.
(B) The right of ownership of land was made hereditary and transferable for the Zaminders.
© Land revenue was constitutionalised (D) Abolition of Zamindari"
The definition of `permanent settlement' as found in the Historical Dictionary of India by Surjit Mansing, is as follows :-
PERMANENT SETTLEMENT : A term applied to the form of revenue settlement introduced by the British Governor General Lord Cornwallis (q.v.) in 1793 to areas controlled by the East India Company (q.v.) in Bengal, Bihar, and Orissa (qq.v.). One objective of the new settlement was to end the rapacious system of annual reassessments and contracts to tax collectors introduced when the East India Company took over the rights of dewani in 1765. Another declared objective of Lord Cornwallis was to create in Bengal a body of hereditary landlords who might extend cultivation, maximize production, and generally function with a sense of public purpose espoused by the eighteenth-century enlightened aristocracy in England.
The distinguishing feature of the Permanent Settlement, therefore, was that tax collecting agents were confirmed in their positions for perpetuity in return for a
- 19 -
fixed annual payment of dues to the government. They were forbidden to evict tenants or dispossess the actual cultivators of the soil.
The consequences of the Permanent Settlement were not as salutary as Cornwallis' intent. While taxes or dues to the government remained constant, actual rents rose, increasing the burden on the cultivator without adding to the revenues of the government. Moreover, revenue collection was harsh, unmitigated even in bad seasons. Third, members of the new class of zaminder did not fit the ideal portrait painted by Cornwallis, who failed to understand the Indian reality. It is noteworthy that no other presidency in British India emulated this system in the various revenue settlements they made and that the Bengal Rent Act of 1859 modified the 1793 law by giving occupancy rights to tenants of twelve years' standing.
Many twentieth-century historians and economists of all nationalities regard the Permanent Settlement as an important factor contributing not only to the social tensions of eastern India in the nineteenth century, but to its continuing social backwardness and agricultural impoverishment." (Emphasis added) Answer no. B was obviously the best answer.
16.3) Question no. 53 of Question Booklet no. A series reads as follows:-
"53. Which of the following instrument measures blood pressure (A) Sphero meter (B) Animo meter © Spigomoho meter (D) Am meter We have not the slightest manner of doubt that the question is accurately formulated. The correct answer is at no.(C), which reads "Spigomoho meter", though with incorrect spelling. The Oxford Concise Medical Dictionary gives the correct spelling of the
- 20 -
instrument as "Sphygmomanometer". We are of the view that incorrect spelling of a suggested answer, which was quite close to the correct answer, cannot qualify for outright rejection. 16.4) To conclude this aspect of the matter, the defective questions suggested by learned counsel for the petitioners are taken care of by instruction no.9, and have also been taken care of by the report of the twelve-member Committee which was accepted by the Commission with certain modifications, and 14 questions were deleted. Everybody was earlier required to answer the same 150 questions, and after deletion the same 136 questions. Therefore, none gained any advantage, nor anybody suffered any prejudice, in a situation where the candidates had no choice of selection between different questions.
17. We must also consider the contention advanced by learned counsel for the petitioners that 7 questions were erroneously deleted. We find it difficult to sit in judgment over the report of the twelve- member Committee comprising of five distinguished academicians of the State. In any case, we have also made an attempt to assess the questions with allegedly defective answers brought to our notice by learned counsel for the petitioners, and have been considered hereinabove. This is apart from the fairness shown by the Commission by making serious efforts to remove the defects.
- 21 -
18. We now pass on to another serious grievance raised by learned counsel for the petitioners, namely, some of the Booklets contained more than 150 questions, or questions, or the pages were repetitive etc. We call attention to instruction no.4 of the Question Booklet series A which reads as follows :-
"4. Immediately after commencement of the examination, you should check up your Question Booklet and ensure that the Question Booklet series is printed on the top right-
hand corner of the booklet. The booklet contains 40 printed pages and no page or question is missing or unprinted or torn or repeated. If you find any defect in this booklet, get it replaced immediately by a complete booklet of the same series." (Emphasis added) In other words, the instruction clearly stated that the Question Booklet contained only 40 pages, which could have been checked very quickly. Failure to do so cannot go to the debit of the Commission. Secondly, the reports of all the Centre Superintendents are on record. It is evident on a plain reading of the same that some of the Question Booklets suffered from the defects pointed out by the writ petitioners, and it is equally manifest that the Question Booklets of a large number of them were replaced in the examination hall. Furthermore, 94 complaints were received by the Commission pointing out this defect. The Commission examined the representations/objections and came to a tentative conclusion that the grievances need deeper scrutiny. It, therefore, promptly constituted a Committee of five
- 22 -
distinguished academicians of the State who submitted their report dated 19.8.2008. The same is not in the nature of a full-length judgment which is not expected, but it does serialize the grievances in a systematic manner and records its conclusions. On a plain reading of the same, apart from the attendant circumstances, we do not get any impression that it was as per the dictates of the Commission. In other words, the grievances of the candidates were taken care of at two stages. Firstly, in the examination hall itself where the Question Booklets of a large number of candidates were replaced on their request, and, secondly, by the scrutiny of the five-member Committee. It is clear from the reports of the Centre Superintendents that the examinations were held in a peaceful atmosphere, free from any blemish, and the Question Booklets of many were replaced as per their request. The reports of 25 Centre Superintendents stated that request for replacement were promptly complied with and were given the replacement Question Booklets. Six of the writ petitioners now state before this Court that they did not get the replacement Question Booklets inspite of persistent request appears to us to be an after- thought. In any case, in order to ensure justice to such candidates, the Commission constituted the Committee which examined as many as 94 representations/objections.
- 23 -
19. We must deal with another contention advanced on behalf of the petitioners. It has been contended that candidates were initially given series A or series C Question Booklets which were replaced by series B Booklet, as a result of which the OMR must have incorrectly read those answer sheets. The Commission has stated in its rejoinder to the counter affidavit in LPA No. 178 of 2009 that the key to the answer of series B of OMR were replaced to adjudge the evaluation correctly. Paragraph -12 of the rejoinder is reproduced hereinbelow :-
"12. That in reply to the statement made in paragraph 32 of the counter affidavit so far as it relates to Annexure-M of the second counter affidavit of the Commission regarding ten candidates whose question booklets of A and C series were replaced by B series question booklets, it is stated that evaluation of their answer sheets has been done by key answer of B series by OMR. Thus the contention of respondent no.1 that proper scanning has not been done by the Computer (OMR) is denied herewith."
This takes care of this part of the grievance of the writ petitioners.
20. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also contended that the conditions were very onerous, difficult to be followed, and matching time was not allowed to tackle the replacement Question Booklets. We have already dealt with one aspect of the matter in relation to instruction no.4 which states that it comprises of 40 pages, the counting of which would take very little time without making any significant erosion in the available time to answer 150 questions.
- 24 -
Secondly, 150 questions had to be answered in 120 minutes. The questions not being of descriptive nature, the candidates were required to make a selection out of four suggested answers to tackle one question. Therefore, answering each question will take less than the apportioned time for each question. In other words, every candidate was provided with adequate time to detect the defects and tackle the replacement Question Booklet. We must state that it may leave some of the candidates with the grievance. It is, however, not possible to provide a tailor-made format to every candidate keeping in view the enormity of the selection process.
21. The stringency and the need to follow such instructions in tests for public recruitment was considered by the Supreme Court in the case of Karnataka Public Service Commission v. B M Vijaya Shankar (supra). That was with respect to a recruitment test for selection to the State Civil Service. Clause (a) of the instructions stated that
Before commencing your answers please write your register number and other particulars in the space provided above. Do not write your name or register number or sign anywhere in the answer book or on any loose sheets, such as precis sheets, maps, graph papers, etc.The respondents who appeared for the test wrote their roll numbers not only on the cover page, in the spaces provided for it, but even at other places in the answer book in disregard of the
- 25 -
instruction issued by the Commission. Such answer books were not subjected to evaluation which was challenged before the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal allowed the applications and directed the Commission to evaluate the answer books. The matter reached the Supreme Court and it has been observed in the judgment that the Tribunal in issuing directions approached the matter technically and attempted to make out much where it would have been better part of the discretion to refuse to interfere. The Tribunal completely misdirected itself in this regard. Paragraphs 3 and 5 of the judgment are reproduced hereinbelow :-
"3. Such instructions are issued to ensure fairness in the examination. In the fast deteriorating standards of honesty and morality in the society the insistence by the Commission that no attempt should be made of identification of the candidate by writing his roll number anywhere is in the larger public interest. It is well known that the first page of the answer book on which roll number is written is removed and a fictitious code number is provided to rule any effort of any approach to the examiner. Not that a candidate who has written his roll number would have approached the examiner. He may have committed a bonafide mistake. But that is not material. What was attempted to be achieved by the instruction was to minimize any possibility or chance of any abuse. Larger public interest demands insistence of observance of instruction rather than its breach.
........ ............ ............ ........
"5. ...Tribunal in issuing directions approached the matter technically and attempted to make out much where it would have been better part of discretion to refuse to
- 26 -
interfere. The Tribunal completely misdirected itself in this regard. In our opinion its order cannot be maintained."
(Emphasis added)
22. Division Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Ganesh Prasad Yadav vs. State of Bihar [1995 (2) PLJR, presented a comparable situation. The Division Bench observed as follows :-
"35. Thus, the suggestive answers of four questions i.e. questions no.82, 78, 121 and 130 are incorrect. Two of them have already been noticed by the Commission and the marks have been awarded to all the candidates. So far as other two questions are concerned, the suggestive answers are incorrect. Now, the question is as to whether on this ground alone the preliminary test has to be held to be vitiated. The total marks in the preliminary test is
150. It is an admitted fact that more than one lac candidates had appeared in the examination and thereafter 11,000 candidates have been selected for appearing in the main examination. The unsuccessful candidates did not object to the aforesaid mistakes either during the examination or filed any objection soon after the examination that they were prejudiced and suffered because of the aforesaid wrong suggestive answers On the other hand, they waited for result of the examination and only when they became unsuccessful they have come out with this case in this Court. They have stated in the writ applications that they had brought the aforesaid mistakes to the notice of the Commission, but nothing has been brought on their behalf on the record to show that such things have been brought to the notice of the Commission, the Commission has emphatically denied that at any point of time they informed about the mistakes in response to the questions.
"36. No doubt, there are mistakes in the alternative answers or responses to the four questions, but on that basis it cannot be said that the Commission
- 27 -
adopted any unfair means or acted in an unfair manner, on the other hand, the aforesaid mistakes appear to have been committed by the experts to whom the work of setting of questions and their suggestive answers was entrusted. It cannot be said that there was unfair treatment to the non-selectees in particular. All the candidates including the successful candidates have answered the same set of questions and in that view of the matter either all the candidates have suffered equally or took advantages of wrong suggestive answers. In that view of the matter, inspite of the aforesaid errors, in my view, it would not be proper to quash the preliminary test for the aforesaid defects."
23. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners has also raised a grievance that the two reports were an eye-wash and were at the dictates of the Commission. We can quite see that the members of the two Committees are distinguished academicians of the State. From the very description of their designations, it appears that all of them (except one) are retired persons and have not to gain anything in life.
In the absence of any tangible proof, on the sole basis of the counsel's ingenuity shown during the course of oral submissions, it is difficult to accept that they acted on the dictates of the Commission. On the contrary, we feel that the two reports dealt with two sets of grievances, and record their respective minutes in their reports in a systematic manner, may not be in the nature of a full-length judgment of court. The contention is rejected.
- 28 -
24. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that the Commission has not come with clean hands. The contention is stated only to be rejected. The candidates, not the Commission, were the petitioners before the writ court. Secondly, the Commission has placed on record all the relevant materials for an effective adjudication. The decisions cited by learned counsel for the petitioners relate to a situation where the aggrieved persons who had approached the court, were found to be guilty of not approaching the court with clean hands. The judgments relied upon on behalf of the petitioners in support of their contention are wholly inappropriate in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
25. Learned counsel for the petitioners in CWJC No. 16015 of 2008 has contended that the Rules are bad in law. The contention is stated only to be rejected, being wholly beyond the frame of the writ petition, which was confined to the fairness of the selection process. In view of the provisions of the Patna High Court Rules, the vires of statutory Rules cannot be considered by a single Judge. Law is well settled that those of the candidates who appeared at the test conducted under the amended Rules cannot turn around and challenge it on that ground. Furthermore, in view of the position that vires of the Rules were not challenged in the writ proceedings, it would not be
- 29 -
appropriate for us to make any comment on the validity or otherwise of the amended Rules.
26. Enormity of such a huge selection process has to be appreciated. In response to the advertisement, 2,63,265 applications were received, admit cards were issued to all of them which by necessary implication meant that sitting accommodation, as well as like number of Question Booklets and answer sheets, had to be kept ready for all of them. The Commission had to make sitting arrangements at as many as 530 centres, in 34 districts of the State, to accommodate 2,63,265 candidates. It is another matter that 1,76,984 candidates appeared at the test which became known only after test commenced. Evaluation of such a large number of answer sheets, to collate the results, and to publish the same according to the system, of 19,318 successful candidates, is a stupendous job. In this background, some defects are bound to happen and, unless those go to the root of the selection process and is of the nature of wholesale malaise or dishonesty or some oblique motive, can lead to cancellation of the whole of the selection process. The second and the third phase of the selection process are yet to commence. Mistakes have undoubtedly taken place which have been discussed hereinabove, and the Commission has made sincere and fair attempts to rectify the same. In the totality of the situation, we are convinced that it would be most
- 30 -
inappropriate to cancel the entire selection process. The grievances of the aggrieved persons have been considered by the Commission and discussed hereinabove. The remaining/surviving grievances shall be taken care of by the court hereinafter.
27. The judgment of the Superme in Sadanand Halo v. Mamtaz Ali Sheikh (supra) may be noticed. That was a case where the selection process for recruitment of 5500 Constables was held in 25 districts of Assam for which as many as two lacs candidates took part. The Supreme Court observed that validity of recruitment could not be judged on the basis of microscopic details. After participating in the selection process, the candidates could not indulge in a roving enquiry. Paragraphs 58 to 60 of the judgment are reproduced hereinbelow for the facility of quick reference:-
"58. It is settled law that in such writ petitions a roving inquiry on the factual aspect is not permissible. The High Court not only engaged itself into a non-permitted fact- finding exercise but also went on to rely on the findings of the amicus curiae, or as the case may be, the scrutiny team, which in our opinion was inappropriate. While testing the fairness of the selection process wherein thousands of candidates were involved, the High Court should have been slow in relying upon such microscopic findings. It was not for the High Court to place itself into a position of a fact-finding commission, that too, more particularly at the instance of those petitioners who were unsuccessful candidates. The High Court should, therefore, have restricted itself to the pleadings in the writ petition and the say of the respondents. Unfortunately, the High Court took it upon itself the task of substituting itself for the Selection Committee and also in the process
- 31 -
assumed the role of an appellate tribunal which was, in our opinion, not proper. Thus, the High Court converted this writ petition into a public interest litigation without any justification.
"59. It is also a settled position that the unsuccessful candidates cannot turn back and assail the selection process. There are of course exceptions carved out by this Court to this general rule. This position was reiterated by this Court in its latest judgment in Union of India v. S. Vinod Kumar where one of us (Sinha,J.) was a party. This was a case where different cut-off marks were fixed for the unreserved candidates and the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates. This Court in para 10 of its judgment endorsed the action and recorded a finding that there was a power in the employer to fix the cut-off marks which power was neither denied nor disputed and further that the cut-off marks were fixed on a rational basis and, therefore, no exception could be taken. The Court also referred to the judgment in Om Prakash Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla where in has been held specifically that when a candidate appears in the examination without protest and subsequently is found to be not successful in the examination, the question of entertaining the petitioner challenging such examination would not arise. The Court further made observations in para 34 of the judgment to the effect : (S.Vinodh Kumar case, SCC p.107, para 19) "19......`34. There is thus no doubt that while question of any estoppel by conduct would not arise in the contextual facts but the law seems to be well settled that in the event a candidate appears at the interview and participates therein, only because the result of the interview is not "palatable" to him, he cannot turn round and subsequently contend that the process of interview was unfair or there was some lacuna in the process.' "
In para 20 this Court further observed that there are certain exceptions to the aforementioned rule. However, the Court did not go into those exceptions since the same were not material.
- 32 -
"60. In our opinion the first basic thing for such a selection process would be the lack of bona fides or, as the case may be, malafide exercise of powers by those who were at the helm of selection process. Both the courts below have not recorded any finding that they found any mala fides on the part of any of the State officials who headed the interviews. On the other hand the tenor of the judgments shows that the whole process did not suffer from mala fides, lack of bona fides, bias or political interference. In Union of India v. Bikash Kumar this Court observed in para 14 thus : ( SCC p.195 ) "14. When a Selection Committee recommends selection of a person, the same cannot be presumed to have been done in a mechanical manner in absence of any allegation of favouritism or bias. A presumption arises in regard to the correctness of the official act. The party who makes any instant case, no such allegation was made. The selection process was not found to be vitiated. No illegality was brought to our notice."
28. In view of the materials placed before us, we are convinced that the Commission has acted with fairness and sincerity. The two Committees were constituted before publication of the PT result. The recommendations of the two Committees were accepted, the results were published after implementing its suggestions, and went a long way in redressal of the grievances of the aggrieved candidates. Noticing the situation that some defects in the selection process might have escaped attention constituting the second chapter of grievances, the Commission had once again with utmost fairness,
- 33 -
incorporated Clause -6 in the PT result , inviting objections/complaints, and is reproduced hereinbelow:
6. किसी प्रकार की त्रुटि के लिये सफल/असफल उम्मीदवार दिनांक 17.10.2008 की संध्या 5 बजे तक अपना अभ्यावेदन स्पीड पोस्ट/निष्चित डाक से भेज सकते है। यह सपश्ट किया जाता है कि अभ्यावेदन दिनांक 17.10.2008 की संध्या 5 बजे तक प्राप्त नहीं होने पर उस पर विचार नहीं किया जायेगा। अतः अभ्यावेदन इस प्रकार भेजे कि दिनांक 17.10.2008 की संध्या 5 बजे तक अधोहस्ताक्षरी के कार्यलय में अवष्य प्राप्त हो जाए।
The Commission was mindful of the defects and, therefore, on its own motion, invited objections/representations from the aggrieved candidates which have been duly considered. There are materials on record to show that, in order to redress the grievances of the aggrieved candidates, the Commission issued letters to 134 such candidates, calling them for the second phase of the selection process. Paragraph- 21 of the Commission's supplementary counter affidavit in the writ proceeding is reproduced hereinbelow :-
"21. That the Commission held several meetings i.e. on 8.11.2008, 10.11.2008, 11.11.2008, 12.11.2008, 13.11.2008, 28.11.2008 and 1.12.2008. Careful examination of all the complaints was made. 1. It was found that first complaint relating to retotalling was wrong. On retotalling non change/difference in marks was found. 2. Since the matter was subjudice, the Commission decided to wait for the decision of the Hon'ble High Court. 3. Regarding mistake about category (reservation) it was found that out of 146 such applications the claim of 126 was found to be correct and it was resolved to publish their results which were published on 2.12.2008 giving these candidates extra time to apply for main examination.
4. The fourth type of complaint was found to be incorrect.
5. It was found that 20 candidates had wrongly encoded
- 34 -
their roll nos. in their answer sheets. When these roll nos. were corrected with the help of original records, eight candidates were found to be successful. Their results were also published alongwith above 126 candidates.
We are, therefore, of the view that the Commission could not have done more to rectify the defects which had inadvertently and for bonafide reason crept into the selection process. We are equally convinced that no unfairness, malafide action, abuse of power, dishonesty, or spirit of favour or disfavour is at all involved in this case. The defects are entirely attributable to the question setters, or the Printers, and the Commission seems to have removed the same in the best possible manner. It is not a case of wide-spread defects, but of limited defects, and have almost entirely been redressed by the Commission in three stages. The candidates are themselves to be blamed if they have failed to cross the cut-off marks. The fourth stage is being taken over by the Court.
29. The judgment of the Supreme Court relied on by learned counsel for the petitioners in the case of Union of India vs. Chakradhar (supra) is wholly inapplicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case. That was a case where the mischief in conducting the selection was so widespread and all-pervasive affecting the results, that it was difficult to identify the persons unlawfully benefited or wrongfully deprived of selection. One of us
- 35 -
(S.K.Katriar,J.) had the occasion to apply the same in the judgment in the case of Sunil Kumar Sinha vs. State of Bihar [2009(1) PLJR
744). Paragraph 47 of the judgment of this Court is reproduced hereinbelow for the facility of quick reference :-
"47. The judgment of the Supreme Court reported in (2002)3 SCC 146 [2002(2) PLJR (SC) 263] (Union of India vs. O Chakradhar), equally covers the present case. The Supreme Court observed that the mischief in conducting the selection process was so widespread and all-pervasive, affecting the results that it was difficult to identify the persons unlawfully benefited or wrongfully deprived of selection, the whole selection could be cancelled without issuing individual show-cause notice to each person selected. It has been observed as follows :-
8. In our view the nature and the extent of illegalities and irregularities committed in conducting a selection will have to be scrutinized in each case so as to come to a conclusion about future course of action to be adopted in the matter. If the mischief played is so widespread and all-pervasive, affecting the result, so as to make it difficult to pick out the persons who have been unlawfully benefited or wrongfully deprived of their selection, in such cases it will neither be possible nor necessary to issue individual show-cause notices to each selectee. The only way out would be to cancel the whole selection. Motive behind the irregularities committed also has its relevance.
9. The copy of the report of CBI has been made available to the Court by the learned Additional Solicitor General and the same was served upon learned counsel for the respondent earlier. To find out the position in the present case, we may have to scrutinize the report of CBI.
10. ...... According to the report, answer-sheet packets were stealthily opened and answers were filled up in the blank spaces left by the examinees. This happened during the period the bags of the answer-sheets were in the
- 36 -
custody of the Chairman. So far as the interview is concerned, it is reported that the two Boards constituted for the interview did not have technical personnel as its member as per requirement. Each member was required to award marks to the candidate in the individual assessment sheets provided to them, and average was to be worked out. The columns for interview marks was later on filled up as per wishes of the Chairman and Member-Secretary of the Board and signatures of the non-official members were obtained on the summary sheet later on.
11. It is mentioned in the report that huge amount of money was taken for selecting the candidates but none is coming forward to indicate as to who and how much one paid for it for fear of being in trouble. It is further that non- official Chairman of the Board made payment of printing of the examination paper etc. not to any firm but to one Gaja Raja Yadav. It may also be mentioned that according to the report a large number of applications were missing and postal orders of the missing applications were encashed and misappropriated and even before the closing date of receiving the applications, it started sending applications to the computer firm for their scrutiny. CBI has named five persons as accused in the report, namely, the Chairman of the Railway Recruitment Board, Bangalore, who is a non- official, the Member-Secretary of the Board, an officer of the Railways, one Shri Hanumanth Bhaiya, a Senior Clerk in the Railway Recruitment Board, and Gaja Raja Yadav, the private person to whom payment had been made for printing of the question paper etc.
12. As per the report of CBI the whole selection smacks of mala fides and arbitrariness. All norms are said to have been violated with impunity at each stage viz right from the stage of entertaining applications, with answer- sheets while in the custody of the Chairman, in holding typing test, in interview and in the end while preparing the final result. In such circumstances it may not be possible to pick out or choose a few persons in respect of whom alone the selection could be cancelled and their services in pursuance thereof could be terminated. The illegality and irregularity are so intermixed with the whole process of the selection that it becomes impossible to sort out the right
- 37 -
from the wrong or vice versa. The result of such a selection cannot be relied or acted upon. It is not a case where a question of misconduct on the part of a candidate is to be gone into but a case where those who conducted the selection have rendered it wholly unacceptable. Guilt of those who have been selected is not the question under consideration but the question is, could such selection be acted upon in the matter of public employment? We are therefore of the view that it is not one of those cases where it may have been possible to issue any individual notice or misconduct to each selectee and seek his explanation in regard to the large-scale, widespread and all-pervasive illegalities and irregularities committed by those who conducted the selection which may of course possibly for the benefit of those who have been selected but there may be a few who may have deserved selection otherwise, but it is difficult to separate the cases of some of the candidates from the rest even if there may be some. The decision in the case of Krishan Yadav applies to the facts and circumstances of the present case. The Railway Board's decision to cancel the selection cannot be faulted with. The appeal therefore deserves to be allowed."
30. The judgment in Sunil Kumar Sinha (supra) related to a selection process conducted by the Commission where, in the facts and circumstances of that case, this Court came to the conclusion that the entire selection was completely over-taken by widespread irregularities and, therefore, the only recourse left was to cancel the entire selection process as a whole. That was a case where the answers had to be recorded in H.B. pencil, were later on erased or altered with ulterior motives and monetary gains. As many as 29 persons including the Chairman, two members, a former Chairperson, and other functionaries of the Commission, were arrested, and are now facing
- 38 -
prosecution in the court of the learned Vigilance Court, Patna. The case in hand presents a fundamentally different picture. We, therefore, do not feel the necessity of cancelling the whole of the selection process.
31. Another consideration which weighs in our minds is that, for historical reasons, the vacancies have remained unfilled for a long time, as a result of which the State Government is finding it extremely difficult to carry on its duties and functions. The present selection process is for recruitment to 12 services, and takes care of recruitment for five batches, i.e. from 48th to 52nd batch. The selection process of the 53rd to 55th batch is already due and shall take place in future. The State Government has placed on record its counter affidavit wherein it is stated that, due to paucity of officers, two posts at the block level, namely, Block Development Officer and Circle Officer, are being manned by one person. It is further stated that, as a result of acute shortage of officers, the entire Government is suffering which is adversely affecting the development of the State. In such a situation, we are in no position to sacrifice the larger interest of the State for the objections of a few.
32. We also take judicial notice of the situation in the Bihar Judiciary. For similar reasons, recruitment to the entry level, namely, Civil Judge (Junior Division), could not take place for a number of
- 39 -
years. The Bihar Civil Services (Judicial Branch) Recruitment Rules 1955 similarly provided for selection process for appointment to Civil Judge (Junior Division) once every year after taking into account the anticipated vacancies in the year following. However, examination could not be held each year and 25th Competitive Examination for appointment to the posts of Civil Judges (Junior Division) was held in the year 1999, and appointments were made in the year 2001, against 152 vacancies of Civil Judges (Junior Division). Thereafter examination for the 26th Competitive Examination for appointment to the posts of Civil Judges (Junior Division) was held in the year 2006. Ultimately 318 Civil Judges (Junior Division) were appointed in September 2007, and have after completion of training started functioning as Judicial Magistrate 2nd Class in December 2008. In view of acute paucity of judicial officers at all levels, disposal of cases very badly suffered. It is only in 2009, vacant posts of Sub Judges, Additional District Judges, Additional District Judges (Fast-Track Courts) could be filled up. The situation will improve after they are vested with the powers of Judicial Magistrate 1st Class. The next competitive examination has already been announced and more than 217 vacancies of Civil Judges (Junior Division) will be filled up.
33. This takes us on to the last issue. In view of the foregoing discussion, it is open to us to close the matter. However, there is no
- 40 -
doubt that there were some defects in the selection process which have been taken care of by the Commission by constituting two Committees, and also by its administrative decisions, as a result of which the grievances have been redressed. It is a possible situation that a few may still survive. We accordingly direct, as alternatively submitted by the learned Advocate General, and taking a very liberal view of the matter, that there shall be a fresh PT for the 94 candidates who had, after the PT and before the publication of results, submitted their representations before the Commission for fresh test on the ground that they were supplied with defective Question Booklets which were misbound. Only six from amongst them are writ petitioners. We disagree with the learned Advocate General that the relief may be confined to the six writ petitioners, and would prefer to extend the relief all the 94 complainants which includes the six writ petitioners. This is not in the nature of public interest litigation, the grievances of individual candidates have been considered by the Commission and now being considered by this Court. We find no justification in the submission advanced on behalf of the petitioners to give relief to persons who neither approached the Commission nor this Court. It is a possible situation that persons other than those 94 complainants which include the writ petitioners, may not be left with any genuine grievance. The first round as well as the second round of
- 41 -
the selection process for such candidates shall be as nearly, and as practicable, as possible, close to the format which has already taken place, i.e., in identical format. The third phase of the selection process shall be common to all. This shall not come in the way of the second phase of the selection process scheduled to commence on 25.5.2009.
34. In the result, we modify the order of the learned single Judge. We do not feel the necessity of cancelling the entire selection process of the first phase. The Commission shall hold fresh selection process for the 94 candidates indicated hereinabove. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.
Alert