- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jaya Shankar Singh v. Champa Devi And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is Defendant No. 27 in Title Suit No. 45 of 1974, which was initiated by the Opposite Party seeking a declaration that certain Pattas, Rehans, and Deeds of transfer were void and not binding on them. The petitioner challenged an order dated 16.12.1997 by the Subordinate Judge-IV, Arrah (Bhojpur), which allowed the plaintiff's petition for withdrawal of the suit. Earlier, the petitioner had filed a petition for transposition as plaintiff, which was initially allowed by the trial court but later set aside by this High Court on 11.8.1997 on the ground that transposition requires the defendant to adopt the plaintiff’s case and file a written statement. Subsequently, the petitioner filed a written statement and a fresh petition for transposition under Order I, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The petitioner contended that the plaintiffs and the petitioner had common interests but colluded with other defendants, making transposition necessary to protect the suit. However, the trial court allowed the plaintiffs’ withdrawal petition without considering the petitioner’s transposition petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial court erred in allowing the plaintiffs’ petition for withdrawal of the suit without considering the defendant-petitioner’s petition for transposition as plaintiff under Order I, Rule 10 CPC.
- Whether the petitioner had a right to be transposed as plaintiff given the prior High Court order and the filing of the written statement adopting the plaintiff’s case.
- Whether the plaintiffs had an unqualified right to withdraw the suit under Order XXIII, Rule 1, sub-rule 1 CPC, despite the pendency of the petitioner’s transposition petition.
- Whether the petitioner suffered prejudice or loss due to the withdrawal of the suit without consideration of his transposition petition.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The trial court erred by allowing the plaintiffs’ withdrawal petition without considering the petitioner’s petition for transposition as plaintiff.
- The petitioner had earlier obtained an order allowing transposition, which was only set aside because he had not filed a written statement; after filing the written statement adopting the plaintiff’s case, he filed a fresh petition for transposition which was not considered.
- The petitioner and the husband of plaintiff Opposite Party No. 1 were brothers with common interests, and plaintiffs colluded with other defendants, necessitating transposition to protect the suit.
- The trial court violated Order XXIII, Rule 1-A CPC by not considering whether substantial questions remained to be decided against other defendants.
- Withdrawal of the suit prejudiced the petitioner, who would have suffered no loss if transposition had been allowed.
Plaintiffs’ Arguments
- The plaintiffs filed their petition for withdrawal on 10.9.1997, before the petitioner filed his written statement and transposition petition on 30.9.1997.
- The trial court rightly took up and decided the earlier withdrawal petition first.
- The plaintiffs filed an unconditional withdrawal petition with affidavit, leaving the court no option but to allow it.
- The High Court had never directed the trial court to allow transposition of the petitioner as plaintiff, only to pass a fresh order in accordance with law.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the earlier civil revision by the plaintiffs did not direct the trial court to allow the defendant’s transposition petition but only made an observation for consideration in accordance with law. Since the plaintiffs’ petition for withdrawal was filed prior to the defendant’s petition for transposition, the trial court was justified in taking up and allowing the withdrawal petition first. The Court emphasized that under Order XXIII, Rule 1, sub-rule 1 CPC, a plaintiff has an unqualified right to withdraw a suit simplicitor, and the court is not required to refuse permission to withdraw or compel continuation of the suit, especially when the defendants have not claimed set-off or counter-claims. Additionally, the Court noted that the suit had been pending for over three decades with minimal progress, and no prejudice or loss was caused to the petitioner by the withdrawal, as he retained the right to file a suit independently. Consequently, the Court found no illegality or jurisdictional error in the impugned order.
Holding and Implications
The civil revision petition is dismissed.
The direct effect of this decision is that the order allowing the plaintiffs’ withdrawal of the suit stands affirmed, and the petitioner’s claim for transposition as plaintiff is denied. No new precedent has been established, and the petitioner remains free to initiate a fresh suit for the reliefs claimed. The judgment reinforces the principle that a plaintiff has an unqualified right to withdraw a suit under Order XXIII, Rule 1 CPC, and that procedural timing of petitions is critical in such matters.
S.N Hussain, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. Petitioner is Defendant No. 27 of Title Suit No. 45 of 1974, which was filed by Opposite Party first set for declaration that certain Pattas, Rehans and Deeds of transfer were void and not binding upon them. The defendant-petitioner is aggrieved by the impugned order dated 16.12.1997 passed in the aforesaid suit by which the learned Subordinate Judge-IV, Arrah (Bhojpur), allowed the plaintiff's petition for withdrawal of the suit.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner doggedly challenges the aforesaid impugned order and submits that earlier the defendant-petitioner had filed a petition for transposition as plaintiff in the suit which was allowed by the trial Court on 22.4.1996 But that order was challenged by the plaintiffs in Civil Revision No. 1403 of 1996 and this High Court set aside the order of the trial Court on 11.8.1997 (Annexure-1) on the ground that unless the defendant files his written statement, such petition cannot be allowed, as transposition can be allowed only when the defendant adopts the plaintiff's case.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner further contends that after the aforesaid order of Hon'ble High Court the defendant petitioner filed his written statement on 30.9.1997 (Annexure-7) adopting the original plaintiff's case and on the same day he filed a fresh petition (Annexure-6) under the provision of Order I, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure for being transposed as a plaintiff. The learned counsel for the petitioner also submits that defendant-petitioner and the husband of plaintiff-Opposite Party No. 1 were full brothers and had common and same interest, but since the plaintiffs had gone in collusion with the contesting defendants after the filling of the suit, it was necessary to transpose the petitioner to save, the suit. He further contended that the learned Court below did not consider as to whether any substantial question has to be decided against other defendants and thus violated the specific provision of Order XXIII, Rule 1-A of CPC.
5. It is also stated by the learned counsel for the petitioner that without considering and taking up his petition for transposition, the learned Court below took up the plaintiff's petition for withdrawal of the suit and allowed it by the impugned order, although, had the petitioner's petition for transposition been taken up, he would have been transposed as plaintiff as per the earlier order of the Hon'ble High Court and there would have been no occasion for withdrawal of the suit as claimed by the plaintiffs-opposite parties, and utmost they would have been transposed as defendants as they did not want to continue the suit as plaintiffs and hence they would have suffered no loss at all, but by the withdrawal of the suit the petitioner was greatly prejudiced as he is bound to suffer serious hardships.
6. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs opposite party first set stated that they had filed petition for withdrawal of the suit on 10.9.1997 (Annexure-4) i.e, much before the filing of written statement and petition for transposition by the defendant-petitioner i.e, 30.9.1997 and hence the learned Court below rightly took up and decided the earlier petition first. He further claimed that when both the plaintiffs had filed the petition alongwith affidavit for unconditional withdrawal of the suit, the Court had not option but to allow the said petition. It was also contended on their behalf that this Hon'ble High Court on the earlier occasion never directed the Court below to transpose the petitioner as plaintiff as is apparent from ordtfr dated 11.8.1997 (Annexure-1) and had only directed to pass a fresh order in accordance with law.
7. After considering the arguments of the parties and after perusing the materials on record including the various petitions and orders of this Court as well as of the learned Court below, it is quite apparent that this Court while allowing the earlier civil revision of the plaintiffs did not direct the learned Court below to allow any such claim of the defendants, rather only an observation for consideration in accordance with law was made. It is also clear that the plaintiff's petition for withdrawal of the suit was filed much before the defendant's petition for transposition was filed, hence the learned Court below was fully justified in taking up the plaintiffs; petition first and ence that petition was allowed there was no occasion for consideration of defendant's petition.
8. Furthermore, the plaintiff had an unqualified right to withdraw a suit simplicitor as per the provision of Order XXIII, Rule 1, sub-rule 1 of the CPC which contains no provision which requires the Court to refuse permission to withdraw the suit and compel the plaintiffs to proceed with it, specially when no set-off has been claimed by the defendants nor any counter claim has been raised by them.
9. Moreover, the suit in question was filed more than three decades back and still nothing had been done in it except filing of pleadings by some of the parties. Hence, neither any prejudice is caused to the petitioner nor he has suffered any loss due to the dismissal of the suit, as he has every right to file a suit himself for the reliefs claimed by him… In the said circumstances, I do not find any illegality or jurisdictional error in the impugned order and as such this civil revision is dismissed.
10. Revision dismissed.
Alert