Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Sagar Ram (In 2060) v. Neena Verma (In 3019)

Patna High Court
Jul 22, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion by S.N. Jha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions, disposed of by a common order, concern reimbursement of medical expenses incurred by government servants for specialised treatment received outside the State of Bihar.

CWJC No. 2060/2003 (Petitioner: retired Secretary (Technical), Central Design Organisation): While in service the petitioner underwent coronary artery bypass graft surgery at Escorts Heart Hospital, New Delhi on 21.9.2001. Earlier he was examined at the Indira Gandhi Institute of Cardiology, Patna, which advised referral to AIIMS, New Delhi. Due to his condition he travelled to Delhi on 11.9.2001 and, because of inability to obtain timely admission at AIIMS, underwent surgery at Escorts on 21.9.2001. Post-facto permission for specialised treatment from 11.9.2001 at Delhi was granted on 16.10.2001. On return he submitted a bill for Rs. 2,46,084/- for reimbursement; the claim was rejected by the Deputy Director of Health Services (Administration) by letter dated 15.4.2002 on the ground that outside-state treatment in a private hospital without prior approval was not permissible under the Rules.

CWJC No. 3019/2003 (Filed on behalf of Anil Kumar Verma by his wife after his death): Anil Kumar Verma, a Probation Officer, was diagnosed with cancer of the right cheek and treated initially at Mahabir Cancer Sansthan, Patna and PMCH, which referred him for specialised treatment to Tata Memorial Hospital, Mumbai or AIIMS, New Delhi. He and his family went to New Delhi but, unable to secure admission at AIIMS, he received treatment (surgery and radiotherapy; later chemotherapy cycles) at other New Delhi cancer centres (Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute & Research Centre; Dharmshila Cancer Hospital & Research Centre). He relapsed and was again treated in New Delhi; he died on 10.11.2000. After his death his wife submitted medical bills and originals for Rs. 2,92,791.98 for reimbursement. She was eventually informed on 5.12.2002 that the claim had been rejected at the level of the Chief Minister.

The respondents filed counter-affidavits in both cases, not disputing the factual narratives but contending that the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules do not provide for outside-state treatment except under discretionary relief under Rule 26 and that reimbursement for outside-state treatment is allowed where treatment was received after recommendation by a Medical Board.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether reimbursement of medical expenses incurred for specialised treatment received outside the State can be permitted where prior approval of a Medical Board was not obtained.
  2. Whether the Government's discretion under Rule 26 of the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules can be exercised to allow reimbursement in such circumstances (emergency/urgency or inability to obtain prior Medical Board approval).
  3. Whether petitioners should be reimbursed at the rates applicable to AIIMS (or other specified scale) despite having received treatment at private or other institutions outside the State.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • CWJC No. 2060/2003 petitioner: The petitioner underwent urgent specialised cardiac surgery in Delhi after being unable to obtain timely admission at AIIMS and obtained post-facto permission; he sought reimbursement of Rs. 2,46,084/- which was denied for lack of prior approval.
  • CWJC No. 3019/2003 petitioner (wife of deceased Anil Kumar Verma): The petitioner sought reimbursement of Rs. 2,92,791.98 for extensive cancer treatment in New Delhi, pointing to inability to secure AIIMS admission and urgent need for treatment; counsel stated that reimbursement at AIIMS rates would satisfy the petition in that case.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents acknowledged the factual narratives but contended the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules do not provide for outside-state treatment generally.
  • They relied on Rule 26, which permits the Government to allow medical attendance and treatment not authorised by the Rules by way of concession in special cases, and submitted that reimbursement for outside-state treatment is permitted where treatment was received after recommendation by a Medical Board.
  • The respondents placed on record resolutions, executive orders and circulars on reimbursement for outside-state treatment, summarised in their stance that prior Medical Board recommendation is a necessary precondition for reimbursement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya Bagga, (1998) 4 SCC 117 State obligation under Article 21 read with Article 47 to secure healthy life; recognition that resources are finite and that fixation of rates/scales for reimbursement is permissible. The Court noted the decision's balancing of state obligation and resource limits; it highlighted that the Supreme Court upheld fixation of rates but also examined individual claims and ordered reimbursements or adjustments in particular cases. The present court relied on this approach to justify directing reimbursement (at applicable rates) in individual circumstances despite general regulatory limits.
State of Punjab v. Mohan Lal Jindal, (2001) 9 SCC 217 Principle that a person may be entitled to reimbursement at a particular institutional rate (AIIMS rate in that case) and that additional amounts may be considered on compassionate grounds where circumstances (e.g., inability to obtain timely admission) justify it. The opinion cited this case as authority for awarding reimbursement at AIIMS rates in appropriate cases and for the practice of authorities considering additional amounts on compassionate grounds. The court invoked that route here, directing reimbursement at AIIMS rates and sympathetic consideration of any balance claims.
Anil Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, 2002 (4) PLJR 447 Illustration of administrative exercise of discretion under Bihar rules (Rule 26) in special/urgent medical situations; factual instance where the Health Department representative indicated willingness to look into reimbursement. The court reproduced the quoted observation in which the Commissioner-cum-Secretary (Health) agreed to look into the matter and to reimburse charges as per rule for treatment in a Government hospital. The present court used this as an administrative precedent demonstrating that discretionary relief has been granted in similar urgent cases, supporting its direction for reimbursement here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by applying legal and factual analysis as follows:

  1. It accepted the undisputed factual narratives of both petitioners: that each required urgent specialised treatment outside Bihar, that attempts to secure admission at AIIMS were unsuccessful, and that treatment was therefore taken at other New Delhi institutions.
  2. It noted the respondents' legal stance: the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules (framed in 1947) do not expressly provide for outside-state treatment, but Rule 26 grants the Government discretion to permit treatment not authorised by the Rules in special cases. The respondents asserted that reimbursement for outside-state private treatment is admissible only when treatment was taken after recommendation by a Medical Board.
  3. The court examined relevant precedents: it relied on State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya Bagga and State of Punjab v. Mohan Lal Jindal to observe that while the State's duty to provide medical facilities is constitutionally grounded (Articles 21 and 47), it is constrained by available resources and that fixation of reimbursement rates is permissible; nevertheless, in individual deserving cases the authorities/courts have made adjustments or directed reimbursement at institutional rates (e.g., AIIMS or Escorts rates) and directed consideration of additional amounts on compassionate grounds.
  4. The court also referred to an earlier Bihar decision (Anil Kumar Singh) where administrative willingness to consider reimbursement under Rule 26 in urgent cases had been recorded, illustrating that discretion has been exercised in comparable situations.
  5. On policy and rules, the court observed that the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules, framed in 1947, are archaic and do not reflect contemporary realities where specialised life‑saving treatment often requires travel outside the State. It emphasised that Rule 26's open-ended discretion, without guidelines, risks arbitrary or uneven application.
  6. On the specific question of prior Medical Board approval: the court held that insisting on prior Medical Board approval in emergency cases is "totally unjustified, meaningless and unworkable." Given the undisputed urgency and inability to obtain prior Medical Board sanction in the petitioners' factual circumstances, the court concluded that reimbursement should not be denied on that ground.
  7. Balancing these considerations, and guided by the cited precedents, the court determined that justice would be served by directing reimbursement of the petitioners' claims at rates applicable to AIIMS without insisting on prior Medical Board approval, while directing that any balance claims may be represented and should be sympathetically considered by the authorities.
  8. The court fixed a specific compliance timeline: the amount found due to the petitioners should be paid within six weeks of receipt of a copy of the order.

Holding and Implications

Writ petitions ALLOWED.

Direct consequences and directives given by the court (as expressly stated in the opinion):

  • The respondents are directed to reimburse the petitioners' claims in both cases at the rates applicable to medical treatment and attendance at AIIMS, without insisting on prior approval of a Medical Board.
  • For any balance amount claimed beyond the AIIMS-rate reimbursement, the petitioners may make representation, which the authorities are to consider sympathetically.
  • The respondents are ordered to pay the amount found due within six weeks of receipt of a copy of the order.

Broader observations and policy implications noted by the court (expressed in the opinion):

  • The Bihar Medical Attendance Rules of 1947 are described by the court as archaic and inadequate for present needs; the court recommended suitable amendments and a comprehensive policy (similar to the State of Punjab approach) rather than reliance on ad hoc executive orders or circulars.
  • The court emphasized that Rule 26, while providing discretionary power, requires guidelines to prevent arbitrary exercise; it found the requirement of prior Medical Board approval in emergency situations to be unjustified and unworkable.
  • The court linked these administrative and policy concerns to constitutional values, observing that a well-laid policy would better implement obligations under Articles 21 and 47 and should be consistent with Article 14 (equal treatment and non-arbitrariness).

No assertion of any new legal principle beyond the directions and observations recorded was made; the decision provides relief in the specific cases before the court and records policy concerns for administrative action.

Show all summary ...

S.N Jha, J.:— These two writ petitions involving an identical dispute are disposed of by this common order. The dispute relates to reimbursement of medical expenses incurred by a government servant in connection with treatment outside the State.

2. The facts of CWJC No. 2060/2003 are as follows. The petitioner is retired Secretary (Technical), Central Design Organisation in the Road Construction Department. While in service he underwent coronary artery bypass graft surgery in the Escorts Heart Hospital, New Delhi on 21.9.2001 Earlier he was examined by Dr. R.K Agrawal of the Indira Gandhi Institute of Cardiology Patna who advised him to go to All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) for further treatment. In view of his condition he could not take steps for examination by a Medical Board at Patna and had to rush to Delhi on 11.9.2001 It is relevant to mention here that on 16.10.2001 post-facto permission for specialised treatment from 11.9.2001 at Delhi was granted. According to the petitioner on account of long queue of patients in the AIIMS he could not be admitted there and in the circumstances under medical advice for immediate surgery he was taken to the Escorts Heart Hospital (Escorts Heart Institute and Research Centre Limited) on 13.9.2001 he underwent surgery on 21.9.2001, as stated above. On return from Delhi he submitted bill for Rs. 2,46,084/- for reimbursement of the medical expenses incurred by him in connection with the aforesaid treatment. The request for reimbursement was rejected on the ground that outside state treatment in private hospital without prior approval was not permissible under the Rules. The rejection was communicated by the Deputy Director of Health Services (Administration) by his letter no. 2256(14) dated 15.4.2002

3. CWJC No. 3019/2003 has been filed on behalf of Anil Kumar Verma by his wife after his death. Anil Kumar Verma was Probation Officer in the Home (Jail) Department at Siwan. In the year 1999 a mass was detected on his right cheek which on examination by experts was detected as cancer. He was treated at the Mahabir Cancer Sansthan, Patna to which he was referred by the Patna Medical College & Hospital. After preliminary investigation he was referred to Tata Memorial Hospital, Mumbai or AIIMS New Delhi for specialised treatment. He along with his family members rushed to New Delhi but finding the admission in the AIIMS difficult he went to Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute & Research Centre, New Delhi. There he was operated upon by a panel of doctors headed by Dr. A.K Diwan. He also underwent radiotherapy. He returned to Siwan but the treatment made him very weak. He sent representation to the I.G (Prisons) Bihar for his transfer to Patna but no order was passed. After his condition started deteriorating, he had to be rushed to Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute, New Delhi again where it was detected after investigation that the disease had relapsed. The members of the family tried for admission in the AIIMS on 21.7.2000 for chemotherapy but failed as no bed was available. As the condition further deteriorated he was taken to Dharmshila Cancer Hospital & Research Centre for a chemotherapy cycle from 17.8.2000 to 2.10.2000 Thereafter he returned to Patna. On 2.11.2000 the Radium Institute of PMCH advised him specialised treatment outside the State at New Delhi. On 2.11.2000 he was rushed to New Delhi where he was readmitted in Dharmshila Cancer Centre for another chemotherapy cycle from 3.11.2000 He finally died on 10.11.2000 After his death the petitioner submitted medical bills along with the original papers, for Rs. 2,92,791.98 for reimbursement. She sent reminders and kept running from pillar to post. Finally on 5.12.2002 she was informed by the Assistant Inspector General (Jails) that claim for reimbursement had been rejected at the level of the Chief Minister.

4. The respondents have filed counter affidavit in both the cases. They do not dispute the facts of the two cases as briefly mentioned above. Their stand is that the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules does not provide for outside state treatment. However the Government has discretion under Rule 26 to allow medical attendance and treatment not authorised by the Rules by way of concession in special cases. In CWJC No. 2060/2003 the respondents have brought on record resolution/executive orders/circulars issued from time to time on the point of reimbursement of medical bill with respect to expenses incurred in treatment outside the State. Without referring to the resolutions, circulars etc. it may in a nutshell be stated that according to the respondents reimbursement of the expenses incurred in treatment outside the State can be allowed where such treatment or attendance was received after Medical Board i.e on the recommendation of the Medical Board. It is this aspect of the case which falls for consideration in these two writ petitions.

5. In State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya Bagga (1998) 4 SCC 117, the Supreme Court observed that under Article 21 read with Article 47 of the Constitution it is the duty of the State to secure healthy life to its citizens. The State can neither urge nor say that it has no obligation to provide medical facility. If that were so it would be ex facie violative of Article 21. However the resources of a State or Country are limited and therefore the provision regarding medical facilities cannot be unlimited. It has to be to the extent finances permit. These observations were made in the context of challenge to a policy of the Government of Punjab fixing revised norms for reimbursement of medical bills. The Court rejected the challenge and upheld the principle of fixation of rate and scale for the reimbursement. Nevertheless the Court went into the individual claims of the persons concerned and in the facts and circumstances of the case directed in one case that the amount already paid not to be refunded; in the other case the respondent was held entitled to difference amount between what was paid and the rate admissible in Escorts at the relevant time. In other words, he was held entitled to re-imbursement at the Escorts' rates. (The respondent had received treatment in the Escorts.) Following the said decision, in State of Punjab v. Mohan Lal Jindal, (2001) 9 SCC 217, the Court held that the respondent was entitled to medical reimbursement at the AIIMS rate; however the respondent's representation for reimbursement of the additional amount was ordered to be considered by the authorities on compassionate ground. The argument put forward on behalf of the respondent was that he was a teacher and he could not afford huge medical expenses which had to be incurred by him due to long queue for bypass surgery in the AIIMS and therefore he had to go to other hospital.

6. It appears that the State Government took a somewhat similar stand before this Court in the case of Anil Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, 2002 (4) PLJR 447. The relevant part of the order reads as under:—

“The Commissioner-curn-Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, who is present in Court in another case, was asked about the claim of the petitioner and his attention was specifically drawn towards rule 26 which subscribes relaxation of rules for such cases as to when the petitioner was suffering from Cancer he had his kidney removed within seven days from his being found suffering from the said disease was there any time for him to apply earlier and face a medical board. He immediately opined that he would be looking into the matter and all the re-imbursable charges as per the rule to which he is entitled on being treated in a Government hospital, shall be re-imbursed.”

(emphasis added)

7. In CWJC No. 3019/2003 Counsel for the petitioner stated that the petitioner will be satisfied if a direction is issued for reimbursement of the pending bills at the rates applicable to the AIIMS. In CWJC No. 2060/2003 which had been heard earlier, no such stand was taken therein. However, I am of the view that ends of justice would be served by directing the respondents to reimburse the claim of the petitioners in both the cases at the rates applicable in case of medical treatment and attendance at the AIIMS without insisting on prior approval of the Medical Board. For the balance amount the petitioners may make representation which should be sympathetically considered. The amount found due to the petitioners should be paid within six weeks of receipt of a copy of this order.

8. Before I part with this case I may observe that the Bihar Medical Attendance Rules framed in 1947 i.e more than five decades ago have become archaic. Without going into the question as to whether there was any justification for not making any provision for outside State treatment at the relevant time, a judicial notice can be taken of the fact that most of the serious ailments which are hazardous to life require specialised treatment which is not available in the State of Bihar-muchless in Government Hospitals, and therefore the patient perforce has to go to New Delhi, Mumbai, Vellore or the like for better treatment. It is therefore only appropriate to make suitable amendments in the Rules. As a matter of fact need of the hour is to frame a comprehensive policy or rules as done in the State of Punjab, referred to above, rather than supplement them by executive orders and circulars from time to time. Rule 26 empowers the Government to permit outside State treatment and attendance as a matter of discretion. Inasmuch as guidelines are not laid down the discretion is more often than not abused. While persons close to the powers-that-be manage to get permission, the lessor mortals are not so fortunate to get such permission resulting in heart burning and frustration. So far as the requirement of prior approval of the Medical Board is concerned, in cases of emergency the provision is totally unjustified, meaningless and unworkable. These things can be taken care of in a well laid down policy be consistent with not only Articles 21 and 47 but also Article 14 of the Constitution.

9. In the result, the writ petitions are allowed with the observations and directions made above.