Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Md. Amanullah v. The State Of Bihar & Ors.

Patna High Court
Oct 14, 2003
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.N. Jha, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a permanent employee of Bihar Finished Leathers Limited appointed as an Accounts Assistant, was deputed to the Muzaffarpur Treasury in March 1997 under a state rehabilitation scheme for employees of sick Boards, Corporations and Companies. Deputation was to continue until regular appointment or absorption in the treasury cadre and was subject to periodic performance review. In 2001 four fraudulent withdrawals amounting to Rs. 10,34,368/- relating to a Primary Health Centre were made; an enquiry by the Deputy Development Commissioner followed. The District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur initiated departmental proceedings against the petitioner and issued an order dated 3.4.2003 repatriating him to his parent organisation (Bihar Finished Leathers Ltd.). The petitioner filed this writ petition challenging only the repatriation aspect of that order; the validity of the departmental proceedings was not challenged. The writ petition was heard and dismissed by the Court. A concurring note indicates B.N.P. Singh, J. agreed with the result.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, deputed to the Government Treasury as part of a rehabilitation scheme, has a right to continue on deputation and can resist repatriation to his parent organisation when departmental proceedings have been initiated alleging misconduct.
  2. Whether the policy changes and orders issued after 16.11.1999 (and letters dated 9.8.2002 and 25.9.2002) govern the petitioner's case, given that his deputation began prior to 16.11.1999.
  3. Whether repatriation effected because of alleged misconduct is impermissible where deputation was described as a rehabilitative measure intended to protect livelihood.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Shri Ganesh Prasad Singh)

  • The petitioner was placed on deputation not as an ordinary deputation but as a rehabilitative measure to safeguard livelihood; therefore repatriation to a near-defunct parent company would defeat the purpose of deputation.
  • Deputation in his case preceded the 16.11.1999 policy change and thus the petitioner is not covered by the later resolution/letters (dated 9.8.2002 and 25.9.2002) or by decisions relying on those instruments cancelling post-16.11.1999 deputations.
  • Reliance on authorities (Priya Ranjan Sinha; Bipin Kumar Singh; State of Bihar v. Amar Nath Singh (unreported); Manikant Pathak) to support the proposition that repatriation in the petitioner's circumstances was impermissible.

Respondents' Arguments (as advanced by Shri R.K. Dutta)

  • As a deputationist, the petitioner has no vested right to remain on deputation; a deputation can be terminated by the authority. Reliance was placed on Ratilal B. Soni v. State of Gujarat for this principle.
  • The deputation was expressly subject to screening and quarterly review; continuation depended on satisfactory performance and it was open to the District Magistrate to repatriate employees whose work was not satisfactory.
  • The petitioner was repatriated because he was found prima facie involved in fraudulent withdrawals of government money; repatriation for misconduct was therefore justified and lawful.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Priya Ranjan Sinha v. State of Bihar, 2002 (3) PLJR 33 Relied on by petitioner to support resistance to repatriation in deputation/rehabilitation contexts. The Court noted the petitioner relied on this decision but held the present case differed because repatriation followed alleged misconduct; the decision did not assist the petitioner on the facts.
Bipin Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, 2003 (2) PLJR 493 Relied on by petitioner to challenge repatriation in context of rehabilitative deputation. The Court observed the reliance but concluded the cited decision was of no avail where repatriation was for misconduct.
State of Bihar v. Amar Nath Singh (LPA No. 1566 of 1997) — unreported Relied upon by petitioner (via cited authorities) in support of resisting repatriation. The Court recorded the reliance and distinguished the present case on grounds of misconduct-based repatriation.
Manikant Pathak v. State of Bihar, 1997 (1) PLJR 664 (Full Bench) Relied on by petitioner as authority relevant to deputation/repatriation matters. The Court noted the reliance but treated the present facts as materially different because repatriation resulted from alleged involvement in fraudulent withdrawals.
Ratilal B. Soni v. State of Gujarat, 1990 Supp SCC 243 : AIR 1990 SC 1132 Cited by respondents for the proposition that a deputationist has no right to insist on continuation of deputation; deputationists retain lien in parent organisation and do not gain an equivalent permanent status on the deputation post. The Court relied on this principle to support the conclusion that the petitioner had no vested right to remain on deputation and could be repatriated when prima facie involved in misconduct.
State of Bihar v. Gopal Prasad (LPA No. 482/2003 and analogous) Division Bench decision holding deputations made after 16.11.1999 were not in accordance with government order and repatriation of such employees did not warrant interference. The Court acknowledged this authority in discussing the policy change of 16.11.1999 but distinguished it because the petitioner’s deputation pre-dated that resolution and, more importantly, the repatriation before the Court was for alleged misconduct rather than pursuant to the post-16.11.1999 policy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the central question as whether, notwithstanding the alleged misconduct, the petitioner was entitled to continue on deputation in the government Treasury. The Court proceeded by reference to the express terms of deputation and to established legal principles as follows:

  • Terms of deputation: The deputation was effected pursuant to government letters (including letter dated 1.3.1996 and the deputation list dated 14.3.1997) and expressly made subject to quarterly review and consideration for extension only if performance was satisfactory at the end of the year. Thus, continuance was conditional on satisfactory performance.
  • Legal position on deputation: The Court accepted the legal principle (as cited in Ratilal B. Soni) that a deputationist does not acquire a vested right to remain on the deputation post; deputationists retain lien in their parent organisations and cannot claim status equivalent to the deputation post.
  • Effect of policy changes: Although the petitioner’s deputation pre-dated the 16.11.1999 policy decision that sought to stop deputations from Boards/Corporations, the Court treated that temporal distinction as irrelevant to the dispositive issue because the repatriation now challenged was taken on grounds of alleged misconduct rather than pursuant to the post-1999 policy.
  • Misconduct as basis for repatriation: The petitioner was found prima facie involved in fraudulent withdrawals of government money (approx. Rs. 10 lacs) on the basis of fake bills; departmental proceedings were initiated and repatriation issued. Given that deputation continuation was expressly contingent on satisfactory performance, and given the prima facie finding of involvement in serious misconduct, the Court held the petitioner could not claim a right to remain on deputation.
  • Practical and procedural considerations: The Court noted parties' submissions that if repatriation were disallowed the District Magistrate might be constrained to award only minor punishment (with major penalties being reserved to the principal employer). The Court accepted that submission as well founded but observed it was unnecessary to address the larger question of the effect of repatriation on the petitioner’s livelihood in this case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was dismissed (the petition challenging repatriation was dismissed) and the Court made no order as to costs. B.N.P. Singh, J. agreed with the result.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner remains subject to repatriation to his parent organisation and to the ongoing disciplinary process; he has no judicial entitlement to continue on the deputation post in the face of prima facie findings of misconduct.
  • No expansion of law: The Court distinguished other authorities relied upon by the petitioner and based its decision on the established principle that deputationists have no vested right to remain on deputation and on the specific fact of alleged involvement in fraudulent withdrawals. The opinion does not purport to create a new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts before it.

Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add factual or legal information not contained therein.

Show all summary ...

S.N Jha, J.:— This writ petition on behalf of the sole petitioner is directed against the order of the District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur dated 3.4.2003 by which a departmental proceeding has been initiated against him and he has been repatriated to his parent organisation, namely, Bihar Finished Leathers Limited. It may straightaway be stated that validity of the departmental proceeding is not under challenge in this writ petition, the petitioner is only aggrieved by the repatriation part of the order.

2. The case of the petitioner is that he was appointed as Accounts Assistant in the Bihar Finished Leathers Limited, a government company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1979. In 1990 the financial condition of the company deteriorated so much so that it was not in a position to even pay salary to its employees. Like this company, many Boards and Corporations of the State too had become sick. The State Government came out with a scheme for rehabilitation of the employees of such Boards, Corporations and Companies vide letter no. 128 dated 1.3.1996 of the Finance Department. At the first instance they were deputed as Accounts Clerk in different District Treasuries/Sub-Treasuries after observing a selection procedure. Such deputation was to continue till regular appointment on the post or their absorption in the cadre of treasury employees. The case of the petitioner is that in the aftermath of the fodder scam in the State of Bihar, vacancies occurred on the post of Accounts Clerk in different Treasuries/Sub-Treasuries in the State and therefore while the employees of the concerned Boards/Corporations had to be rehabilitated, the government too needed employees to man those posts. The deputation of the employees was thus to serve dual purpose. In the light of above said letter of the Finance Department dated 1.3.1996, the Directorate of Treasuries issued letter no. 305 dated 6.6.1996 for deputation of the suitable employees of the Boards and Corporations on the vacant posts in the Treasuries. Accordingly, on 14.3.1997 a list of employees of 16 Boards and Corporations including Bihar Finished Leathers Limited found suitable was finalised by the Directorate of Treasuries and sent to the Department for their deputation in different Treasuries. The petitioner was one of them. He was the solitary employee of the Bihar Finished Leathers Ltd. found suitable. He was deputed to Muzaffarpur Treasury by the said letter dated 14.3.1997 The further case of the petitioner is that Treasury Officer, Muzaffarpur allotted work of different treasury heads amongst Accounts Clerks as per duty charge and the petitioner discharged his functions as per the roster honestly, sjncerely and to the satisfaction of superior officers. In the year 2001 four fraudulent withdrawals against fake bills amounting to Rs. 10,34,368/- appertaining to Primary Health Centre, Daudpur Paroo, took place. An enquiry was held by Deputy Development Commissioner. The petitioner was asked to explain certain acts of omission and commission relating to the said withdrawals. He submitted explanation. However, without considering the same, the impugned order was issued initiating departmental proceeding against him and repatriating him to his parent organisation i.e Bihar Finished Leathers Ltd. On behalf of the respondents counter affidavit affirmed by Treasury Officer, Muzaffarpur has been filed wherein it has been stated that the petitioner was found prima facie involved in the fraudulent withdrawals of money and accordingly departmental proceeding was initiated against him on 3.4.2003 followed by charge memo on 31.5.2003 As already indicated above, validity of the disciplinary proceeding is not under challenge and therefore it is futile to refer to facts relating to the fraudulent withdrawals.

3. As regards his repatriation, the case of the petitioner is that as Bihar Finished Leathers Ltd. is virtually non-existent, his repatriation cannot be said to be in accord with the purpose for which the petitioner was deputed to the district Treasury, namely, rehabilitation of the employees of the concerned Boards and Corporations. The deputation was on the basis of selection and on the premise that the same would continue till regular appointment is made on the post or the employees so deputed are absorbed in the cadre of treasury employees. The impugned repatriation in the circumstances would not only render the petitioner without any means of livelihood but also be counter productive of the objects of deputation.

4. Shri Ganesh Prasad Singh, learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that it is true that the petitioner like others was brought on the post of Accounts Clerk in the district Treasury on deputation but it was not an ordinary deputation which could be terminated at any point of time. The deputation was a measure of rehabilitation so as to safeguard life and liberty of the employees of the concerned Boards and Corporations, in true spirit of governance in a welfare state and therefore the respondent District Magistrate was not justified in repatriating the petitioner to his parent organisation which would land him without any source of livelihood. Reliance was placed on decisions in Priya Ranjan Sinha v. State of Bihar, 2002 (3) PLJR 33 and Bipin Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, 2003 (2) PLJR 493-by a learned Single Judge, an unreported order in LPA No. 1566 of 1997 (State of Bihar v. Amar Nath Singh)- by a Division Bench, besides a Full Bench decision in Manikant Pathak v. State of Bihar, 1997 (1) PLJR 664.

5. On behalf of the respondents Shri R.K Dutta, leaned Standing Counsel No. 4, submitted that as a deputationist the petitioner has no right to remain on deputation post. He referred to the case of Ratilal B. Soni v. State of Gujarat, 1990 Supp SCC 243 : AIR 1990 SC 1132. As regards the instant case, he submitted that the petitioner has been repatriated on account of his misconduct. It was pointed out that the government order contained in letter dated 1.3.96 (supra) envisaged screening of the employees for finding out their suitability. In the letter of deputation dated 14.3.97 (supra) too it was made clear that the deputation was subject to quarterly review of the employees and only on their work being found satisfactory at the end of the year, they could be considered for extension of their deputation. After the Directorate of Treasuries was abolished and the employees of the Treasury were brought under the control of the concerned District Magistrate, fresh guidelines were framed by the Finance Department vide letter no. 6749 dated 7.10.1999 wherein also it was stipulated that continuance of the employees in the Treasury/Collectorate would depend on satisfactory service during the period of deputation and that it would be open to the District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner to repatriate such employees whose work was not found satisfactory during deputation period, which too implies that continuance of the deputed employees was dependent on their satisfactory work.

6. It is relevant to mention here that a policy decision was taken on 16.11.1999 not to make any deputation from the Boards and Corporation of the State Government and in the light of said policy decision, on 9.8.2002 by letter no. 6403 the Finance Department cancelled the said letter dated 7.10.1999 The letter states that services of the Board/Corporation employee deputed in Treasuries after 16.11.1999 be immediately returned to their parent Board/Corporation. The direction was reiterated by letter no. 7752 dated 25.9.2002 of the Finance Department. A Division bench of this Court in LPA no. 482/2003 and analogous (State of Bihar v. Gopal Prasad) has accordingly held that deputation in government treasuries made after 16.11.1999 was not in accordance with the said Government Order and repatriation of the concerned employees did not warrant any interference. The order of the learned Single Judge by which such repatriation had been cancelled was set aside.

7. Shri Ganesh Prasad Singh submitted that deputation of the petitioner being prior to 16.11.1999, the petitioner is not covered by the resolution dated 16.11.1999 and/or letters dated 9.8.2002 and 25.9.2002 or decision of this Court in LPA No. 482/2003 and analogous. The submission to this extent appears to be well founded. However in my opinion the real issue involved in the present writ petition is whether notwithstanding the misconduct allegedly committed by the petitioner he is entitled to continue on deputation post in the government Treasury. It may be that deputation was intended to provide better opportunities to the petitioner-described by him as ‘rehabilitation’, while filling the vacant posts of Accounts Clerk, in the treasury at the same time, the deputation however was not on absolute terms, it was subject to the scrutiny of performance in every quarter and therefore where the work/performance of the concerned employee was not found to be satisfactory in terms of letter dated 14.3.1997 (supra), the authority would certainly be competent entitled to return him to his parent organisation. Besides the express terms of deputation, the position in law is well settled that a deputationist has no right to continue on the deputation post. Being permanent employee of the respective Board and Corporation the deputationists hold lien in the concerned Boards/Corporation and cannot claim an equivalent status on the deputation post in the government Treasury. The petitioner thus cannot claim any vested right that he cannot be repartiated to his parent organisation notwithstanding his alleged misconduct.

8. Shri Ganesh Prasad Singh submitted that the petitioner has no objection to the initiation of the departmental proceeding and if the charge is proved against him, he may be dismissed from service. Learned Standing Counsel submitted that though departmental proceeding has been initiated against the petitioner, no major penalty can be awarded to him by the District Magistrate, which can be done only by his principal employer. Thus if the petitioner is not allowed to be repatriated to his parent organisation, the result would be that he may have to be let off with some minor punishment—in the event charge against him is proved in the enquiry, which would not be in the interest of justice. The submission of the Counsel appears to be well founded. In the facts of the case it is not necessary to go into the larger question as to effect of repatriation on the petitioner's livelihood—considering which in some of the cases this Court interfered with repatriation orders. Even if it is accepted that the petitioner's deputation to government treasury was as a measure of rehabilitation, in order to provide him livelihood, this cannot be stretched to give a carte blanche to commit misconduct and yet remain on deputation post on the plea that he was brought on deputation as a rehabilitatory measure and if the deputation is cancelled it would affect his livelihood.

9. The repatriation in the instant case being sequel to misconduct, the decision cited on behalf of the petitioner are of no avail to him. It is true that the resolution dated 16.11.1999 does not affect the deputation made in the past and therefore they are not covered by decisions as contained in letters dated 9.8.2002 and 25.9.2002 directing cancellation of all deputations of the Corporations/Boards employees in the Government Treasuries or the order in LPA No. 482 of 2003. The present case stands on a different footing inasmuch as the petitioner has been repatriated not pursuant to resolution dated 16.11.1999 or decisions/letters referred to above, but on account of his misconduct. If the continuance of deputation was subject to satisfactory performance, having been found prima facie involved in the fraudulent withdrawals of government money to the tune of Rs. 10 lacs on the basis of fake bills, the petitioner cannot claim any right to remain in the government Treasury. I thus do not find any merit in the grievance of the petitioner. In the result, the writ petition is dismissed but without any order as to costs.

10. B.N.P Singh, J.:—I agree.