- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Yugeshwar Nath Mishra v. Arpana Kumari & Anr.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an application under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash two lower court orders: the Magistrate's order dated 5.10.1999 in Misc. No. 122 of 1996 (Trial No. 387 of 1999) recorded by the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Ara, and the order dated 5.8.2000 in Criminal Revision No. 288 of 1999 recorded by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Ara.
The underlying maintenance petition was initiated by Vidyawati Devi and her daughter Arpana Kumari under section 125 CrPC. Vidyawati died during the proceedings and her daughter Arpana continued the case. Arpana Kumari, an unmarried female who deposed on 31.5.1999 stating her age as 18, was granted maintenance by the Magistrate at the rate of Rs. 500 per month until she married or could maintain herself, on the basis of the Supreme Court decision in Noor Saba Khatoon v. Mohd. Quasim.
The Magistrate's order was challenged in Criminal Revision No. 288 of 1999; the Sessions Judge upheld the Magistrate's order on 5.8.2000, rejecting the petitioner's contention that the Noor Saba Khatoon decision applied only to Muslim female children. The present section 482 petition challenges the orders on the ground that maintenance under section 125 CrPC could not have been granted to a major female child born to a Hindu parent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether maintenance under section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure can be granted to a major unmarried female child born to a Hindu parent.
- Whether the principle in Noor Saba Khatoon (which treated a Muslim daughter as entitled to maintenance till marriage) is applicable to Hindu parents or can be applied by analogy when read with the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956.
- How to reconcile the provisions of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (notably section 20 and the related sections 21 and 22) with section 125 CrPC with regard to the maintenance entitlement of an unmarried daughter (including whether sub‑section (3) of section 20 is limited by sub‑section (2)).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The primary contention advanced by the petitioner (the party seeking to quash the orders) was that maintenance under section 125 CrPC could not be granted to a major female child born to a Hindu parent, implying that the Magistrate and the Sessions Court erred in awarding maintenance to Arpana Kumari, who had attained majority.
- The petitioner also argued (as noted in the Sessions Court) that the Supreme Court decision in Noor Saba Khatoon applied only to Muslim female children and was not authority for granting maintenance to a Hindu major daughter under section 125 CrPC.
Opposite Party No. 1's Arguments (Arpana Kumari)
- Learned counsel for Arpana Kumari argued that, apart from Noor Saba Khatoon, a Hindu father is liable to maintain his unmarried daughter under section 20 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, and therefore by analogy and harmonious construction the orders of the lower courts are valid and legal.
- The argument relied on the provisions of the Maintenance Act (sections 20, 21 and 22) which, as contended, treat an unmarried daughter as a dependent "so long as she remains unmarried" and thus entitled to maintenance irrespective of majority.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Noor Saba Khatoon v. Mohd. Quasim, 1997 (2) P.L.J.R (SC) 110 | Held that under Muslim personal law and section 125 CrPC a Muslim father having sufficient means is bound to maintain his female child until she gets married (and generally until majority or marriage), and that such a claim under section 125 is not curtailed by rights of a divorced wife under the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986. | The court considered Noor Saba Khatoon as demonstrating that where personal law imposes an obligation (Muslim law here) the protective scope of section 125 may extend to a female child until marriage. The court used this principle as a basis to consider analogous protection for unmarried Hindu daughters by reading section 125 in harmony with the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by textual and contextual analysis of the statutes involved and by harmonizing provisions:
- The court first examined section 125 CrPC. It observed that section 125, by its plain terms, provides maintenance for a "legitimate or illegitimate minor child" and, in limited circumstances, for a child who has attained majority but is physically or mentally unable to maintain himself or herself. Thus, as written, section 125 primarily contemplates maintenance for minors unless specific exceptions apply.
- The court reviewed Noor Saba Khatoon, noting that the Supreme Court relied on Muslim personal law (as described in Tahir Mahmood's text) to conclude that a Muslim father's obligation to maintain a daughter continues until she marries; the Supreme Court therefore allowed maintenance under section 125 for the period until marriage or self‑support.
- Turning to Hindus, the court examined the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956. Section 20(2) provides that a child may claim maintenance "so long as the child is a minor." Section 20(3), however, extends the obligation "to the extent the parent is unable to maintain himself or herself out of his or her own earnings or other property" and specifically mentions an unmarried daughter without prescribing an age limit.
- The court then analysed sections 21 and 22 of the Maintenance Act. Section 21 defines dependents: sons (legitimate or illegitimate) are dependents "so long as he is a minor", whereas an unmarried daughter is a dependent "so long as she remains unmarried" (explicitly irrespective of being a minor). Section 22 provides that dependents are entitled to maintenance out of the estate of the deceased, reinforcing the idea that an unmarried daughter may be maintained even after attaining majority.
- From these statutory provisions the court concluded that a clear legislative distinction exists between sons (dependents only while minors) and daughters (dependents so long as they remain unmarried). Accordingly, an unmarried daughter—whether minor or major—is capable of being a dependent under the Maintenance Act and can claim maintenance.
- The court emphasised the principle of harmonious construction: where two statutes grant essentially the same relief, they should be read together and not in contradiction. Therefore it is not appropriate to deny maintenance under one statute to a category of persons who are entitled to maintenance under another statute dealing with the same subject‑matter.
- The court also invoked social and purposive considerations: the Maintenance Act and section 125 CrPC are beneficial provisions reflecting societal realities where unmarried daughters may lack independent means and remain dependent on parents until marriage; these realities support a construction that protects unmarried daughters.
- Applying this reasoning, the court found no ground to interfere with the lower courts' orders that granted maintenance to Arpana Kumari, and concluded that the orders were legally tenable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is dismissed and the impugned orders are upheld. The court's core ruling is:
DISMISSED — the petition under section 482 CrPC is dismissed and the orders granting maintenance to the unmarried daughter are sustained.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The Magistrate's order dated 5.10.1999 and the Sessions Judge's order dated 5.8.2000, which granted maintenance of Rs. 500 per month to Arpana Kumari until she marries or is able to maintain herself, remain in force.
- Statutory interpretation: The court held that an unmarried daughter (whether minor or major) is a dependent under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act and is entitled to maintenance so long as she remains unmarried and is unable to maintain herself. The provisions of the Maintenance Act (sections 20, 21 and 22) must be read in harmony with section 125 CrPC where similar relief is concerned.
- Broader precedent: The opinion applies existing statutory provisions and the reasoning in Noor Saba Khatoon by analogy; it does not purport to create an entirely new legal doctrine beyond harmonising the Maintenance Act and section 125 CrPC for the facts before the court. The immediate consequence is the upholding of maintenance entitlement for the specific claimant (Arpana Kumari) in this matter.
This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what appears in that text.
1. This is an application under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Code’) for quashing order dated 5.10.1999 in Case no. Misc. 122 of 1996 corresponding to Trial no. 387 of 1999 recorded by Sri Rajendra Kumar Singh, Judicial Magistrate, first class, Ara as well order dated 5.8.2000 recorded in Cr. Rev. no. 288 of 1999 by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Ara. In this case learned counsel for the petitioner, for opposite party no. 1, Arpana Kumari, and learned Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the State have been heard. This application, therefore, is being disposed of at this stage.
2. One Vidyawati Devi, who had expired in course of the proceeding and Arpana Kumari, her daughter, had filed a petition under section 125 of the Code for their maintenance. On death of her mother the daughter continued to prosecute the case. Arpana Kumari was unmarried who had stated her age to be eighteen years on the date of her deposition, on 31.5.1999 The case was contested and in the final order the learned Magistrate directed payment of maintenance at the rate of rupees five hundred her month to Arpana Kumari till she got married or was able to maintain herself, whichever was earlier. This order was passed in view of a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Noor Saba Khatoon v. Mohd. Quasim; 1997 (2) P.L.J.R (SC) 110. That order was challenged in Cr. Rev. no. 288 of 1999 which was disposed of by the learned First Additional Sessions Judge, Bhojpur at Ara on 5.8.2000 by which, rejecting the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the aforesaid decision of the Apex Court was applicable only in the case of a Muslim female child, the court upheld the order of the lower court. In this case the only point that has been argued before me was that maintenance under section 125 of the Code could not have been granted to a major female child born to a Hindu parent, hence to that extent the orders of the lower courts could not be upheld. On the other hand, learned counsel for the opposite party no. 1, Arpana Kumari, argued that apart from the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Noor Saba Khatoon, a Hindu father was also liable to maintain his unmarried daughter under section 20 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the “Maintenance Act”, in short), hence on the same analogy as in the decision of the Supreme Court in the aforesaid case, the orders of the learned lower court must be held to be valid and legal. The relevant portion of section 125 of the Code is reproduced below:
“125. Order for maintenance of wives, children and parents.—(1) If any person having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain
(a) his wife, unable to maintain herself, or
(b) his legitimate or illegitimate minor child, whether married or not, unable to maintain itself, or
(c) his legitimate or illegitimate child (not being a married daughter) who has attained majority, where such child is by reason of any physical or mental abnormality or injury unable to maintain itself, or
(d) his father or mother, unable to maintain himself or herself,
a Magistrate of the first class may, upon proof of such neglect or refusal, order such person to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of his wife or such child, father or mother, at such monthly rate not exceeding five hundred rupees in the whole, as such Magistrate thinks fit, and to pay the same to such person as the Magistrate may from time to time direct:
Provided that the Magistrate may order the father of a minor female child referred to in clause (b) to make such allowance, until she attain her majority, if the Magistrate is satisfied that the husband of such minor female child, if married, is not possessed of sufficient means.
Explanation.—For the purpose of this Chapter,—(a) “minor” means a person who, under the provisions of the Indian Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875), is deemed not to have attained his majority….. .”
3. From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision it will appear that any person having sufficient means neglect or refuses to maintain his legitimate or illegitimate minor child or such a child, not being a married daughter, who has attained majority when such child is by reason of any physical or mental abnormality or injury unable to maintain himself, can be granted such a monthly allowance for his/her maintenance as the Magistrate may deem fit. From a plain reading of this provision it will appear that a father having sufficient means is bound to maintain a normal minor child, male or female irrespective of the fact whether such child is married.
4. In the beginning the argument of the learned counsel for opposite party no. 1 was that the decision in the case of Noor Saba Khatoon (supra) applied equally to Hindu parents.
5. It will appear that in that case while deciding the maintenance of a Muslim female child their Lordships had referred to a book authored by Proof. Tahir Mahmood “Statute-Law relating to Muslims in India” (1995 Edition) and in so far as a Muslim child was concerned, had quoted as follows—“by Muslim Law maintenance (Nafaqa) is a birth right of children and an absolute liability of the father. Daughters are entitled to maintenance till they get married if the are bakira (maiden) or till they get re-married if they are thayiba (divorcee/widow)….”. Noting this their Lordship further observed that both under personal law and statutory law (section 125 of the Code) the obligation of a Muslim father, having sufficient means, to maintain his minor children, unable to maintain themselves, till they attain majority and in case of female child till they get married, was absolute. Thus, their Lordships allowed the female child of Muslim parents (paragraph 10) to claim maintenance under section 125 of the Code for the period till they attained majority or were able to maintain themselves, whichever was earlier, and in case of a female, till they got married holding that this right was not restricted, effected or controlled by divorced wife's right to claim maintenance for the infant child or children under her custody till two years from the date of birth of child concerned under section 3(1)(b) of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986.
6. Notwithstanding the fact that section 125 of the Code is applicable to grant maintenance only to a child male or female, who is a normal child till he attains majority under the provisions of Indian Majority Act, 1875, a Muslim father was held bound to maintain a female child till she was married, under section 125 of the Code read with Muslim Personal law in that regard.
7. The Maintenance Act is applicable to a person who is a Hindu by religion as defined under section 2 of that Act. Petitioner here is a Hindu. Section 20 of the Maintenance Act is reproduced below.
“Maintenance of Children and aged parents.—“(1) Subject to the provisions of this section a Hindu is bound, during his or her lifetime, to maintain his or her legitimate or illegitimate children and his or her aged or infirm parents.
(2) A legitimate or illegitimate child may claim maintenance from his or her father or mother so long as the child is a minor.
(3) The obligation of a person to maintain his or her aged or infirm parent or a daughter who is unmarried extends in so far as the parent or the unmarried daughter, as the case may be, is unable to maintain himself or herself out of his or her own earnings or other property.
Explanation.—In this section “parent” includes a childless step-mother.”
8. Under sub-section (2) of section 20 a legitimate or illegitimate child may claim maintenance from his father or mother so long as the child is minor but sub-section (3) defines the extent of the liability of a person for maintaining such dependent including a daughter who is unmarried providing that he would be liable to maintain them so long such person, including unmarried daughter, is unable to maintain himself or herself out of his/her own earning or other property. A question here may arise as to whether the scope of sub-section (3) which also speaks of maintaining unmarried daughter without providing for her age could be limited by sub-section (2) of section 20.
9. To answer this question sections 21 and 22 of the Maintenance Act may also be taken into account. Section 21 defines the dependents and section 22 deals with the maintenance of dependents. In so far as son and daughter are concerned as dependents, the relevant portions of section 21 is reproduced below:
“21. Dependents defined.—For the purpose of this chapter “dependents” mean the following relatives of the deceased:
……………………………………………..
……………………………………………..
(iv) his or her son or the son of his predeceased son or the son of a predeceased son of his predeceased son, so long as he is a minor: provided and to the extent that he is unable to obtain maintenance, in the case of a grandson from his father's or mother's estate, and in the case of a great-grandson, from the estate of his father or mother or father's father or father's mother;
(v) his or her unmarried daughter, or the unmarried daughter of his predeceased son or the unmarried daughter of a pre-deceased son of his predeceased son, so long as she remains unmarried; provided and to the extent that she is unable to obtain maintenance in the case of a grand-daughter from her father's or mother's estate and in the case of a great-grand-daughter from the estate or her father or mother or father's father or father's mother:
……………………………………………..
……………………………………………..
(viii) his or her minor illegitimate son, so long as he remains a minor;
(ix) his or her illegitimate daughter, so long as she remains unmarried.”
10. From a reading of aforesaid provision it is manifest that the son legitimate or illegitimate is considered to be a dependent so long as he remains minor, but a daughter is a dependent so long she remains unmarried irrespective of the fact whether or not she is a minor.
11. The relevant portion of section 22 of the Maintenance Act’ is also reproduced:
“22. Maintenance of dependents.—(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (2) the heirs of a deceased Hindu are bound to maintain the dependents of the deceased out of the estate inherited by them from the deceased.
(2) Where a dependent has not obtained, by testamentary or intestate succession, any share in the estate of a Hindu dying after the commencement of this Act, the dependent shall be entitled, subject to the provisions of this Act, to maintenance from those who take the estate.”
12. A dependent, who may be unmarried daughter is, under the given circumstances, entitled to maintenance even out of the estate of the deceased. Therefore, it has to be held that an unmarried daughter, whether minor or major, is entitled to maintenance.
13. If two statutes grant the same relief then both the provisions have to be read in harmony, not in contradiction. That is to say, that it would not be a proper construction of law to hold that under one statute a dependent (read unmarried daughter, minor or major) would be entitled to maintenance but, in other statute providing for the same relief, that dependent would be denied the relief of maintenance on the ground that she was a major. On similar premises their lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Noor Saba Khatoon (supra) had held that an unmarried Muslim female child would be entitled to maintenance though application was filed under section 125 of the Code.
14. A law reflects the ground realities prevailing in the society to which it is applicable and while interpreting law such ground realities are also to be taken into account, particularly when it is a piece of beneficial legislation. By and large unmarried daughters, having no property or personal income, have to be dependent for their maintenance upon their parents as without that protection most of them could be exposed to the dangers that stalk a female child in the society. However, situation would be different if a female child, though a minor, is married because in that situation it would be the lawful responsibility of her husband to maintain her. But, otherwise, till she is unmarried, it will be the legal responsibility of her parents to maintain her till she marries.
15. This being so, I find no scope for interfering with the impugned orders. The petition, therefore, stands dismissed.
Alert