Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Narayan Das Sharma And Others, Etc. v. State Of Bihar And Others

Patna High Court
Jan 24, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Judgment by S.N. Jha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions (C.W.J.C No. 8655/2000 and C.W.J.C No. 11341/2000) concern filling vacancies reserved for Scheduled Tribes (ST) in the Bihar Subordinate Judicial Service arising from the 24th and 25th Judicial Service Examinations. The petitioners (practicing advocates) sought quashing of (a) the State Government's decision to keep 23 ST vacancies reserved/carry them forward for three years under sub-section 6(a) of Section 4 of the Bihar Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services Act, 1992 (“Reservation Act”) (letter No. 6749 dated 18-8-2000) and (b) the Bihar Public Service Commission's decision to keep unfilled ST posts vacant for non-availability of eligible candidates in respect of the 25th Examination.

Relevant chronology and procedural posture as reflected in the opinion: - Advertisement and written examination for the 24th Judicial Service Examination were issued/held in 1990 and April 1991 respectively; written result published 18-4-1994; interviews and final result published 14-5-1994 but appointments were stayed because of an interim order from the Supreme Court dated 13-5-1994 (later modified on 16-11-1995). - The applicability of the Reservation Ordinance/Act to judicial service recruitment was earlier challenged and this Court held it did not apply; the State took SLP to the Supreme Court which ultimately dismissed the SLP on 14-3-2000 in State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah [(2000) 4 SCC 640], holding the Reservation Act does not apply to recruitment in the Bihar Subordinate or Superior Judicial Service governed by rules framed under Article 234. - Following the Supreme Court's decision, the State Government issued letter No. 6749 dated 18-8-2000 directing the Commission to reserve/carry forward vacancies under Section 4(6)(a) of the Reservation Act for three years; the Commission had earlier kept certain ST posts vacant for non-availability of eligible candidates in the 25th Examination. - Petitioners sought directions that vacancies be filled in accordance with Rule 20 of the Bihar Civil Service (Judicial Branch) (Recruitment) Rules, 1955 (“Recruitment Rules”) by preparing a supplementary list from the merit list under Rule 19.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government could direct that unfilled ST vacancies be carried forward/reserved for three years under sub-section 6(a) of Section 4 of the Reservation Act in light of the Supreme Court's decision in State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah.
  2. Whether the Bihar Public Service Commission could keep unfilled ST posts vacant for non-availability of eligible candidates instead of preparing a supplementary list from the merit list under Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules.
  3. Whether Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules requires the Commission to submit a supplementary list drawn from the merit list prepared under Rule 19 (i.e., whether the supplementary list is restricted to SC/ST candidates or may include general-category candidates from the merit list when SC/ST candidates of requisite standard are not available).
  4. Whether the proviso to Rule 17 (relaxation to admit SC/ST to viva voce with prior government approval) can be invoked after the viva voce/tests are over and the merit list is prepared so as to justify not submitting a supplementary list under Rule 20.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners challenged the State Government's direction to carry forward ST vacancies and the Commission's decision to keep ST posts vacant, seeking quashing of both actions and a direction to fill vacancies by following Rule 20 (i.e., by preparing a supplementary list from the merit list under Rule 19).

Commission's Arguments

  • The Commission stated its role is limited to conducting examinations and recommending successful candidates; it claimed it has no role in deciding the number of vacancies, categories for recommendations, or de-reservation of reserved vacancies.
  • In the counter-affidavit (for the 25th Examination matter) the Commission contended that, in view of the proviso to Rule 17, it was under a bona fide impression that it should first seek Government approval to exercise discretion under Rule 17 (to admit SC/ST candidates to viva voce despite not meeting written minimum marks) and that Rule 20 would become relevant only thereafter.
  • Counsel for the Commission (Shri Ashok Kumar Choudhary) argued that Rule 17 permits relaxation of qualifying marks for SC/ST with prior Government approval and thus Rule 20 comes into play only after that exercise; this was advanced to justify not invoking Rule 20 immediately after preparing the merit list.

State Government's Arguments

  • The State Government, through the Deputy Secretary (author of the impugned letter), justified the direction to carry forward vacancies by reference to Section 4(6)(a) of the Reservation Act and returned recommendations relating to OBC candidates (though the opinion notes the present matters concern ST vacancies only).
  • The affidavit by the State's Under-Secretary in the other petition did not add significant material according to the court's account.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah, (2000) 4 SCC 640 Held that Section 4 of the Reservation Act does not apply to recruitment in the Bihar Subordinate Judicial Service or Bihar Superior Judicial Service, which are governed by statutory rules framed under Article 234 of the Constitution (i.e., recruitment Rules). The court relied on this decision to conclude that the Reservation Act could not be invoked to justify the State Government's direction under Section 4(6)(a) to carry forward ST vacancies; consequently the Government's instruction in letter dated 18-8-2000 was not in accordance with law.
Surendra Narain Singh v. State of Bihar, (1998) 5 SCC 246 : AIR 1998 SC 1841 Interpreted Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules: the expression "such candidates" in Rule 20 must be understood to refer to candidates who figure in the merit list prepared under Rule 19 (not exclusively to SC/ST), and the Commission must prepare a supplementary list from that merit list; there is no provision to carry forward reserved vacancies under the 1955 Rules. The court applied this authoritative interpretation to hold that Rule 20 requires the Commission to submit a supplementary list from the merit list when adequate SC/ST candidates are not available, and that vacancies cannot be carried forward or be kept pending for future years.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by linking the factual matrix to the governing statutory and rule provisions, and to controlling Supreme Court precedent:

  1. Precedent Control: The court took as decisive the Supreme Court's holding in State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah that the Reservation Act does not apply to recruitment into subordinate or superior judicial services governed by rules under Article 234. Because recruitment to the Bihar Subordinate Judicial Service is governed by the Recruitment Rules, the State Government could not lawfully rely on Section 4(6)(a) of the Reservation Act to order carry-forward of vacancies.
  2. Interpretation of Rule 20: The court relied on Surendra Narain Singh v. State of Bihar for the construction of Rule 20. That decision held that "such candidates" in Rule 20 refers to candidates from the merit list prepared under Rule 19, and that the Commission must prepare a supplementary list from that merit list if the initial list under Rule 19 does not contain an adequate number of SC/ST candidates suitable for appointment. The court adopted this interpretation as fully applicable to the present disputes.
  3. Consequences for Carry‑Forward and Vacancy‑Holding: Because the 1955 Recruitment Rules contain no provision to carry forward reserved vacancies, neither the State Government nor the Commission had authority to carry forward vacancies for years or to keep them vacant on account of non-availability. The court held that the vacancies must be addressed by the mechanism in Rules 19 and 20, not by reservation under the Reservation Act or by administrative carry-forward.
  4. On Rule 17 Reliance: The court examined the Commission's reliance on the proviso to Rule 17 (relaxation to admit SC/ST to viva voce with prior government approval). It concluded that proviso to Rule 17 relates to admission to the viva voce stage (i.e., a stage-specific relaxation of written-test qualifying marks) and cannot be invoked after the viva voce has been held and the merit list published to justify not invoking Rule 20. The court observed that Rule 15(b) and Rule 17 together show that any adjustment of qualifying marks under Rule 17 is relevant to the viva voce stage; once the merit list exists, Rule 20 governs filling unfilled reserved vacancies.
  5. On Institutional Roles and Chronology: The court noted the Commission's claim of being bound by State decisions on vacancies but observed that, in the instance of the 25th Examination, the Commission itself had decided to keep posts vacant prior to the State's 18-8-2000 direction (i.e., the Commission had independently chosen to keep those posts vacant in the published result of 6-8-2000).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Both writ petitions are allowed; the impugned direction of the State Government and the Commission's decision to keep ST posts vacant are quashed.

Direct consequences and directions ordered by the court:

  • The State Government's direction (para 2 of letter dated 18-8-2000) to carry forward 23 ST vacancies for three years is quashed as not in accordance with law.
  • The Commission's decision to keep unfilled ST posts vacant in respect of the 24th and 25th Judicial Service Examinations (as reflected in the note to the published result) is quashed.
  • The Commission is directed to proceed in accordance with Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules: prepare a supplementary list of successful and suitable candidates drawn from the merit list prepared under Rule 19 and recommend them to the Government for appointment against such vacancies.
  • The supplementary list and recommendations are to be made within six weeks of receipt/production of a copy of the order.
  • There is no order as to costs.

Broader implications:

The decision enforces the established principle (as articulated by the Supreme Court) that recruitment to the Bihar Subordinate/Superior Judicial Services is governed by the statutory Recruitment Rules under Article 234, not by the Reservation Act; and it follows the prior Supreme Court interpretation of Rule 20 that the Commission must fill unfilled reserved vacancies by preparing a supplementary list from the existing merit list rather than carrying vacancies forward or keeping them unfilled. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying those controlling authorities to the present facts; it directs immediate remedial action in the specific matters before the court.

Show all summary ...

S.N Jha, J.:— As same point is involved in these two writ petitions, they have been heard together and are disposed of by this common order. The dispute relates to filling of the vacancies meant for the Scheduled Tribes in the Bihar Subordinate Judicial Service. C.W.J.C No. 8655/2000 relates to 24th Judicial Service Examination while C.W.J.C No. 11341/2000 relates to the 25th Examination. In the former, the petitioners seek quashing of the decision of the State Government to keep the vacancies in question reserved for three years in terms of sub-section 6(a) of Section 4 of the Bihar Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1992 (Act 3 of 1992) (in short ‘Reservation Act’). The said decision of the Government is contained in para 2 of letter No. 6749 dated 18-8-2000 of the Deputy Secretary, Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department. In the other case, i.e, C.W.J.C No. 11341/2000, the petitioner seeks quashing of the decision of the Bihar Public Service Commission (in short ‘the Commission’) to keep the unfilled posts in the, Scheduled Tribes category vacant on account of non-availability of eligible candidates. In both the cases, the petitioner seek consequential direction to fill the vacancies as per the procedure laid down in Rule 20 of the Bihar Civil Service (Judicial Branch) Recruitment Rules, 1955 (in short ‘the Recruitment Rules’), and to consider them for appointment against those vacancies.

2. There is no dispute about the factual aspects of the case. The salient facts may be noted from C.W.O.C No. 8655/2000 as under, ??? 1990, advertisement was issued by the Commission inviting applications for the 24th Judicial Service Examination for appointment in the Bihar Judicial Service. The petitioners, who are practising advocates in this Court, submitted applications. The written examination was held in April 1991. The result thereof was published on 18-4-94. in the meantime, the Ordinance was promulgated in 1991 providing for reservation in posts and services for other backward classes, besides scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, which was iater replaced by the Reservation Act in 1992. The applicability of the said Ordinance/Act in vis-a-vis subordinate judicial service was challenged in this Court in C.W.J.C No. 7619/91. The writ petition was allowed on 6-8-93. It was held that the Reservation Ordinance/Act does not apply to recruitment in the Judicial Service and the same was ultra vires Article 234 of the Constitution. The State of Bihar preferred SLP (Civil) No. 16476/93 in the Supreme Court. During pendency of the the SLP. as mentioned above, result of the written examination was published on 18-4-94. Thereafter, interview of the successful candidates was held and the final result was published on 14-5-94. However, no appointment was made pursuant to the interim order passed by the Supreme Court a day earlier on 13-5-94. The said interim order was latter modified on 16-11-95 The Court clarified that if selection process is over, the selectees may be appointed subject to the result of the SLP and further subject to the seniority that may be required to be adjusted if reservation is upheld and the candidates in the reserved slots are selected any time hereinafter and Decome entitled for appointment. The SLP however, was eventually dismissed on 14-3-2000 along with Civil Appeal No. 9072 of 1996 preferred by the State against another decision of this Court relating to appointment in the Bihar Superior Judicial Service. The Supreme Court held that Section 4 of the Reservation Act does not apply to recruitment in the Bihar Subordinate Judicial Service or Bihar Superior Judicial Service, which are governed by the statutory rules framed under Article 234 of the Constitution namely Bihar Civil Services (Judicial Branch) (Recruitment) Rules. 1955 and Bihar Superior Judicial Service Rules, 1951. respectively. The said judgment entitled State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah is reported in (2000) 4 SCC 640, In the light of the said decision of the Supreme Court, the Deputy Secretary. Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department, Government of Bihar, wrote the impugned letter No. 6749 dated 18-8-2000 to the Commission conveying its decision regarding filling up the vacancies in the reserved categories. In these cases, we are concerned with the vacancies meant for the scheduled tribes category alone and the direction of the Government in that regard. As indicated at the outset, the State Government directed the Commission to reserve 23 posts in the scheduled tribes category for three years on account of non-availability of suitable candidates, under sub-section 6(a) of Section 4 of the Reservation Act. It may be mentioned here that 24 vacancies were earmarked for the scheduled tribes candidates against which only one candidate was recommended by the Commission as no other candidate was found suitable. The Commission has filed counter-affidavit stating that the function of the Commission is limited to holding examination and recommending the names of successful candidates in different categories, it has no say in matters relating to number of vacancies, categories under which recommendations are to be made, nor it has any say in the matter relating to de-reservation of any reserved vacancy. The State Government has also filed counter-affidavit, sworn by the author of the impugned letter, namely, Shri Kunj Bihari Das, Deputy Secretary, Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department, stating that pursuant to the decision of the Supreme Court, by the impugned letter dated 18-8-2000, the Commission has been asked to recommend candidates of general category against the vacancies meant for the candidates of OBC category and the recommendations of the Commission with respect to OBC candidates sent earlier have been returned to it. As already indicated above, in this case we are not concerned with the reservation/ de-reservation of vacancies meant for the OBC candidates. The only thing which may be said to be relevant for the purpose of this case has been stated in para 7 of the affidavit to the effect:—

“Rule 20 of 1995 Rules is not clear regarding preparation of supplemen-tary list by the B.P.S.C It does not provide whether the supplementary list may contain the names of general category candidates also or not”.

3. Although I do'not propose to state the facts of C.W.J.C No. 11341/ 2000, as C.W.J.C No. 8655/2000 has been treated as the representative case; also because there is not dispute regarding the facts, I consider it proper to mention that in the counter-affidavit filed by the Commission in that case a plea has been taken that:—

“In view of the proviso to Rule 17 as quoted above, the Commission was under the bona fide impression that prior to complying with Rule 20, it would be proper for it to seek approval of the Government to exercise their discre-tion to call for the candidates belonging to the scheduled caste and scheduled tribes category … In case, the State Government refuses to accord its ap-proval to the said intention of the Commission in terms of Rule 17 the question of complying with Rule 20 will come into play only thereafter”.

In this case also, the State Government has filed counter-affidavit sworn by the Under-Secretary of Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department but nothing significant has been stated therein.

4. At this stage before examining the correctness or otherwise of the stand of the State Government and/or the Commission, it would be apposite to quote the relevant provisions of the Bihar Civil Service (Judicial Branch) (Recruitment) Rules, 1955:—

“17. On the basis of the marks obtained at the written examination, the Commission shall arrange for viva voce test of the candidates who have quali-fied at the written examination according to Rule 15:

Provided that in exceptional circumstances and with the prior approval of Government, the Commission may, at their discretion, admit candidates of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes to the viva voce test even though they may not have obtained the minimum qualifying marks at the written test,

19. The marks obtained at the viva voce test shall be added to the marks obtained at the written examination. The names of candidates will then be ar-ranged by the Commission in order of merit. If two or more candidates obtained equal marks in the aggregate, the order shall be determined in accordance with the marks secured at the written examination. Should the marks secured at the written examination of the candidates concerned be also equal then the orde shall be decided in accordance with the total number of marks obtained in the optional papers. From the list of candidates so arranged, the Commission shall nominate such number of candidates as may be fixed by the Governor in order of their position in the list. The nominations so made shall be submitted to the Gov-ernor by such date in each year as the Governor may fix.

20. The Commission shall, while submitting their recommendations un-der Rule 19, consider the claims of qualified candidate belonging to the Sched-uled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. If the list of nominees submitted under Rule 19 does to contain an adequate number of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes who may be appointed to the vacancies reserved for them, the Commission shall submit a supplementary list nominating a sufficient number of such candidates as in their opinion at-tain the required standard of qualifications and are in all respects suitable for appointment to the Service.”

5. The question as to how the unfilled vacancies meant for scheduled tribes candidates (or, for that matter, scheduled castes candidates also) are to be filled up, having regard to the provisions of Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules, is not res-integra. The decision of the apex Court in Suren&a Narain Singh v. State of Bihar, [(1998) 5 SCC 246 : AIR 1998 SC 1841] fully answers the question. The dispute in that case had arisen on account of appointment of general category candidates against the vacancies which were earmarked for the reserved category candidates after converting the unfilled vacancies in the reserved categories into general vacancies. An argument was made that the supplementary list required to be prepared under Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules refers to only SC/ST candidates. Rejecting the argument the Court observed (at Page 1847 of the Report):—

“Upon careful consideration of the rival contentions on interpretation of Rule 20, we are of the considered view that the expression “such candidates” in Rule 20 cannot be given in restricted meaning to include only SC/ST candi-dates in the supplementary list. The merit list prepared by the BPSC nominat-ing 33 candidates therefrom unmistakably indicated that the BPSC prepared the merit list of 241 candidates who were qualified under Rule 19 of Home only 15 candidates of SC/ST could be nominated. No other qualified candi-date of SC/ST was available in the said merit list. There is no provision under the Rules which enables the BPSC to recall or hold fresh written examination and viva-voce; test and any exercise in that behalf would be contrary to 1955 Rules. Despite the proviso to Rule 17, no SC/ST candidate would qualify by securing the minimum marks of 30% prescribed by the BPSC in consultation with the High Court. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the expression “such candidates” in Rule 20 would be referably to the candidates who figure in the merit list prepared by the BPSC and out of this merit list a supple-mentary list of candidates under Rule 20 was required to be prepared who in the opinion of the BPSC have attained the required standard of qualifications and are in all respects suitable for the appointment of service. This may even include SC/ST candidates. Any other construction would result into keeping the 33 posts reserved for SC/ST vacant and consequently there would have been shortage of munsifs to man the Judiciary. It is not the contention of the 1 appellants that SC/ST candidates were available in the merit list who fulfil the qualifying marks yet they were not nominated in a supplementary list. It must be remembered that Judiciary being a vital organ to administer the law, any future relaxation may cause a damage to the institutional structure. For these reasons, in our considered opinion, the expression “such candidates” appear-ing in Rule 20 cannot be given restricted meaning. The supplementary list has to contain the names of the candidates from the merit fist. Once the merit list is prepared, the same cannot be modified and the same has to remain in force until the supplementary list is prepared to fill in the advertised post but without any compromise as regards merit. While submitting the supplementary list the BPSC shall nominate sufficient number of such candidates, i.e, candi-dates from the merit list who, in its opinion, have attained the required stan-dard of qualifications and are in all respects suitable for appointment to the service. In this view of the matter, we must hold that 33 candidates nominated by the BPSC in a supplementary list drawing from the merit list could not be assailed on any ground”.

6. In view of the clear enunciation of the scope of Rule 20. there is no scope for any doubt, as averred by the State in its affidavit in C.W.J.C No. 8655/2000, that if the list of recommendees submitted under Rule 19 does not contain adequate number of candidates in the SC/ST categories who may be appointed against the vacancies reserved for them, the Commission has no option but to submit a supplementary list from the merit list prepared without treating them to be reserved. Thus, the vacancies cannot be kept pending or carried forward for the next year/years. The carry forward aspect of the matter was also considered by the Apex Court in the aforementioned case. Repelling the contention to that effect, the Court observed as under (at Page 1847:—

“It was then urged that the BPSC and the State Government have no power to convert 33 vacancies of SC/ST into General Category. These vaca-tion posts according to the learned counsel for the appellants ought to have been carried forwarded. This submission does not appeal to us for the reason that there is no provision under 1955 Rules to carry forward the vacancies/ posts resolved for SC/ST. In the absence of any such provision under 1955 Rules, it was not permissible for the BPSC or the State Government to adopt such course.”

7. In view of above clear exposition of law the impugned direction of the Stdte Government contained in its letter dated 18-8-2000 directing the Commission to carry forward 23 unfilled vacancies in the scheduled tribes category for next three years cannot be said to be in accordance with law. The direction to that effect has been issued in terms of Section 4 (6) (a) of the Reservation Act but in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in State of Bihar v. Bal Mukund Sah, [(2000) 4 SCC 640 (supra)], it is now settled that the Reservation Act does not apply to recruitment to the Bihar Subordinate/Superior Judicial Service which is governed by the respective recruitment Rules framed under Article 234 of the Constitution. For the same very reasons the decision of the Commission to keep the unfilled posts in the scheduled tribes category, which were subject-matter of the 25th Examination, vacant vide Clause 4 of the Note appended to the result of the successful candidates published on 6-8-2000 cannot be said to be in accordance wjth law. From Dare perusal of the above clause of the Note, it is manifest that unfillled posts (described as seats) In the scheduled tribes category have been kept vacant “for non-availability of eligible candidates in ST(03) category”. Put as already indicated above if eligibie/??? candidates ??? the scheduled tribes category are not available as per Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules, the Commission is required to submit a supplementary list of candidates from the merit list already prepared under Rule 19. Thus the vacancies which remained unfilled on account of non-availability of eligible suitable candidates conforming to the required standard can neither be kept vacant as decided by the Commission with respe ct to the vacancies ot 25th examination nor can be “carried forward” as directed by the Sr;vte Government with respact to the vacancies of 24th examination the decision of Doth the State Government and the Commission to this effect trust be set aside.

8. Before I conclude 1 must deal with the contention of Shri Ashok Kumar Choudary counsel for the Commission, based on Rule 17 of the Recruitment Rules, As indicated above in its counter-affidavit filed in C.W.J.C No. 11341. 2000, the Commission has taken the ??? that Rule 17 enables the Commission to relax the minimum qualifying marks in the case of SC/ST candidates with the prior approval of the Government under proviso to Rule 17. Rule 20 comes jnto piay thereafter The ??? is based on wrong interpretation of Rule 17 and must be summariiy rejected. Proviso to Rule 17 doubt, enables the Commission to admit candidates of SC/ST catagories even though they have not obtained the minimum qualifying marks at the written test, that is to say, relax the minimum qualifying marks with the prior approval of the Government, but it is apparent from bare perusal of the Rule that such relaxation is for the purpose of viva voct? test alone it may be mentioned here that under Rule 15(b) the minimum qualifying marks for the candidates belonging to SC/ST category has been fixed at “not higher than 35% unless the number of such candidates qualifying at the written test according to standards applied for other candidates s considerably in excess of the number of candidates required to fiil all the vacancies reserved for the SC/ST. Thus while under Rule 15(b) ??? the number of SC/ST candidates qualifying at the written test is considerably in excess of the number of candidates required to fill the vacancies in those categories the minimum qualifying marks can be raised if number of candidates obtaining the minimum qualifying marks is ess, under proviso to Rule 17 the minimum qualifying marks can be reduced/relaxed with prior approval of the Government. The relevant stage for such rtduction/relaxation of the qualifying marks is at the stage of viva voce test. This is evident from the words “the Commission shall arrange for viva voce test”, “the Commission may at their descret on admit candidates of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled tribes to the viva voce test” in Rule 17 Where the viva voce test has been held and the final results have been published that is to say. the merit list has been prepared, there is no question of invoking the provisions of Rule 17, in the view of the matter of reference to Rule 17 as being the basis or justification for keeping the posts vacant before submitting the supplementary list under Rule 20, is totally misplaced and the plea totally ???.

9. I may also mention in this connection that though in the counter-affidavit filed in C.W.J.C 8655.2000, as indicated above the Commission has taken its stand that it is bound toy the decisiors of the State Government in the matters of number of “acancies, etc., it is clear that the decision to keep the unfilled posts meant for scheduled tribes candidates vacant with respect to the 25th Examination was its own. Not only because of the plea taken in the counter-affidavit in that case but also because the decision to keep the posts vacant was taken prior to 6-8-2000 when the final result was published containing such stipulation. The direction of the State Government regarding ‘carry forward’ of the vacancies came later on 18-8-2000.

10. In the result. both the writ petitions are allowed. The impugned direction of the State Government contained in para 2 of the letter dated 18-8-2000 regarding carry-forward of the 23 vacancies in scheduled tribes category as well as the Jecision of the Commission to keep the posts in the scheduled tribes category vacant with respect to 24th and 25th Judicial Service Examinations respectively are quashed. The Commission is directed to proceed in accordance with the arovisions of Rule 20 of the Recruitment Rules, i.e, prepare a supplementary list of the successful and suitable candidates from the merit list prepared under Rule 19 and recommend them to the Government for appointment against such/acancies.

11. This should be done within six weeks of the receipt/production of a copy of this order. There will be no order as to costs.

12. Petition allowed.