Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rabindra Nath Sahu v. Mrs. Maya Devi And Another

Patna High Court
Feb 7, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale dated 28-11-1980 concerning 4 kathas of land owned by defendant No. 1. The plaintiff alleged that an application for permission to sell the land under Sections 26 and 27 of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 was filed but rejected. The defendants contended that the plaintiff filed another application without their knowledge and fraudulently obtained a sanction, which the defendant alleged was forged. A complaint case for forgery against the plaintiff is still pending. The trial court dismissed the plaintiff’s suit based on findings of forgery and other issues, leading to this first appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Is the suit as framed maintainable?
  2. Has the plaintiff got valid cause of action or right to sue?
  3. Is the plaintiff entitled to get the decree for specific performance of the contract of sale as claimed by him in this suit for the suit lands?
  4. To what other relief or reliefs, if any, is the plaintiff entitled?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Agreed to purchase 4 kathas of land at Rs. 4,000/- per katha, totaling Rs. 16,000/-.
  • Paid Rs. 5,000/- as advance and tendered Rs. 11,000/- further, showing readiness and willingness to perform the contract.
  • Claimed entitlement to specific performance based on the agreement dated 28-11-1980.

Defendant's Arguments

  • Alleged the plaintiff forged the signature of defendant No. 1 in the application for permission to sell the land.
  • Asserted that the competent authority refused permission, rendering the agreement void.
  • Claimed the agreed price was Rs. 10,000/- per katha, differing from plaintiff’s claim.
  • Denied the validity of the purported sanction obtained by plaintiff without their knowledge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sections 26 and 27 of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 Requirement of obtaining permission for sale of urban land under the Act. Rejected application undermined the validity of the agreement; forgery in application affected equity.
Section 25 of the Indian Contract Act An agreement without consideration is void. Agreement lacked a fixed consideration amount, rendering it void.
Section 29 of the Indian Contract Act A contract becomes void if its terms and conditions are uncertain. Uncertainty as to price and consideration made the contract unenforceable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the agreement dated 28-11-1980 and found it did not specify the consideration amount or the rate per katha, which is essential for enforceability under contract law. Section 25 of the Indian Contract Act renders agreements without consideration void, and Section 29 voids contracts with uncertain terms. The parties were not ad idem on the price, making the agreement an unenforceable "agreement to agree." Additionally, the plaintiff was found guilty of forging the defendant's signature in the application for permission under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976, which further disentitled him from equitable relief. The defendant’s counsel agreed to refund the advance payment of Rs. 5,000/-, which was done during the hearing. Consequently, the appeal lacked merit and was dismissed, with parties bearing their own costs. The plaintiff was also entitled to recover the Rs. 11,000/- deposited in court.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The court held that the agreement of sale was void due to uncertainty in consideration and the plaintiff’s act of forgery. The plaintiff was not entitled to specific performance. The defendant refunded the advance amount, and the plaintiff was allowed to withdraw the deposit made in court. The parties bore their own costs. No new precedent was established; the decision directly affected the parties by denying specific performance and enforcing refund of amounts paid.

Show all summary ...

1. This first appeal at the instance of the plaintiff arises out of a judgment and decree dated 23-12-1983 passed by Shri D.N Pathak, Special Sub-Judge, Ranchi in Title Suit No. 102 of 1982 whereby and whereunder the said learned Court dismissed the plaintiff-appellant's suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale dated 28-11-1980.

2. The facts of the case lie in a very narrow compass.

3. Allegedly the plaintiff and the defendant No. 1, who was admittedly the owner of the disputed land as described in schedule ‘A’ of the plaint entered into an agreement on 28-11-1980 whereby and whereunder the defendant No. 1 agreed to sell 4 kathas of land.

In terms of the said agreement allegedly an application for permission to sell the aforementioned land purported to be under Ss. 26 and 27 of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 was filed and the said application was rejected.

5. The defendants however, alleged that another application for permission was filed by the plaintiff without their knowledge and the plaintiff manipulated the matters in this regard and obtained a purported sanction of the competent authority. It is admitted that in relation to the said purported agreement of sale dated 28-11-1980, the plaintiff served a notice upon the defendant No. 1 through his advocate. The defendant No. 1 upon receipt of the aforementioned notice, replied to the plaintiff's advocate alleging therein that the said purported application was a forged document.

The defendant further brought the said matter to the notice of the Dy. Commissioner, Ranchi with a prayer to start a complaint case against the plaintiff for forging the signature of defendant No. 1. Upon the said application a case being case No. 15 of 1982-1983 was initiated wherein notice was issued to the plaintiff to show cause and the said case is still pending.

6. According to the defendant as the competent authority refused to grant permission, the purported agreement dated 28-11-1980 has lost its force.

7. On the basis of the aforementioned pleadings of the parties the following issues were framed:—

“1) Is the suit as framed maintainable?

2) Has the plaintiff got valid cause of action or right to sue?

3) Is the plaintiff entitled to get the decree for specific performance of the contract of sale as claimed by him in this suit for the suit lands?

4) To what other relief or reliefs, if any, is the plaintiff entitled?”

8. The learned trial Court while deciding issue No. 2 held that the plaintiff is guilty of forging the signature of the defendant No. 1 in the aforementioned purported application for grant of permission before the authorities concerned.

9. The learned Court below, therefore, dismissed the plaintiff-appellant's suit in view of the aforementioned findings.

10. Admittedly, a dispute existed between the parties with regard to the rate at which the defendant No. 1 agreed to sell the properties in question to the plaintiff.

11. According to the plaintiff the rate was fixed at Rs. 4,000/- per katha and as such the entire consideration amount which was to be paid by him to the defendant No. 1 was Rs. 16,000/- and out of the said amount the plaintiff tendered a sum of Rs. 5,000/- to the defendant No. 1 which was accepted by her.

According to the plaintiff he was all along ready and willing to perform his part of contract and in fact tendered the sum of Rs. 11,000/- in terms of the agreement. The plaintiff further deposited a sum of Rupees 11,000/- in the Court.

On the other hand, according to the defendant the price of the land which was fixed between the parties for selling the same by the plaintiff to the defendant No. 1 was at the rate of Rs. 10,000/- per katha.

12. From a perusal of Ext. 2 that is the agreement dated 28-11-1980, however, it appears that neither the said consideration amount nor the rate of the said land per katha has been mentioned therein. It has, however, been mentioned in the said agreement that the plaintiff has paid a sum of Rs. 5,000/- by way of advance to the defendant No. 1.

13. It is, therefore, clear that the agreement itself which is sought to be specifically enforced does not contain any stipulation fixing the amount of consideration which was agreed to by and between the parties of the suit.

Section 25 of the Contract Act provides that an agreement without consideration is void. However, in any event from the pleadings of the parties as also the evidences adduced by them, it is evident that the parties were not ad idem with regard to the essential terms and conditions of the agreement so far as the same related to the quantum of consideration payable by the plaintiff in favour of the defendant No. 1 is concerned.

14. In terms of S. 29 of the Indian Contract Act a contract becomes void if the terms and conditions thereof are uncertain.

15. It is a well settled principle of law that if a consideration is not fixed for an agreement, the same will only amount to an agreement to agree and not a binding contract.

16. The agreement dated 28-11-1980 (Ext. 2) which was sought to be specifically enforced having not contained any stipulation with regard to amount of consideration which was required to be passed from the plaintiff to the defendant No. 1, the same was not enforceable. If the parties had agreed to pay some consideration at a future date, the modification of the agreement was required to be done by reason of another agreement.

Admittedly neither any separate agreement was entered into by and between the parties of the suit nor the parties were ad idem with regard to the amount of consideration relating to the aforementioned agreement for sale dated 28-11-1980.

17. In this situation, in my opinion, the said purported agreement dated 28-11-1980 was void and thus was not enforceable in a suit for specific performance of contract.

18. Further in any event as the plaintiff was found guilty of forging the signature of the defendant No. 1 in the application for permission filed before Additional Collector, Ranchi in terms of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976, in my opinion, the plaintiff is also not entitled to any decree for specific performance of contract in equity.

19. However, the learned counsel for the defendant, when questioned, as to why the defendant shall not refund the advance amount of Rs. 5,000/- to the plaintiff, very fairly agreed to refund the said amount and in fact during course of hearing Mr. R.C.P Shah, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the defendant-respondent handed over a sum of Rs. 5,000/- to Shri B.P Tetarbe, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the plaintiff-appellant in Court which was accepted by Mr. Tetarbe.

20. In this view of the matter, in my opinion, there is no merit in this appeal which is dismissed.

21. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the parties shall bear their own costs also.

22. Before parting with the case, it must be mentioned that in view of the dismissal of the suit the plaintiff is entitled to take back the sum of Rs. 11,000/- which he has deposited before the learned Court below.

Appeal dismissed.