Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ganesh Prasad And Others, Etc. v. State Of Bihar And Others

Patna High Court
Sep 27, 1984
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions arise from common orders challenging the validity of Annexures-1, 2, and 3. The petitions relate to a pre-emption application filed by respondent Lallan Singh under Section 16(3) of the Bihar Land Reforms (Fixation of Ceiling Area and Acquisition of Surplus Land) Act, 1961. The pre-emption application concerns a sale deed executed on 30th December 1976 by Shrimati Shanti Devi in favor of Ashok Kumar Singh and Madan Kumar Singh. Subsequently, Ashok Kumar Singh and Madan Kumar Singh executed another sale deed dated 22nd January 1977, which was not registered until 9th February 1977, the same date on which Lallan Singh filed the pre-emption application. The petitioners in one writ petition are subsequent purchasers, while in the other they are original purchasers. The concurrent findings by the authorities established that Lallan Singh is a co-sharer or adjoining raiyat of the disputed plot.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a pre-emption application under Section 16(3) of the Bihar Land Reforms Act can be filed against a subsequent sale deed which was not registered at the time of filing the pre-emption application.
  2. Whether it is necessary to file a separate pre-emption application against a subsequent sale deed when the pre-emption application has been filed against the first sale deed.
  3. The validity and effect of the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January 1977, particularly whether it is a sham transaction.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The pre-emption application should have been filed against the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January 1977.
  • According to Section 16(3) of the Act, the pre-emption application must be filed within three months from the date of registration of the sale deed, and since the second sale deed was registered after the pre-emption application was filed, the application should have targeted that deed.

Respondent's Position

  • The pre-emption application was rightly filed against the first sale deed dated 30th December 1976, which was registered before the application.
  • The subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January 1977 was not registered at the time of filing and has been concurrently held to be a sham transaction.
  • The vendee of the second sale deed has been added as a party to the pre-emption case, ensuring no prejudice to subsequent purchasers.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the timing of the registration of the sale deeds in relation to the filing of the pre-emption application under Section 16(3) of the Bihar Land Reforms Act. It held that since the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January 1977 was not registered until 9th February 1977, the same date on which the pre-emption application was filed, the application could not be validly filed against this subsequent deed. The pre-emption application was maintainable only against the first sale deed registered on 30th December 1976. The Court further reasoned that it is not necessary to file a separate pre-emption application against the subsequent sale deed if the vendee of that deed is added as a party in the pre-emption proceeding. Importantly, the Court upheld the concurrent findings of the authorities that the subsequent sale deed is a sham transaction, reinforcing that no separate pre-emption application is required against it. This approach prevents prejudice to subsequent purchasers and aligns with the statutory time limits prescribed for filing pre-emption applications.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court dismissed both writ petitions without costs, upholding the validity of the pre-emption application filed against the first sale deed and affirming that no separate pre-emption application is necessary against the subsequent sale deed found to be a sham transaction. The direct effect is that the pre-emption application remains valid and enforceable against the first sale deed, and the subsequent sale deed is disregarded for pre-emption purposes. No new legal precedent was set beyond the affirmation of existing statutory interpretation and concurrent findings.

Show all summary ...

B.P Jha, J.:—I shall dispose of these two writ petitions by a common judgment as they arise out of common orders.

2. In both these writ petitions, the petitioners challenge the validity of Annexures-1, 2 and 3. Annexures-1, 2 and 3 are common in both the cases.

3. These writ petitions arise out of a preemption application filed by Lallan Singh. In C.W.J.C No. 72 of 1979, the petitioners are the subsequent purchasers. In C.W.J.C No. 73 of 1979, the petitioners are the original purchasers.

4. Respondent Lallan Singh filed an application under S. 16(3) of the Bihar Land Reforms (Fixation of Ceiling Area and Acquisition of Surplus Land) Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) in respect of a sale deed which was executed by Shrimati Shanti Devi in favour of Ashok Kumar Singh minor son of Baijnath Singh and Madan Kumar Singh minor son of Ramadhar Singh. The sale deed was registered on 30th December, 1976. On 9th February, 1977, respondent Lallan Singh filed a pre-emption application on the ground that he is an adjoining raiyat or a co-sharer. The concurrent findings of the authorities are that Lallan Singh is a co-sharer or an adjoining raiyat of the disputed plot.

5. The case of Ashok Kumar Singh and Madan Kumar Singh was that they had already sold the land by means of a sale deed dated 22nd January, 1977. The subsequent sale deed was not registered till 9th February, 1977, that is, the date on which the pre-emption application was filed.

6. The grievance of the learned Counsel of the petitioners in both the cases is that the pre-emption application ought to have been filed against the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January, 1977. According to S. 16(3) of the Act, an application under S. 16(3) of the Act can be filed within the three months from the date of the registration. In view of the fact that the second sale deed was not registered till 9th February, 1977, as such the Court below was right in holding that no pre-emption application can be filed against the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January, 1977 as the same was not registered till 9th February, 1977. It is, therefore, clear that the pre-emption application was maintainable so far as the first sale deed is concerned.

7. A pre-emption application is required to be filed against the first sale deed. The only thing which is required is that the vendee of the second sale deed ought to be added as a party in the pre-emption application. It is an admitted position that the petitioners in C.W.J.C No. 72 of 1979 who are the subsequent purchasers have been added as parties in the pre-emption case. Therefore, in the present case, no prejudice will be caused to the subsequent purchasers. Hence, I hold that in a case of this type, it is not necessary to file a pre-emption application in respect of the subsequent sale deed which was not registered on the date of filing an application for pre-emption. It is also not necessary to file a pre-emption application against the subsequent sale deed as all the authorities have concurrently held that the subsequent sale deed is a sham transaction.

8. I, therefore, uphold the concurrent findings of all the authorities and hold that it is not necessary to file a pre-emption application against the subsequent sale deed dated 22nd January, 1977 as the same has been found to be a sham transaction.

9. In these circumstances, I dismiss both the writ petitions but without any costs.

S.S Sandhawalia, C.J:— I agree.

Petition dismissed.