Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajendra Singh v. The State Of Bihar And Others

Patna High Court
Sep 25, 1981
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, who had been elected Pramukh of the Begusarai Panchayat Samiti on 24 March 1979 (a body of 36 members), obtained a rule from this Court challenging the legality of a meeting convened on 19 March 1981 to consider a motion of no confidence against him. A writ application was filed on 18 March 1981; the challenged meeting took place on 19 March 1981 and a motion of no confidence was carried, but this Court stayed operation of the resolution when admitting the application on 30 March 1981.

Background facts: on 27 October 1980, 22 members requisitioned a meeting to consider a no-confidence motion. The requisition was handed to the Samiti's Secretary on 28 October 1980, who forwarded it to the Pramukh on 29 October 1980 and asked him to call a special meeting within seven days, failing which the Secretary would call a meeting within three days. The Pramukh avoided receiving that communication for some time and only received it on 17 November 1980. He called a meeting for 9 December 1980 at 11 a.m., but notices were sent only to some members and not to the requisitionists.

The 9 December 1980 meeting, chaired by Ganesh Singh, saw only 12 members present half an hour after the appointed time. The chairman concluded the meeting could not be held and closed it, recording that those present opposed the no-confidence motion. The requisitionists lodged a complaint with the Collector; an enquiry by the District Panchayat Raj Officer supported the requisitionists. The District Development Officer, by letter dated 3 March 1981, instructed the Pramukh to convene a fresh meeting within seven days or else the Block Development Officer (also Secretary) should convene it within three days. The Pramukh did not convene a meeting; the Block Development Officer issued notice fixing 19 March 1981, which the petitioner challenged in the present proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the meeting convened on 19 March 1981 to consider a no-confidence motion against the Pramukh was legally constituted and valid under Section 32 of the Bihar Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishads Act, 1961 and the relevant rules.
  2. Whether the meeting of 9 December 1980, at which 12 members were present, was a valid meeting for the purposes of a no-confidence motion under Section 32 and the Conduct of Business Rules (in particular rules 7, 13 and 14), and if valid, whether the failure to put the motion then caused the requisition to lapse.
  3. How Section 32(3)'s six-month bar (the interdiction on giving notice until after six months from the date of such a meeting) applies to the facts — i.e., whether the subsequent meeting (19 March 1981) fell within the prohibited six-month period.
  4. Whether the time-limits prescribed by rule 7 (seven days for the Pramukh, and three days for the Block Development Officer/Secretary if the Pramukh fails) are mandatory or directory, and how the three-day period should be computed (contested by the Government Pleader).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Rash Bihari Singh)

  • When 12 persons were present at the 9 December 1980 meeting, that constituted the quorum of one-third of the Samiti; consequently the meeting could not have been lawfully adjourned without putting the no-confidence motion to the vote.
  • Because the quorum was achieved and the motion was not put, the requisition had to be treated as having failed or lapsed as of 9 December 1980; therefore it could not be revived and placed before a meeting on 19 March 1981.

Government / Respondents' Arguments (as recorded)

  • The learned Government Pleader-V argued that the three-day period allowed the Block Development Officer to call the meeting should not be construed as a continuation of the seven days given to the Pramukh, but should be computed from the date on which the Block Development Officer actually received information of the Pramukh's failure to call the meeting.
  • In the counter-affidavit it was asserted that the 9 December 1980 meeting was not a legally or validly constituted meeting (only one requisitionist was present), implying the 9 December meeting could not be treated as the decisive first meeting for Section 32 purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by outlining the statutory and regulatory framework governing no-confidence motions:

  • Section 32 of the Bihar Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishads Act, 1961: a motion of no confidence may be made by notice signed by not less than one-third of total members (sub‑section (1)); the motion can be carried only with the support of not less than two-thirds of members present and voting at the meeting (sub‑section (2)); and sub‑section (3) addresses the consequences where the motion is not carried or where the meeting cannot be held for want of quorum, providing that notice of such a motion shall not be given until after the expiration of six months from the date of such a meeting (a six‑month "truce").
  • Relevant Rules (Bihar Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads (Conduct of Business) Rules, 1963): Rule 5 (ordinary meetings — ten clear days' notice), Rule 6 (agenda prepared by Block Development Officer in consultation with Pramukh), Rule 7 (special meetings under Section 32 — Pramukh to call within seven days of requisition, otherwise Block Development Officer/Secretary to call within three days), Rule 13 (quorum — one third), Rule 14 (if quorum not present within half an hour the meeting stands adjourned and no quorum is necessary for adjourned meeting).

The Court analyzed how these provisions apply to the facts:

  1. The Court emphasized that a no-confidence motion must be considered in a special meeting called under Section 32 read with Rule 7, and not under the ordinary meeting procedures. Because sub‑section (3) of Section 32 contemplates that, upon certain outcomes (e.g., failure of the motion or meeting not held for want of quorum), a fresh notice must be given and a six‑month bar applies, the ordinary adjournment provisions are not fully applicable to such special meetings.
  2. Rule 14's rule about adjournment where quorum is absent within half an hour was discussed: the chairman at the 9 December meeting observed half an hour had elapsed and only 12 persons were present. The Court noted that 12 members constituted the quorum (one-third of 36), so the chairman's conclusion that the meeting could not be held was based on a mistaken application of the adjournment rule applicable to ordinary meetings. Because the quorum was present, the motion should have been considered at that meeting.
  3. The Court rejected, to an extent, the Government Pleader's contention concerning computation of the three-day period for the Block Development Officer, reasoning that the Block Development Officer is responsible for preparing the agenda and would be aware whether the Pramukh was going to convene the meeting within seven days; thus, if notice is not received within the time, the Block Development Officer ought to act. However, the Court refrained from laying down that the seven-day and three-day limits are mandatory; instead, it characterized those time-limits as directory rather than strictly mandatory.
  4. The Court examined the case on two alternative factual assumptions and reached the same result in either scenario:
    • If the 9 December 1980 meeting was invalid (as the respondents/intervenors contended), then the first valid meeting to consider the motion would be the 19 March 1981 meeting; but the requisition dated 27 October 1980 and the meeting dated 19 March 1981 were separated by a period of five months, and the Court concluded the resolution could not be permitted to be operative in those circumstances (i.e., it fell afoul of the timing restrictions contemplated by Section 32(3)).
    • If the 9 December 1980 meeting was valid, then because the quorum (12 members) was present the motion should have been put at that meeting; failing which, the requisition lost its life on 9 December 1980 and could not be revived or be the subject of the meeting held on 19 March 1981, which lacked the required fresh requisition and fell within the six‑month limitation.
  5. On this basis the Court concluded that, whichever way the facts were viewed, no legally valid meeting could have been held on 19 March 1981 to consider the no-confidence motion according to the Act and the rules, and so the motion purportedly carried on that date could not be treated as a valid resolution.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition succeeds. The Court held that no legal meeting could be held on 19 March 1981 to consider the no-confidence motion and that the resolution purportedly carried on that date is void. The orders contained in Annexures 2 and 3 to the application are quashed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the resolution adopted on 19 March 1981 is declared void and the Annexures 2 and 3 impugned in the petition are quashed. The Court made this order without any order as to costs.
  • Broader implications: the opinion reasons about the proper application of Section 32 and Rules 7, 13 and 14 to no-confidence proceedings, indicating that (a) special meetings under Section 32 must be treated differently from ordinary meetings for purposes of adjournment and the six‑month bar in sub‑section (3), and (b) the seven-day/three-day time-limits are to be viewed as directory rather than strictly mandatory. The opinion does not expressly state that it is laying down a binding precedent beyond the resolution of the present dispute.
Show all summary ...

Hari Lal Agrawal, J.:— The petitioner has obtained a rule from this Court as to why the meeting said to be convened on 19th March, 1981 to consider a motion of no confidence against the petitioner the Pramukh of the Panchayat Samiti, Begusari be not held illegal. The writ application was filed on the 18th March and the meeting was held on the 19th March, 1981 when a motion of no confidence against the petitioner was carried. The operation of the resolution was, however, stayed by this Court while admitting the application on 30-3-81.

2. The facts of the case are that the petitioner was elected the Pramukh of the Pegusarai Panchayat Samiti on 24th March, 1979, consisting of 36 members. On 27-10-1980, 22 of its members filed a requisition petition for calling a meeting of the Samiti to consider the no confidence motion against the Pramukh on various charges against him. As would appear from the statements made in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents, the aforesaid requisition petition was handed over to the Secretary of the Panchayat Samiti an, 28th October, 1980, who sent, the same to the Pramukh under his letter dated 29-10-80, asking the petitioner to call for a special meeting for consideration of the motion failing which he (the Secretary) would himself call for a meeting within three days thereafter. The petitioner is said to have avoided to receive the said letter for a considerable time which was, however, ultimately received by him on 17th November, 1980. Thereafter the petitioner called for the meeting on 9-12-80 at 11 a.m but issued notices of the meeting only to some of the members and not to all of them, particularly the requisitionists.

3. In the meeting convened on 9th December, 1980, under the Chairmanship of Ganesh Singh, the Mukhiya of Khamhar Panchayat, only 12 members of the Samiti including the petitioner, could be present half an hour after the time appointed for the meeting. The Chairman, in view of this fact, thought that the meeting could not be held and he accordingly closed the meeting observing that the persons who were present opposed the motion of no confidence. I would do better to quote the relevant minutes of this meeting which read as follows:—

“11 baje din se baithak bulai gayi thi. 11.35 baje din tak sirf 12 hi weyakti upasthit ho paye. Isliye aaj ki karyawai par kisi parkar ka vichar vimarsh nahin ho saka. Atba aaj ki baithak samapt kiya jaye. Upasthit sadasyon ne awishwas prastao ka virodh kiya.

Sd. Sabhapati (Adhyaksh)

Ganesh Singh

9-12-80”

4. In the counter-affidavit it has been further stated that in the meeting of 9th December, 1980 only one of the quisitionists Bhadai Sao was present and that it was not a legally and validly constituted meeting. The requisitionists moved the Collector of Begusarai against the conduct of the petitioner in calling for the meeting in a clandestine manner. An enquiry was held by the District Panchayat Raj Officer, Begusarai who supported the case of the requistionists. The Pramukh was, therefore, instructed by the letter dated 3rd March, 1981 of the District Development Officer, Begusarai to convene a fresh meeting within seven days of the receipt of the same falling which, the Block Development Officer, who was also the Secretary of the Samiti, was asked to convene the meeting within three days thereafter. The Pramukh, however, did not carry out this direction and accordingly, the impugned notice was issued by the Block Development Officer fixing the date for convening the meeting on 19th March, 1981 (vide Annexure-3) which has been challenged by the petitioner.

5. Before, however, going to the points advanced in challenged of this notice and the subsequent meeting, the relevant provisions of the law may be noticed.

6. Section 32 of the Bihar Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishads Act, 1961 (briefly, ‘the Act’) deals with the procedure to consider the matter of no confidence against the Pramukh or Up-Pramukh and according to sub-section (1) therefore, a motion expressing want of confidence in either of the two officers may be made by a notice signed by not less than one third of the total number of the members of the Panchayat Samiti. According to the procedure prescribed under sub-section (2), the said motion can be carried only with the support of not less than two-third of the members of the Panchayat Samiti present and voting at the meeting. Then sub-section (3) deals with situations (1) where the motion of no confidence is not carried as contemplated under sub-section (2) or (2) the meeting in question is not held for want of a quorum. It is obvious that if the meeting is held and the motion fails, there is the end of the matter. But life of the motion is also to cease and the out if the meeting cannot be held for want of quorum, because it further provides that notice of such motion shall not be given until after the expiration of six months from the date of such a meeting. In other words after one dual a six months' “Truce” period is contemplated and after expiry of the said period, if the members want to re-agitate the question of no confidence, then everything has to be done without driving any aid from the previous events.

7. It is on the basis of this provision that Mr. Rash Bihari Singh appearing in support of the petition contended that inasmuch as in the meeting of 9th December, 1980, 12 persons were present thereby making a qurom of one-third members of the Samiti, the meeting could not have been adjourned. To put in more clear term, the argument was that if the quorum was complete, then the motion had to be put for consideration. If that was not done for any reason, then the motion of no confidence did not survive beyond 9-12-1980.

8. Before, however, recording may conclusion, I may also refer some of the Rules of the Bihar Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads (Conduct of Business) Rules, 1963. The relevant rules are 5, 6, 7, 13 and 14.

9. Rule 5 deals with ordinary meeting of the Panchayat Samities and ‘no meeting shall be held unless notice of the place, date and time of the meeting and of the business to be transacted, is given in writing to members at least ten clear days before the date of the meeting’. Under Rule 6, the agenda for the meeting is to be prepared by the Block Development Officer in consultation with the Pramukh. Rule 7 deals with the procedure for convening the special meeting under Section 32 of the Act for considering a no confidence motion against the Pramukh which reads as follows:

“The Pramukh/Adhyaksha shall call for a special meeting including the meeting for considering no confidence motion against the Pramukh or Up-Pramukh/Adhayksha or Up-Adhyaksha within seven days of the receipt of the request in writing signed by not Jess that one-third of the total number of members of the Samiti/Parishad specifying the resolution which it is proposed to move:

Provided that where the Pramukh/Adhyaksha does not call the meeting within the time-limit, the Block Development Officer/Secretary shall call the meeting within three days thereafter.”

10. Rule 13 prescribes the quoram to be one third of the total number of the members of the Samiti/Parishad. According to rule 14, if within half an hour after the time appointed for a meeting, the quorum is not present, the meeting shall stand adjourned to another date and time, and no quorum is to be necessary for the adjourned meeting.

11. From persual of the above rules and the provisions of the Act, it is obvious that a no confidence motion has to be considered in a special meeting called for an conducted under Section 32 read with rule 7, and not according to the procedure for convening the ordinary meeting. The provisions of adjournment of a meeting, in my view, therefore, would not apply to a special meeting, in view of sub-section (3) of Section 32 of the Act, which contemplates of making of a fresh notice for any subsequent motion of no confidence. Even the postpone out of a meeting of a Samiti or Paruhad is contemplated only in one circumstance, viz., absence of the requisite quorum within half an hour of the appointed time of the meeting. It is perhaps under this impression that the Chairman of the meeting had said that half an hour has passed and only 12 persons could be present, although that had constituted the quorum. The motion has to be considered with speed and the meeting has to be called for only within seven days' time, and on the failure of the Pramukh, the Block Development Officer/Secretary has got to call for the meeting within three days thereafter.

12. The learned Government Pleader-V, however, contended that the limitation of three days put for calling for the meeting by the Block Development Officer should not be considered to be in continuation of the seven days' time and that the limitation of three days must be considered from the receipt of the information by the Block Development Officer/Secretary of the failure of the Pramukh to convene the meeting within seven days aforesaid. It is net possible to accept this argument as under rule 6, it is the Block Development Officer, who is to prepare the agenda etc. and, therefore, he must be aware that the meeting is not going to be convened within seven days, and, therefore, if notice of the meeting to be convened by the Pramukh is not received within the time, then the Block Development Officer has to move in the matter himself; but assuming for the argument's sake that the there days' time fixed for convening the meeting is to be computed from the date of his being aware of the failure of the pramukh, event in that event, it cannot be gain said that the Block Development Officer could convene the meeting at his pleasure. I, however, do not propose to lay down that the time-limit for convening the meeting by the Pramukh or three days on his failure by the Block Development Officer/Secretary, as aforesaid is mandatory. In my view it is simply directory.

13. Be that as it may, if the meeting of 9th December, 1980 was invalid, as is the case of the intervenor and/or of the contesting respondents, and if the first meeting be deemed to have been held to consider the motion of no confidence only on 19th March, 1981; the date of requisition being 27-10-1980, it was held after a period of five months. The resolution in such circumstances cannot be permitted to be operative. On the other hand, if the meeting of 9th December, 1980 is held to be valid, then the quorum was complete as twelve members were present and the motion bad got to be put through that having been not done, the requisition lost its life and it could not be placed in the meeting of 19th March, 1981, which was not only without limitation of six months provided under Section 32(3) of the Act, but also without any fresh, requisition.

14. Therefore, considering the case from any angle, I have no hesitation in holding that no legal meeting could be held on 19th March, 1981 to consider the motion according to the prescribed procedure under the Act and the rules discussed above. Once this view is taken, it goes without saying that the motion of no confidence purported to have been carried in this meeting cannot stand as having been adopted in an illegally constituted meeting. The said resolution is, therefore, void.

15. In the result, the application succeeds as indicated above and I quash the orders contained in Annexures 2 and 3 to this application, but without any order as to costs.