- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The State Of Bihar v. Ram Naresh Singh & Others Opp. Party.
Judgment Summary — C.N. Tiwary, J. — State v. Ramnaresh Singh & others
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion addresses whether an application under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (the "new Code") by the State Government for leave to appeal from an original order of acquittal is barred by limitation. The original order of acquittal was dated 16.3.74 and was passed by Sri V. Prasad, Judicial Magistrate, Motihari, in the case State v. Ramnaresh Singh and others. The application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 was presented on 17.6.64, and the procedural question is whether that application is time-barred.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the application under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the new Code by the State Government for leave to appeal from the order of acquittal dated 16.3.74 is barred by limitation.
- What is the period of limitation for presenting an application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the new Code when the appeal is on behalf of the State Government (distinguishing cases instituted upon complaint and cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint).
- How Article 114 of the Limitation Act (Act XXXVI of 1963) and the re-enactment/references from the old Code (Section 417) to the new Code (Section 378) operate to determine the applicable limitation periods.
Arguments of the Parties
Stamp Reporter's Position
- The Stamp Reporter reported that the period of limitation for filing an application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 would be 60 days from the date of the order of acquittal as provided in Sub-section (5), and therefore, according to that report the present application is barred by limitation.
Government Advocate's Arguments
- The learned Government Advocate contended that no period of limitation for presenting an application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 from an order of acquittal has been prescribed by the new Code.
- On that basis, the Government Advocate argued that such an application may be presented within the period of limitation prescribed under Article 114(a) of the Limitation Act for presenting appeal from an order of acquittal, namely 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal.
- The Government Advocate did not distinguish between applications for leave to appeal on behalf of the State Government from orders of acquittal in cases instituted upon complaint and those in cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a statutory and contextual analysis, beginning with a comparison of the old Code (Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898) and the new Code (Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973), and then interpreting the limitation provisions in the Limitation Act in light of these provisions.
Key steps of the court's analysis (as stated in the opinion):
- Under the old Code, appeals from an order of acquittal could be presented on behalf of the State Government under Sub-section (1) of Section 417 and on behalf of the Central Government under Sub-section (2) of Section 417. Under the old Code, the Government did not require leave to appeal from an order of acquittal, and consequently no period of limitation for presenting an application for leave existed in that context.
- The court applied Section 8 of the General Clauses Act (Act X of 1897) to treat references to Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 417 of the old Code in Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act as references to the corresponding provisions now reenacted as Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 378 of the new Code. Consequently, Clause (a) of Article 114 prima facie prescribes a 90-day limitation for filing an appeal from an order of acquittal under Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 378.
-
The court set out the relevant provisions of Section 378 of the new Code:
- Sub-section (1) permits the State Government to direct the public prosecutor to present an appeal to the High Court from an original or appellate order of acquittal (subject to Sub-sections (3) and (5)).
- Sub-section (2) permits the Central Government to direct an appeal in certain cases investigated by central agencies (subject to Sub-section (3)).
- Sub-section (3) provides that no appeal under Sub-sections (1) or (2) shall be entertained except with the leave of the High Court.
- Sub-section (5) prescribes time limits for applications under Sub-section (4) (special leave to appeal from an order of acquittal) — six months where the complainant is a public servant and sixty days in every other case, computed from the date of the order of acquittal.
-
The court interpreted the structure of Section 378 and observed:
- Sub-section (3) (leave requirement) applies to both Sub-sections (1) and (2).
- Sub-section (5) applies to Sub-section (1) (State Government appeals) but not to Sub-section (2) (Central Government appeals). Therefore, there is no period of limitation prescribed by Sub-section (5) for applications for leave to appeal on behalf of the Central Government.
- The court examined the meaning of "complaint" under the new Code (reference to the explanation added to Clause (d) of Section 2) which deems a police report disclosing, after investigation, the commission of a non-cognizable offence to be a complaint, and the police officer making such a report to be the complainant. The court used this to define which cases are "instituted upon complaint."
- The court concluded that Sub-section (5) prescribes a limitation period only for applications for leave to appeal (under Sub-section (3)) made on behalf of the State Government where the order of acquittal relates to a case instituted upon complaint. In such complaint cases the application for leave must be made within six months where the complainant is a public servant and within sixty days in every other case, counted from the date of the order of acquittal.
- For cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint, Sub-section (5) prescribes no limitation for an application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) on behalf of the State Government. The court therefore concluded that in such non-complaint cases an application for leave to appeal may be presented within the period of limitation for presenting the appeal itself under Article 114(a) — i.e., 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal.
- The court then addressed the period of limitation for presenting the actual appeal once leave is granted in complaint cases. It held that Clause (b) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act prescribes 30 days from the date of grant of leave for presenting the appeal on behalf of the State Government when the acquittal was in a complaint case. This follows because Sub-section (4) of Section 378 of the new Code is a verbatim reproduction of Sub-section (3) of Section 417 of the old Code, and references in Article 114(b) to the old Code must be construed as references to the new Code provision.
- Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the order of acquittal in the instant case was passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint. Therefore, the application for leave under Sub-section (3) could be presented within the 90-day period provided by Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act. The application in the instant case had been filed within 90 days of the order of acquittal.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The court held that the application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, in the instant matter is not barred by limitation.
Reasoned consequences and immediate effect:
- The application filed in this case was presented within 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal applicable to cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint (Article 114(a) of the Limitation Act) and is therefore timely.
- For State Government appeals arising out of cases instituted upon complaint, the time limits in Sub-section (5) of Section 378 govern the time for seeking leave (six months where the complainant is a public servant and sixty days otherwise), and once leave is granted the appeal must be filed within 30 days as prescribed by Article 114(b) of the Limitation Act.
- The opinion does not state that a new general precedent beyond the statutory interpretation was intended to be created; the decision addresses the specific limitation question and the direct effect is that the present application is maintainable on the ground of limitation.
Application not barred by limitation.
This summary is prepared solely from the text of the provided opinion and does not add information not contained therein.
C.N Tiwary, J.:— The question for consideration is whether this application under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the new Code’) by the State Government for leave to appeal from the original order of acquittal, dated 16.3.74 passed by Sri V. Prasad, Judicial Magistrate, Motihari in the case State v. Ramnaresh Singh and other is barred by limitation.
2. As stated above, the order of acquittal is dated 16.3.74 This application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the new Code was presented on 17.6.64 The Stamp Reporter has reported that the period of limitation for filing application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 would be 60 days from the date of the order of acquittal as provided in Sub-section (5) and therefore, according to the stamp report this application for grant of leave under Sub-section (3) being barred by limitation, cannot be entertained. The learned Government Advocate has contended that no period of limitation for presenting application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the new Code from order of acquittal has been prescribed and therefore, application for leave to appeal from an order of acquittal may be presented within the period of limitation, prescribed under Article 114(a) of the Limitation Act (Act XXXVI of 1963) for presenting appeal from an order of acquittal, which is 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal. The learned Government Advocate has not made any distinction between an application for leave to appeal on behalf of the State Government from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint and an application for leave to appeal from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint.
3. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (hereinafter referred to as the old Code), appeal from order of acquittal could be presented on behalf of State Government under Sub-section (1) of Section 417. If such an order of acquittal was passed in any case, in which the offence had been investigated by the Delhi Special Police Establishment, Central Government could also present appeal from order of acquittal under Sub-section (2) of Section 417 of the old Code. Under the old Code Government was not required to obtain leave to appeal from an order of acquittal and therefore, no period of limitation for presenting application for leave to appeal on behalf of State Government was prescribed. Under Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act the period of limitation for presenting appeal under Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 417 of the old Code is 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal. Where an earlier statute is not merely repealed but repealed and re-enacted with or without modification a reference to the provisions of the repealed Act, according to Section 8 of the General Clause Act (Act X of 1897), in any other enactment shall, unless different intention appears, be construed as reference to the corresponding provisions so reenacted. Hence, reference to Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 417 of the old Code in Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act shall be construed as reference to Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 378 of the new Code. Hence the period of limitation for filing appeal from order of acquittal under Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 378 of the Code will prima facie be 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal by virtue of Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act.
4. Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 378 of the new Code under which appeal from order of acquittal may he presented on behalf of Government, are as under:
“378(1) save as otherwise provided in Sub-section (2) and subject to the provisions of Sub-sections (3) and (5) the State Government may, in any case, direct the Public prosecutor to present an appeal to the High Court from an original or appellate order of acquittal passed by any Court other than a High Court.
(2) If such an order of acquittal is passed in any case in which the offence has been investigated by the Delhi Special Police Establishment constituted under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946 or by any other agency empowered to make investigation into an offence under any central Act other than this Code, the Central Government may also direct the public prosecutor to present an appeal, subject to the provisions of Sub-section (3), to the High Court from the order of acquittal.”
5. Sub-section (3) and Sub-section (5) of Section 378 of the new Code referred to in Sub-section (1) are in the following terms:
“(3) No appeal under Sub-section (1) or Sub-section (2) shall be entertained except with the leave of the High Court.
(5) No application under Sub-section (4) for the grant of special leave to appeal from an order of acquittal shall be entertained by the High Court after the expiry of six months, where the complainant is a public servant, and sixty days in every other case, computed from the date of that order of acquittal”.
6. It is thus, evident that provisions of Sub-section (3) apply not only to Sub-section (1) under which the State Govt. may present appeal but also to Sub-section (2) of Section 378 under which appeal may be presented on behalf of the Central Govt. from order of acquittal in cases mentioned therein. Without the leave of High Court no appeal can be presented under Sub-section (1) or Sub-section (2) of Section 378. It is, however, significant to note that provisions of Sub-section (1) of Section 378 are subject to the provisions of Sub-section (5) also; whereas the provisions of Sub-section (2) are not subject to the provisions of Sub-section (5). It cannot therefore, be said by any stretch of imagination, that there is any period of limitation prescribed for presenting application for leave to appeal on behalf of Central Government. It remains now to be seen whether there is any period of limitation prescribed for presenting application for leave to appeal on behalf of State Government. The provisions of Sub-section (1), under which the State Government may present appeal from an order of acquittal are subject to the provisions of Sub-section (5). Sub-section (5) prescribes the period of limitation for presenting application under Sub-section (4) for grant of special leave to appeal from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint. Under Sub-section (1) the State Government may present appeal from order of acquittal passed in any case, which may be even a case instituted upon complaint. It will presently be seen that if the State Govt. happens to present appeal from order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint the application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 has to be made within the period of limitation prescribed by Sub-section (5). An explanation has been added to the definition of complaint in Clause (d) of Section (2) of the new Code, according to which a report made by a police officer in a case which discloses, after investigation, the commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint and the police officer by whom such report is made shall be deemed to be the complainant. Such case will also be treated as cases instituted on complaint. As the provisions of Sub-section (1) of Section 378 are subject to Sub-sections (3) and (5) application for grant or leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint shall not be entertained after expiry of six months where the complainant is a public servant and sixty days in every other case, computed from the date of that order of acquittal as provided in Sub-section (5). But Sub-section (5) does not prescribe any period of limitation for presenting application for grant of leave to appeal from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon complaint. Therefore, it is evident that no period has been prescribed for presenting application on behalf of the State Government for grant of leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint. This view finds support from the fact that the provisions of Sub-section (2), under which an appeal from order of acquittal may be presented on behalf of the Central Government are not subject to provisions of Sub-section (5). Sub-section (2) of Section 378 shows that there would be no occasion for the Central Government to present an appeal from an order of acquittal passed in complaint case. It is for this reason that the provisions of Sub-section (2) of Section 378 are not subject to the provisions of Sub-section (5) If the intention had been to prescribe period of limitation for presenting application for grant of leave to appeal from order of acquittal passed in all types of cases i.e cases instituted upon complaint as well as cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint the provisions of Sub-section (2) of Section 378 also would have beet subject to the provisions of Sub-section (5). It must, therefore, be held that the period of limitation for presenting application for leave to appeal provided in Sub-section (5) governs only such applications under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 made on behalf of the State Government for grant of leave to appeal which relate to an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint. The period of limitation is six months where the complainant is a public servant and sixty days in every other case computed from the date of the order of acquittal. There is no period of limitation prescribed for presenting application for grant of leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon complaint. Hence, application for leave to appeal from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint may be presented within the period of limitation for presenting such an appeal.
7. Then comes the question as to what would be the period of limitation for presenting appeal on behalf of the State Government from order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint. As stated above, application for leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 in such a case may be made within the period of six months when the complainant is a public servant and sixty days in every other case computed from the date of the order of acquittal. The period of limitation for presenting appeal in such a case would be thirty days from the date of the grant of leave as provided in Clause (b) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act. Clause (b) of Article 114 prescribes the period of limitation for presenting appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section. 417 of the old Code. It is thirty days computed from date of the grant of special leave. Sub-section (4) of Section 378 of the new Code is a verbatim reproduction of Sub-section (3) of Section 417 of the old Code and it relates to social leave to appeal from an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint. It has already been pointed out that where an earlier statute is repealed and re-enacted with or without modification a reference to the provisions of the repealed Act in any other enactment, shall unless different intention appears, be construed as reference to the provisions so re-enacted. Therefore, reference to Sub-section (3) of Section 417 of the old Code in Clause (b) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act will be construed as reference to Sub-section (4) of Section 378 of the new Code. Therefore, the period of limitation for presenting appeal from order of acquittal on behalf of the State Government when the order of acquittal has been passed in a case instituted upon complaint, will be thirty days from the date of grant of leave as provided in Article 114(b) of the Limitation Act by virtue of the provisions of Sub-sections (1), (3) and (5) read with Sub-section (4) of Section 378.
8. As pointed out above reference to Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 417 of the old Code in Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act will be construed as reference to Sub-sections (1) and (2) respectively of Section 378 of the new Code. The period of limitation for presenting appeal on behalf of the State Government from order of acquittal is 90 days from the date of that order of acquittal according to Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act. The period of limitation prescribed in Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act for presenting appeal from order of acquittal passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint remains intact. But the provisions of Section 378 of the new Code are to be read as qualification of the provisions of Article 114 of the Limitation Act, so far as they relate to appeal from order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon a complaint. Hence, appeal on behalf of the State Government from order of acquittal passed in a case instituted upon complaint must be presented within 30 days from the date of grant of leave to appeal as provided in Clause (b) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act.
9. In the instant case the order of acquittal was passed in a case instituted otherwise than upon a complaint. Therefore, application for grant of leave to appeal under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 could be presented within the period of limitation prescribed in Clause (a) of Article 114 of the Limitation Act, which is 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal. As this application for grant of leave under Sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the new Code has been filed within 90 days from the date of the order of acquittal, it is not barred by limitation.
Application not barred by limitation.
Alert