- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
In Re: Girindra Kishore Jha ... v. Unknown
Analytical Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Sri Z. Ahmad, a magistrate with first class powers at Bettiah, made a reference under Section 13(b) and Section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act through the District Magistrate and the District and Sessions Judge of Champaran at Motihari.
On 13 November 1952 cognizance was taken in a criminal case under Section 188 of the Penal Code against Ramsanehi Singh (Case No. 205 O.C. of 1952). Bail in the amount of Rs. 800 with two sureties of Rs. 400 each was directed. Mohan Lal and Rafique Mian offered bail and were certified as fit sureties by Pleader Sri Girindra Kishore Jha. A Sub-Deputy Magistrate, S.N. Tewari, held an enquiry and reported that those proposed bailors were not fit. Other sureties (Ram Asrey and Sukhi) were certified by the pleader but also reported not to be fit. On 15 November 1952 Kanhai Ram offered bail, was certified by the pleader and reported fit by Mr. Tewari; that bail was accepted and Ramsanehi released. On 26 November 1952 a fresh bail purportedly executed by one Raj Kishore Prasad Singh was accepted after certification by the pleader.
Ramsanehi later failed to appear; Raj Kishore Prasad Singh denied executing the bond. A criminal case under Sections 465/471 IPC was then initiated against Ramsanehi (Case No. 204 O.C. of 1953). Trial was conducted by Mr. Zahur Ahmad (who later made the present reference). Girindra Kishore Jha was examined as prosecution witness No. 3 in that trial. At the conclusion of that trial Mr. Zahur Ahmad acquitted the accused but concluded the pleader had committed misconduct.
On 14 June 1956 Mr. Zahur Ahmad framed three charges against the pleader under Section 14 read with Section 13(b) of the Legal Practitioners Act alleging false or reckless certifications of the fitness and identity of bailors and failure to verify execution of bail bonds. The pleader failed to file a show-cause petition before the magistrate, sought but was denied time for certain evidence, declined to participate further at the magistrate's enquiry, and ultimately the magistrate examined witnesses and made the reference dated 10 July 1956 to the higher authorities.
The District Magistrate delayed action on the reference until 1958, forwarding it only after learning of the pleader's expulsion from a Bar Association. The District and Sessions Judge transmitted the matter to the Patna High Court. The Government Pleader supported the reference; Mr. Raghunath Jha appeared for the pleader.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the pleader, Sri Girindra Kishore Jha, was guilty of gross professional misconduct under Section 14 read with Section 13(b) of the Legal Practitioners Act for certifying the fitness and identity of bailors without proper verification.
- Whether the presiding officer who conducted the magistrate's enquiry (Mr. Zahur Ahmad) had jurisdiction to make the enquiry and submit the reference, or whether the enquiry should have been held by the presiding officer of the court in which the misconduct was alleged to have been committed (i.e., the question of proper forum for enquiry under the Act).
- What penalty, if any, should be imposed on the pleader upon a finding of misconduct, taking into account any mitigating circumstances and the delay in prosecution of the reference.
Arguments of the Parties
Government Pleader's Arguments
- The charges against the pleader have been proved by his own admissions in his deposition in case No. 204 O.C. of 1953.
- Those admissions show that the pleader did not know the bailors and endorsed certificates of fitness on bail bonds without verifying that the bail bonds had been executed by the bailors and sureties.
Mr. Raghunath Jha (for the Pleader) — Arguments
- Mr. Zahur Ahmad had no jurisdiction to make the enquiry and to submit the reference under the Legal Practitioners Act.
- There exist mitigating circumstances in favour of the pleader (including a claim of bona fide action and alleged confusion or apprehension during prior proceedings).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Bihar v. Chandreshwar Prasad, AIR 1960 Pat 1 (Special Bench) | Discusses conflicting views on which presiding officer may hold an enquiry under Section 14 — i.e., whether only the presiding officer of the court where misconduct occurred or any presiding officer under the same District Judge or District Magistrate may hold the enquiry. | The Court referenced this Special Bench decision and, without resolving the conflict, proceeded on the basis that the High Court itself can take cognizance under Section 13(b) if all facts are before it; thus no further enquiry was necessary and the court considered the record directly. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in sequential analytical steps grounded on the record and the pleader's own admissions:
- Jurisdictional controversy: The court acknowledged a serious conflict of opinion about which presiding officer may hold an enquiry under Section 14, referring to the Special Bench decision in State of Bihar v. Chandreshwar Prasad. The court deemed it unnecessary to resolve that controversy because the High Court itself may take cognizance under Section 13(b) when all facts are before it; therefore the High Court proceeded to consider the matter on the record before it.
- Reliance on primary evidence: The court examined the pleader's deposition in case No. 204 O.C. of 1953, noting his admissions that the certificates of fitness on several bail bonds were in his pen and that he had signed them (Exhibit 1(1), Exhibits A-1, B-1, C-1 and corresponding bail bonds). The pleader admitted he did not remember knowing certain bailors (Mohan Lal, Rafique, Kanhai Ram) and that with respect to Raj Kishore he had not met him on the date of the signed bond, did not recognise Raj Kishore's handwriting, and that no part of the bail bond was written in his presence.
- Legal significance of admissions: From those admissions the court concluded that the pleader certified the fitness and identity of bailors without ascertaining their identity or verifying that they had executed the bail bonds. The court observed that had the pleader exercised due care he would have discovered that someone other than Rajkishore had signed the bond dated 26 November 1952.
- Consideration of defence arguments: Counsel for the pleader argued that the pleader's deposition was made in confusion and cited an application where the pleader alleged threats and apprehension. The court noted that while there may have been apprehension, the pleader never stated that any of his deposition statements were false or inaccurate, and did not point to any inaccuracy in those statements in his show cause petition to the High Court. Consequently, the court found those arguments insufficient to rebut the force of the admissions.
- Characterisation of misconduct: On the factual showing — in particular the pleader's admissions regarding signing certifications without personal knowledge or adequate verification — the court concluded the pleader had acted without knowing or believing the truth of his certificates, constituting gross professional misconduct under the Legal Practitioners Act.
- Mitigating factors and penalty assessment: The court weighed mitigating circumstances: (a) the pleader's assertion that he acted bona fide (which the court read as possibly meaning he acted on information from others rather than after his own enquiry), and (b) the undue delay (about eight to nine years) in prosecution of the reference for which the pleader was not at fault. The court held that these factors did not excuse the pleader's conduct but warranted mitigation in the measure of punishment.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court concluded that Sri Girindra Kishore Jha had been guilty of gross professional misconduct based on his admissions that he signed certificates of fitness on bail bonds without verifying the identity and the execution of those bonds by the purported bailors.
DISPOSITION: Taking mitigating factors into account (the claim of bona fides and the undue delay in proceeding), the court directed that Sri Girindra Kishore Jha be suspended from the legal profession for two years with immediate effect.
Implications: The direct and operative consequence is the two-year suspension from practice imposed on the pleader, effective immediately. The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader legal rule beyond application of the Legal Practitioners Act to the facts in this case; no novel precedent or sweeping doctrinal change is announced in the text of this decision.
JUDGMENT
1. Sri Z. Ahmad, a magistrate with first class powers of Bettiah has made this reference under Section 13(b) and Section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act, through the District Magistrate and the District and Sessions Judge of Champaran at Motihari.
2. The facts may be shortly stated. Cognizance of a Criminal case under Section 188 of the Penal Code was taken against one Ramsanehi Singh on the 13th November, 1952. That case was numbered as case No. 205, O. C. of 1952. The learned Magistrate who took cognizance passed an order on the same date, directing Ramsanehi to be released on bail of Rs. 800/- with two sureties of Rs. 400/-cach. Bail was offered by Mohan Lal and Rafique Mian. Sri Girindra Kishore Jha, Pleader, against whom this reference has been made, certified that they were fit persons to be bailors. A Sub Deputy Magistrate named Mr. S.N. Tewari held an enquiry and reported that those two proposed bailors were not fit persons. Ram Asrey and Sukhi stood sureties to the extent of Rs. 400/- each and they were also certified by the pleader to be fit persons. On the 15th November, 1952 Kanhai Ram offered bail of Rs. 800/-. The pleader certified him to be fit and Mr. Tewari also reported that he was fit. The bail offered by Kanhai with Ram Asrey and Sukhi as sureties was accepted and Ramsanehi was released on bail. The case was then transferred to the court of Mr. S.N. Tewari. On the 26th November, 1952, fresh bail was to be offered. One Raj Kishore Prasad Singh purported to execute the bail bond and the pleader certified him to be fit. The bond was accepted and Ramsanehi was released on fresh bail.
3. Ramsanehi did not appear on a date fixed in the case. Raj Kishore Prasad Singh was, therefore, noticed to show cause why the bail bond should not be forfeited. He appeared and stated that the bail bond had not been executed by him and that some other persons appeared to have executed it in his name. Thereafter, a case under Section 465/471 of the Penal Code was started against Ramsanehi. This case was numbered as case No. 204 O. C. of 1953. Trial was held by Mr. Zahur Ahmad, who has made the present reference. Sri Girindra Kishore Jha was examined in that case as prosecution witness No. 3. At the conclusion of the trial. Mr. Ahmad acquitted the accused, but came to the conclusion that the pleader was guilty of misconduct.
4. On the 14th June, 1956, Mr. Ahmad drew up three charges against the pleader in a proceeding under Section 14 read with See. 13(b) of the Legal Practitioners Act. These charges were as follows:
"(1) That you on 13-11-52 in case No. 205 OC/52 gave a certificate that bailors Mohan Lal, son of Gopal Singh, Rafique Mian son of Hurbur Mian of Bettiah (sic) and sufficient properties to stand as sureties for accused Ramsaheni Singh to the extent of Rs. 400/- each. But on enquiry, Mr. S.N. Tewari, Magistrate, Bettiah found the bailors not fit and recommended not to accept the bail bonds. You gave another certificate with respect to other bailors Ramasrey Mahto and Sukhi Ram Sah on the same bail bond, who were also found to be not fit sureties by the same Magistrate, after enquiry that you certified the bailors named to be fit and possessing sufficient properties. But in year cross examination in case No. 204 OC of 1953 in (your cross-examination) on 26-5-58 you stated that you did not remember to know the said bailors. That from your statements it appears that you gave a false certificate.
2. That you on 26-11-52 in case No. 205 OC of 1952 certified one Rajkishore Singh son of Udit Narain Singh of village Barwat P.S. Naulan as a fit surety and possessing sufficient property without verifying whether there was any such person of the above name and parentage and whether the said person had signed the bail bond. You also failed to verify as to who filled in the bail bond and whether some fictitious name was inserted with a view to secure release of the accused from custody. On verification, later on the bail bond was found to be a forged one and the accused could not have been released bad you not certified the bailors to be fit. (3) That you in case No. 205 OC of 1952 on 15-11-52 certified that bailor Kanhi Rout son of Khedan Rout of village Kargehia P.S. Bettiah was personally known to you and he possessed sufficient properties to stand as surety. But in your cross examination on 26-5-56 in case No. 204 OC of 1953 State v. Ramsanehi Singh AIR 465, I. P. C. (sic) you stated that you did not remember to have known Kanhi Ram son of Khedu Ram of village Kargahia P.H. Bettiah which shows that you gave false certificate of knowing the bailor personally which you did not know."
The pieader did not show cause on the date fixed i.e. the 29th June, 1956. He merely filed an application for time. The Magistrate in his order of that date stated that he was under orders of transfer and hence he could not grant one fortnight's time, as prayed for. He however, gave the pleader time until the 5th of July, 1956, and added that no further time would be given. On the 2nd of July, 1956, the pleader prayed for summons to be issued to Mr. S.N. Tewari, for his appearance as a witness. Mr, Ahmad rejected this petition, giving his reasons at length for not summoning Mr. Tewari. In that order he has expressed the view that this was only an excuse for avoiding disposal of the Legal Practitioners Act case by him and that Mr. Tewari could not really give any material evidence in the case. The Pleader then ceased to take any part in the case. On the date fixed for hearing, i.e., the 5th July, 1956, the pleader was present, but he did not file any show cause petition nor did he take any part in the case. Mr. Ahmad examined three witnesses and he came to the conclusion that the pleader was guilty of gross misconduct; he made the present reference dated the 10th July, 1956. As required by law, he submitted it through the District Magistrate and the District and Sessions Judge.
5. It is rather Surprising that the District Magistrate took no action at all on this reference until 1958. Mr. C.R. Vaidyanathan, District Magistrate stated in his letter dated the 29th July/1st August, 1958 to the District and Sessions Judge that his predecessor did not take any action as he learned that the pleader had been expelled from the Bar Association of Bettiah. In our opinion, that is hardly any excuse. As the reference was addressed to the Registrar of the Patna High Court, the District Magistrate concerned acted extremely improperly in detaining it for a long period. In any case, Mr. Vaidyanathan forwarded the reference to the District and Sessions Judge and the District and Sessions Judge forwarded it with his letter dated the 13th/18th October, 1958, to this Court.
6. The government Pleader has appeared in support of the reference and Mr. Raghunath Jha has appeared on behalf of the pleader. The point which the Government Pleader has urged is that the charges framed against the pleader have been made out, as his own admission in his deposition in case No. 204 OC of 1953 shows that the pleader did, not know the bailors and that he endorsed the certificates of their fitness on the bail bonds without knowing that the bail bonds had been executed by the bailors and the sureties. On the other hand, Mr. Jha has urged, firstly, that Mr Zahur Ahmad had no jurisdiction to make the present enquiry and report, and secondly that there are mitigating circumstances in favour of the pleader.
7. There has been a serious conflict of opinion in this court on the point as to whether it is the Presiding Officer of the Court in which the pleader has committed misconduct who can hold enquiry under Section 14 or the Presiding Officer of any other Court under the same District Judge or the same District Magistrate can hold it. Reference to the cases in which conflicting opinion upon this point has been expressed has been made in Special Bench decision of this Court in the case of the State of Bihar v. Chandreshwar Prasad, AIR 1960 Pat 1 (SB). We consider it unnecessary, however, to enter into this controversy because as stated in that very decision, this Court, itself can take cognizance under Section 13(b) if all the facts are before it. It seems to us that no further enquiry is necessary in this case, because there is no fact which the pleader in question proposed to prove in addition to the facts which are already on record. We, therefore, proceed to Consider the facts.
8. The pleader has filed show cause petition in this court. As we have said, he did not file any show cause petition before Magistrate concerned and, indeed, he did not take any defence there. In his deposition in case No. 204 O.C. of 1953, he admitted that the certificate of fitness (Exhibit 1(1)) on the bail bond (Exhibit 1) and the certificates of fitness (Exhibits A-1, B-1 and C-1) on the bail bonds (Exhibits A, B and C) were in his pen and he had signed them. . He further stated that he did not remember to have known Mohan Lal, Rafique and Kanhai Ram. He also stated that he knew Raj Kishore Narain Singh of Barwat, who was the richest man in his village, but he had not met Raj Kishore Singh on the date on which he signed the certificate on the bail bond purported to have been executed by Raj Kishore Singh, that he did not recognise the handwriting of Raj Kishore and that no part of the bail bond including the signature of the bailor was written in his presence. In view of these admissions, it is manifest that he gave the certificate on the bail bonds in question without ascertaining whether the bailors were really fit, and even without knowing whether the bailors, who purported to have executed the bonds, had actually executed them. If he had taken care, he would surely have known that some one other than Rajkishore had signed the bail bonds dated the 26th November, 1952.
9. Mr. Jha has argued that the statements made by the pleader in his deposition in case No. 204 O.C. of 1953 were made under a confusion as shown by an application which he filed before Mr. Ahmad. It appears that the pleader was examined in chief on the 24th November, 1955, and that he was partly cross examined on the 26th May, and partly on the 28th May, 1956. In his application dated the 28th May, 1956, before Mr. Z. Ahmad, the pleader stated that his enemy, Sri Ramawater Pd. Varma, Vakil, had been engaged to cross-examine him land that he was also under threat of assault by Ramsanehi and the men of Ramawatar Prasad Varma. It may be that he was under some apprehension of assault, but he does not say that the statements made by him in his deposition were False. He did not say at any stage before the matter came up to this court that there was any inaccuracy in any statement made by him. He did not say that even in his application dated the 28th May, 1956. Mr. Raghunath Jha has not been able to point out to us anything in his show cause petition filed in this court to the effect that any statement made by him in his deposition was inaccurate. In these circumstances, it is manifest that the pleader gave his certificates without knowing or believing that what be stated in those certificates was true.
10. In view of the circumstances mentioned above, we have come to the conclusion that Sri Girindra Kishore Jha has certainly been guilty of gross misconduct. The question which now arises is, what punishment should be awarded. There are some mitigating circumstances in this case, Firstly, he has stated in paragraph 13 of his sbow cause petition in the Court, that he acted bona fide in certifying those bailors as fit persons. This has not been controverted. But as we have said, it cannot mean that he gave those certificates after making necessary enquiries. What it may mean is that some one told him that the bailors were fit persons and that the bailors who purported to have executed the bonds had really executed them, and he acted on such information. This conduct is not excusable, because by giving the certificate he took the responsibility upon his head on both the points, namely, that the bailors and sureties had executed the bonds and that they were fit At the same time, we think that this may be a mitigating circumstance.
11. Another mitigating circumstance is that the proceeding has been unduly delayed for no fault of the pleader and he has been in suspense throughout a period of about 8 or 9 years.
12. Taking the above circumstances into consideration in mitigation, we think that suspension for two years from practice will meet the ends of justice in this case. We therefore direct that Sri Girindra Kishore Jha be suspended from the legal profession for two years with immediate effect.
Alert