Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ramphal Gope And Others v. The State Of Bihar .

Patna High Court
Dec 20, 1957
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, Ramphal Gope and Roshan Gope, along with others, were convicted by the trial Court under various sections of the Indian Penal Code including Section 148 and Section 324. The trial Court sentenced Ramphal Gope and Roshan Gope to one year's rigorous imprisonment and the remaining petitioners to three months' rigorous imprisonment, with no separate sentences for the Section 324 convictions. The appellate Court altered the convictions by reducing the charges from Sections 148 to 147 and from 324 to 323 IPC, and correspondingly reduced the sentences of imprisonment to fines. The prosecution case arose from an incident on 24th January 1957, when the petitioners demanded payment for onion seedlings from Ramdeo Gope, which led to a refusal and subsequent assault by the petitioners. A compromise petition was filed and accepted by the trial Court for the offences under Section 323 IPC, but the appellate Court convicted the petitioners under Sections 323 and 323/34 IPC. The revisional Court considered the effect of the compromise and the nature of the charges, particularly noting that the charge under Section 147 IPC was not compoundable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compromise petition accepted by the trial Court for offences under Section 323 IPC can be given effect at the appellate or revisional stage after conviction under those sections by the appellate Court.
  2. Whether the charge under Section 147 IPC, which is not compoundable, can stand if the charges under Sections 323 and 323/34 IPC fail due to the compromise.
  3. Whether the petitioners should be acquitted of all charges based on the compromise and the common object of the unlawful assembly.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • A compromise petition had been filed and accepted by the trial Court concerning the offence under Section 323 IPC.
  • The compromise should be recognized and put into effect even at the appellate or revisional stage.
  • Since the common object of the unlawful assembly was to assault, if the charges under Sections 323 and 323/34 IPC fail due to the compromise, then the charge under Section 147 IPC must also fail.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the effect of the compromise petition accepted by the trial Court on the charges under Section 323 IPC. It observed that the appellate Court had convicted the petitioners under Sections 323 and 323/34 IPC despite the compromise. The Court reasoned that since the offence under Section 147 IPC is not compoundable, it remains a charge. However, because the common object of the unlawful assembly was to assault, and the assault charges under Sections 323 and 323/34 IPC would fail if the compromise is given effect, the charge under Section 147 IPC must also fail. Therefore, the Court was satisfied that the petitioners should be acquitted of all charges. The Court accordingly allowed the revision application and set aside the convictions and sentences.

Holding and Implications

Application allowed.

The Court allowed the revision application, resulting in the acquittal of the petitioners and setting aside the order of conviction and sentence passed against them. This decision directly affects the parties by overturning their convictions, but the opinion does not establish any new precedent or broader legal implications beyond the case at hand.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an application in revision, against the order of the learned appellate Court, dismissing the petitioners' appeal. The petitioners Ramphal Gope and Roshan Gope were convicted; by the trial Court under Section 148 Indian Penal, Code and sentenced to one year's rigorous imprisonment. They were further convicted under Section 324 Indian Penal Code but no separate sentence was passed. The remaining petitioners were convicted by the trial Court under Section 148 Indian Penal Code and sentenced to three months rigorous imprisonment, and also convicted under Sections 324/34 Indian Penal Code but no separate sentence was passed. The appellate Court altered the convictions from under Sections 148 to 147 Indian Penal Code, and from 324 to 323 Indian Penal Code and from 324/34 to 323/34 Indian Penal Code, and reduced the sentence of imprisonment of one year to a fine of Rs. 100/-, and the three months' rigorous imprisonment to a-fine of Rs. 50/-.

2. The prosecution case, in short, is that on the 24th January, 1957, Ramphal Gope and one other man came to the house of Ramdeo Gope and demanded the price of onion seedlings which was due Ramdeo told that he would pay the price when he would get the price of milk which he had supplied to others.

3. This led to not words. It is said that on the following day at about 8 or 8-30 a.m the petitioners came to the house of Ramdeo and demanded payment of the price at once, but Ramdeo refused. Thereafter it is said that Ramdeo was assaulted by all the petitioners.

4. Mr. Baidya Nath Prasad appearing for the petitioners has pointed out to me that before the trial Court there was a compromise petition filed, and the trial Court accepted the compromise so far as the offence under Section 323 Indian Penal Code was concerned. Now that the appellate Court has found these petitioners guilty under Sections 323 and 323/54, Indian Penal Code, in my opinion, the compromise petition can be put into effect even at this stage. There now remains the charge under Section 147 Indian Penal Code which is not compoundable. But it appears that, the common object of the unlawful assembly was to assault. If the charges under Sections 323 and 323/34 Indian Penal Code fail on account of the compromise, it is obvious that the charge under Section 147 Indian Penal Code must also fail because the common object was to assault. For this reason I am satisfied that the petitioners must be acquitted of all the charges framed against them. The application is accordingly allowed, and the order of conviction and sentence passed on the petitioners is set aside.

CG/RMG/D.V.C

5. Application allowed.