Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Suresh Chandra Chaudhary v. Srimati Ranjana Devi And Others Opposite Party.

Patna High Court
Sep 30, 1988
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Jagannath Chaudhary instituted Title Suit No. 95 of 1979 in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, Munger seeking, inter alia, a declaration that a deed of gift dated 25 July 1979 executed in favour of defendant no. 1 Smt. Ranjana Devi was void and should be set aside, and that the defendant derived no title thereunder. Jagannath Chaudhary died on 3 April 1981 and his widow, Annapurna (substituted plaintiff), was placed in his stead.

On 23 April 1985 Annapurna filed an application under Order 23, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking withdrawal of the suit, stating among other things that no fraud had been practised in relation to the deed of gift and that it had been executed by her husband out of his free will as to his one-third share. The petitioner (who had been defendant no. 4 in the trial court) alleged that this application was collusive and untrue.

Annapurna allegedly died on 2 May 1985. The petitioner filed an application on 24 June 1985 seeking transposition to the category of plaintiff and challenged the authenticity of a vakalatnama said to have been executed by Annapurna. Before the transposition application was decided, on 28 June 1985 counsel appearing for Annapurna filed the withdrawal application (with an affidavit by Brahmanand Jha) and the Additional Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, Munger allowed the plaintiff's withdrawal by order dated 28 June 1985. The petitioner contends that the order was passed without calling out the suit, without hearing the defendants, and without dealing with the transposition application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court could permit withdrawal of the suit under Order 23, Rule 1 without hearing the opposing defendants and without addressing an application for transposition filed by a defendant.
  2. Whether the authority of a lawyer to press or withdraw a suit continues after the death of the client (specifically whether the counsel could press the withdrawal application after Annapurna's death).
  3. Whether, in view of Order 23, Rule 1A (as inserted by the Civil Procedure Code Amendment Act, 1976), the petitioner (defendant) ought to have been transposed to the plaintiff's role and whether the court was obliged to consider such transposition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Defendant no. 4) Arguments

  • The impugned order of 28 June 1985 was illegal because the learned court below permitted withdrawal without hearing the petitioner or giving notice to defendants regarding the withdrawal application.
  • After the (substituted) plaintiff Annapurna died (2 May 1985), her lawyer had no authority to represent her or press the withdrawal application; thus the order obtained at the counsel's behest is wholly illegal.
  • Under the express provision of Order 23, Rule 1A (as inserted by the Amendment Act of 1976), the court was obliged to transpose the petitioner to the category of plaintiff; the transposition application should have been allowed or at least considered.

Opposite Parties' (Respondents 1 & 2) Arguments

  • No fraud was practised by the original plaintiff in executing the deed of gift; the withdrawal application filed by Annapurna on 23 April 1985 was genuine.
  • Because the withdrawal application had been filed by Annapurna prior to her death on 2 May 1985, the learned court below was competent to pass the withdrawal order and the counsel pressing the application should be held to have had requisite authority.
  • The petitioner's transposition application under Order 23, Rule 1A was premature; if the petitioner files a fresh application under that provision, the learned court below may consider it on merits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Md. Muzahid v. John Wilson Zedak Interpreting limitations on plaintiff's right to withdraw/abandon suit after amendment; consideration of transposition under Order XXIII/Order 23 rules. Relied upon as recent authority explaining that the plaintiff's right to withdraw is not absolute after the 1976 amendment and that Rule 1-A requires courts to consider transposition where substantial questions between defendants exist.
Hulas Rai Baij Nath (supra) Cited among authorities laying down when a defendant may be transposed as plaintiff. Noted as part of the line of authorities showing limits on the plaintiff's right to withdraw; used to support interpretation that right to withdraw cannot always be absolute.
R. Ramamurthi Aiyer v. Rajeshwararao Authority on circumstances when defendant may be transposed as plaintiff under Order XXII, Rule 1(1). Counted in the line of cases relied on to show that transposition may be appropriate where defendants have substantive rights to be adjudicated.
AIR 1973 SC 643 Referenced in the same cluster of authorities dealing with transposition and limits on withdrawal. Used as part of the supporting authorities for the proposition that a plaintiff's right to withdraw is not unfettered in all circumstances.
Basudeb Narayan Cited among cases laying down principles for transposition of defendants as plaintiffs. Included in the line of cases relied upon to interpret Rule 1-A and the court's discretion regarding transposition.
AIR 1979 Pat. 73 Referenced together with Basudeb Narayan as part of authorities on transposition. Relied upon as part of the jurisprudential backdrop for limiting the plaintiff's right to withdraw and for considering transposition.
Debi Chand v. Prabhu Lal Authority referenced on when a defendant may be transposed as plaintiff. Used to illustrate existing case-law that transposition may be proper depending on the nature of the suit and rights already vested.
AIR 1926 All 582 Referenced in conjunction with Debi Chand and similar authorities on transposition. Countenanced as part of the established line of authority concerning limits on withdrawal and criteria for transposition.
Loke Nath Saha v. Radha Govind Saha Cited among cases that address transposition of defendants as plaintiffs. Relied on as one of several precedents demonstrating circumstances where a defendant may be transposed to prosecute the suit.
AIR 1026 Cal 184 Cited as part of the older authorities on transposition and withdrawal. Included in the set of precedents used to show that courts have limited the plaintiff's absolute right to withdraw in certain circumstances.
Jethiben's case Referenced for an interpretation of Rule 1-A which the court declined to follow. The court expressly stated it was unable to accept the interpretation of Rule 1-A as held in Jethiben's case and preferred the reading set out in Md. Muzahid and allied authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the impugned order of 28 June 1985 and found that the learned trial court granted permission to withdraw without hearing the other defendants, including the petitioner. The counsel for Annapurna had accepted that Annapurna died on 2 May 1985 but nonetheless pressed the withdrawal application; the trial court acceded to that prayer without assigning reasons.

The court emphasised the obligation under Order 23, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code that the court must apply its mind to the contents of an application for withdrawal. It noted also that under Order 23, Rule 1(4) withdrawal without requisite permission can attract costs, and that where withdrawal is opposed by a defendant who is vitally interested, the court must scrutinise the application carefully.

The substituted plaintiff's withdrawal application contained statements inconsistent with the original plaint (notably admissions about the genuineness of the deed of gift). Allowing withdrawal on such a basis would have directly benefited respondents 1 and 2 by accepting admissions contrary to the original suit's case.

On the question of counsel's authority, the court considered Order 3, Rule 4 (pleader's authority) and observed that while a counsel with authority may withdraw a suit unless acting contrary to instructions or misconducting himself, the appointment of a lawyer generally continues until the client's death only in certain exceptional circumstances. The court concluded that after Annapurna's death the lawyer's authority came to an end and he had no power to press the withdrawal application.

The court analysed the import of the Civil Procedure Code (Amendment) Act, 1976 which inserted Order 23, Rule 1A. It explained that Rule 1-A was meant to enable a defendant to apply for transposition as plaintiff where the suit is withdrawn or abandoned, and the court must consider whether the applicant has a substantial question to be decided against other defendants. On a plain reading, an application for transposition is not premature merely because the plaintiff has expressed intent to withdraw; such an application may be filed and considered at that stage.

Applying these principles, and having found the impugned order to be made without jurisdiction and without required application of mind, the court held that the order could not be sustained. It set aside the 28 June 1985 order and allowed the civil revision, leaving the trial court to reconsider the transposition application at the appropriate stage.

Holding and Implications

The impugned order dated 28th June, 1985 is set aside and the civil revision application is allowed.

Direct consequences:

  • The trial court is directed to pass a fresh order in accordance with law and to consider the petitioner's application for transposition under Order 23, Rule 1A at the appropriate stage.
  • The court held that the lawyer for the (substituted) plaintiff had no authority to press the withdrawal application after the plaintiff's death; therefore the withdrawal order was illegal and without jurisdiction.
  • In the circumstances of this case, there shall be no order as to costs.

Broader implications:

The opinion reiterates that after the 1976 amendment (Order 23, Rule 1A) a plaintiff's right to withdraw is not absolute: courts must consider transposition applications where substantial questions exist between defendants and may deny withdrawal or transpose parties as appropriate. The court directed application of these principles but did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond its application to the facts here.

Show all summary ...

S.B Sinha, J.:— This revision application is directed against an order dated the 28th June, 1985, passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, Munger, in Title Suit No. 95 of 1979 whereby and whereunder the plaintiff was permitted to withdraw the suit.

2. In view of the point involved in this case, it is not necessary to state the facts of the case in detail. The facts of the case lie in a very narrow compass. One Jagannath Chaudhary instituted Title Suit No. 95 of 1979 in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, Munger inter alia, for a declaration that the deed of gift dated the 25th July, 1979, executed in favour of defendant no. 1 Smt. Ranjana Devi (opposite party no. 1) was void and be set aside and for a further declaration that the defendant first party had derived no title thereto. The said Jagannath Chaudhary died on the 3rd April, 1981, and his widow Annapurna was substituted in his place. On the 23rd April, 1985 Annapurna Devi filed an application under Order 23, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for withdrawal of the suit. In the said application, it was inter alia, stated that no fraud was practised in the matter of the execution of the aforementioned deed of gift and it was further stated that the same was executed by her husband (the original plaintiff) Jagannath Chaudhary out of his own free will with regard to his one third share.

3. According to the petitioner who was defendant no. 4 in the court below, the said application for withdrawal of the suit was collusive and did not represent the true state of affairs. However, before any order could be passed on the said petition, the aforementioned Annapura Devi died on the 2nd May, 1985. On the 24th June, 1985, the petitioner filed an application for being transposed to the category of the plaintiff. It was further stated that the purported vakalatnama allegedly executed by Smt. Annapurna Devi was a forged and fabricated document as she had been ailing for a long time and was not in her senses to execute any vakalatnama. The said petition was directed to be put up on the next date fixed. However, on the 28th June, 1985, the lawyer appearing on behalf of the aforesaid Annapurna Devi who, as stated hereinbefore, died in the meanwhile filed the said application for withdrawal of the suit along with the affidavit of one Brahmanand Jha in which it was alleged that the deceased Annapurna Devi was his own aunt and on whose asking he was working as Karpordaj. According to the petitioner, the impugned order was passed without calling out the suit and hearing the defendants and without hearing and/or passing any order on the application for transposition filed on behalf of the petitioner.

4. In this case, a counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the opposite party nos. 1 and 2. According to the said opposite party, no fraud was committed by Jagannath Chaudhary in the matter of execution of the aforementioned deed of gift dated the 25th July 1979. It has further been submitted that the petition dated the 23rd April, 1985, filed by Smt. Annapurna Devi for withdrawal of the suit was genuine.

5. Mr. Debendra Narain Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, in support of the civil revision application has raised three questions. According to the learned counsel, the learned court below could not have passed the impugned order without hearing the petitioner and without giving any notice to the defendants with regard to the said application for the suit. The learned counsel secondly contended that, as the original plaintiff died on the 2nd May, 1985, her lawyer ceased to have any authority whatsoever to represent her and, in this view of the matter, the impugned order dated the 28th June, 1985, which was passed at the behest of the counsel for the plaintiff must be held to be wholly illegal. Mr. Sinha lastly contended that in view of the express provision contained in Order 23, Rule 1A, Civil Procedure Code as inserted by the Amendment Act of 1976, it was obligatory of the learned court below to transpose the petitioner to the category of the plaintiff.

6. Mr. Ashok Kumar Keshri, learned counsel appearing for the opposite party nos. 1 and 2, however, submitted that, in view of the fact that the application for withdrawal of the suit was filed by the aforementioned Annapurna Devi on the 23rd April, 1985, and she having died on the 2nd May, 1985 the learned court below was competent to pass the impugned order and the counsel must also be held to have the requisite authority to press the said application. Mr. Keshri further submitted that in any event the petitioner's application for transposition in terms of Order 23, Rule 1A of the Civil Procedure Code being premature, the petitioner cannot make any grievance in relation to the subject matter. He submitted that, if the petitioner files a fresh application in terms of Order 23, Rule 1A of the Civil Procedure Code, now the same may be considered on its own merits by the learned court below.

7. From the impugned order dated the 28th June, 1985, passed by the learned court below, it is evident that before passing the said order, he did not hear the other defendants, including the petitioner. From a perusal of the said order, it is further evident that the counsel on behalf of the aforementioned Annapurna Devi accepted that she died on the 2nd May, 1985, but pleaded that, as it was not possible to adduce evidence on her behalf in view of her death, the application for withdrawal filed by her should be accepted. The learned court below without assigning any reason whatsoever has acceded to the aforementioned prayer and permitted the suit to be withdrawn. Order 23, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code postulates that when an application for withdrawal of suit is filed, the Court has to apply its mind with regard to the contents of the said application.

8. In terms of Order 23, Rule 1(4) of the Civil Procedure Code if the plaintiff withdraws from a suit without the permission referred to in sub-rule (3), he becomes liable for payment of such cost as the court may award. It is, therefore, evident that before a court grants permission to the plaintiff to withdraw the suit, it must apply its mind to the facts of the case particularly when such withdrawal is opposed by one of the defendants who is vitally interested in the subject matter of the suit. Further in the instant case it is evident that the said application for withdrawal of the suit was not necessitated because of any defent therein but while praying for withdrawal of the suit the substituted plaintiff, namely, Smt. Annapurna Devi made out a case which was completely contradictory to and inconsistent with the case made out in the original plaint. If the suit was permitted to be withdrawn on the basis of such application, the same would certainly be beneficial to respondents 1 and 2 inasmuch as admissions have been made therein with regard to the genuineness of the deed of gift executed by the original plaintiff although the same was the subject mailer of the suit.

9. In this view of the matter, the impugned order passed by the learned court below cannot be sustained. In terms of Order 3, Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code a counsel, who has the authority, may be held to have the power to withdraw the suit unless it is shown that the pleader has acted contrary to his instruction or against the interest of the client or is otherwise guilty of misconduct. However, it is well known that the appointment of a lawyer continues till the death of his client. Only in certain exceptional circumstances, as for example, curing of some defects in the suit, etc. a lawyer may act in pursuance of the authority in spite of the death of his client.

10. However, in the instant case, in my opinion, there cannot be any doubt whatsoever that after the death of Smt. Annapurna Devi the authority of her lawyer also cams to an end and, as such he had absolutely no power to press the application for withdrawal of suit filed on behalf of Smt. Annapurna Devi.

11. By reason of the Civil Procedure Code (Amendment) Act, 1976, a new provision by way of Order 23, Rule 1A has been inserted. The said provision reads as follows:—

“Where a suit is withdrawn or abandoned by a plaintiff under Rule 1, and a defendant applies to be transposed as a plaintiff under Rule 10 of Order 1, the court shall, in considering such application, have due regard to the question whether the applicant has a substantial question to be decided as against any of the other defendants.

12. In a recent decision in the case of Md. Muzahid v. John Wilson Zedak (1988 PLJR 857), it was held as follows:—

“7. There are decisions of Supreme Court and different High Courts including this Court (to notice a few Hulas Rai Baij Nath (supra), R. Ramamurthi Aiyer v. Rajeshwararao, AIR 1973 SC 643, Basudeb Narayan, AIR 1979 Pat. 73. Debi Chand v. Prabhu Lal, AIR 1926 All 582, Loke Nath Saha v. Radha Govind Saha, AIR 1026 Cal 184, which lay down when a defendant may be transposed as plaintiff if the latter files application under Order XXII, Rule 1(1). In a suit for partition, if the plaintiff wants to withdraw the suit, the defendant if he wants to prosecute the suit, should be transposed as plaintiff. The same is the position with regard to suit for accounts by a partner. There is no difficulty in appreciating this proposition as in such suits, the position of all the parties is that of plaintiff. Again if a preliminary decree has been passed, the plaintiff should not be allowed to withdraw the suit, and if a right has already vested in defendant, the plaintiff shall not be allowed to withdraw the suit.”

“8. It will thus, be noticed that in spite of the language of Order XXIII, Rule 1(1) as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Hulas Rai Baij Nath's case, Courts held that in all cases right of plaintiff to withdraw a suit cannot be said to be absolute. These decisions were rendered before the amendment of the Code in 1976.”

13. In the said decision, it was further held as follows:—

“17. Rule 1 was substituted by Act, 104 of 1976. In the old rule, both the words ‘withdraw’ and ‘abandon’ were used. In the new Rule 1, in sub-rule (1) of Rule 1, the word used is ‘abandon’ and sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, the word used is withdraw. Rule 1-A applies to both cases of abandonment and withdrawal. The right of plaintiff to abandon the suit under Rule 1(1) has been left unfettered, but in a case where court is of opinion that substantial question is to be decided as against any of the other defendants, the defendant who may apply for transposition ought to be transposed as plaintiff and the original plaintiff ought to be transposed as a defendant. The right of plaintiff to walk out of a suit by abandoning it or withdrawing from suit has been curtailed. Before insertion of Rule 1-A, there was no question of transposing a defendant as plaintiff, if the dispute was inter se defendants. But now it is specifically provided that court shall take into consideration whether there is substantial question to be decided between the defendants inter se. For all these reasons with respect. I am unable to accept the interpretation of Rule 1-A as held in Jethiben's case.”

14. In the said decision, it was further held that when a prayer for transposition may be allowed will depend on the facts of each case.

15. The aforesaid rule 1-A of Order 23 was inserted to meet the circumstances where 1 the defendant may be allowed to be transposed as plaintiff, where the suit is withdrawn or abandoned by the plaintiff. It is obvious that the said provision was inserted in order to facilitate the defendant to get the adjudication of his right.

16. However, reading the provision of Order 23, Rule 1 and Order 23, Rule 1-A of the Civil Procedure Code together, I am of the view that an application for transposition filed by a defendant cannot be said to be premature if no order has been passed on the said application. On a plain reading of Order 23, Rule 1-A of the Civil Procedure Code, to my mind, an application can be filed even when the plaintiff expresses his intent to withdraw or abandon the suit by way of filing an application or otherwise. As a matter of fact, at that stage, the Court may not only pass the necessary order on such application for transposition filed on behalf of the defendants or any of them, but would be in a position to consider as to whether in such a situation, the plaintiff himself should be transposed to the category of defendant or not.

17. In any event, in view of the fact and as I have held hereinbefore, that the impugned order was wholly illegal and without jurisdiction and is, thus liable to be set aside, it would be open to the learned court below to consider the application for transposition filed on behalf of defendant no. 1 petitioner at the appropriate stage. In this view of the matter, the order dated the 28th June, 1985, is set aside and the civil revision application is allowed. The learned court below is hereby directed to pass a fresh order in accordance with law. However, in the circumstances of this case, there shall be no order as to costs.