Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sachidanand Lal And Another, Etc. v. State Of Bihar And Others

Patna High Court
Mar 1, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions involve the acquisition of multiple plots of land for establishing an Industrial Area in Lohardaga. The acquisition process began with a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, published on 16th July 1982, followed by a declaration under Section 6 on 1st February 1985. The award was published on 5th November 1987. The petitioners challenged the validity of the award, arguing it was invalid because it was published beyond the two-year period prescribed by Section 11-A of the Act, which came into force on 24th September 1984. The respondents contended that a prior writ petition (C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R)) had stayed the proceedings temporarily, and the period of that stay should be excluded in computing the two-year limit. The earlier writ petition was disposed of on 4th April 1986 after the land in question was de-notified, and the respondents argued the award was published within the legally permissible period when the stay period was excluded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the effect of the stay order passed by this Court in C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R) on the land acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894?
  2. Whether the period during which the stay order was operative should be excluded in computing the two-year period prescribed under Section 11-A of the Act for publication of the award?
  3. How should the Explanation to Section 11-A, which excludes periods during which any action or proceeding pursuant to the declaration is stayed by a Court order, be interpreted—narrowly (limited to the land involved in the earlier writ petition) or broadly (affecting the entire acquisition proceeding)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The stay order dated 24th April 1985 restrained the respondents only from making any award with respect to the land involved in the earlier writ petition (C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R)).
  • The respondents cannot claim exclusion of the stay period for the present acquisition proceedings because the subject matter of the current writ petitions was not the subject matter of the earlier writ petition.
  • The Explanation to Section 11-A should be interpreted narrowly and confined to the land involved in the earlier writ petition.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The stay order related to any action or proceeding pursuant to the declaration under Section 6 and thus operated to stay the entire acquisition proceeding.
  • The period during which the stay order was in force should be excluded from the two-year period for publishing the award under Section 11-A of the Act.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in Balak Ram Gupta v. Union of India, AIR 1987 Delhi 239 (FB), which held that even if a stay order relates to a portion of the land, it affects the whole acquisition proceeding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balak Ram Gupta v. Union of India, AIR 1987 Delhi 239 (FB) Interpretation of stay orders affecting land acquisition proceedings; exclusion of stay period in computing statutory time limits under the Land Acquisition Act. The Court accepted the reasoning that a stay order affecting a portion of the land acquisition proceeding effectively stays the entire proceeding for the purpose of computing time under Section 11-A, giving the Explanation the widest amplitude.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the effect of the stay order passed in the earlier writ petition on the computation of the two-year period prescribed under Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act. It noted that the Explanation to Section 11-A excludes from the computation any period during which a stay order is operative in respect of proceedings pursuant to the declaration under Section 6.

The Court observed that although the stay order was passed in relation to a portion of the land, the acquisition was for a composite Industrial Area requiring the entire area to be available simultaneously for effective planning and development. Since a substantial portion of the land was under stay, the respondents could not proceed with the acquisition of the remaining land independently.

Relying on the precedent set by the Delhi High Court in Balak Ram Gupta, the Court held that the language of the Explanation is broad and must be interpreted to cover the entire acquisition proceeding, not just the land directly involved in the stay order. This interpretation aligns with the legislative intent to prevent undue delay in land acquisition and to protect landowners from prolonged uncertainty.

Therefore, the Court concluded that the period during which the stay order was in effect (24th April 1985 to 4th April 1986) must be excluded from the two-year period for publishing the award. On this basis, the award published on 5th November 1987 was within the prescribed period and valid.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are dismissed.

The Court held that the stay order passed in the earlier writ petition effectively stayed the entire land acquisition proceeding, and the period of the stay must be excluded when computing the two-year time limit under Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act. Consequently, the award published on 5th November 1987 was valid and within time. This decision directly affects the parties by upholding the validity of the acquisition award. No new precedent beyond the application of existing principles from Balak Ram Gupta was established.

Show all summary ...

Satyeshwar Roy, J.:— The facts involved in these two writ petitions and the law applicable thereto are the same, they were heard together and are being disposed of by this judgment.

2. On 16th July, 1982, a notification under S. 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (the Act) was published in Ranchi District Gazette for acquisition of number of plots for setting up an Industrial Area in Lohardaga, copy of notification is Annexure 1 to the writ petition. On 1st, Feb., 1985, a declaration under S. 6 of the Act was published in Ranchi District Gazette, copy of which is Annexure 2 to the writ petition. Award was published on 5-11-1987. According to the petitioners, since award has not been published within two years from 24-9-1984 when S. 11-A of the Act came into force, it was invalid.

3. In the counter-affidavit, inter alia, it has been stated on behalf of respondent 4 that some of the persons had moved this Court challenging the validity of the acquisition, the subject matter of Annexures 1 and 2; that was registered as C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R). In that writ petition, a Bench of this Court on 24-1-1985 passed an interim order to the effect that pending further orders. The respondents are restrained from making any award with respect to the land in question. On 4-4-1986 on the basis of a petition filed by the petitioner in that case and the Collector, respondent in that case in which it was stated that the land of the petitioners of that case had been, de-notified, the case was disposed of. It is the case of the respondents that in view of the order of stay passed on 24-4-1985 in that writ petition which automatically stood vacated on 4-4-1986, that period shall have to be excluded for computing the period of two years from 1st Feb., 1985 and if that is done, it is their further case, the award has been published within the time prescribed under S. 11A of the Act.

4. The question that is necessary to be answered is: what was the effect of the order of stay passed by this Court in C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R) on the land acquisition proceeding.

5. It was urged on behalf of the petitioners that by order dt. 24-4-1985, the respondents were restrained from making any award with respect to the land which was subject matter of that writ petition and the respondents in this case cannot be heard to say that they are entitled to exclude the period during which that writ petition was pending as the subject matter of this writ petition was not the subject matter of that writ petition. According to the respondents, since the order of stay was with regard to any action or proceeding to be taken in pursuance of the declaration as contained in Annexure-2, the period during which the stay order was operative shall have to be excluded. Reliance was placed in the case of Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India…., AIR 1987 Delhi 239 (FB).

For various development projects vast areas of land throughout the country was required to be acquired. It is common experience that in the past in large number of cases, after notification under S. 4 of the Act was made for acquisition of land for public purpose, no further steps in that regard were taken for a number of years for publishing the award which resulted in serious pecuniary loss to the owners of the lands sought to be acquired as they were entitled to the value of the lands at the date of the publication of the notification under S. 4 of the Act. This fact was also judicially noticed. To remove this, the Parliament amended the Act by inserting new sections and also amending the existing sections inter alia, by prescribing time limit for publication of declaration under S. 6 and for publishing the award. This was done by the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, 1954, which came into force on 24th Sept., 1984. Section 11A was introduced by the Amendment Act which reads as follows:—

“The Collector shall make an award under Section 11 within a period of two years from the date of the publication of the declaration and if no award is made within that period, the entire proceedings for the acquisition of land shall lapse:

Provided that in a case the said declaration has been published before the commencement of the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, 1984, the award shall be made within a period of two years from such commencement.

Explanation:— In computing the period of two years referred to in this section, the period during which any action or proceeding to be taken in pursuance of the said declaration is stayed by an order of a Court shall be excluded”.

6. Admittedly, in an earlier writ petition, order of stay was passed by this Court in publishing the award with regard to the land in question in that writ petition. According to the petitioners, since the order of stay specifically referred to the land involved in that writ petition, the respondents cannot be heard to say that because of the order of stay, they did not publish the award and were entitled to claim exclusion of the period when the order of stay was operative. Should the explanation be interpreted in a narrow sense and confine it to the land involved in the earlier writ petition or should it be interpreted in a broad sense and held that the order affected the whole land acquisition proceeding in question?

7. As a broad proposition of law, it cannot be disputed that order of stay order of injunction operates between the parties to the lis and with regard to the subject matter; but such order may have indirect effect to the action or proceeding with regard to property which may not be directly involved in that us in which the order of injuction or stay has been passed. Further, in interpreting the explanation, we must keep in view the object for which it was introduced and should interpret it to give effect to that object.

8. From the report of Balak Ram Gupta's case (AIR 1987 Delhi 239) (FB) it appears that a number of writ petitions were filed in Delhi High Court challenging the validity of the declaration made under S. 6 of the Act on the ground that it was made beyond the period prescribed in that section. Respondents in that case pleaded that as order of stay had been passed in writ petitions challenging the validity of the notification under S. 4, the period when the orders of stay were operative shall have to be excluded. This was countered by the other side by stating that the order of stay operated only with regard to land involved in those writ petitions and had no effect on the whole proceeding.

9. The Delhi High Court noticed a large number of decisions of different High Courts and the Supreme Court and held that even if the order of stay or order of injunction was with regard to a portion of the subject matter of the acquisition, the prohibition or stay had the effect on the whole proceeding to be taken in pursuance of notification made under S. 4 of the Act. Explanation-1 to sub-sec. (1) of S. 6 of the Act was applicable to the facts to those cases. The Court held that the words used in the explanation are of widest amplitude and there is no justification whatever to confine its terms and operation only to the cases in which the stay order is actually obtained. I do not think it necessary to exercise over it again as the language of Explanation 1 to S. 6(1) and that to S. 11A is same. With respect, I accept the reasoning given by the Delhi High Court and hold that the language used in Explanation to S. 11A is of widest amplitude. The order of stay passed in the earlier writ petition by this Court in C.W.J.C No. 319 of 1985 (R) had the effect of staying the whole of the proceeding after the declaration was made under S. 6 of the Act.

10. In this particular case, as noticed above, a large track of land consisting of a large number of plots was sought to be acquired for setting up the Industrial Area. For giving effect to that, it was necessary for the respondents to take into consideration the total area available for the purpose of laying down roads constructing sheds where the entrepreneurs may put up their factories, providing sewerage, drinking water and such other amenities and facilities which are essentially to be provided in such area. The respondents were also required to take into consideration the fact that entrepreneurs may have to be given other facilities keeping in view the provisions of the Indian Factories Act, 1948, for instance canteen, creche etc. It must also be kept in mind that the Industrial Area is to be set up on a composite block of land. The plan for setting up the Industrial Area can be executed only if the whole of the area sought to be acquired is available at a time. We are informed that the area involved in the earlier writ petition was 14.70 acres and the total area sought to be acquired under Annexures 1 and 2 is 51.17 acres, more or less.

It will thus be noticed that substantial area out of the total area sought to be acquired was the subject matter of the earlier writ petition. That being the position, the respondents could not have been expected to proceed with the acquisition of the balance area when nobody knew whether the area which was the subject matter of the writ petition would be ultimately available to be used as a part of the Industrial Area. This also is a ground for which the Explanation must be given a broader interpretation and it must be held that the order of stay passed in earlier writ petition had the effect of staying the land acquisition proceeding itself.

11. For all the reasons aforesaid, I am of the opinion that the period from 24-4-1985 to 4-4-1986 shall have to be excluded for computing the period of two years from the date the declaration under S. 6 was made. That being the position, the award published on 5th Nov., 1987 was within the period prescribed under S. 11A of the Act.

12. In the result, both the writ petitions are dismissed, but I shall make no order as to costs.

B.P Singh, J.:— 13. I agree.

Petitions dismissed.