Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jitendra Ku. Choudhur v. Banku Sahoo

Orissa High Court
Jul 25, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, defendant in C.S No. 102 of 2006 and petitioner in C.M.A No. 23 of 2011 under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), challenged an order dated 22.12.2012 rejecting the prayer to set aside an ex parte decree dated 25.4.2011. The respondent, plaintiff in the suit, filed for specific performance of a contract dated 20.4.2004 for a property sale. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed another suit (C.S 52 of 2007) to restrain the defendant and the bank from taking action against the property given as security for a loan. Both suits were heard analogously.

During trial, the plaintiff was examined partially due to adjournments sought by the defendant. On 22.4.2011, the defendant sought another adjournment which was allowed as a last chance subject to a cost of Rs. 50/-, with the case posted to 23.4.2011 for payment of cost and hearing. On 23.4.2011, the defendant appeared but did not pay the cost nor requested extension of time, and declined to further cross-examine the plaintiff's witness. The court barred the defendant from further defending and heard arguments, ultimately decreeing the suit on 25.4.2011.

The defendant filed a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC to set aside the judgment, registered as C.M.A No. 23 of 2011. During its pendency, the plaintiff challenged the maintainability of the petition. The trial court initially held the petition maintainable on 17.8.2012 but later took a contrary view and dismissed the petition, holding that Order 9 Rule 13 CPC did not apply. The present appeal challenges this dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC to set aside the ex parte decree is maintainable in the facts and circumstances of the case.
  2. Whether the principle of res judicata applies to the trial court’s contradictory findings on maintainability of the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC.
  3. Whether the defendant was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing on the relevant date to justify setting aside the decree under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC.
  4. Whether the provisions of Order 17 Rule 2 of CPC are attracted in the dismissal of the suit and the subsequent petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The earlier finding that the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC was maintainable was not challenged and hence the later contradictory finding is erroneous and illegal.
  • The trial court erred in considering the defendant’s past conduct rather than whether he was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing on the relevant date.
  • The circumstances of the suit dismissal attract the provisions of Order 17 Rule 2 CPC, making the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC maintainable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The last adjournment was granted subject to payment of cost, which the defendant did not pay, justifying the trial court’s decision to debar the defendant from defending.
  • The plaintiff had closed evidence and the suit was rightly decided on merits.
  • The petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC is not maintainable in the case’s facts.
  • The appellant did not approach the trial court with clean hands, having filed both a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC and a regular appeal challenging the same judgment and decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satyadhyan Ghosal v. Smt. Deorajin Debi, AIR 1960 SC 941 Principle of res judicata between stages of same litigation Applied to hold that a court will not allow re-agitation of a matter already decided at an earlier stage in the same proceeding, but interlocutory orders not appealed can be challenged in appeal from final decree.
Mulia Maharana v. Narayan Patra, AIR 1964 Orissa 246 Interpretation of non-appearance and sufficient cause under Order 9 CPC Quoted to emphasize that presence alone does not preclude sufficient cause for non-appearance and that non-cooperation with court is not a determinative factor; each case depends on facts and circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the principle of res judicata as applied in Satyadhyan Ghosal’s case, finding that the trial court’s contradictory findings on maintainability of the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC are subject to this principle but can be reviewed in the present appeal.

The court analyzed the applicability of Order 17 Rules 2 and 3 CPC, noting that Rule 2 applies when parties fail to appear generally, and Rule 3 applies when parties fail to produce evidence despite being present. Since the defendant was present but declined to continue cross-examination after rejection of his adjournment petition and did not pay the cost, Rule 3 was not applicable.

The court relied on the observations from Mulia Maharana’s case to highlight that mere presence does not automatically negate sufficient cause for non-appearance, but the defendant failed to prove any sufficient cause preventing appearance on 23.4.2011. The defendant’s claim of having filed a petition for transfer of the suit was unsupported by any material evidence.

Further, the court emphasized that the trial court’s order of 23.4.2011 clearly stated the defendant was debarred from further defense due to non-payment of cost under Section 35-B CPC, and the plaintiff had closed evidence. Under these circumstances, the trial court rightly proceeded to judgment and the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC was not attracted.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal (F.A.O) without costs.

The direct effect of this decision is the upholding of the trial court’s dismissal of the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC to set aside the ex parte decree. No broader precedent was established beyond affirming the trial court’s exercise of discretion in the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

The present appellant who is the defendant in C.S No. 102 of 2006 and the petitioner in C.M.A No. 23 of 2011 under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC in the court of the 2nd Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Cuttack challenges the order dated 22.12.2012 passed by the learned Civil Judge in the C.M.A rejecting the prayer to set aside the ex parte decree dated 25.4.2011 passed in the C.S

2. The respondent herein is the plaintiff in the suit. He filed the suit for a decree for specific performance of contract directing the appellant-defendant to perform an agreement dated 20.4.2004 and to execute and register a Sale Deed in respect of the plaint schedule ‘A’ property on receiving the balance consideration money from the respondent-plaintiff and to deliver possession of the property to him. Subsequently, the respondent-plaintiff filed another suit registered as C.S 52 of 2007, on the allegation that the suit property being given on security with State Bank of India, Tulasipur Branch, against a loan availed by the appellant-defendant was going to be attached and sold under the Securitization & Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002, made a prayer to restrain the defendant so also the Bank from taking action in respect of the suit property for realization of Bank dues with further prayer to direct the Bank to receive the outstanding loan dues from the plaintiff and to release the title deeds in respect of the suit property which was deposited with the Bank by the defendant-appellant. Both the suits were taken up for analogous hearing. When the trial commenced, the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 On different dates he was cross-examined in parts because of petitions for adjournment filed by the defendant from time to time. Ultimately, the date was fixed to 22.4.2011 for further cross-examination of P.W.1 On that date the defendant again prayed for adjournment. Observing that P.W.1 was already sent back on several occasions without examination, the learned trial court allowed the petition and granted adjournment as last chance subject to payment of cost of Rs. 50/- and posted the case to 23.4.2011 for payment of cost as well as hearing of the suit. On 23.4.2011 the defendant appeared in person and filed an adjournment petition on the ground that he had made an application to the learned District Judge seeking transfer of the suit to some other court. On that date neither the cost was paid nor any prayer for extension of time was made. The learned trial court rejected the petition for time. Since the defendant, who was present in person, declined to further cross-examine P.W.1 and since the plaintiff had already closed his case, the learned lower court passed order debarring the defendant from further prosecuting his defence on the ground of non-payment of cost and on the same date argument was heard and the case was adjourned to 25.4.2011 for judgment. On the date fixed, the judgment was pronounced decreeing the suit bearing C.S No. 102 of 2006 and dismissing the other suit bearing C.S No. 52 of 2007.

3. After dismissal of the suit, the defendant filed petition under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 of C.P.C to set aside the judgment dated 25.4.2011 The same was registered as C.M.A No. 23 of 2011. During pendency of the proceeding in the C.M.A, the plaintiff-opposite party filed a petition to take up the point of maintainability of the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of C.P.C before going to the main proceeding. On that petition, the learned trial court passed a detailed order on 17.8.2012 observing that the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of C.P.C is maintainable. Thereafter, hearing on the petition was taken up. The petitioner-defendant adduced evidence by examining himself as P.W.1 None was examined on behalf of the opposite parties. No documents were exhibited on behalf of any of the parties. While passing the impugned order, the learned trial court once again entered into the point of maintainability and this time took a contrary view holding that in the facts and circumstances the provisions of Order 9 Rule 13 of C.P.C did not get attracted.

4. In the aforestated background, the present appeal against the impugned order has been filed. It is submitted on behalf of the appellant that the earlier finding that the application under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC was maintainable having not been challenged in any higher forum, the subsequent finding of the same court on the same point is erroneous and illegal. Further submission is that the learned trial court instead of finding out as to whether the defendant was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing before the court on the relevant date took into consideration the past conduct of the defendant on previous dates and thereby committed illegality. Further submission is that the circumstances under which the suit has been dismissed attract the provisions of Order 17 Rule 2 of the C.P.C and, consequently, a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of C.P.C to set aside the decree is maintainable. On behalf of the respondent, it is submitted that since last adjournment was granted subject to payment of cost and on the next adjourned date cost was not paid, the learned trial court rightly debarred the appellant from prosecuting his defence and that since evidence from the side of the respondent-plaintiff was complete, learned trial court proceeded to dispose of the suit on merit. Further submission is that a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC in the facts and circumstances of the case is not maintainable. It is further contended that the appellant-petitioner did not approach the trial court in clean hands inasmuch as he did not only file a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC to set aside the impugned judgment and decree but also prefer a regular appeal before this Court in RFA No. 97 of 2011 challenging the same judgment and decree.

5. First, the point on res judicata may be taken into consideration. It is not disputed that on 17.8.2012 the learned trial court passed order on the point of maintainability of the CMA and observed that the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC is maintainable. However, while finally deciding the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC, the same court dismissed the petition observing that Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC was not attracted. In Satyadhyan Ghosal v. Smt. Deorajin Debi, reported in AIR 1960 SC 941, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that the principle of res judicata applies also as between two stages in the same litigation to the extent that a court, whether the trial court or a higher court having at an earlier stage decided the matter in one way will not allow the parties to re-agitate the matter again at a subsequent stage of the same proceeding. Thus, the submission made on behalf of the appellant that the subsequent decision of the learned lower court on the maintainability of the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC is hit by the principles of res judicata is quite tenable. However, since the same question has again been raised before this Court in an appeal against the final order, the controversy can be thrashed out in this appeal. This position has been made clear by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforecited decision in Satyadhyan Ghosal's case (supra) observing that an interlocutory order, which had not been appealed from either because no appeal lay or even though an appeal lay an appeal was not taken, can be challenged in an appeal from the final decree or order.

Therefore, it is now to be considered as to whether the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC is maintainable or not. Before adverting to the factual aspects, Rule 2 and Rule 3, Order 17 of CPC are reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-

“Rule 2. Procedure if parties fail to appear on day fixed - Where, on any day to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, the parties or any of them fail to appear, the Court may proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes directed in that behalf by Order IX or make such other order as it thinks fit.

Explanation - Where the evidence or a substantial portion of the evidence of any party has already been recorded and such party fails to appear on any day to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, the Court may, in its discretion, proceed with the case as if such party were present.

Rule 3. Court may proceed notwithstanding either party fails to produce evidence, etc. - Where any party to suit to whom time has been granted fails to produce his evidence, or to cause the attendance of his witnesses, or to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit, for which time has been allowed, (the Court may, notwithstanding such default,-

(a) if the parties are present, proceed to decide the suit forthwith, or

(b) if the parties are, or any of them is, absent, proceed under Rule 2).”

6. A comparative reading of the two Rules would make it clear that their application is meant for distinct and different sets of circumstances. It is well settled that Rule 2 applies when an adjournment has been generally granted and not for any special purpose whereas Rule 3 applies where the adjournment has been given for one of the purposes mentioned in Rule 3. Rule 2 empowers the Court to dispose of the suit in any of the modes specified in Order 9 of CPC. Rule 3 empowers the Court to decide the suit forthwith provided the conditions laid down in the said Rule are satisfied. Rule 2 has no application unless the parties or any of them failed to appear at the hearing. Rule 3 authorizes/empowers the court to proceed to decide the suit forthwith only when the parties are present.

7. At this point, it is important to refer to the following observations made by this Court in Mulia Maharana v. Narayan Patra, reported in AIR 1964 Orissa 246:

“Mere presence of a party most often would not conduce to or subserve the interest of the party in establishing his case. Occasions do arise when a party having a right cause in his favour, due to justifying an unforeseen circumstance, is not able to collect the necessary materials and evidence in support of his case. Without being so armed, if the party enters into the arena of contest, he would merely satisfy the formalities of a trial but would not be able to get justice in support of his righteous cause. It is for these reasons various provisions in Order 9, C.P.C have been prescribed to give full opportunity to a party to contest the case when his non-appearance is for sufficient cause. In the face of statutory provisions, Courts cannot prescribe an invariable rule that in all cases where the party is present in court without evidence, he must contest the suit to maintain co-operation with the court. A party cannot be penalized for non-cooperation with the Court. In fact the statutory provisions do not use the expression “co-operation with Court”. If in certain circumstances the party, though present in court, chooses not to appear after the adjournment petition is rejected, it is not on account of a desire to have non-cooperation with the Court, but only with the paramount consideration of contesting the litigation not in a half-hearted manner which would generally culminate in frustration of justice so far as the party is concerned.

The real consideration in such a case is not whether the party non-cooperated with the Court, or made voluntary retirement, but whether the non-appearance of the party, after the rejection of the petition for time, was sufficient cause. The answer to such a question will vary according to the facts and circumstances of each case. In a particular case, such voluntary retirement or withdrawal may amount to absence of sufficient cause if the party fails to satisfy the Court after witnesses are examined in a proceeding under Order 9, Rule 9 or 13, C.P.C” (Underlined by me)

8. In the light of the above quoted observations, the applicability of Order 17 Rule 3 of CPC is now to be examined. Admittedly, on 23.4.2011 defendant's Advocate was not present. The defendant was present in person but after rejection of his time petition he withdrew himself from the proceeding by declining to further cross-examine P.W.1 This being the position, Order 17 Rule 3 of CPC is not applicable.

9. Now, let it be thrashed out as to whether the defendant's withdrawal from participation in the proceeding on 23.4.2011 amounts to sufficient cause as contemplated under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC. On 23.4.2011 he made a prayer to defer the cross-examination of PW1 on the ground that on the same date he had made a complaint before the learned District Judge, Cuttack alleging that the Presiding Officer was prejudiced against him for which the suit should be transferred to some other court. But, while adducing evidence in support of his petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC, the present appellant did not produce any material showing that he had filed any formal petition for transfer of the suit. Therefore, the learned lower court has rightly refused to accept this contention as a sufficient cause preventing the appellant from participating in the proceeding. Thus, it is found that the appellant defendant has failed to show sufficient cause that prevented him from appearing when the suit was called on for hearing on 23.4.2011

Had it been a mere case of withdrawal from taking part in the proceeding, the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC would have been maintainable. But, the order dated 23.4.2011 is very clear to the extent that on account of non-payment of cost awarded under Section 35-B of the CPC, the learned lower court debarred the defendant from further prosecuting his defence and finding that the plaintiff-respondent has already closed his evidence, the learned trial court proceeded to hear argument and thereafter passed the judgment. On 23.4.2011 the defendant-appellant did not pay the cost, nor did he make a prayer for extension of time to pay the cost. Confronted with such a situation, the learned trial court debarred the defendant-appellant from further prosecuting his defence and then proceeded with the trial and ultimately delivered the judgment followed by the impugned decree. Under such circumstances, the impugned judgment and decree cannot be brought under the purview of Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC. Therefore, from that point of view, the learned trial court has correctly arrived at a conclusion that the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC is not attracted.

10. In the result, the F.A.O is dismissed but, in the facts and circumstances, without any cost.