Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Public Interest Protection Council v. Union Of India & Ors.

Orissa High Court
Apr 27, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (I.M. Quddusi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a voluntary organisation, filed a public interest writ petition challenging what it alleged to be a Central Government policy decision to establish highly technical institutions modelled on the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) at Bhubaneswar, Pune, Allahabad and Chennai. The petition asserted that the University Grants Commission (UGC) had communicated that the Central Government would meet the full cost and that the State of Orissa would earmark land near Vani Vihar, Bhubaneswar. The petitioner alleged that funds were to be released in phases (Rs. 25 crores during the 10th Plan, Rs. 50 crores in the next five-year plan, and Rs. 100 crores subsequently) and that a newspaper report (Samaj, 17-8-2005) indicated a decision to shift the proposed Institute from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata. The petitioner claimed the alleged shift was arbitrary, politically motivated and discriminatory, and sought a direction to Opposite Party No.1 (Union of India) to complete establishment of the institute in Bhubaneswar within a stipulated time.

The Union of India filed a counter-affidavit denying any Central Government decision to set up an Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER) at Bhubaneswar before or on the date of the petition; it explained the UGC had proposed advanced centres in 2002, but the Law Ministry opined that UGC lacked power under Section 12(ccc) of the UGC Act to set up such institutions. The Scientific Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (SAC-PM) later recommended creation of two IISERs, and the Central Government decided to locate IISERs at Pune and Kolkata as national institutes funded centrally. The Union explained that proposals with heavy budgetary implications require approvals (Planning Commission, Expenditure Finance Committee, Cabinet) and that the matter had been processed in accordance with that procedure.

The State Government of Orissa filed a counter-affidavit stating it had identified 75 acres near Bhubaneswar and had communicated availability of land to the UGC; the State also produced correspondence from the Chief Minister to the Prime Minister and related acknowledgements, and argued that in the absence of a clear explanation rejecting the earlier Bhubaneswar proposal, the earlier decision should still have priority.

After hearing and perusal of records, an additional affidavit from a Ministry of Human Resource Development official was filed stating that the Prime Minister had announced on 28-8-2006 the setting up of the National Institute of Science Education and Research (NISER) at Bhubaneswar under the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE). The additional material stated that NISER would initially function within the Institute of Physics (IOP), Bhubaneswar, would seek requisite approvals (Atomic Energy Commission/CCEA), and that it was proposed to start the first batch in August 2007.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was any decision by the Central Government to establish an IISER at Bhubaneswar, and if so whether that decision had been shifted to Kolkata (i.e., whether the alleged "shift" from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata arose).
  2. Whether the UGC had power to establish such an institution on its own (in light of the Law Ministry opinion on Section 12(ccc) of the UGC Act) and the proper governmental procedure for taking final decisions on such projects.
  3. What is the scope of judicial review in respect of executive policy decisions concerning establishment and location of national institutes of excellence — specifically, whether the Court can direct the Union to establish an institution at a particular place.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Allegations

  • The Central Government had taken a policy decision to establish highly technical institutions (IISc pattern) at Bhubaneswar, Pune, Allahabad and Chennai, with full funding from the Centre and land earmarked by the State of Orissa near Vani Vihar, Bhubaneswar.
  • Funds were to be released in phases (Rs. 25 crores in the 10th Plan, Rs. 50 crores in the next five-year plan, Rs. 100 crores subsequently).
  • A newspaper report indicated the Government decided to shift the proposed institute from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata; this shift was alleged to be arbitrary, malicious, discriminatory and politically motivated.
  • The State of Orissa suffers neglect from the Centre and faces threats of central manipulation and shifting of institutions (citing IIMC and proposed AIIMS), and the petitioner sought an order directing Opposite Party No.1 to complete establishment at Bhubaneswar within a stipulated time.

Union of India (Opp. Party No. 1) — Counter-Affidavit

  • Denied that there was any decision by the Central Government to set up an IISER at Bhubaneswar before or on the date of filing the writ petition; accordingly, no question of shifting to Kolkata arises.
  • Explained that the UGC had proposed Advanced Centres in 2002, but the Ministry of Law and Justice opined UGC lacked power under Section 12(ccc) of the UGC Act to set up such institutions.
  • Stated SAC-PM recommended creating two IISERs; the Central Government decided to locate IISERs at Pune and Kolkata as national (not regional) institutes to be centrally funded.
  • Emphasised that any substantial financial proposal must follow laid down procedures (Planning Commission, Expenditure Finance Committee, Cabinet) and that the proposal for IISER at Pune and Kolkata was processed in accordance with those procedures.
  • Denied that any politically motivated decision or arbitrary shifting occurred, and submitted the writ petition was misconceived and liable to be dismissed with costs.

State of Orissa (Department of Higher Education) — Counter-Affidavit

  • Stated funds to UGC are provided through the Central Budget and that the State provided 75 acres of land near Bhubaneswar (village Gothapatna) in response to UGC's request; copies of communications were annexed.
  • Reported that UGC had sent a project report and that the Chief Minister had written to the Prime Minister urging sanction of a National Institute of Science at Bhubaneswar, with an acknowledgment from the Prime Minister's office.
  • Argued that the Union's counter-affidavit did not state why Bhubaneswar should not be considered, and therefore logically the earlier decision in favour of Bhubaneswar should continue to have priority over later decisions proposing Kolkata and Pune.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Asif Hammed v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, AIR 1989 SC 1899 Judicial review is not an appellate review of administrative action; courts cannot direct or advise the executive on matters of policy that fall within the executive or legislature's domain, provided they do not transgress constitutional or statutory limits. The court relied on this precedent to underscore that decisions about establishment and location of national educational institutions are policy matters for the executive and expert bodies, not for the courts to substitute their judgment for that of the executive.
Ekta Shakti Foundation v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, AIR 2006 SC 2609 The correctness of the reasons motivating government decision-making is not a matter for judicial review; courts should not probe policy choices so long as fundamental rights are not infringed and the executive acts within its powers. The court applied this principle to decline interference in the executive's selection and funding decisions for institutes of excellence, observing that policy choices on location and institutional structure are for the government and its expert advisers.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the pleadings and affidavits placed on record:

  1. Factual record and denials: The Union denied any Central Government decision to set up an IISER at Bhubaneswar as of the petition date and explained the provenance of the UGC's 2002 proposal. The Law Ministry had opined that the UGC lacked power under Section 12(ccc) to set up such institutions. The SAC-PM later recommended creation of two national IISERs and the Government decided to locate them at Pune and Kolkata.
  2. Administrative procedure: The court noted (relying on the Union's affidavit) that large financial or budgetary proposals must go through a sequence of administrative approvals (Planning Commission, Expenditure Finance Committee, Cabinet) before becoming final, and that the IISER matter was processed per that procedure.
  3. Scope of judicial review: Applying binding Supreme Court authorities (Asif Hammed and Ekta Shakti Foundation), the court reiterated that it cannot substitute its view for executive policy choices and that correctness of executive reasons is not subject to court scrutiny unless there is transgression of constitutional or statutory limits or infringement of fundamental rights.
  4. Institutional competence: The court observed that establishment of national educational institutions is within the domain of the Union and expert bodies, and UGC cannot establish an institution without Central Government approval; hence the court cannot direct the Union to establish an institute at a specific place as a matter of policy.
  5. Subsequent material — change in position: The court then considered the additional affidavit and annexed letters filed by the Ministry of HRD which recorded that the Prime Minister had announced on 28-8-2006 the setting up of NISER at Bhubaneswar under the Department of Atomic Energy, and that follow-up action to obtain necessary approvals (Atomic Energy Commission/CCEA) was on hand. The material indicated an intention to initially host NISER within the IOP, Bhubaneswar, and to start the first batch in August 2007.
  6. Conclusion from facts: Given the Ministry's additional affidavit and supporting letters showing concrete implementation steps and a governmental decision regarding NISER at Bhubaneswar under DAE, the court found it appropriate to dispose of the petition by directing Opposite Party No.1 to ensure establishment of NISER at Bhubaneswar so that the first batch may commence.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ petition is disposed of with a direction to Opposite Party No.1 (Union of India) to ensure that the National Institute of Science Education and Research (NISER) is established at Bhubaneswar pursuant to the decision of the Department of Atomic Energy so that its first batch may commence studies.

Implications and consequences:

  • Direct effect: The Union is directed to take steps to establish NISER at Bhubaneswar in accordance with the Government of India's decision (Department of Atomic Energy) and the additional implementation material on record, including initial functioning within the Institute of Physics and commencement of the first batch (proposed August 2007).
  • Scope of precedent: The court emphasised established principles limiting judicial interference in executive policy-making relating to establishment and location of national educational institutions; the decision applies those principles to decline to act as a policy-making authority, intervening only because documentary material showed a government decision and implementation steps for Bhubaneswar.
  • No broader legal precedent created: The opinion applies existing Supreme Court authorities to the facts and does not lay down a new principle of law; it confirms that institutional location/policy remains primarily within the executive's domain except where constitutional or statutory limits are transgressed.

Additional notation: The order records that A.K. Samantaray, J. agreed with the decision and the operative line reads "Order accordingly."

Show all summary ...

I.M Quddusi, J.:— The petitioner, a voluntary organization, has filed the Instant writ petition in the form of Public Interest Litigation inter alia alleging that the Government of India in the Ministry of Human Resources Development had taken a policy decision deciding to establish highly technical institutions at Bhubaneswar, Pune, Allahabad and Chennai in the pattern of ‘Indian Institute of Science at Bangalore’ for the purpose of promotion of the High Skilled Scientific Education and Research. The said decision was communicated to the Government of Orissa by the University Grants Commission in which it was mentioned that it was decided that the entire cost and expenses for establishment of the said highly technical education and research centre would be met by the Government of India and the Institution would mainly meet the demands and necessity of the Eastern region. The State of Orissa also shall earmark a patch of land near Vani Vihar at Bhubaneswar for that purpose. It is also alleged that according to the Government decision, a sum of Rs. 25 crores would be provided during the Xth Plan and during next five year plan Rs. 50 crores shall be spent and subsequently a sum of Rs. 100 crores shall be spent. But from the daily Samaj news paper dated 17-8-2005 it has come to the knowledge of the petitioner that the Government have taken a decision to shift the establishment of the said proposed Indian Institute of Science from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata which is allegedly arbitrary, malicious, discriminatory and politically motivated. It is also averred in the writ petition that the State of Orissa is under constant neglect and victim of discrimination from Center owing to lack of strong leadership as a result of which in spite of it's natural resources in abundance and sufficient expertise man power, the State has been placed at the lowest position among the Indian States so far its economic growth is concerned. Due to such reasons the State is not able to receive it's genuine claims for establishment of special projects. It is also averred in the writ petition that another such Institute i.e Indian Institute of Mass Communication established and functioning the more than a decade now at Dhenkanal and the proposed establishment of ‘All India Institute of Medical Sciences’ are under constant central manipulation and threat of shift to out of the State. However, prayer has been made for a direction to the Opp. Party No. 1 to complete the project of establishment of Indian Institute of Science’ in it's originally decided location at Bhubaneswar within a stipulated time.

2. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record, which has been produced by Sri J.K Mishra, learned Assistant Solicitor General. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the Union of India, it has been denied that there was any decision of the Central Government to set up Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER) at Bhubaneswar either before or on the date of filing of the writ petition. Hence the question of shifting that institution from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata does not arise at all. In fact it was the University Grants Commission, which had proposed in 2002 to establish Advanced Centres for Science & Technology Education as autonomous institutions. The said proposal was examined by the Government of India in the Ministry of Human Resources Development and an opinion was sought from the Ministry of Law and Justice which opined that UGC does not have any power to set up such institution under Section 12(ccc) of the University Grants Commission Act. It is further averred in the counter-affidavit that in view of the felt need to create Centres of Excellence in Science Education, the Scientific Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (SAC-PM) headed by Prof. Shri C.N.R Rao and other members comprising of eminent educationists and scientists in its meeting held on 4-3-2005 at New Delhi recommended creation of two new institutions devoted to Science Education and Research to be named as “Indian Institute of Science Education & Research” (IISER). The Central Government has decided to locate the IISER at Pune and Kolkata. The IISER's will be National Institutes as distinct from Regional Institutes so that there is no issue of regional representation and they are proposed to be funded under the Central Scheme. The basic idea for setting of such IISER is to create research Universities of the highest calibre at national level in which teaching and education will be totally integrated with the ‘state-of-the-art’ research. These Institutes will be devoted to undergraduate and post-graduate teaching in sciences in an intellectually vibrant atmosphere of research. One of the important objectives of creating those institutes is to make education and careers in basic sciences more attractive by providing opportunities in integrative teaching and learning of sciences and break the barriers of traditional disciplines.

3. In paragraph 3 of the counter-affidavit it was however submitted that in the Government of India any proposal/scheme/project involving huge financial/budgetary involvement has to be routed through as per the laid down procedure such as obtaining approval of the Planning Commission, approval of the Expenditure Finance Committee and a final approval finally by the Cabinet. Then only the decision of the Government of India will be treated to be finalized and accordingly suitable orders are issued by administrative ministries. The matter regarding establishment of IISER at Pune and Kolkata was processed in accordance with the procedure mentioned therein above. It is also submitted that no policy decision was finalized for setting up of IISER at Kolkata as on the date of the filing of the instant writ petition and therefore all the averments, allegations and contentions in the writ petitions are totally immature, imaginary and illusive.

4. It is further submitted that the allegation of the petitioner that the decision of shifting of the Institute from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata was a politically motivated decision is totally wrong and vehemently denied for the reason that there was no decision by the Central Government at any time to set up a science institute at Bhubaneswar and therefore, the question of shifting of the science institute from Bhubaneswar to Kolkata does not arise.

5. In paragraph 5, it is submitted that the decision to set up the IISER at Pune and Kolkata was taken by the Government, based on the recommendations of scientists, eminent experts and educationists. In the light of the above categorical submissions, the averments of the writ petition are wholly misconceived, wrong and denied and, therefore, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed with costs.

6. A counter-affidavit has also been filed on behalf of the Government of Orissa in the Department of Higher Education in which paragraphs 9 and 13 are liable to be perused, as relevant, which are reproduced as under:

“Paragraph 9: It is humbly submitted that provision of funds to UGC is always made through the Central Budget passed by Parliament, UGC had also requested the State Government to provide 50 acres of land for establishment of the NISc. The State Government promptly took action and identified 75 acres of land in village Gothapatna under Bhubaneswar Tahasil in the proximity of Bhubaneswar Municipal Corporation and the same fact was intimated to the UGC vide Higher Education Department letter No. 67134 dated 8-12-2003, a copy of the same is enclosed as Annexure-B/2. Subsequently the U.G.C sent copy of Project Report of NISc to Vice-Chancellor of Utkal University vide their letter dated 23-2-2004, the copy of which is annexed herewith as Annexure-C/2. The State Government has been waiting since then for starting of the institute by Government of India. When the matter was delayed, Hon'ble Chief Minister drew the attention of Hon'ble Prime Minister and urged him to sanction establishment of National Institute of Science at Bhubaneswar at the earliest vide his D.O letter No. 1.OS-421.CM dated 23-8-2005, a copy of the said letter is annexed herewith as Annexure-D/2. The Hon'ble Prime Minister acknowledged the letter vide his D.O dated 27-8-2005, and the copy of which is annexed herewith as Annexure-F/2. The State Government has been waiting for the action by Government of India for starting the Institute.

Paragraph 13: That it is humbly submitted that one thing is very clear from the counter-affidavit filed by the O.P No. 1 that Government of India wants to create centers of excellence in Science and Education during the current financial year. In the said counter filed by Op. No. 1, nothing has been mentioned as to why Bhubaneswar should not be considered for setting up of the NISc. In the absence of specific mention of the grounds regarding rejection of earlier proposal for setting up NISc at Bhubaneswar the logical conclusion is that earlier decision still stands and gets priority over any decision for establishment of two institutes i.e at Kolkata and Pune taken at a later date.”

7. The establishment of an Educational Institution either in the form of excellence in Education like Indian Institute of Technology, Indian Institute of Management, Indian Institute of Information Technology and Central Universities in different States is the matter of expert bodies domain of the Union of India and there is no scope of judicial review over the same.

8. The Apex Court in the case of Asif Hammed v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, reported in AIR 1989 SC 1899 considering the scope of Judicial review held that while exercising the power of judicial review of administrative action, the Court is not an appellate authority. The Constitution does not permit the Court to direct or advise the executive in matters of policy or to sermonize qua any matter, which under the Constitution lies within the sphere of legislature or executive, provided these authorities do not transgress their constitutional limits or statutory power. In Ekta Shakti Foundation v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi., AIR 2006 SC 2609, the Apex Court taking note of its earlier decisions on the point held that the correctness of the reasons which prompted the Government in decision making, taking one course of action instead of another, is not a matter of concern in judicial review and the Court is not the appropriate forum for such investigation. The policy decision must be left to the Government at it alone can adopt which policy should be adopted after considering all the points from different angles. In matter of policy decisions or exercise of discretion by the Government so long as the infringement of fundamental right is not shown, Courts will have no occasion to interfere and the Court will not and should not substitute its own judgment for the judgment of the executive in such matters. In assessing the propriety of a decision of the Government, the Court cannot interfere even if a second view is possible from that of the Government.

We may state here that the University Grants Commission has no power to establish an Institution without approval of the Central Government. The intimation sent to establish four centres for studies in Integrated Science was the UGC's new initiative in collaboration with other scientific agencies. But the same was not approved by the Central Government. Therefore, this Court cannot direct Union of India to establish an Institution at a particular place.

9. However an additional affidavit has been filed by Mr. Seema Raj, Director, Technical Section-1, Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India, New Delhi stating that Hon'ble Prime Minister during his visit to the Institute of Physics, Bhubaneswar, Orissa on 28-8-2006 had announced setting up of the National Institute of Science Education and Research (NISER) at Bhubaneswar. The same would be at par with the ISSERs being established in other places but will operate under the Department of Atomic Energy. The said institution including NISER will undertake integrated 5 year Masters courses in core and emerging branches of Science to provide world class education to students after 10 + 2 stage. It may also include an integrated M.Sc, Ph.D after graduation level while working within the Department of Atomic Energy family and awarding degrees under the Homi Bhabha National Institute (HBNI), which is already a Deemed University for post-graduate studies. NISER is proposed to be an institute of excellence at par with the best in the country in terms of facilities and faculty etc. The Director, Homi Bhabha National Institute vide letter dated 11-9-2006 informed the above facts to the Director, Human Resources Development, Government of India and the administrative department i.e Department of Atomic Energy, Government of India vide letter dated 15-3-2007 informed that the follow up action for the implementation of announcement of Prime Minister regarding setting up of NISER at Bhubaneswar is already on hand to obtain requisite, approval of Competent Authorities viz. Atomic Energy Commission/Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA). It was further informed that initially NISER would start functioning within the campus of Institute of Physics (IOP), Bhubaneswar by augmenting the existing infrastructure. Subsequently NISER will be shifted to an independent campus to be developed for the purpose. It is proposed to start the 1st batch of NISER in August, 2007.

10. In view of the above statement made in the additional affidavit and the letters annexed with the same which show that initially NISER will start functioning within the campus of IOP, Bhubaneswar and it is intended to start the 1st batch of NISER in August, 2007, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the Opp. Party No. 1 to ensure that the NISER is established at Bhubaneswar pursuant to the decision of the Government of India in Department of Atomic Energy so that its 1st batch may start studies.

A.K Samantaray, J.:— 11. I agree.

Order accordingly.