- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ahalya Mangaraj v. State Of Orissa And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
This writ petition challenges an order of the Collector, Kalahandi disqualifying the petitioner from holding the office of Sarpanch of Chapriya Gram Panchayat. The opinion states that the impugned order was passed in G.P. Case No. 6 of 2005 and is dated 3.4.2006 (paragraph 3 of the opinion). However, the operative paragraph recording the court's disposition refers to the impugned order as dated 03.04.2005 (paragraph 13). The Collector's order was issued under Clause (v) of Section 25 of the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act (disqualification for having more than two children), by exercising powers under Section 26 of the Act.
Procedurally, following a complaint and an office note (Letter No. 1121 dated 23.6.2005), the Collector asked the Child Development Project Officer (CDPO), Golamunda to inquire (letter dated 1.8.2005). The CDPO submitted a report dated 30.8.2005 based on Anganwadi records identifying three children with dates of birth recorded. The District Panchayat Officer (DPO) submitted a further enquiry report by Memo No. 1782 dated 14.11.2005, noting the Anganwadi records and also referring to an affidavit before the Sub-Collector (dated 19.11.03) and other documents. The Collector, relying on these reports but without conducting an independent inquiry, commenced hearing counsel on 20.3.2006, continued on 27.3.2006 and passed the impugned order on 3.4.06 (paragraph 7).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Collector complied with the procedural requirements of Section 26 (and as described in the opinion, Sub-Section (2)) of the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act by making "such enquiry as he considers necessary" and by giving the person alleged to be disqualified an opportunity of being heard before determining disqualification (paragraphs 8 and 12).
- Whether the Collector could validly base a disqualification order solely on the CDPO and DPO reports (Anganwadi/register extracts) without conducting an independent enquiry and affording the affected person a full and fair opportunity to rebut the material used against her (paragraphs 5–9, 12).
- What weight should be accorded to birth certificates and related public records maintained under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969, in determining membership/disqualification under the Gram Panchayat Act (paragraph 9 and 12).
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Fazal Bhai Dhala v. Custodian-General Evacuee Property New Delhi and Anr | That the custodian (administrative decision-maker) must allow a party a reasonable opportunity of being heard and, in suitable cases, permit the party to adduce evidence (principle of fair hearing and ability to lead evidence). | The court invoked this authority to emphasize that where the Orissa Grama Panchayats Act provides for an enquiry by the Collector, the Collector must observe principles of natural justice: the person concerned should be supplied with the material and evidence to be used against her and allowed to rebut evidence and cross-examine witnesses (paragraph 10). |
| Kuldeep Singh v. The Commissioner of Police and Ors. | That "reasonable opportunity" means a hearing in accordance with principles of natural justice, which includes examination of witnesses in the presence of the delinquent and an opportunity to cross-examine. | The court relied on this statement to support the conclusion that the Collector was required to follow a full and fair enquiry procedure—examining witnesses and permitting cross-examination where appropriate—before making a disqualification order (paragraph 10). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, as reflected in the opinion:
- Statutory framework: The court quoted and relied on Sections 25 and 26 of the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act. Clause (v) of Section 25 disqualifies a person who "has more than two children" and Section 26 prescribes the procedure for giving effect to disqualifications, including the Collector's power to inquire and determine disqualification after giving the person an opportunity to be heard (paragraphs 4, 7–10).
- Factual record: Two administrative reports were placed before the Collector—the CDPO report (30.8.2005) and the DPO enquiry report (Memo No.1782 dated 14.11.2005). These reports recorded entries from Anganwadi registers and identified three children with dates of birth. The DPO report also recorded that an affidavit before the Sub-Collector indicated that one child (Rinki) was recorded as the daughter of the first wife (Kasturi), and that the husband had stated facts about two wives and the parentage of children (paragraphs 12, 21–29, 38–41).
- Procedural defect: The court noted that Sub-section (2) of Section 26 requires the Collector to make "such enquiry as he considers necessary" and to give the person an opportunity of being heard. The court found nothing on record to show that the Collector conducted an independent inquiry; instead, the Collector relied upon the CDPO and DPO letters/reports and proceeded to hear arguments and pass the impugned order (paragraphs 8 and 33).
- Evidentiary observations: The court observed inconsistencies/recorded facts in the materials—e.g., two children with birth years in 1994—and noted that the Collector had not addressed such anomalies. The court further noted that the birth certificates (Form No. 9) and medical/birth registration documents are public documents maintained under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969, and "cannot be disbelieved" on the record before the court (paragraph 9 and 12).
- Natural justice requirement: Applying the authorities cited (Fazal Bhai Dhala and Kuldeep Singh), the court held that the Collector, in determining disqualification under the Gram Panchayat Act, must follow the principles of natural justice: supply the material to the person against whom the case is made, allow rebuttal, and permit cross-examination where appropriate. The court emphasized that reasonable opportunity must be "full and fair" and may require examination of witnesses in the presence of the person affected (paragraph 10).
- Conclusion from facts and law: Because no proper enquiry was conducted and the petitioner was not granted a fair opportunity to defend herself, the Collector's decision was held to be not in consonance with the statutory procedure and with principles of natural justice. Given the presence of public documents (birth/registration records) and the other materials on file, the court found that the impugned order could not stand on the record as it then existed (paragraphs 12–13).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court allowed the writ petition and quashed the impugned order. The operative paragraph states: "The impugned order dated 03.04.2005 passed by the Collector, Kalahandi in G.P. Case No. 6 of 2005 is quashed. No order as to cost." (paragraph 13).
Immediate implications and directions:
- The quashing directly annuls the Collector's disqualification order as recorded in the opinion.
- The court expressly left open the right of the Collector to conduct a fresh enquiry: the Collector may conduct enquiry afresh and conclude it, but only after affording reasonable opportunity to the petitioner to defend her case and in accordance with law (paragraph 14).
- No costs were awarded against the petitioner (paragraph 13).
- The opinion does not state that it establishes any new binding precedent beyond applying existing authority on the requirements of natural justice in administrative enquiries; its direct effect is confined to quashing the impugned order and permitting a fresh enquiry conducted in accordance with statutory procedure and principles of natural justice.
Note on internal inconsistencies in the source opinion: The opinion as provided refers at different places to Section 26 and also refers to Sub-Section (2) of Section 25 when discussing the Collector's obligations (paragraphs 8 and 12). The opinion also records two different years for the impugned order (3.4.2006 in paragraph 3, and 03.04.2005 in paragraph 13). These observations are reproduced from the opinion text and not corrected or reconciled, in accordance with the requirement to summarize only the information present in the provided opinion.
1. Heard Mr. Lalitencea Mishra, learned Counsel for the petitioner and learned Additional Government Advocate.
2. Perused the record produced by the learned Additional Government-Advocate.
3. This writ petition has been filed against the impugned order dated 3.4.2006 passed by the learned Collector, Kalahandi in G.P. Case No. 6 of 2005 under Section 25 of the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') disqualifying the petitioner to hold the post of Sarpanch of Chapriya G.P. in exercise of his power conferred upon him under Section 26 of the Act. The ground of disqualification of the petitioner has been indicated in the impugned order of the Collector that the petitioner has three living children.
4. At the outset, it is necessary to peruse the relevant provisions under Sections 25 and 26 of the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act, which are quoted hereunder:
Disqualification for membership of Grama Panchayat (1) a person shall be disqualified for being elected or nominated as a Sarpanch constituted under this Act, if he xxx xxx xxx xxx
(v) has more than two children Provided that the disqualification under Clause (v) shall not apply to any person who has more than two children on the date of commencement of the Orissa Grama Panchayats (Amendment) Act, 1994 or, as the case may be, within a period of one year of such commencement, unless he begets an additional child after the said period of one year.
26. Procedure of giving effect to disqualifications-
(1) Whenever it is alleged that any Sarpanch or Naib-Sarpanch or any other member is or has become disqualified or whenever any such person is himself in doubt whether or not he is or has become so disqualified such person or any other member may, and the Sarpanch at the request of the Grama Panchayat shall, apply to the Collector for a decision on the allegation of doubt.
(2) The Collector may suo motuor on receipt of an application under Sub-Section (1), make such enquiry as he considers necessary and after giving the person whose disqualification is in question an opportunity of being heard, determine whether or not such person is or has become disqualified and make an order in that behalf which shall be final and conclusive.
(3) Whether the Collector decides that the Sarpanch, Naib-Sarpanch or any other member is or has become disqualified such decision shall be forthwith published by him on his notice-board and with effect from the date of such publication the Sarpanch, Naib Sarpanch or such other member, as the case may be, shall be deemed to have vacated office, and till the date of such publication he shall be entitled to act as if he was not disqualified.
The Clause V of Sub-section (1) of Section 25 was earlier in Orissa Gazette Extraordinary No. 426 dated 18.4.934 and substituted thereafter in Notification No.6139-I_egis dated 18.4.1994 with effect from date of notification.
5. On the basis of the letter No. 1121 dated 23.6.2005 of. O.I.C. General and Misc. Section, Collectorate, Kalahandi and basing on the complaint of some members of Chapriya G.P. alleging that the petitioner has three children and is not eligible to hold the post of Sarpanch, the Collector asked the Child Development Project Officer, Golamunda/District Panchayat Officer, Kalahandi vide his letter dated 1.8.2005 to inquire into the matter. The Child Development Project Officer, Golmunda, Kalahandi vide his letter dated 30.8.2005 submitted his report to the Officer in Charge, Judicial Section, Collectorate, Kalahandi. The said letter is reproduced below:
As per your letter No. 1485 dt. 10.8.05, I went to the village of Turechhada along with the concerned Sector Supervisor on 26.8.05 and enquired into the matter.
As reported by the Anganawadi Worker of Turechhada, the birth and death register is not available with her where the names of children were enter and the same register was eaten by the white ants.
In the register immunization and pre-school the names of the children of Smt. Ahalya Mangraj is found. The Xerox copy of register is enclosed herewith.
The present Sarpanch Smt. Ahalya Mangaraj has three children namely:
Date of Birth
1. Rinki Mangaraj 10.1.94
2. Pinki Mangaraj 17.12.94
3. Karisima Mangaraj 28.2.96 The report of the Anganawadi Worker of Turechhada is enclosed herewith for your kind information and necessary action.
6. A perusal of the above letter shows that the Child Development Project Officer, Golamunda had conducted an inquiry only to the extent of collection of relevant records and referred it to the Collectorate. Another report was sent by the District Panchayat Officer vide his Memo No. 1782 dated 14.11.2005, which is also reproduced hereunder:
Enquiry report on the G.P. Case No. 6/05- State v. Smt. Ahalya Mangaraj Sarpanch Chapriya G.P.
As per memo No. 1485 dated 10.08.05 of O.I.C., Judicial Sec, the undersigned has conducted enquiry into the matter as detailed below:
1. As per the records available with the Anganwadi worker of Turechhada A.W. Centre Smt. Ahalaya Mangaraj, W/O of Sri Krushna Ch. Mangaraj has 3 living children as detailed below:
2. 1st child-Rinki Mangaraj-DOB 10.01.94 2nd child-Pinki Mangaraj DOB 17.12.94 3rd child-Karisma Mangaraj DOB 28.2.96 However during the enquiry Smt. Mangaraj has submitted a copy of the Court affidavit sworn before the Sub-Collector, Dharmagarhon 19.11.03. By virtue of this, name of Rinki Mangaraj (1st child) recording her mother name as Kasturi Mangaraj (1st wife of Krushna Ch. Mangaraj) instead of Ahalya Mangaraj.
Copy of all relevant documents are enclosed herewith for reference.
Sd/-
District Panchayat Officer Kalahandi.
Memo No. 1782/ G.P. Dt. 14.11.2005.
Copy forwarded to Officer-in-Charge, Judicial Sec., Collectorate, Kalahandi for information and necessary action with reference to his memo No.1485 dt. 10.8.05.
Sd/-
District Panchayat Officer Kalahandi.
7. On the basis of the above quoted two reports, i.e., of the CD.P.O. and D.P.O., the Collector without holding any inquiry started to hear arguments of the learned Counsel for the parties on 20.3.06. Thereafter the remaining arguments were heard on 27.3.06 and the impugned order was passed on 3.4.06.
8. Sub-section (2) of Section 26 of the Act (quoted above) provides that the Collector shall make such enquiry as he considers necessary and only after giving the person whose disqualification is in question an opportunity of being heard, determine whether or not such person has become disqualified. In the instant matter there is nothing on record to show that at any point of time the Collector conducted inquiry. He, relying upon the letter of the Child Development Project Officer and District Panchayat Officer in part passed the impugned order. The Collector, in the impugned order, has shown the Date of Birth of three children as under:
1. 10.1.94
2. 17.12.94
3. 28.2.96
9. But the Birth certificate issued by the Registrar of Births and Deaths, P.H.C. Chapriya in the District of Kalahandi in a prescribed form, i.e. Form No. 9 under Rule 9 of the Rules made under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969. It appears that the name of the mother is mentioned as Ahalya Mangaraj in respect of the female child born on 18.1.2004 and a male child born on 21.2.96 but in respect of a female child born on 17.12.94, the name of mother has been mentioned as Smt. Kasturi Mangaraj, i.e. different to the instant petitioner. Further, on the record an affidavit of Shri Krushna Ch. Mangaraj, husband of the petitioner is available, in which it has been inter alia stated as under:
(1)That I have married-two wife, Kasturi Mangaraj (1st wife) & Ahalya Mangaraj (2nd wife) (2) That kumari Rinki Dei is my 2nd daughter through Kasturi Mangaraj (1st wife) born on dt 17.12.94.
(3) That Ahalya Mangaraj (2nd wife) have one son and one daughter born on 15.1.94 and 21.2.96 respectively.
10. Determination of disqualification can only be made by the Collector after an opportunity is given to the person concerned of being heard meaning thereby that no order prejudicial to a person can be made without giving him reasonable opportunity of being heard. That reasonable opportunity should be full and fair. In the case of Fazal Bhai Dhala v. Custodian-General Evacuee Property New Delhi and Anr. , the Apex Court has held that the custodian has also to allow a party either personally or through counsel, a reasonable opportunity of being heard and in suitable cases it may be property and necessary for the custodian to allow the party concerned even to adduce evidence. Since in the Orissa Grama Panchayats Act though procedure has been laid down to conduct an enquiry, therefore, it is necessary that the Collector by determining the disqualification to follow the principle of natural justice, the requirement of which is that the person concerned should be supplied with the material and the evidence which is to be used against him and he should be allowed to rebut evidence and to cross-examine the witnesses. In the case of Kuldeep Singh v. The Commissioner of Police and Ors. the Apex Court has held that reasonable opportunity means "hearing" in accordance with the principles of natural justice under which one of the basic requirements is that all the witnesses in the departmental enquiry shall be examined in the presence of the delinquent who shall be given an opportunity to cross-examine them.
Principle of natural justice cannot be subjected to any straightjacket formula and it will vary from case to case, circumstance to circumstance and situation to situation. The genesis of the action contemplated, the reasons thereof and the reasonable possibility of prejudice are some of the facts, which weigh with the Court in considering the effect of violation of principles of natural justice.
11. In the instant case, from the undisputed facts, it appears that the years of birth of two children have been shown within one year, i.e. in the year 1994. But it appears that the Collector has not paid any attention towards the same. Learned Counsel for the caveator has submitted that it may possibly be a premature child but that could be taken into consideration only when there would have been allegation to that effect.
12. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the opinion that the impugned order passed by the Collector is not in consonance with Sub-Section (2) of Section 25 of the Act as no proper inquiry was conducted by the Collector and the petitioner was not granted any opportunity to defend her case. The Medical Certificate issued by the Registrar Births and Deaths, available on record are the public documents issued on the basis of Register, maintained under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969. Therefore, the documents cannot be disbelieved.
13. In view of the above-mentioned facts and circumstances, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 03.04.2005 passed by the Collector, Kalahandi in G.P. Case No. 6 of 2005 is quashed. No order as to cost.
14. However, it will be open for the Collector to conduct enquiry into the matter afresh and conclude the same, but only after affording reasonable opportunity to the petitioner to defend her case, in the light of the observation made above, in accordance with law.
N. Prusty, J.
15. I agree.
Alert