- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Allied Chemical... v. Presiding Officer, D...
Summary of the Opinion (A.K. Parichha, J.) — Writ Petition under Article 226
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, sole proprietor of "Allied Chemical Laboratories", obtained a loan of Rs. 3.5 lakhs from the opposite party No.2 (Bank) in 1986 for technical changes in the unit. In 2001 the Bank filed an Original Application (O.A. No. 322 of 2001) before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (D.R.T.), Patna for recovery of the loan and interest; that application was transferred to D.R.T., Orissa, Cuttack and renumbered as O.A. No. 328 of 2001. The Bank's claim (for Rs. 23,27,390.16) was decreed by the Presiding Officer, D.R.T., Orissa, Cuttack by order dated 9-4-2003.
On notice the petitioner appeared and filed show-cause, pleading that the claim was barred by limitation and denying execution of certain revival letters and balance-confirmation acknowledgments (alleging they were fake). The Bank filed a reply and affidavit evidence of its Branch Manager. The petitioner sought production of the Branch Manager for cross-examination; the D.R.T. rejected that prayer and, relying on the affidavit evidence, decreed the Bank's claim. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the writ petition is maintainable despite the availability of an appellate forum under the statute.
- Whether the D.R.T.'s refusal to allow the petitioner to cross-examine the Bank's Branch Manager (who had given affidavit evidence) violated principles of natural justice and the provisions of Rule 12(6) of the Debts Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The D.R.T. violated principles of natural justice and contravened Rule 12(6) of the Debts Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993 by refusing the petitioner's request to cross-examine the Branch Manager who had given affidavit evidence.
- The petitioner specifically challenged the genuineness of the revival letters and balance-confirmation acknowledgments produced by the Bank and therefore required cross-examination of the Branch Manager and examination of the documents by a handwriting/expert.
Opposite Party No. 2 (Bank)'s Arguments
- The Bank denied that the revival letters and balance-confirmation acknowledgments were fake or forged.
- The Bank submitted that producing a witness who has given evidence by affidavit is not mandatory and that the D.R.T. may refuse such a prayer if it considers the prayer not bona fide.
- The Bank challenged maintainability of the writ petition, submitting that the powers under Articles 226 & 227 should not be invoked where a specific appellate forum is available and that the petitioner had filed the writ to delay recovery proceedings and to overcome a delay of 10 months after the impugned order.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bombay Telephone Canteen Employees' Association v. Union of India, AIR 1997 SC 2817 | That writ jurisdiction is normally not to be invoked where an alternative effective remedy exists, but this is not absolute. | Used to support the proposition that availability of an alternative forum does not ipso facto oust the High Court's writ jurisdiction under Article 226; High Court retains discretion. |
| Collector of Monghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka, AIR 1962 SC 1694 | Authority for the High Court's discretionary power to grant relief despite existence of alternative remedies. | Relied upon to emphasize that the High Court may exercise extraordinary jurisdiction when justice so requires. |
| Baburam Prakash Chandra Maheshwari v. Antarim Zilla Parishad, Muzaffarnagar, AIR 1969 SC 556 | Support for the discretionary scope of writ jurisdiction in appropriate cases. | Cited as part of the line of authorities establishing that alternative remedies do not automatically bar writ jurisdiction. |
| M.S. Grewal v. Deep Chand Sood, AIR 2001 SC 3660 | Illustration that courts should not be prevented from responding to societal needs and justice by technicalities. | Applied to justify exercise of writ jurisdiction where refusal would defeat justice or where natural justice is violated. |
| T.K. Rangarajan v. Govt. of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2003 SC 3032 | Recognition that High Court can exercise extraordinary jurisdiction to meet unprecedented or extraordinary situations. | Invoked to support entertaining the writ petition despite alternative remedy, given alleged violation of natural justice by the D.R.T. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in two main analytical strands: (A) whether the availability of an alternative appellate remedy barred entertaining the writ petition, and (B) whether the D.R.T.'s conduct violated Rule 12(6) and principles of natural justice.
A. Jurisdictional principle:
The court recalled established Supreme Court authorities (listed above) to explain that although normally writ jurisdiction should not be invoked where an alternative effective remedy exists, that rule is not absolute. The High Court retains discretion under Article 226 to grant relief where natural justice has been violated, established procedure of law has been flagrantly ignored, or where refusing relief would defeat the ends of justice. The cited precedents were used to support the proposition that the existence of an alternative remedy does not automatically oust the High Court's extraordinary jurisdiction.
B. Application of Rule 12(6) and principles of natural justice to the facts:
- The court quoted and scrutinized the D.R.T.'s orders rejecting the petitioner's request to summon the Branch Manager for cross-examination. The D.R.T. required the petitioner to "initially establish by specific proof of facts" that would warrant summoning the witness and viewed petitioner's request as possibly aimed at delay or "grill[ing]" the affidavit-holder.
- The court examined the language of Rule 12(6) of the D.R.T. (Procedure) Rules, 1993, which permits the Tribunal to order proof by affidavit but contains a proviso stating that "where it appears to the Tribunal that either applicant or defendant desires the production of a witness for cross-examination, and that such witness can be produced an order shall not be made authorizing the evidence of such witness to be given by affidavit." The court contrasted this with Order 19, Rule 1 of the C.P.C., which allows the court some latitude to examine the bona fides of a party seeking production of a witness.
- The court concluded that, unlike Order 19 Rule 1 CPC where the court may probe bona fides, Rule 12(6) of the D.R.T. Rules contains an unqualified proviso that precludes authorizing affidavit evidence if a party genuinely desires production of the witness and the witness can be produced. Consequently, the D.R.T. had no jurisdiction under Rule 12(6) to decline production of the Branch Manager simply by suspecting lack of bona fides without permitting cross-examination where the petitioner had sought it.
- The court noted that the petitioner had specifically alleged forgery of revival letters and balance-confirmation acknowledgments and had raised limitation as a defence; the D.R.T.'s refusal to allow cross-examination and refusal to permit expert examination of the disputed documents amounted to ignoring the established procedure and violated natural justice.
- Given these findings, the court held that the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Articles 226 and 227 had to be exercised to correct the injustice caused to the petitioner.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The court set aside the impugned D.R.T. order dated 9-4-2003 (and related order dated 11-11-2002) which had decreed the Bank's claim based on affidavit evidence without permitting cross-examination.
Direct orders and immediate consequences:
- The court directed the D.R.T., Cuttack to dispose of O.A. No. 328 of 2001 afresh in accordance with law.
- The D.R.T. was instructed to give the petitioner an opportunity to cross-examine the Branch Manager of the Bank who had tendered affidavit evidence.
- The D.R.T. was directed to have the genuineness of the disputed documents (revival letters and balance-confirmation acknowledgments) examined by an expert.
- To expedite proceedings, the parties were directed to appear before the D.R.T. on 25th August, 2004, when the Tribunal was to fix a date of hearing.
Implications: The immediate effect is to remit the matter for fresh adjudication with adherence to Rule 12(6) and principles of natural justice by permitting cross-examination and expert scrutiny of disputed documents. The opinion applies established precedents to justify exercise of writ jurisdiction in these circumstances; it does not purport to announce a new legal principle beyond applying existing law to the facts at hand.
Disposition: Petition allowed. (A.K. Patnaik, J. concurred.)
A.K Parichha, J.:— The petitioner has challenged the order dated 9-4-2003 passed by the Presiding Officer, Debts Recovery Tribunal Orissa, Cuttack in O.A No. 328 of 2001 in terms of which the claim of opp. party No. 2-Bank for a sum of Rs. 23,27,390.16 has been decreed with interest and cost.
2. The petitioner is the sole proprietor of the firm, namely, “Allied Chemical Laboratories”. For bringing some technical changes in his unit he availed a loan of Rs. 3.5 lakhs from opp. party No. 2-Bank in the year 1986. In the year 2001 the Bank filed Original Application No. 322 of 2001 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, (in short, ‘D.R.T’), Patna for recovery of the loan amount and interest thereon from the petitioner. The said Original Application was transferred to the D.R.T, Orissa, Cuttack and was renumbered as O.A No. 328 of 2001. On notice, the petitioner appeared and filed show-cause taking a plea that the claim is barred by limitation. He also pleaded that neither he himself nor his guarantor ever executed the revival letters and balance confirmation acknowledgment and that opp. party No. 2 created those fake documents. Opp. party No. 2 filed reply to the said show-cause and also filed affidavit evidence of the Branch Manager of the Bank. The petitioner then made a prayer before the D.R.T demanding production of the Branch Manager for cross-examination, but the learned D.R.T rejected the said prayer and basing on the affidavit evidence decreed the claim of opp. party No. 2 vide the impugned order. Aggrieved by the order decreeing the claim, the petitioner has filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
3. The submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that by not giving an opportunity to cross-examine the witness of opp. party No. 2-Bank, the D.R.T not only violated the principles of natural justice but also acted contrary to the provisions of Rule 12(6) of the Debts Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules, 1993’). According to him, when the petitioner had specifically challenged the genuineness of revival letters and balance confirmation acknowledgments produced by opp. party No. 2, opportunity of cross-examining the Branch Manager should have been extended and the documents should have been sent for examination by the handwriting expert. Opp. party No. 2 in the counter affidavit while denying the allegations that the revival letters and balance confirmation acknowledgments were fake and forged, specifically asserted that production of witness who has given evidence by affidavit is not mandatory and that the D.R.T may refuse such prayer of a party, if it feels that the prayer is not bona fide. Opp. party No. 2 also challenged the maintainability of the present writ petition on the ground that the power under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution cannot be invoked where specific appellate forum is available. According to opp. party No. 2, the petitioner has filed this writ petition with an intention to drag the recovery proceeding which has already been initiated on the basis of the judgment and certificate issued thereon and also to overcome the delay of 10 months which has occurred after the passing of the impugned order.
4. From the above noted stand of the parties, the points which emerge for consideration are:— (i) whether the present writ petition is maintainable in spite of availability of appellate forum; (ii) whether disallowing the prayer of the petitioner for production of the Branch Manager of the Bank for cross-examination was violative of the principle of natural justice and the provisions of the Rules, 1993.
5. As has been held in the case of Bombay Telephone Canteen Employees' Association v. Union of India, AIR 1997 SC 2817, normally writ jurisdiction is not to be invoked where alternative, effective and efficacious remedy is available under the law. But this rule is not an absolute one. Availability of an alternative forum does not ipso facto oust the writ jurisdiction of the High Court. The High Court has always its discretion to grant relief under Article 226 of the Constitution even if there are other alternative statutory remedies. This view finds support from the observation of the Apex Court in the cases of Collector of Monghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka, AIR 1962 SC 1694, Baburam Prakash Chandra Maheshwari v. Antarim Zilla Parishad, Muzaffarnagar, reported in AIR 1969 SC 556, M.S Grewal v. Deep Chand Sood, AIR 2001 SC 3660 and T.K Rangarajan v. Govt. of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2003 SC 3032 to the effect that a law Court will lose its efficiency if it cannot possibly respond to the need of the Society and justice oriented approach ought not to be thwarted on the basis of technicalities. In T.K Rangarajan's case (supra) it was pointedly observed that High Court is empowered to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction to meet unprecedented extraordinary situations.
6. The observations of the apex Court in the above noted cases clearly suggest that existence of alternative remedy is not a bar for entertaining a writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution particularly in cases where natural justice is violated or established procedure of law flagrantly ignored or where ends of justice will be defeated by refusing to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction.
7. In the present case, the contention of the petitioner is that in spite of the clear provision under Rule 12(6) of the Rules, 1993 to allow cross-examination of a witness who has tendered his evidence by way of affidavit, his demand for cross-examination of the Branch Manager of the Bank was rejected and the impugned order was passed without affording any opportunity of hearing. According to him, such action of the D.R.T is not only against the established procedure of law but also violative of the principles of natural justice.
8. It is apparent from the impugned order under Annexure-1 as well as order dated 11-11-2002 under Annexure-A/2 that the petitioner prayed for allowing him to cross-examine the Branch Manager of the Bank who had produced the revival letters and balance confirmation acknowledgments to prove that those documents were forged ones and that they were never executed by him or his guarantor. But the said prayer was rejected by the learned D.R.T with the following observations:
“xxxxxxxxx
To require the opposite party for purpose of cross examination, the party seeking that prayer should initially establish by specific proof of facts which would warrant summoning of the witness to explain the facts asserted by him. Unless such discharge of initial burden, he (petitioner) cannot seek for summoning the opposite party's Affidavit holder.
Saying that calculation of interest is wrong, account is wrong, or saying he signed blank documents and bonds but they were manipulated is not sufficient. The party should first prove such things by discharging his initial burden.
Saying account is wrong is not sufficient. He should file his calculation and show how it is wrong. Then the other side will be called to substantiate the correctness of their claim. For this oral evidence is not necessary. A calculation on paper will be sufficient.
As far as execution of documents and it's validity are concerned, it is for the party to prove how they are not valid and binding (when he admits the documents and execution).
No such circumstances are placed by the petitioner in his petition or pleadings. His prayer appears to be for gaining time or for satisfying his desire to grill the affidavit holder in the witness box. This Tribunal does not find any grounds to summon the applicant's affidavit holder as the matter stands. However, if during the course of hearing arguments, if the Tribunal feels the necessity, it will consider and pass appropriate orders.”
9. Rule 12(6) of the Rules, 1993 reads thus:
“The Tribunal may at any time for sufficient reason order that any particular fact or facts may be proved by affidavit, or that the affidavit of any witness may be read at the hearing on such conditions as the Tribunal thinks reasonable;
Provided that where it appears to the Tribunal that either applicant or defendant desires the production of a witness for cross-examination, and that such witness can be produced an order shall not be made authorizing the evidence of such witness to be given by affidavit.”
Thus, the provision of Rule 12(6) makes it clear that the Tribunal may for sufficient reasons order the proof of a particular fact or facts by affidavit, but such affidavit evidence will not be entertained if any of the parties desires the production of the witness for cross-examination. Order 19, Rule 1 of the C.P.C provides that any Court may at any time, for sufficient reason, order that any particular fact or facts may be proved by affidavit, or that the affidavit of any witness may be read at the hearing, on such conditions as the Court thinks reasonable; provided that where it appears to the Court that either party bona fide desires the production of a witness for cross-examination, and that such witness can be produced, an order shall not be made authorizing the evidence of such witness to be given by affidavit. A close reading of the above noted provisions shows that while the Court has some option under Order 19 Rule 1 C.P.C to examine the bona fides of a party asking for production of a witness for cross-examination, the D.R.T has no such option under Rule 12(6) of the Rules, 1993 as the proviso to the said Rule 12(6) states that where either the applicant or the defendant desires the production of a witness for cross-examination and such witness can be produced an order shall not be made authorizing such witness to give evidence by affidavit. In the impugned order as well as in the order dated 11-11-2002, learned D.R.T Cuttack not only remarked about lack of bona fide intention of the petitioner, but also said that in matters relating to claim of the Bank, there is hardly any scope for oral evidence forgetting the fact that the petitioner had challenged the claim of opp. party No. 2 on the ground of limitation and had alleged that Bank has created fake and forged balance confirmation acknowledgments and revival letters to overcome the bar of limitation. He also ignored the demand for examination of those revival letters and balance confirmation acknowledgments by an expert saying that such examination is unnecessary. This approach of the D.R.T is clearly violative of the principles of natural justice as well as the provision of Rule 12(6) of the Rules, 1993. In such extraordinary circumstance, the power of this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution has to be exercised to set right the injustice which has been caused to the petitioner.
10. We accordingly allow the writ petition, set aside the impugned order and direct the D.R.T, Cuttack to dispose of O.A No. 328 of 2001 afresh in accordance with law after giving opportunity to the petitioner to cross-examine the Branch Manager of the Bank who had tendered his affidavit evidence and after getting genuineness of the disputed document examined by an expert. To avoid further delay, we direct the parties to appear before the D.R.T on 25th August, 2004 when the latter shall fix a date of hearing.
A.K Patnaik, J.:— 11. I agree.
Petition allowed.
Alert