- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Adhunik Steel Limited And Anr. v. State Of Orissa And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The revision challenges an order dated 8.3.2004 passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (S.D.M.), Bonai, under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in Misc. Criminal Case No. 3 of 2004. The Government of Orissa granted a lease of mining land in Sundargarh district to Orissa Manganese and Minerals Pvt. Limited (opposite party), who entered into an agreement with Adhunik Steels Limited (petitioner) to operate mining for manganese ores for ten years starting May 18, 2003. The petitioner invested heavily in plants, machinery, and labor, incurring costs of Rs. 2.5 crores and paying salaries of Rs. 3 lakhs per month. The opposite party terminated the agreement on 24.11.2003 alleging violation of Minerals Concession Rules, 1960. The petitioner sought interim protection under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 from the Kolkata High Court, which restrained both parties from taking steps under the agreement until resolution. Despite this, the opposite party allegedly forcibly attempted to evict the petitioner and misappropriate assets, leading the petitioner to file an FIR and seek protection under Section 144 Cr.P.C. before the Sub-Collector and S.D.M., Bonai, resulting in the impugned order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the learned S.D.M. had jurisdiction to entertain and pass an order under Section 144 Cr.P.C. while the matter was pending before the Kolkata High Court.
- Whether the impugned order of appointing the opposite party as caretaker of the mines and restraining the petitioner from entering the leasehold area was lawful and in conformity with the interim order of the Kolkata High Court.
- Whether the Magistrate should have proceeded under Section 107 Cr.P.C. instead of Section 144 Cr.P.C. to prevent breach of peace.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that despite the Kolkata High Court's order restraining both parties from taking steps under the agreement, the opposite party forcibly entered the mines, assaulted staff, and looted Rs. 2 lakhs.
- The petitioner filed a petition under Section 144 Cr.P.C. to prevent large-scale disturbance and illegal eviction.
- The S.D.M., instead of passing an order consistent with the Kolkata High Court's restraint, appointed the opposite party as caretaker of the mines and restrained the petitioner from entering, which was contrary to the High Court’s order.
- The petitioner feared that placing the opposite party in charge would lead to sale of petitioner’s assets and expulsion of employees, causing loss and breach of peace.
Opposite Party's Arguments
- The opposite party argued that subsequent orders of the Kolkata High Court were not disclosed to the Court, warranting modification or vacation of the ex parte order passed by this Court.
- Since the matter was pending before the Kolkata High Court, the learned S.D.M. had no jurisdiction to entertain the Section 144 Cr.P.C. application.
- The Kolkata High Court’s interim orders allowed the petitioner to excavate the mines without disturbing the possession of the opposite party and prohibited creation of third party rights or removal of materials by the opposite party.
- The Kolkata High Court appointed a Special Officer to inventory the plant, machinery, and excavated ores, indicating that appropriate relief should be sought from the High Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mahant Ram Saran Dass v. Harish Mohan and Anr., (2001) 10 S.C.C. 758 | Jurisdiction of Magistrate under Section 145 Cr.P.C. during pendency of a civil suit | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that when a civil suit is pending, the Magistrate has no jurisdiction to entertain proceedings under Section 144 or 145 Cr.P.C. and that appropriate relief must be sought from the civil court. |
| Ashok Kumar Agarwala and Anr. v. Sankarlal Choudhury, (1988) 1 OCR 13 | Proceedings under Section 144 or 145 Cr.P.C. when civil suit with injunction pending | The Court applied this precedent to affirm that if a civil suit with injunction is pending, proceedings under Section 144 or 145 Cr.P.C. should not be entertained and any breach of peace should be addressed under Section 107 Cr.P.C. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that the matter was sub judice before the Kolkata High Court, which had passed an interim order restraining both parties from acting under the agreement. The Court examined the jurisdiction of the learned S.D.M. to entertain the Section 144 Cr.P.C. application in light of the Apex Court's decision in Mahant Ram Saran Dass and the decision of this Court in Ashok Kumar Agarwala. It observed that when a civil or arbitration proceeding is pending, the Magistrate lacks jurisdiction to pass orders under Section 144 or 145 Cr.P.C. that conflict with the civil court’s interim orders. The Court held that the S.D.M.'s order appointing the opposite party as caretaker and restraining the petitioner was not in conformity with the Kolkata High Court’s order and was therefore unsustainable. The Court further held that if there was an apprehension of breach of peace, the Magistrate should have proceeded under Section 107 Cr.P.C. rather than Section 144 Cr.P.C. Consequently, the impugned order was quashed.
Holding and Implications
The Court quashed the order dated 8.3.2004 passed by the learned S.D.M., Bonai under Section 144 Cr.P.C. It also held that the interim order passed by this Court on 19.3.2004 directing the Deputy Director of Mines to remain in charge was no longer necessary. The decision directly restores the status quo pending before the Kolkata High Court and directs the parties to seek appropriate relief therein. There is no creation of new precedent; the ruling emphasizes the primacy of jurisdiction of the civil or arbitration forum over the Magistrate’s powers under Section 144 Cr.P.C. when the matter is sub judice.
1. This revision is directed against the order dated 8.3.2004 passed by the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Bonai in a proceeding under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure vide Misc.Criminal Case No. 3 of 2004.
2. Before considering the legality of the impugned order, it is necessary to look into the facts leading to filing of cases in different Courts in West Bengal as well as in Orissa. The Government of Orissa granted a lease of mining land at Patmunda, Orahri, Tentulldihl, Kusumdihi, Sonpatholi and Bhanajaikusum in the district of Sundargarh in favour of the opposite party. The opposite party-Orissa Manganese and Minerals Pvt. Limited entered into an agreement with the petitioner-Adhunik Steels Limited to carry out mining operation in the aforesaid mines and excavate/extract/remove manganese ores for and on behalf of the opposite party and to deliver the same to it or its customers for a period of 10 years with effect from May 18, 2003 with an option to renew the same on terms and conditions. It is the case of the petitioner that after execution of the agreement it purchased and acquired valuable plants and machineries to work in the mines and also incurred costs, charges and expenses amounting to Rs. 2.5 crores. It is further case of the petitioners that workmen and personnel were engaged and employed to operate mines and since July, 2003 the petitioners have been paying salary and wages of Rs. 3 lakhs per month. Apart from the above, it is the case of the petitioner that it has undertaken massive development of mines by removing more than 2.5 lakhs cum over burden to expose manganese ores valued at Rs. 10 crores. However, on 24.11.2003 the opposite party-company claimed that the agreement was in violation of the Minerals Concession Rules, 1960 and therefore is illegal and void and terminated the same with immediate effect. Since the agreement contained an arbitration clause the petitioner approached Kolkata High Court by way of filing an application under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 seeking interim protection by way of an order restraining the opposite party to take over possession of the schedule mines and to refrain from interfering in the mining operation which the petitioner is entitled to carry on in terms of the agreement. Kolkata High Court after hearing counsel for both parties, by order dated 9.2.2004 restrained both parties from taking any step in accordance with the agreement until the matter is decided. Further case of the petitioner is that in spite of such order passed by the Kolkata High Court the opposite party attempted to evict the petitioner forcibly and illegally and misappropriate the assets created by them valued at Rs. 13 crores. In view of such conduct of the opposite party the petitioner made representation to the Collector, Sundargarh on 30.1.2004 to invoke Section 144 Cr.P.C. and prevent a large scale disturbance that may occur due to conduct of the opposite party. It is further case of the petitioner that on 3.2.2004 some representatives and supporters of the opposite-party-company including the three Directors forcibly entered into the premises of the petitioner-company and assaulted, threatened staff of the petitioner and looted Rs. 2 lakhs. Making such allegations an F.I.R. was also lodged in Koira Police Station vide Koira P.S, Case No. 3 of 2004. It further appears that the petitioner filed an application under Section 144 Cr.P.C. before the Sub-Collector-cum-Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Bonai which was registered as Misc.Criminal Case No. 3 of 2004 and after hearing learned counsel for both parties, the impugned order was passed.
3. Sri Parija, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that though in the Arbitration proceeding pending before the Kolkata High Court an order was passed on 9.2.2004 restraining both the parties from taking any further step in accordance with the agreement until the matter is decided, three Directors of the opposite party-company along with some other staff forcibly entered into the mines area under the occupation of the petitioners on 3.2.2004, assaulted staff of the petitioners and looted away Rs. 2 lakhs. To meet the situation which led to breach of peace, a petition under Section 144 Cr.P.C. was filed before the Sub-Collector and S.D.M., Bonai. Shri Parija further contended that instead of passing an order in terms of order passed by Kolkata High Court, the Sub-Collector-cum-
S.D.M., Bonai though restrained both parties from excavating mines, appointed the opposite party as care-taker to watch the mines, to check theft of ores from lease-hold mines as well as the camp at Koira. The S.D.M. also restrained the petitioner from entering into the lease-hold area till the matter is disposed by the competent Court. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that since the S.D.M. was aware of the order passed by the Kolkata High Court he could have only passed order in conformity with the order passed by Kolkata High Court and could not have appointed the second-party to remain in charge of the mines and restrain the present petitioner from entering into the mines. The apprehension of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the moment the opposite party is kept in-charge of the mines, valuable plants and machineries installed by the petitioner and the manganese ore already excavated shall be sold by the opposite party and employees of the petitioner shall be thrown out of mines giving rise to serious breach of peace as well as loss to the petitioner-company.
Considering such submission, this Court by an ex parte order dated 19.3.2004 directed the Deputy Director of Mines to remain in charge of the entire mines instead of opposite party as directed by the S.D.M.
4. Shri Jagannath Das, learned senior counsel appearing for the opposite party had filed an application for vacating the interim order on the ground that subsequent orders passed by Kolkata High Court were suppressed and not brought to the notice of the Court, as a result of which the ex parte order is liable to be modified/vacated. Shri Das further contended that since the matter is pending before Kolkata High Court, the learned S.D.M. had absolutely no jurisdiction to entertain the application under Section 144 Cr.P.C. Learned counsel brought to the notice of the Court the order dated 12.3.2004 passed by the Kolkata High Court and it appears that as an interim measure, the Kolkata High Court passed the following order :
"Such being the position and since as it appears that the main matter is coming up for hearing on 15th March, 2004, it would be proper for me to direct at this stage that this order will not stand in the way of the petitioner either to enter into the agreement with the authorities to excavate the mines without disturbing the possession of Adhunik Steels Ltd., if any, which has been specifically disputed by Mr. Pal appearing for the respondent, Orissa Manganese and Minerals Pvt. Ltd.
I further make it clear that no third party right can also be created by Mr. Pal's client in respect of the materials lying at the said Mines and Mr. Pal's client shall not remove the same."
It further appears that after such order was passed, the Kolkata High Court has again by order dated 30.3.2004 appointed Mr. Pradip Mitra (Sr.) of Bar Library Club, 1st Floor, High Court, Calcutta as Special Officer who will make inventory of the plant and machinery and the goods i.e. the excavated manganese ores and also take measurement of the same with the help of an expert to be appointed by the Special Officer at the cost of the petitioner. It is further directed that the Special Officer will not interfere with any other things. Referring to the aforesaid orders Sri Das, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the opposite party submitted that since the matter is pending before the Kolkata High Court, the petitioner should have approached the said Court in the said proceeding for any other appropriate order to prevent breach of peace.
5. There is no dispute that the matter is pending before Kolkata High Court and some orders as indicated above have been passed by the said High Court. In the case of Mahant Ram Saran Dass v. Harish Mohan and Anr., reported in (2001) 10 S.C.C. 758, while dealing with the jurisdiction of the Magistrate under Section 145 Cr.P.C. during pendency of a civil suit, the Apex Court observed as follows :
"The short question that arises for consideration is whether in the facts and circumstances of the present case, a civil suit for declaration under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure being pending before the competent forum, the Civil Court, the respondent was entitled to invoke the jurisdiction of the Magistrate under Section 145 Cr.P.C., and the Magistrate was entitled to initiate the proceedings and pass any interim order of appointment of receiver therein. It is not disputed that in the civil suit itself the Court has passed interim order of injunction, and put certain restrictions on the parties with regard to alienation of the property in question. It is true that the applicant before the Magistrate, has not been arrayed as party-defendant in the civil suit, but that will not alter the position in any manner since in our view the Civil Court being in seisin of the matter, any appropriate relief could be obtained from the Civil Court itself and the Magistrate had no jurisdiction in the case in hand to entertain the application under Section 145 Cr.P.C., and to pass any orders thereon. In the circumstances, the impugned order of the High Court as well as the proceeding initiated before the Magistrate under Section 145 Cr.P.C. stand set aside. The appeal is disposed of accordingly. Needless to mention the status quo as of today to be maintained to enable the parties to move the Civil Court for appropriate orders."
Same view was also taken by this Court in the case of Ashok Kumar Agarwala and Anr. v. Sankarlal Choudhury reported in (1988) 1 OCR 13. In the aforesaid decision this Court held that if civil suit is pending between the parties relating to self-same property and ad interim injunction has been issued by Civil Court restraining possession of one party, there is no need of starting proceeding under Section 144 or 145 Cr.P.C. If there is any proceeding pending under either of the provisions, it should be dropped. If the Magistrate finds any breach of peace he can proceed under Section 107 Cr.P.C.
The order dated 9.2.2004 passed by Kolkata High Court clearly shows that both parties are restrained from taking any further steps in accordance with the said agreement until the matter is decided. In view of restraint order passed by the Kolkata High Court and in view of what has been decided by the Apex Court and this Court in the aforesaid decisions, I am of the view that the learned S.D.M. could not have passed any order which is not in conformity with the order passed by the Kolkata High Court. If there was apprehension of breach of peace the learned Magistrate could have proceeded under Section 107 Cr.P.C. Therefore, directions issued by the learned Magistrate in the impugned order are not sustainable. One may further observe that in view of the decisions referred to above the proceeding under Section 144 Cr.P.C. could not have been entertained by the S.D.M.
6. I, accordingly, quash the order dated 8.3.2004 passed by the learned S.D.M., Bonai. Since the order dated 8.3.2004 is quashed, there cannot be any further apprehension as expressed by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the opposite party-company once kept in charge of the mines, shall either sell away plant and machineries as well as manganese ores. Accordingly, there is also no need to continue interim order passed on 19.3.2004 by this Court.
This revision is disposed of with the aforesaid observations and directions. If the parties are aggrieved by the conduct of either party, they should move Kolkata High Court where the matter is subjudice.
Alert