Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

New India Assurance Company, Ltd. v. Mohan Kumar Sahoo And Another

Orissa High Court
Jul 23, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises under S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 and was instituted by the insurer challenging an award passed by the Deputy Labour Commissioner and Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Rourkela. The central dispute concerns whether the deceased, Bisen alias Biswanath Mahanta, who died from injuries sustained in a motor-vehicle collision, was a "workman" under the Workmen's Compensation Act when he had been engaged by the vehicle owner to drive the bus for one day.

The claimant (Respondent No. 2) sought compensation for the death of her husband, alleging that he was employed as a driver by Respondent No. 1 (the owner, Mohan Kumar Sahoo). According to the claimant, the deceased received personal injury in an accident on 27 December (the opinion contains both 1993 and 1992 in different paragraphs) and died on 4 January, 1994 while undergoing treatment. The owner admitted that the deceased drove the bus on the fateful date but stated that the engagement was only for a single day and that the deceased was paid Rs. 70 for that day.

It is undisputed that the vehicle was validly insured with the appellant (insurer) and that the policy covered the date of the accident. The insurer admitted the insurance but contested liability on multiple grounds, including lack of knowledge about the employment details and, crucially, the absence of a master-servant relationship between the insured and the deceased.

Before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner three issues were framed; the principal one for present purposes was whether the deceased was a casual workman not entitled to compensation. The Commissioner held that the driver’s work is by nature regular for the employer’s trade and business and that the deceased was not a casual workman; consequently the dependants were held entitled to compensation. The insurer appealed that award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person engaged for one day to drive the vehicle of the owner can be construed to be a "workman" within the meaning of S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Insurer's) Arguments

  • The insurer challenged liability and contended there was no master-servant (employer-employee) relationship between the insured owner and the deceased.
  • Learned counsel for the appellant relied on the definition in S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act to argue that a person whose employment is of a casual nature and who is employed otherwise than for the purpose of the employer's trade or business is excluded from "workman".
  • The appellant relied on authorities (including decisions under related statutory provisions) to argue that where there is no contract of service or where the worker is effectively an independent licensee, paid by piece or working under subcontract, such persons are not "workmen". Specific cases relied upon by appellant include Ma Htwa Yin v. Maung Thet Hnin and In re Workmen's Compensation of Jaglipathan and references to distinctions drawn in cases addressing "contract of service" versus "contract for service".

Respondent's / Claimant's Arguments and Commissioner's Findings

  • The claimant's case (as accepted by the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner) was that the deceased was employed as a driver by the owner and received fatal injuries in an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.
  • The owner admitted engaging the deceased to drive the bus on the relevant date (albeit claiming it was only for one day) and admitted payment of wages for that day.
  • The Workmen's Compensation Commissioner found that the work of a driver is of a regular nature for the employer's trade or business and that a person performing the duties of a driver is a workman irrespective of the limited tenure of engagement; the owner could not manage the vehicle without a driver and thereby exerted the requisite control.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
61 (1986) C.L.T 137 — Rebati Gantayat v. Haguru Sethi (and after him) Haramoni Held that a relationship of employer and employee must exist before a person can be a "workman" vis-à-vis his employer; once such relationship is established, one must consider whether employment is casual and whether it is for the employer's trade or business; employment must be in a capacity mentioned in Sch. II. The Court observed that driver is included in Sch. II; therefore the element of capacity is satisfied and the aspect of capacity did not require further consideration in the present case.
A.I.R 1957 S.C 264 — Dharangadhra Chemical Works Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra Decision under S. 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act distinguishing "a contract for services" and "a contract of services". The Court noted this decision was relied upon by the appellant but stated it would be of no help to the appellant on the facts of the present case.
A.I.R 1955 Saurashtra 33 — Dharangadhra Chemical Works, Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra (High Court decision cited in the judgment) In distinguishing "contract of service" and "contract for service" the crucial test for a contract of service is the degree of control by the master over the work and an obligation on the worker to obey orders. The Court treated control as the basic inquiry to determine whether a contract of service existed and expressly sought to ascertain whether the owner had control over the deceased driver.
A.I.R 1941 Rangoon 61 — Ma Htwa Yin v. Maung Thet Hnin Held that a person who was a mere licensee on the mine, paid by piece-work and not controlled by the mine authorities, was not a "workman" under S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. The appellant relied on this case, but the Court found the facts distinguishable because, in the present case, there was an admission of engagement and evidence of control by the owner over the deceased.
A.I.R 1936 Rangoon 89 — In re Workmen's Compensation of Jaglipathan Held that persons working as members of a coolie gang under sub-contract were not workmen under the Act; elaborated that to be a workman a person must be under a contract of service with some other person. The Court cited this decision for the proposition that contract of service is a material test, but applied the control test and factual findings (owner's control) to conclude that the deceased was under the employer's service.
2000 (4) L.L.N 453 — Trivandrum Port and Headload Worker Co-operative Society, Ltd. v. Dhanesh Kumar Held that a person employed only for 2 or 3 days as a substitute driver for a lorry would be a "workman" under S. 2(1)(n) of the Act. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that a substitute engaged for short periods can still be a "workman" when engaged for the principal employer's service.
1985 A.C.J 38 — K.K. Saraswathi v. Narayanaswami (Madras High Court) Decision relied upon by the Kerala High Court in the Trivandrum Port case to support that short-term/substitute drivers can be workmen. The Court referenced this decision indirectly (via Trivandrum Port) in support of the legal position that substitutes retained for the employer's service can be workmen even if engaged for a short period.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by focusing on the statutory definition in S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act and on whether the factual matrix established an employer-employee relationship and the existence of requisite control by the owner.

Key legal points and steps in the Court's reasoning:

  • The Court observed that a driver is explicitly mentioned in Schedule II to the Act, satisfying the capacity requirement under S. 2(n).
  • Relying on the line of authority that requires proof of an employer-employee relationship before the definition of "workman" applies vis-à-vis the employer, the Court noted that once such a relationship exists, the employment's casualness and whether it was for the employer's trade or business must be examined.
  • The Court accepted the proposition (drawn from decisions concerning "contract of service") that the essential inquiry is whether the master (owner) had control over the worker; the degree of control and the obligation to obey directions are critical markers of a contract of service.
  • Applying the facts, the Court found that the written statement of the owner and the findings of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner showed the owner had engaged the deceased to drive the bus and that on the relevant date the deceased was driving under the direction of the owner. Thus, there was definite control and an admission of engagement.
  • The Court held that the fact of engagement for a single day did not automatically exclude the person from being a "workman." S. 2(n) excludes only those whose employment is casual and who are employed otherwise than for the purpose of the employer's trade or business. Here the engagement was for the employer's trade (operation of the passenger vehicle) and the deceased performed duties for the employer when the accident occurred.
  • The Court also relied on authorities holding that substitutes engaged for short periods may nevertheless be workmen if they are engaged for the principal employer's service and retained to perform duties for that employer.
  • On the combined facts and law, the Court concluded that the deceased was engaged in service of the owner, was under the owner's control, and died in the course of employment; therefore he fell within the definition of "workman" under S. 2(n).

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: APPEAL DISMISSED. The Court held that the deceased was a "workman" under S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act and that his dependants were entitled to compensation as awarded by the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner.

Direct consequences and orders made by the Court:

  • The appeal was dismissed and the award in favour of the claimant was upheld.
  • Out of the awarded amount, Rs. 60,000 shall be placed in a fixed deposit in the name of the claimant for a period of five years; the balance of the award shall be paid to the claimant by way of an account-payee cheque.
  • It was noted that the awarded amount had been deposited after the expiry of thirty days; the insurer was directed to pay interest under the Workmen's Compensation Act from the date of the award until the date of deposit. The insurer was ordered to deposit the interest component within six weeks.
  • On depositing the interest component, that interest shall be kept in a non-encumberable fixed deposit in the name of the claimant for five years.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles (including the control test and schedule membership) to the facts and reaffirms that short-term or substitute engagement does not automatically exclude a person from being a "workman" where they are engaged for the employer's trade and are under the employer's control. The decision's direct effect is to uphold the award in favor of the claimant; the opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying and reaffirming existing principles discussed in the cited authorities.

Appeal dismissed.
Show all summary ...

1. This appeal under S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) is at the instance of the insurer challenging the award passed by the Deputy Labour Commissioner and Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Rourkela (in short, the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner).

2. The question of law that arises for consideration in this appeal is whether the deceased being engaged for one day to drive the vehicle of the owner can be construed to be a workman under the Workmen's Compensation Act.

3. The brief facts leading to this appeal are follows:

Respondent No. 2 was the claimant before the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation claiming compensation for the death of her husband namely Bisen alias Biswanath Mahanta, who died in a motor vehicular accident. The case of the claimant before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner was that her husband was employed as a driver by present respondent No. 1. Mohan Kumar Sahoo of Naranpur, in the district of Keonjhar. On 27 December, 1993 he received personal injury due to an accident arising out of and in course of his employment and while he was being treated in the Government Hospital, Keonjhar, succumbed to the injury on 4 January, 1994. The claimant claimed for a sum of Rs. 1,00,000. The owner of the vehicle filed his written statement disclosing therein that the deceased Bisen alias Biswanath Mahanta was employed by him in his bus bearing registration No. ORJ-7401 only for a day, i.e, 27 December, 1992 in absence of his regular driver and he was paid Rs. 70 for that day as wages including food charges. On 27 December, 1992 the said bus met with an accident being collided with a truck, ultimately resulting in the death of the deceased driver. There was no factual dispute that the vehicle was validly insured with the present appellant and the date of accident was covered under a valid insurance policy. The insurer also contested the proceeding before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner by filing written statement admitting the factum of valid insurance of the vehicle in question disclosing the policy number, but it denied to accept the liability on several grounds, one of which being that it is not liable to indemnify the compensation as it had no knowledge about the employment of the deceased, his age, wages and more specifically there was absence of master and servant relationship between the insured and the deceased.

4. The Workmen's Compensation Commissioner framed as many as three issues. The issue with which we are concerned is whether the deceased was a casual workman not entitled to compensation?

5. While answering the aforesaid issue, the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner held that whether a workman is casual or regular depends upon the nature of Job for which he is engaged and in this particular case, the job of the driver is regular one so far the trade or business of the employer is concerned.

6. According to the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner, the very nature of the job of driver in this case is of regular or permanent type and the workman engaged therein irrespective of his tenure of employment is a regular workman. Reason as stated by the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner is that the owner cannot manage the vehicle without a driver. Basing upon the aforesaid reasoning, the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner held that the deceased was not a casual workman and for his death due to an accident arising out of and in course of his employment, his dependants are entitled to compensation.

7. The fact of engagement of the deceased as a driver to drive the vehicle of the owner is not disputed, so also the fact that he was engaged for a day only.

8. Learned counsel for the appellant draws my attention to the provision of S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, which defines “workman” as follows:

Section 2(1)(n) runs as follows:

“(n) ‘workman means any person (other than a person whose employment is of a casual nature and who is employed otherwise than for the purpose of the employer's trade or business) who is—

(i) a Railway servant as defined in S. 3 of the Indian Railways Act, 1890 (9 of 1890) not permanently employed in any administrative, district or Sub-Divisional Office or a railway and not employed in any such capacity as is specified in Sch. II; or

(ia)(a) a master, seaman or other member of the crew of a ship;

(b) a captain or other member of the crew of an aircraft;

(c) a person recruited as driver, helper, mechanic cleaner or in any other capacity in connection with a motor vehicle;

(d) a person recruited for work abroad by a company, and who is employed outside Iidia in any such capacity as is specified in Sch. II and the ship, aircraft or motor vehicle, or company, as the case may be, is registered in India; or

(ii) employed 1(***) 2(***) in any such capacity as is specified in Sch. II.

Whether the contract of employment was made before or after the passing of this Act and whether such contract is expressed or implied, oral or in writing; but does not include any person working in the capacity of a member of 3 (the armed forces of the union) 4(***), and reference to a workman who has been injured shall, where the workman is dead include a reference to his dependants or any of them.”

9. There is also no dispute that the driver is also specified in Sch. II of the Workmen's Compensation Act. In this regard my attention was drawn to the decision reported in 61 (1986) C.L.T 137 (Rebati Gantayat v. Haguru Sethi (and after him) Haramoni, wherein this Court held that there must be relationship of an employer and employee before a person can be said to be a workman vis-a-vis his employer. Once such relationship is established it has to be further analysed to find if the employment of the employee is of a casual nature and if he was employed for the purpose of employer's trade or business. He must be employed in such capacity as is mentioned in any of the items included in Sch. II. The driver is already included in the Sch. II. So this aspect does not require consideration.

10. But the learned counsel for the appellant relying upon the above cited decision submits that there is no relationship of an employer and employee for which there is no need of further going into the question whether the nature of employment of the employee was casual or not. In this regard my attention was drawn to a decision reported in A.I.R 1957 S.C 264 (Dharangadhra Chemical Works Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra). That was a case under S. 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, where the Court distinguished the expressions “a contract for services” and “a contract of services”. The said decision will be of no help to the appellant in the facts of the present case.

11. Learned counsel for the appellant further relied upon a decision of the Apex Court reported in A.I.R 1941 Rangoon 61 (Ma Htwa Yin v. Maung Thet Hnin), which was a decision dealing with S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. It was held in the said decision that the deceased was a mere licensee upon the mine, that he was paid by piece work rates for the work, which he did, and that there was no control over him by the mine authorities. So he was not a “workman” within the meaning of the Act.

12. Learned counsel for the appellant draws my attention to another case reported in A.I.R 1936 Rangoon 89, In re. Workmen's Compensation of Jaglipathan. Wherein it was held that a person working as a member of coolie gang in carrying out work in collaboration and partnership under a sub-contract is not a workman within the meaning of the Act. But dealing elaborately, in the aforesaid case it was held that in order to be a workman within the meaning of Workmen's Compensation Act, a person must be under a contract of service with some other person.

13. The contract of service, is a different test under the Industrial Disputes Act. In the case of Dharangadhra Chemical Works, Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra reported in A.I.R 1955 Saurashtra 33, the High Court distinguished the expressions “contract of service” and “contract for service” while deciding a case under the Industrial Disputes Act and held that the crucial test to determine a contract of service is control by the master over the work of the servant and an obligation on the part of the servant to obey the orders of the master.

So the basic thing which this Court is to find out is whether there was control of the owner of the vehicle over the deceased.

14. The fact as narrated in the judgment and award passed by the Workmen's Compensation Court and also the written statement filed by the owner disclose that on certain terms he had engaged the deceased-driver to drive his bus, which is a passenger carrying vehicle and on the fateful date, he was working under him. This indicates that the owner had definite control over the deceased. He was driving the vehicle on the direction of the owner of the vehicle, may be, he was employed for a day only. His engagement for one day will not throw him out of the definition of workman under S. 2(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. Section 2(n) further postulates that the persons excluded from definition are those whose employment is not only of casual nature, but who are employed otherwise than for the purpose of the employer's trade or business.

15. A Division Bench of Kerala High Court in 2000 (4) L.L.N 453, Trivandrum Port and Headload Worker, Co-operative Society, Ltd. v. Dhanesh Kumar considered a similar question and relying on a decision of the Madras High Court in the case of K.K Saraswathi v. Narayanaswami, reported in 1985 A.C.J 38, held, that a person employed only for 2 or 3 days as a substitute driver for a lorry would be a workman’ under S. 2(1)(n) of the Act.

16. From a reading of the aforesaid decisions the legal position that emerges is that even if there is no employer-employee relationship with the principal employer, a substitute can be a workman if he is engaged for the service of the principal employer, and he is occupied in the performance of work or duties for the principal employer or if he is retained for the service of the principal employer.

17. The case at hand, stands on a better footing because there is direct relationship between the employer and the deceased. The evidence in that regard goes unimpeached. The owner had admitted to have engaged the deceased and directed him to drive his vehicle which means, the deceased was engaged in the service of the employer and died while performing the work and duty for his employer. It was proved that he was retained for the service of the employer, which is the paramount consideration.

18. Even assuming that the deceased's employment on that day was of a casual nature, that by itself is not enough to push him out of the ambit of the definition of “workman” because the casual nature of his engagement must couple with the definition that such employment should not be for the trade or business of the employer. In the present case the deceased was engaged by the employer for the purpose of performing, duties for the employer and the accident so occurred can safely be construed to be in course of his employment.

19. In view of the facts stated above, there is no merit in this appeal and the same “is accordingly dismissed.

20. Out of the awarded, amount. Rs. 60,000 shall be kept in a fixed deposit in the name of the claimant for a period of five years and the balance amount shall be paid to her by way of an account payee cheque. It is stated that the awarded amount has been deposited after the expiry of thirty days. The insurer is directed to pay the interest as provided under the Workmen's Compensation Act from the date of award till the date of deposit. The interest component will be deposited within a period of six weeks. On depositing the interest component, the entire interest component shall be kept in a non-encumberable fixed deposit in the name of the claimant for five years.

Appeal dismissed.