- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sitaram Mahendra Ghosh (C.R.P No. 89 Of 2002) v. Jogendranath Bhoi (C.R.P No. 107 Of 2002)
Judgment Summary — P.K. Tripathy, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This common judgment considers a large number of Civil Revision Petitions (listed by number in the opinion) which challenge diverse interlocutory orders passed by subordinate civil courts. The petitions arise from orders such as substitution of parties, rejection or allowance of applications for amendment of plaint or written statement (Order 6, Rule 17 CPC), rejection or admission of additional evidence (Order 41, Rule 27 CPC), appointment of a guardian ad litem, directions on the order of examination of evidence, rejection of applications to implead parties (Order 1, Rule 10 / Section 151 CPC or Order 22, Rule 10), applications to stay suits (Section 10 CPC), acceptance of documents in evidence, and other interlocutory rulings.
The common procedural context is the amendment of Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by Act 46 of 1999 (effective 1 July 2002). The primary procedural question framed by the Court is whether civil revisions against such interlocutory orders remain maintainable in view of the amended Section 115, particularly where the proviso requires that the order, if made in favour of the party seeking revision, would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether civil revisions under Section 115 of the Code are maintainable against interlocutory orders after the amendment by Act 46 of 1999 (effective 1.7.2002), when such orders qualify as a "case decided".
- Whether, under the amended Section 115, a revision is maintainable when the proviso to Sub-section (1) requires that the impugned order, if made in favour of the revision applicant, would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
- How the phrase "suit or other proceedings" (and specifically the word "proceeding") in Section 115 is to be interpreted — particularly whether proceedings arising in or out of a suit fall within the meaning of "other proceedings".
- Whether prior decisions (including this Court's decision in Simplex Engineering) construing "proceeding" to include proceedings arising in or out of suits remain correct in light of Supreme Court authority applying the principle ejusdem generis.
Arguments of the Parties
Arguments advanced on behalf of petitioners (and supporting counsel)
- Counsel for petitioners argued that many of the impugned interlocutory orders fall within the meaning of the term "case decided".
- They relied principally on Supreme Court decisions such as Major S.S. Khanna v. Brig. F.J. Dillon (AIR 1964 SC 497) and Baldebdas Sibalal v. Filmstar Distributors (India) Pvt. Ltd. ((1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406) as core precedents interpreting "case decided".
- They contended that the amendment to Section 115 by Act 46 of 1999 does not oust maintainability of civil revisions against interlocutory orders that qualify as "case decided".
- Reference was also made to this Court's earlier decision in Simplex Engineering and Foundry Works Ltd. v. Bhubaneswar Patnaik (reported 2003 (1) OLR 508) as supporting the view that proceedings arising in or out of a suit may be treated as "proceeding" within the meaning of the proviso to Section 115.
Arguments advanced on behalf of opposite parties (and some State counsel)
- Counsel for some opposite parties argued that the amended statutory text of Section 115 restricts maintainability: even if an order qualifies as a "case decided", a revision is barred unless the proviso condition is satisfied — namely that the order, had it been passed in favour of the applicant, would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
- They relied on the principle of ejusdem generis as applied by the Supreme Court in Shri Vishnu Avatar etc. v. Sriram Avatar ((1980) 4 SCC 81 : AIR 1980 SC 1575) to argue that "other proceedings" does not include proceedings arising in or out of a suit; rather it refers to original proceedings of equivalent status to a suit (for example arbitration or proceedings under the Indian Succession Act).
- Accordingly, counsel contended that this Court's earlier approach in Simplex Engineering (treating proceedings arising out of suits as "proceedings" within the proviso) is not correct in view of the Supreme Court's ruling.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Major S.S. Khanna v. Brig. F.J. Dillon, AIR 1964 SC 497 | Interpretation of the term "case decided" — used to identify interlocutory orders that can qualify as a case decided. | The Court regarded this decision as one of the core authorities supporting the proposition that many of the impugned interlocutory orders fall within the meaning of "case decided". |
| Baldebdas Sibalal v. Filmstar Distributors (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406 | Further authority on the interpretation of "case decided". | Relied upon with Major S.S. Khanna to conclude that the impugned orders come within "case decided". |
| M/s Simplex Engineering and Foundry Works Ltd. v. Bhubaneswar Patnaik (Civil Revision Petition No. 57 of 2003), 2003 (1) OLR 508 | This Court's prior view that a final order in a proceeding arising in or out of a suit, if appelable under Order 43 Rule 1, may be treated as a "proceeding" within "suit or other proceeding" for the proviso to Section 115 because such proceedings are transferable under Section 24 and governed by Section 141 procedures. | The present Court reviewed that view, observed it was expressed without considering the Supreme Court's ratio in Shri Vishnu Avatar, and concluded that Simplex's approach is not consistent with the apex Court authority interpreting "proceeding". |
| Shri Vishnu Avatar etc. v. Sriram Avatar, (1980) 4 SCC 81 : AIR 1980 SC 1575 | Application of the maxim ejusdem generis to construe "suit or other proceeding" — held that "proceeding" must be of equivalent status to a suit and excludes proceedings arising in or out of a suit. | The Court accepted this ratio and applied it to hold that miscellaneous proceedings arising in or out of a civil suit (e.g., injunction applications, appointment of receiver, restoration, setting aside ex parte decree) do not fall within "other proceedings" for the proviso to amended Section 115. |
| Shiv Shakti Cooperative Housing Society, Nagpur v. Swaraj Developers, 2003 (4) SCALE 241 | Consideration of the amended provision in Section 115 and its effect on revisional jurisdiction. | The Court relied on this decision in support of the conclusion that the amendment to Section 115 imposes a substantive restriction — a revision is not maintainable unless the proviso condition (final disposal if order had been in favour of applicant) is met. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in the following analytical steps (as reflected in the opinion):
- Identification of common issue: The amendment to Section 115 of the Code (Act 46 of 1999) restricts revisional jurisdiction; the immediate issue is whether the Civil Revisions attacking interlocutory orders are maintainable under the amended provision.
- Assessment of "case decided": The Court accepted that many of the impugned interlocutory orders qualify as a "case decided" in light of precedents such as Major S.S. Khanna and Baldebdas Sibalal and other High Court decisions cited at the Bar.
- Application of the amended Section 115 proviso: Despite finding that many impugned orders are "cases decided", the Court emphasized that the amended statute contains an additional, cumulative precondition — the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 115 — which bars revision unless the impugned order, if made in favour of the applicant, would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
- Interpretation of "suit or other proceeding": The Court examined its earlier decision in Simplex Engineering (which had treated proceedings arising in or out of suits as "proceedings" for purposes of Section 115) and contrasted it with the Supreme Court's interpretation in Shri Vishnu Avatar applying the ejusdem generis principle. The apex Court's view is that "proceeding" in that phrase must be of equivalent status to a suit and thus does not include proceedings arising in or out of a civil suit (such as miscellaneous applications). The present Court accepted that interpretation.
- Consequential test formulation: On applying the statutory text and the Supreme Court's interpretative approach, the Court formulated a cumulative test (set out below) that must be satisfied for a civil revision to be maintainable under the amended Section 115.
- Application to the petitions: The Court found that none of the impugned orders in the listed Civil Revisions satisfied the cumulative statutory requirements and, therefore, all the Civil Revisions were not maintainable and were dismissed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: All the Civil Revision Petitions considered in this common judgment are dismissed as not maintainable under the amended Section 115 of the Code.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The interlocutory orders impugned in the listed Civil Revisions remain in force; the respective civil revisions are dismissed and do not proceed further in this Court on revision ground under Section 115 as presently amended.
Legal implications stated by the Court (as articulated in the opinion):
- The Court set out the cumulative circumstances that must be satisfied for maintainability of a Civil Revision under the amended Section 115:
- (a) Preliminary conditions:
- Impugned order amounts to a "case decided".
- Such order must have been passed by a Court subordinate to the High Court.
- Such order must not be an appealable one.
- (b) There must be an allegation of jurisdictional error of the types listed in clauses (a)–(c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 115 (i.e., exercise of jurisdiction not vested by law; failure to exercise vested jurisdiction; or acting illegally or with material irregularity).
- (c) The proviso condition: If the impugned order had been passed in favour of the revision-petitioner, it would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
- Proceedings arising in or out of a civil suit (for example miscellaneous cases instituted for interlocutory reliefs) do not fall within the meaning of "other proceedings" in the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 115, following the Supreme Court's interpretation using ejusdem generis (Shri Vishnu Avatar etc. v. Sriram Avatar).
- Even if an impugned order qualifies as a "case decided" and there is jurisdictional error, a revision will still be barred unless the proviso's final-disposal condition is satisfied.
Disposition: "Revision Petitions dismissed." (as per the concluding line of the opinion)
P.K Tripathy, J.:— By this common judgment ail the aforesaid Civil Revisions are considered relating to maintainability in view of the amendment of Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short, ‘the Code’), which came into force by Act 46 of 1999 with effect from 1st July, 2002. Before considering the legal issue, orders which are impugned in each of the revision petitions are briefly noted as follows:
C.R.P No. 89 of 2002
The respondent in Munsif Appeal No. 95 of 1999 pending in the Court of District Judge, Balasore has preferred this revision challenging to the order dated 30.7.2002 passed by the District Judge in allowing the application for substitution filed by the appellant and rejecting the application for abatement filed by the respondent.
C.R.P No. 107 of 2002
Plaintiff in Title Suit No. 341 of 1996 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Bhubaneswar, has preferred this revision challenging to the order of addition of party by substituting the petitioners as against deceased defendant No. 2.
C.R.P No. 115 of 2002
Appellant in R.F.A No. 24 of 2002 has preferred this revision challenging to the order dated 26.8.2002 passed by the Fast Track Court No. 2 at Bhubaneswar allowing his application under Order 41, Rule 5 of the Code subject to petitioner depositing Rs. 4,000/- (four thousands) per month in the Court towards occupation of the suit premises.
C.R.P No. 124 of 2002
Plaintiffs in Title Suit No. 277 of 1999 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), 1st Court, Cuttack, have preferred this revision against the order dated 20.8.2002 In that order the Court below rejected the prayer of the plaintiffs to issue a direction to the defendants No. 7 and 8 to adduce evidence first.
C.R.P No. 139 of 2002
Plaintiff's application under Order 6, Rule 17, CPC having been rejected by the Civil Judge (Sr. Dvn.), Bhanjanagar in Title Suit No. 16 of 2000, she has filed this revision.
C.R.P No. 158 of 2002
Plaintiff's successive application under Order 6, Rule 17 of the Code for amendment of the plaint in Title Suit No. 2 of 2000 of the Court of- Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Udala was rejected as per the impugned order passed on 29.8.2002, and that order has been challenged in this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 169 of 2002
Defendant No. 1 in Title Suit No. 290 of 2001' of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), First Court, Cuttack, has preferred this revision challenging to the order of appointment of G.A.L to represent the interest of defendant Nos. 2 and 3 who are persons of unsound mind.
C.R.P No. 181 of 2002
Plaintiffs in Title Suit No. 46/217 of 2002/1995, who are also the defendants 1 and 2 in Title Suit No. 47/260 of 2002/1995 of the Fast Track Court No. 1, Bhubaneswar, have preferred this revision as against the order dated 23.9.2002, because the trial Court directed the parties to file affidavits as contemplated under Order 18, Rule 4, CPC.
C.R.P No. 232 of 2002
Petitioners' application for adding them as parties to Title Suit No. 442 of 1996 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Puri was rejected by that Court on 4.10.2002 Hence, they have filed this revision.
C.R.P No. 237 of 2002
The revision-petitioner filed an application under Order 1, Rule 10, read with Section 151 of the Code to implead him as the representative of Shri Lingaraj Mahaprabhu, the defendant No. 1, instead of permitting one Pranab Kishore Bharati Gosain to represent the deity. As per the impugned order dated 8.11.2002 in Title Suit No. 592 of 2001, learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Bhubaneswar has rejected that application. Hence the revision.
C.R.P No. 242 of 2002
Plaintiffs application for acceptance of documents in evidence in Title Suit No. 60 of 1999 having been rejected on 20.11.2002 by the Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Dhenkanal, he has preferred this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 254 of 2002
The 3rd party-petitioner challenges to the order dated 10.7.2002 in Civil Revision No. 42 of 2002 of the Court of District Judge, Puri, by which learned District Judge has dismissed the revision at the stage of admission.
C.R.P No. 255 of 2002
The plaintiff/opp. party filed Money Suit No. 18 of 2001 in the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Khurda claiming for compensation of Rs. 1,52,000/- on the ground of negligent act of the defendants/petitioners, as a result of which plaintiff's mother suffered the death. In that suit petitioners filed an application under Section 10, read with Section 151 of the Code to stay the suit on the ground that G.R Case No. 8 of 2001 registered against them is pending subjudice in the Court of S.D.J.M, Khurda. That application was rejected and hence this revision.
C.R.P Nos. 261 of 2002 and 326 of 2002
Common order was passed on 4.10;2002 by the Addl. District Judge, Baripada in Title Appeal No. 32/23/38 of 2002/1996, by rejecting the application under Order 6, Rule 17, CPC for amendment of the written statement and also for additional evidence under Order 41, Rule 27, CPC. Both the petitions were rejected. As against that, C.R.P No. 261 of 2002 has been filed challenging to the order refusing to accept additional evidence, and C.R.P No. 326 of 2002 has been filed challenging to the rejection of the application for amendment.
C.R.P No. 269 of 2002
Appellant in Title Appeal No. 8 of 1991 has preferred this revision challenging to the order dated 15.11.2002 passed by the Ad hoc Addl. District Judge, Dhenkanal in rejecting an application under Order 41, Rule 27 of the Code moved by the appellant.
C.R.P No. 270 of 2002
Defendants/Appellants in Title Appeal No. 44 of 1990 of the Court of District Judge, Cuttack, have preferred this revision challenging to the rejection of the application under Order 6, Rule 17, CPC, in which they wanted to amend their written-statement by introducing a counter claim for mandatory injunction against the plaintiff, so also an application was moved under Order 41, Rule 27 of the Code to admit the deposition of one of the parties to the proceeding in an earlier suit as additional evidence. In the impugned order dated 21.11.2002 learned 2nd Addl. District Judge, Cuttack has rejected the application under Order 6, Rule 17 of the Code and has directed to consider the other application at the time of hearing of the appeal.
C.R.P No. 283 of 2002
In Title Suit No. 51 of 2002 of the Court of Civil Judge (Jr. Division), Bhubaneswar, defendants filed an application for stay of the suit during pendency of O.E.A Appeal. That application having been rejected by the lower Court, the present revision has been preferred.
C.R.P No. 285 of 2002
Plaintiff of Title Suit No. 77 of 1998 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Aska has preferred this revision against the order dated 6.11.2002 of that Court. As per that order, the Court below allowed the prayer for amendment of the written statement to correct certain typographical error and clerical mistakes.
C.R.P No. 293 of 2002
In this revision plaintiff in Title Suit No. 137 of 1992 of the Court of First Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Cuttack has challenged to the order dated 7.10.2002, by which the Court below has rejected the report submitted by the Amin Commissioner in the Final Decree Proceeding and has directed for deputing a fresh Amin Commissioner.
C.R.P No. 305 of 2002
Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Banki on 10.10.2002 allowed plaintiff's application for amendment of the plaint, and defendant No. 1 has challenged that order in this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 315 of 2002
In Title Appeal No. 29 of 1996, on 23.11.2002 learned Ad hoc Addl. District Judge, Balasore rejected the application under Order 41, Rule 27 of the Code filed by the defendants/appellants. Hence, they have preferred this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 317 of 2002
Plaintiff has filed this revision challenging to the refusal to the prayer of amendment of the plaint under Order 6, Rule 17 of the Code, in Title Suit No. 2 of 1991 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Bhanjanagar, as per the impugned order dated 2.12.2002
C.R.P No. 336 of 2002
Application filed by the petitioners to implead them as parties in Title Suit No. 106/324 of .1996 having been rejected by the Fast Track Court No. 2, Bhubaneswar, the said interveners have preferred this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 4 of 2003
Defendants in Money Suit No. 1/62 of 2001-1999 of the Court of Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Puri are the petitioners as against the order passed on 21.9.2002 The trial Court rejected the application for amendment of the written statement. Hence they have filed this civil revision.
C.R.P No. 22 of 2003
Defendant No. 1 in Title Suit No. 14 of 2001 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Udala has preferred this civil revision challenging to the order passed by that Court on 7.1.2003 in rejecting the application for amendment of the written statement.
C.R.P No. 36 of 2003
Defendant No. 1 in Title Suit-No. 152 of 1996 of the Court of Fast Track Court No. 4, Bhubaneswar has filed this civil revision against the order dated 17.1.2003 It appears from that order that, after the case from both sides were closed but before hearing of argument plaintiff filed some sale, deeds and the same was accepted on record on the ground that such documents are not accepted as additional evidence. Hence the revision.
C.R.P No. 44 of 2003
In Title Suit No. 22/81 of 1990-2000 of the Court of Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Balasore, plaintiff filed three applications, one to accept the registered sale deeds of 30 years old on record subject to proof and relevancy and the other two petitions to prove execution of the documents and also about the custody of such 30 years old document. As per the impugned order dated 22.11.2002 all such applications were rejected by the trial Court. Hence the revision.
C.R.P No. 53 of 2003
Misc. Case No. 9 of 1997 has been filed by the opposite parties 1 & 2 in the Court of District Judge, Cuttack for grant of Probate or Letter of Administration on a Will executed on 10.3.1992 by their mother in their favour including the sole opposite party/the present petitioner. In that proceeding opposite parties 3 & 4 (of this civil revision) filed an application under Order 1, Rule 10, read with Order 22, Rule 10 of the Code with the prayer to implead them as parties to that proceeding. On hearing the parties, the Court below allowed that application treating the same to be one under Sections 283 and 284 of Indian Succession Act. Opposite party in Misc. Case No. 9 of 1997 has thus preferred this civil revision challenging to that order passed on 16.8.2002
C.R.P Nos. 71, 72 & 73 of 2003
Three separate orders passed on 10.1.2003 in Misc. Case No. 367 of 1998 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Jagatsinghpur are under challenge. The aforesaid Misc. Case has been filed by the petitioner claiming for revocation of Succession Certificate granted in favour of the opposite parties who were the petitioners in Succession Misc. Case No. 17 of 1996. Learned Civil Judge allowed the prayer to cause production of Exts. 1 to 8 (of Succession Misc. Case No. 17 of 1996) and that order is under challenge in C.R.P No. 72 of 2003. Learned Civil Judge allowed the prayer for causing production of the originals of the Succession Certificate granted in the above noted Succession Misc. Case and that order is under challenge in C.R.P No. 73 of 2003, and the order passed by learned Civil Judge in recalling the P. Ws. .1 and 2 for their cross-examination is under challenge in C.R.P No. 71 of 2003.
C.R.P No. 83 of 2003
Petitioner is the appellant in Title Appeal No. 42 of 2002 of the Court of District Judge, Balasore. He has preferred this civil revision challenging to the order passed by that Court on 16.12.2002 in rejecting the application for amendment of the written statement.
C.R.P No. 85 of 2003
Defendant in Money Suit No. 52 of 2001 of the Fast Track Court No. 4, Bhubaneswar has preferred this civil revision challenging to the order dated 6.1.2003 of that Court. By that order the Court below has directed the defendant to adduce evidence first on the ground that the claim of the plaintiff relating to the suit transaction has been admitted by the defendant/petitioner in his written statement and therefore the onus lies on him to prove withdrawal and adjustment.
C.R.P No. 103 of 2003
The sole defendant in Title Suit No. 73 of 2000 challenges to the order passed by learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Udala on 21.2.2003 in that suit directing for examination of the document, i.e, the will (Ext. A) by a Hand-writing Expert.
C.R.P No. 116 of 2003
Plaintiff is the petitioner in this civil revision as against the order passed on 1.2.2003 by learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Bhubaneswar in Title Suit No. 600 of 2000 by rejecting the application for amendment as well as for addition of parties.
C.R.P No. 117 of 2003
The sole defendant in Money Suit No. 522 of 1994 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Berhampur has preferred this civil revision challenging to the order passed by that Court on 20.2.2003 in rejecting the prayer for amendment of the written statement.
C.R.P No. 123 of 2003
Plaintiff's application for amendment of the plaint having been rejected by learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Chhatrapur in Title Suit No. 6 of 1997 as per the impugned order passed on 13.2.2003, she has preferred this revision.
C.R.P No. 277 of 2002
Petitioner in Succession Misc. Case No. 3 of 2001 of the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Bhubaneswar has challenged to the order passed by that Court on 18.9.2002 Learned Civil Judge in that order has directed the petitioner to deposit the duty money.
2. It appears from substance of the dispute in each of the above noted Civil Revisions that the interlocutory applications were disposed of in the impugned manner by the concerned Courts below. In view of the amendment of Section 115 of the Code, the prime question that emerges for consideration is as to whether such Civil Revisions are maintainable. In other words, whether this Court exercising the revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the Code should admit and entertain such revisions in the event the impugned orders, if had been made in favour of the revision- petitioners, i.e the party applying for revision, would not have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
3. In all the above noted Civil Revisions learned counsel appearing for petitioners in each of the cases, learned Addl. Govt. Advocate appearing for the State (as opposite party) in some cases and some learned counsel even appearing for the other'opposite party members in some other cases, have advanced argument in support of maintainability of such Civil Revisions as against the impugned interlocutory orders on the ground that such impugned orders come within the meaning of the term “eases decided” as per the interpretations made in the cited cases, out of which case of Major S.S Khanna v. Brid. F.J Dillon, AIR 1964 S.C 497, and Baldebdas Sibalal v. Filmstar Distributors (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406 are relied on as core decisions in that respect. Accordingly, it was argued that amendment in Section 115 of the Code by Act 46 of 1999 does not affect maintainability of civil revisions. In that respect, referring to the case of Simplex Engineering and Foundary Works Ltd. v. Bhubaneswar Patnaik (Civil Revision Petition No. 57 of 2003 decided by this Bench as per the judgment delivered on 11.2.2003 and reported in 2003 (1) OLR 508) they argued that the ratio stated in that case is not correct in view of the above noted two decisions of the Apex Court and series of other decisions from different High Courts including this Court on the interpretation of the term “Case decided”.
4. Some counsel appearing for some opposite party members however did not agree to the aforesaid argument advanced in support of maintainability of civil revisions against interlocutory orders. Their contention is that in view of the statutory provision in Section 115 of the Code, as it stands now, even if an order comes within the meaning of the term “case decided” then also a revision application shall not be maintainable unless that qualifies to the requirement of law in the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 115 of the Code, where it has been prescribed that “except when the order, if it had been made in favour of the party applying for revision, would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings”. Some of such counsel also argued that decision of this Court in the case of Simplex Engineering (supra) relating to construing the meaning of the term “other proceedings” appearing in the phrase “suit or other proceedings” is not correct in view of the ratio in the case of Shri Vishnu Avatar etc. v. Sriram Avatar, (1980) 4 SCC 81 : AIR 1980 SC 1575, in which, with the help of the maxim ‘ejusdem generis’ their Lordships have excluded proceeding arising out of suits from the purview of the term “other proceedings”. Therefore, according to them, a proceeding arising in or out of a suit is not a proceeding within the meaning of the term “ other proceedings” used in Section 115 of the Code and in that respect the term “other proceedings” means proceedings of original nature like Arbitration Proceeding, Proceeding under the Indian Succession Act, etc.
5. Keeping in view the principle stated by the apex Court in the case of S.S Khanna (supra) and Baldev Das Sibalal (supra) besides a series of decisions of this Court and different High Courts cited at the Bar, this Court finds that the impugned orders of different categories, in the above noted Civil Revisions come within the meaning of the term ‘case decided’. But, satisfying that requirement of Section 115 (1) of the Code and even satisfying the requirement of the jurisdictional error as noted in clauses (a) to (c) of Subsection (1) of Section 115 of the Code, this Court finds that the Civil Revisions are not maintainable as per the amended provision of Section 115. The simple reason for the same is that notwithstanding qualifying to any other requirement as prescribed under Section 115, a person applying for revision against a particular order must satisfy the Court that if the impugned order would have been passed in his favour then the ‘suit or other proceeding’ would have stood disposed of finally. Unless that requirement is satisfied, a revision is not entertainable even if the impugned order amounts to a case decided and there is jurisdictional error committed by the Court below in dealing with and disposing of that matter. In that context this Court while relying on the amended provision in Section 115 of the Code, also relies on the case of Shiv Shakti Coop. Housing Society, Nagpur v. Swaraj Developers, 2003 (4) SCALE 241.
6. So far the meaning of the term ‘proceeding’ which occurs in Section 115 of the Code, this Court in the case of M/s Simplex Engineering (supra) took the view that if a final order passed in a proceeding arising in or out of a suit and such order is appelable under Order 43 Rule 1 of the Code then such a proceeding be treated as a ‘proceeding’ within the meaning of the term “ Suit or other proceeding” as mentioned in the proviso under Sub-section (1) of Section 115 of the Code because such proceeding are transferable under Section 24 of the Code and procedure for disposal of such proceedings shall be in accordance with the provision in Section 141 of the Code. That view was expressed and the judgment was delivered without being cognisant of the ratio in the case of Shri Bishnu Awatar etc. (supra) because that decision was not brought to the notice. In that case the apex Court interpreted the term ‘suit or other proceeding’ and propounded that the term ‘proceeding’ must be a proceeding of the equivalent status of a suit and does not include a proceeding arising in or out of a suit. Therefore, if the principle of ‘ejusdem generis’ shall be applied as propounded by the Apex Court, then the proceeding arising in or out of a Civil Suit cannot be termed as a proceeding Within the meaning of Section 115 of the Code. Therefore, all the proceedings registered as Misc. Cases on the basis of miscellaneous application, be it for a temporary injunction, appointment of receiver, restoration of the suit, setting aside the ex parte decree, etc., are concerned, such miscellaneous cases will not come within the purview of the term ‘proceeding’ as provided in the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 115 of the Code.
7. Therefore, this Court finds that a Civil Revision, at the instance of a litigant, is maintainable on satisfaction of the following circumstances cumulatively, viz.:
(a) (i) Impugned order amounts to a case decided.
(ii) Such order must have been passed by any Court subordinate to such High Court.
(iii) Such order must not be appealable one.
(b) There must be allegation of jurisdictional error, i.e to say:
(i) exercise of jurisdiction not vested in the Court below by law, or
(ii) a jurisdiction vested in it by law was failed to be exercised, and/or
(iii) has acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity.
(c) If the impugned order had been passed in favour of the revision-petitioner then that would have finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.
8. Thus, keeping in view the stringency of the law, the rational behind that and Constitutional obligation of the Court to prevail the law, this Court finds that none of the impugned orders satisfy to the aforesaid requirement of law cumulatively. Thus, all the Civil Revisions are found not maintainable in view of the prohibition prescribed by Section 115 of the Code. Therefore, all the Civil Revisions are dismissed accordingly.
Revision Petitions dismissed.
Alert