- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. And Others v. Biswanath Barman And Others
Summary of Full Bench Opinion — Workmen's Compensation Act: Liability of Insurer for Interest and Penalty
Factual and Procedural Background
The Full Bench reference arose in Misc. Appeal No. 355 of 1992 where a learned single Judge of the Orissa High Court referred two questions under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923: (1) whether an insurer can be made liable for interest and penalty under the Act notwithstanding absence of a specific provision therefor in the Act and absence of a stipulation in the insurance policy; and (2) whether the levy of penalty is automatic or whether the insurer is entitled to an opportunity to show that levy of penalty is not warranted. Other appeals referred only the first question. The reference was necessitated by conflicting decisions of single Judges and Division Benches of various High Courts (including an earlier single Judge decision in Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Matias Burla, 1986 ACJ 732, and a Division Bench decision in Khirod Nayak v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1992 ACJ 76 (Orissa)). The Full Bench heard counsel and considered the language of section 4-A of the Act and related authorities before answering the reference.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an insurer can be made liable for interest and penalty under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 notwithstanding the absence of any specific provision in the Act or any stipulation in the insurance policy issued by the insurer.
- Whether the levy of penalty under section 4-A(3) is automatic or whether the insurer is entitled to an opportunity to show that the levy of penalty is not warranted, even if the insurer is held liable.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Cartledge v. E. Jopling & Sons Ltd. ((1963) AC 758) | Principle that plain and unequivocal statutory language must be enforced as enacted. | Invoked to support the starting point that if section 4-A's language is clear, the Court must enforce it as it stands. |
| Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee v. Dinamani Dei (1982 ACJ 338) (Orissa) | Decision on liability of insurer under the Motor Vehicles Act vis-à-vis Workmen's Compensation Act (different statutory context). | Held not applicable to the present reference because the issue before that single Judge concerned the Motor Vehicles Act rather than section 4-A of the Workmen's Compensation Act. |
| National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nathibai Chaturabhuj (1982 ACJ 153) (Gujarat) | Decision dealing with Motor Vehicles Act issues. | Considered similar to Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee and stated to be not applicable for the present section 4-A issue. |
| Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Brajakishore Sahu (1986 ACJ 692) (Orissa) | Interpreted section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act; insurer held liable for entire amount awarded where additional premium paid. | Noted that section 4-A was not specifically considered in that decision; therefore not applicable to the present references. |
| Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Matias Burla (1986 ACJ 732) (Orissa) | Interpreted section 4-A(3): held that provision can be invoked only against an employer; insurer is not the employer and thus not liable for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3). | The Full Bench respectfully agreed with the ratio and relied on its plain reading of section 4-A(3) to the same effect. |
| Khirod Nayak v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation (1992 ACJ 76) (Orissa) | Division Bench view that the mere mention of 'employer' in section 4-A(3) does not exonerate the insurer when the Motor Vehicles Act makes insurance compulsory; insurer may be liable to indemnify for penalty as well as principal. | The Full Bench disagreed with this Division Bench view, holding instead that liability for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3) is that of the employer unless the insurance policy specifically provides otherwise. |
| New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhukhan (1989 ACJ 923) (Madhya Pradesh) | Held that if insurer's liability arises for the principal amount under MV Act provisions, and payment is not made in time, the insurer incurs liability to pay penalty. | This decision was relied upon by the Division Bench in Khirod Nayak; the Full Bench observed that Madhya Pradesh emphasized the terms and conditions of the insurance policy in reaching that conclusion. |
| Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Hasmat Khatoon (1989 ACJ 862) (Delhi) | Single Judge accepted view that insurer is not liable for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3), following Matias Burla and Jevaramma. | Cited as an authority taking the view that insurer is not liable for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3). |
| Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jevaramma (1988 ACJ 671) (Karnataka) | Held insurer liable for all compensation including penalty/interest payable for the risk covered unless the policy excludes such liability; emphasized policy terms (payment of additional premium etc.). | The Full Bench stated it had no dispute with the proposition that where the policy expressly covers such liabilities (e.g., by extra premium), insurer will be liable. |
| Om Parkash v. Ramkali (1987 ACJ 803) (Madhya Pradesh) | Held insurer liable for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3) and sections 95(1) and 96 of the Motor Vehicles Act; also noted insurer could exclude in policy liabilities not statutory under section 95(1)(b). | Cited as an authority taking the view that insurer can be liable; the Full Bench observed the Madhya Pradesh decision allowed insurers to exclude non-statutory liabilities by policy terms. |
| Jayantilal & Co. v. Garasia Rajvirba Udesinh (1992 ACJ 286) (Gujarat) | Held insurer could not be made liable for penalty under section 4-A(3); judgment considered the insurance policy. | Cited in support of the view that insurer is not liable where policy does not provide for interest/penalty. |
| S.D. Sharma v. Ramesh Mahakud (1993 ACJ 385) (Orissa) | Held insurer is not liable for interest and penalty under section 4-A(3). | Cited as an authority consistent with the Full Bench's conclusion that insurer is not liable absent policy stipulation. |
| Dromati Devi v. Sohan Singh (1995 ACJ 1019) (Himachal Pradesh) | One of two Division Bench decisions holding insurer not liable for interest and penalty. | Relied upon by the Full Bench as part of a cluster of authorities concluding insurer not liable where policy does not cover such liabilities. |
| United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nako (1996 ACJ 516) (Himachal Pradesh) | Division Bench decision holding insurer not liable for interest and penalty; relied on multiple earlier authorities. | Identified by the Full Bench as supporting the position that insurer is not liable where policy does not provide for interest/penalty. |
| Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Moola Singh (1970 ACJ 401) (P&H) | One of several authorities relied upon in subsequent High Court decisions holding insurer not liable. | Listed among authorities supporting the non-liability view; cited by later benches considered by the Full Bench. |
| Kochu Velu v. Purakkattu Joseph (1984 ACJ 630) (Kerala) | Authority cited in other High Court decisions rejecting insurer liability for interest/penalty. | Included among precedents relied on for the view that insurers are not automatically liable for interest/penalty. |
| U.P. State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Abdul Hameed (1985 ACJ 832) (Allahabad) | Authority cited in other High Court decisions rejecting insurer liability for interest/penalty. | Included among authorities relied on for the view that insurers are not automatically liable for interest/penalty. |
| Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Raju (1994 ACJ 191) (Karnataka) | Division Bench held authorities exercising power must examine the insurance policy to determine whether insurer is liable to indemnify interest/penalty; insurer not liable where policy excludes such liability. | The Full Bench endorsed this approach and stated it represents the correct position of law. |
| Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sahah Bahadur (1996 ACJ 558) (Bombay, Nagpur Bench) | Expressed view that insurer not liable for interest/penalty. | Cited as another authority aligning with the Full Bench's conclusion that insurer is not liable unless policy stipulates. |
| New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Guddi (1994 ACJ 1134) (Madhya Pradesh) | Held insurer liable for penalty where policy clause (clause 17) made insurer liable for all legal liabilities of the employer. | Cited to illustrate that insurer liability may arise from the terms of the policy rather than by operation of section 4-A(3) itself. |
| United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. L.N. Tamuly (1996 ACJ 644) (Gauhati) | Held insurer liable for penalty and interest, but judgment noted no policy was filed so exclusion could not be considered. | The Full Bench treated this as supporting the proposition that insurer liability depends on whether the policy excludes such liabilities. |
| United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Roop Kanwar (1991 ACJ 74) (Rajasthan) | Referenced case; not directly on the specific point addressed in the reference. | The Full Bench observed it was not directly relevant to the specific issue before it. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Full Bench began with the established interpretive principle that clear and unequivocal statutory language must be enforced as written (citing Cartledge). It then closely examined the definition of "employer" in section 2(1)(e) of the Workmen's Compensation Act and the text of section 4-A(3).
Key analytical steps taken by the Court (as stated in the opinion):
- The plain reading of section 4-A(3) indicates that where an employer defaults in paying compensation within one month, the Commissioner may order recovery of interest and, if delay is unjustified, a penalty of up to fifty percent of the arrears. The subsection explicitly refers to recovery from the "employer."
- On a literal reading, the obligation to pay interest and penalty arises against the employer alone; to make the insurer directly liable under that subsection would require substituting the word "insurer" for "employer" in the statutory text, which the Court considered impermissible.
- The Court analyzed conflicting authorities from various High Courts. It accepted precedent (e.g., Matias Burla) that construes section 4-A(3) as a provision invoking liability against the employer and not as imposing a penal liability on insurers per se.
- The Court observed that a number of decisions taking the contrary view (i.e., that insurers are liable) did so because of the terms of the insurance policy or because the policy was not placed before the court. Several authorities (including Madhya Pradesh decisions) stressed policy terms and the Motor Vehicles Act provisions.
- The Full Bench emphasized that the insurer's liability to indemnify the employer is a matter of contract (insurance policy) governed by the Indian Contract Act. If the policy specifically stipulates that the insurer will indemnify the employer for interest and penalty (for example, by payment of additional premium or by a clause making the insurer liable for legal liabilities), the insurer will be liable in accordance with the policy's terms.
- Conversely, if the insurance policy does not provide for payment of interest and penalty, the insurer cannot be saddled with those liabilities by judicial construction of section 4-A(3) to include the insurer; doing so would override the contractual allocation of risk between employer and insurer.
- Because the first question was answered in the insurer's disfavor (i.e., insurer not automatically liable), the Court deemed it unnecessary to answer the second referred question concerning the automaticity of penalty levy.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Full Bench answered the primary reference by holding that the insurer cannot be made liable for interest and penalty under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, in the absence of any stipulation in the insurance policy to that effect.
Implications and direct consequences stated in the opinion:
- The liability to pay interest and penalty under section 4-A(3) of the Act, on its plain reading, rests with the employer. An insurer is not automatically liable under that subsection unless the insurance policy expressly provides indemnity for such liabilities.
- The Full Bench declined to answer the second question because the answer to the first made that unnecessary.
- All appeals were to be sent to the appropriate Bench for decision on merits. The appropriate Bench was directed to decide each appeal on the facts of the case and with reference to the terms of the insurance policy presented in each matter.
- The opinion emphasizes that insurer liability for interest and penalty arises from contractual terms of the policy (governed by the Indian Contract Act) and not by implicit judicial substitution of "insurer" for "employer" in section 4-A(3).
- The opinion does not purport to create any novel statutory construction beyond enforcing the plain wording of section 4-A(3); its practical effect is to preserve the arrangement of liabilities as set out in statute and in the insurance contract.
S.N Phukan, C.J:— In Misc. Appeal No. 355 of 1992 a learned single Judge of this court has referred the following two questions arising out of Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (for short ‘the Act’) for our decision:
“(1) Whether insurer can be made liable for interest and penalty under the Act notwithstanding absence of specific provision therefor in the Act and stipulation in the policy issued by the insurer?
(2) Whether levy of penalty is automatic or the insurer is entitled to an opportunity to show that levy of penalty is not warranted, even if it is held that insurer is liable?”
2. In the other appeals, only the first question has been referred. The necessity for making the present references to this Full Bench arose as a learned single Judge of this court in the Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Matias Burla, 1986 ACJ 732 (Orissa), held that under section 4-A, the insurer is not liable to pay either penalty or interest; but the decision of the learned single Judge was not accepted by a Division Bench of this court in Khirod Nayak v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1992 ACJ 76 (Orissa).
3. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
4. We may now extract below the relevant sections of the Act before we consider the two questions referred to us.
5. Sub-clause (e) of clause (1) of section 2 of the Act defines the word ‘employer’ which runs as follows:
“‘employer’ includes any body of persons whether incorporated or not and any managing agent of an employer and the legal representative of a deceased employer, and, when the services of a workman are temporarily lent or let on hire to another person by the person with whom the workman has entered into a contract of service or apprenticeship, means such other person while the workman is working for him;”
6. Section 4-A runs as follows:
“Compensation to be paid when due and penalty for default.—(1) Compensation under section 4 shall be paid as soon as it falls due.
(2) In cases where the employer does not accept the liability for compensation to the extent claimed, he shall be bound to make provisional payment based on the extent of liability which he accepts, and such payments shall be deposited with the Commissioner or made to the workman, as the case may be, without prejudice to the right of the workman to make any further claim.
(3) Where any employer is in default in paying the compensation due under this Act within one month from the date it fell due, the Commissioner may direct that, in addition to the amount of the arrears, simple interest at the rate of six per cent per annum on the amount due together with, if in the opinion of the Commissioner there is no justification for the delay, a further sum not exceeding fifty per cent of such amount shall be recovered from the employer by way of penalty.”
7. It is the settled law that where the language is plain and admits of but one meaning, the task of interpretation can hardly be said to arise. Where the legislature while enacting a statute used clear and unequivocal language capable of only one meaning, it must be enforced, however harsh or absurd or contrary to common sense the result may be. [See Cartledge v. E. Jopling & Sons Ltd., (1963) AC 758]. Therefore, if the language of section 4-A of the Act is clear, it is the duty of this court to expound the section as it stands.
8. Reading the definition of ‘employer’ with section 4-A of the Act, there can only be one interpretation that the employer is liable if there is any default in paying the compensation due under the Act within one month from the date it fell due. The interest and penalty shall be recoverable only from the employer as is clear from sub-section (3) of section 4-A of the Act. If we hold that the insurer is liable for penalty or interest, it would amount to substituting the word ‘employer’ in sub-section (3) of section 4-A of the Act with the word ‘insurer’. Now let us consider the various decisions of different High Courts placed before us.
9. The decision of a learned single Judge of this court in Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee v. Dinamani Dei, 1982 ACJ 338 (Orissa), was relied upon at the Bar. This decision, in our opinion, is not applicable to the case in hand as the question that came up before the learned single Judge was liability of the insurance company under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, vis-a-vis, the Act as the cleaner of the vehicle died in the accident. We are not concerned in the present references with the liability of the insurance company under the Motor Vehicles Act. Similar is the position in respect of the Full Bench decision of the Gujarat High Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nathibai Chaturabhuj, 1982 ACJ 153 (Gujarat).
10. The next decision for consideration is the decision of a learned single Judge of this court in Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Brajakishore Sahu, 1986 ACJ 692 (Orissa). Though the learned single Judge while interpreting section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, held that the insurer is liable for the entire amount awarded in view of the additional premium paid, yet specific question as regards liability of the insurance company on newly added section 4-A of the Act was not considered. Therefore, we are of the opinion that this decision is not applicable to the case in hand.
11. In Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. v. Matias Burla, 1986 ACJ 732 (Orissa), the learned single Judge specifically considered section 4-A of the Act and we extract below para 7 of the judgment which is relevant for our purpose:
“A bare glance at section 4-A (3) is enough to show that it can be invoked against an employer. The use of the word ‘employer’ in this provision as distinct from the phrase ‘any person’ in section 31 of the Act, which deals with recovery of compensation, also further confirms the view that the provision can be invoked against an employer. Being a penal provision, it is to be construed rigidly. The insurer, who takes the liability to indemnify the employer, is not the employer. On this short ground only, the contention of Mr. Basu that the interest claimed and the penalty imposed on the insurer is unauthorised, becomes unassailable.”
12. As indicated above, we are of the opinion that on a plain reading of the definition of the word ‘employer’ and section 4-A(3) of the Act, it is sufficient for us to hold that under the provisions of the above section 4-A of the Act, the employer is liable to pay the interest and penalty. Therefore, we are in respectful agreement with the ratio laid down by the learned single Judge. The decision in Khirod Nayak, 1992 ACJ 76 (Orissa), which is the decision of a Division Bench of this court, which did not accept the decision of the learned single Judge in Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee, 1982 ACJ 338 (Orissa), needs our careful consideration. The Division Bench of this court after referring to the above para 7 of the judgment of the learned single Judge in Matias Burla, 1986 ACJ 732 (Orissa), considered the law laid down by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhukhan, 1989 ACJ 923 (MP), which is contrary to the above views expressed in Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee (supra) and was of the opinion that:
“(7) The question for our consideration is, which of the two views merits our acceptance. According to us, the mere mention about the liability being of the employer in section 4-A(3) of the Act is not enough to exonerate the insurer to indemnify the employer in this regard in cases of accident involving a motor vehicle which requires compulsory insurance under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. We have stated so because the primary liability of paying compensation is also fastened on the employer as would appear from section 3(1) of the Act. If an insurer is liable to indemnify the employer for the latter's liability to pay compensation as visualised by section 3(1) of the Act, we do not find any cogent reason to exonerate the insurer from paying the penalty fastened on the employer because of what is stated in section 4-A(3) of the Act. If the liability of the insurer arises for the principal amount, though the same is required to be paid by the employer as stated in section 3(1) of the Act, by the same token, the insurer's liability would arise to pay the penalty which is imposed on the employer because of the default in making the payment. If the employer commits the default in paying the compensation and if it was the liability of the insurer to pay compensation in time, we are of the view that for the default in making payment, the insurer is also to suffer. The mere fact that section 4-A(3) has spoken about ‘employer’ is, therefore, not enough to exonerate the insurer.”
13. The Division Bench quoted the following portion from para 9 of the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhukhan, 1989 ACJ 923 (MP):
“…in accidents of motor vehicle, the liability to pay compensation is upon the owner of the vehicle, but where the vehicle is insured, it is for the insurer to make good the compensation awarded in accordance with the terms and conditions of the policy. The said liability of the insured is covered under the provisions of section 96 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Therefore, if the liability of the insurer arises for the principal amount and the same is not deposited or paid well in time within the meaning of the provisions of section 4-A(3) of the Act of 1923, i.e, within a month from the date of intimation, the insurer incurs liability to pay penalty.”
(Emphasis supplied)
14. From the above, it is clear that the Madhya Pradesh High Court gave emphasis on the terms and conditions of the policy. In other words, if the terms and conditions of the policy do not specifically provide for payment of interest and penalty, the insurer cannot be fastened with the liability of payment of interest and penalty under the Act. With respect, we are unable to accept the ratio laid down by the Division Bench of this court in Khirod Nayak (supra) inasmuch as under section 4-A of the Act it is the primary liability of the employer to pay penalty and interest. If there is any insurance policy taken out by the employer, the amount of liability of the insurance company to indemnify the employer would depend upon the terms and conditions of the contract, namely, the insurance policy and if it is not within the terms of the policy, the insurance company cannot be saddled with the liability to pay the interest and penalty under the Act. Any contrary view will run counter to the contract of insurance.
15. The Division Bench in Khirod Nayak, 1992 ACJ 76 (Orissa), also relied on a decision of the Gauhati High Court in Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Nani Bala Devi, 1987 ACJ 655 (Gauhati). In this case the question, namely, section 4-A of the Act was not at all considered. The facts of the case were that an employee, namely, the deceased Tarini was employed as handyman-cum-cleaner of a particular truck and the truck met with an accident and the employee died. The truck was insured and as per the provisions of the Act, the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation directed the insurer to pay a sum of Rs. 18,000/- as compensation. Feeling aggrieved, the insurance company filed an appeal before the High Court. On perusal of the judgment, it does not appear that any penalty or interest was imposed. Therefore, this decision is also not relevant for our purpose. We may only point out that the learned single Judge of the Gauhati High Court held that the provisions of the Act cannot be viewed in isolation when the Motor Vehicles Act has specifically stated that a policy of insurance taken out under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act cannot exclude the liability arising under the Act. Therefore, this decision, as stated above, is not applicable to the case in hand.
16. The Division Bench of this court in Khirod Nayak (supra) also took note of the decision of this court in Bibhuti Bhusan Mukherjee, 1982 ACJ 338 (Orissa). We have already stated that the above decision is not relevant for our purpose by giving reasons in para 7 of this judgment.
17. We may now refer to the decisions of the various High Courts taking the view that under sub-section (3) of section 4-A of the Act employer is liable to pay interest and penalty.
18. In Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Hasmat Khatoon, 1989 ACJ 862 (Delhi), a learned single Judge of Delhi High Court took the view that under sub-section (3) of section 4-A of the Act the insurance company is not liable to pay interest and penalty. The learned single Judge accepted the view expressed by this court in Matias Burla, 1986 ACJ 732 (Orissa) and also the view expressed by the Karnataka High Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jevaramma*, 1988 ACJ 671 (Karnataka). The learned single Judge, however, did not accept the view expressed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Om Parkash v. Ramkali, 1987 ACJ 803 (MP).
19. The Gujarat High Court in Jayantilal & Co. v. Garasia Rajvirba Udesinh, 1992 ACJ 286 (Gujarat), took the same view that the insurance company could not be made liable for the penalty imposed under section 4-A(3) of the Act. In arriving at the above view, the learned single Judge considered the policy of insurance.
20. In the decision rendered by a learned single Judge of this court in S.D Sharma v. Ramesh Mahakud, 1993 ACJ 385 (Orissa), it was held that under section 4-A(3) of the Act, the insurance company is not liable for the interest and penalty.
21. We may now refer to the two decisions of the Himachal Pradesh High Court, namely, Dromati Devi v. Sohan Singh, 1995 ACJ 1019 (HP) and United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nako, 1996 ACJ 516 (HP). These two decisions were rendered by the same Division Bench in which one of us (S.N Phukan, C.J) was a member. Relying on the decisions in Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Moola Singh, 1970 ACJ 401 (P&H); Kochu Velu v. Purakkattu Joseph, 1984 ACJ 630 (Kerala); U.P State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Abdul Hameed, 1985 ACJ 832 (Allahabad); Jayantilal & Co. v. Garasia Rajvirba Udesinh, 1992 ACJ 286 (Gujarat); and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Raju*, 1994 ACJ 191 (Karnataka), it was held that the insurance company was not liable for payment of interest and penalty. Similar view was also expressed by the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) in Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sahah Bahadur, 1996 ACJ 558 (Bombay).
22. We may also refer to the decision of the Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Raju*, 1994 ACJ 191 (Karnataka), more particularly the relevant portion of para 8, which runs as follows:
“…Therefore, the authorities exercising power under the Act must necessarily apply their mind to see whether under the policy covering the risk there arises liability to indemnify the payment of interest or penalty. To make it clear, in the event of the insured having entered into a contract with the insurer, the latter shall not be made liable to indemnify the insured as to payment of interest/penalty that may arise in a claim of this kind. In the instant case, we are satisfied that in view of the exclusion of the liability to pay interest or penalty arising out of the claim petition, the appellant insurer shall not be liable to pay interest imposed in the instant case.”
23. In our opinion this is the correct position of law.
24. Now let us consider the decisions on which reliance has been placed in support of the argument that the insurance company is liable both for interest and penalty.
25. A Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jevaramma*, 1988 ACJ 671 (Karnataka), held that under section 4-A(3) of the Act the insurance company is liable to meet all compensation including penalty and interest payable for the risk covered unless the policy does not exclude the liability of the insurance company to pay penalty and interest. We have no dispute on this point. If under the insurance policy the insurance company on payment of additional premium or otherwise agrees to indemnify the owner for the penalty imposed and interest awarded, the insurance company shall be liable to indemnify the owner.
26. The Madhya Pradesh High Court in Om Parkash v. Ramkali, 1987 ACJ 803 (MP), held that under section 4-A(3) of the Act and under sections 95(1) and 96 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, the insurer is liable to pay interest and penalty. In para 14 of the judgment, the learned single Judge observed that the statutory requirement envisaged under section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act does not extend to all types of liabilities arising under the Act in respect of any accident and it would be open to an insurer to exclude, in the policy, any such liability which, though it arises under the Act, is not the statutory liability envisaged under section 95(1)(b) or under any provision of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. Thus, it appears, according to the learned single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High Court, that it is even open to an insurer to exclude in the policy any liability which is not statutory.
27. We may refer to another decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Guddi, 1994 ACJ 1134 (MP), wherein it was held that the insurance company is liable for payment of penalty. This view was taken as there was no clause in the insurance policy exempting the insurance company against liability for penalty in case of default in making payment. On reading para 2 of the judgment, we find that under clause 17 of the insurance policy, the insurance company was liable in that case for all legal liabilities of the employer. Thus, the above view was taken by the learned single Judge not in view of the provisions in the section of the Act but because of the conditions in the insurance policy.
28. In another decision of the Gauhati High Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. L.N Tamuly, 1996 ACJ 644 (Gauhati), it was held that under section 4-A of the Act the insurance company is liable to pay penalty and interest. In para 6 of the judgment, the learned single Judge has held that interest and penalty are not integral part of the compensation and that the same can be imposed only if the employer fails to settle the claim within one month when it is falling due. From the said para, we find that insurance policy was not filed. Therefore, the learned single Judge had no opportunity to find out that under the insurance policy the insurance company was liable to indemnify the owner for the penalty and interest. Thus, reading the judgment as a whole, we find that the insurance company is liable to pay penalty and interest not because of section 4-A of the Act but because the whole insurance policy was not exhibited to support that the insurance company is not liable for such penalty and interest. Therefore, this decision supports our view as stated above.
29. Reference has also been made to the decision in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Roop Kanwar, 1991 ACJ 74 (Rajasthan), which, in our view, needs no consideration, as this decision is not directly on the point.
30. Thus, the above decisions, which have been cited before us in support of the contention that insurance company is liable to pay interest and penalty, are based mainly on insurance policy. We are of the opinion, as stated earlier, that if the insurance policy which is governed by the Indian Contract Act does not provide for payment of interest and penalty by the insurance company, the court cannot take the view that the word ‘employer’ in section 4-A (3) of the Act would include ‘insurer’ as it would amount to substituting the word ‘employer’ by the word ‘insurer’ in sub-section (3) of section 4-A of the Act.
31. Situated thus, we hold on a plain reading of the definition of ‘employer’ and section 4-A(3) of the Act that the insurer cannot be made liable for interest and penalty under the Act in the absence of any stipulation in the policy of insurance. The first question is answered accordingly. In view of our above answer to the first question, it is not necessary to answer the second question referred to us. The references are disposed of accordingly. Let all the appeals be sent to the appropriate Bench for deciding the matter on merits. The appropriate Bench shall decide the appeals on the facts of each case and with reference to the policy of insurance.
A. Pasayat, J.:— I agree.
C.R Pal, J.:— I agree.
32. Reference answered.
Alert